6 ms·
Airlines in the U.S. charge separately for checked bags in order to reduce tax
- yau8edq12i 3y agoChecked bags aren't cheaper outside the US...
- refurb 3y agoNot only that, this law was in place before 1962.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThat doesn't make it not a loophole.
- refurb 3y agoIt makes it not a cause for charging for luggage which started over 40 years later. Plus it’s not a “loophole” it’s a law.
- ceejayoz 3y agoPlanting a seed 40 years ago may, in part, cause a tree to fall on my house at some point. > Plus it’s not a “loophole” it’s a law. "A loophole is an ambiguity or inadequacy in a system, such as a law or security, which can be used to circumvent or otherwise avoid the purpose, implied or explicitly stated, of the system." Moving revenue from fares to fees evades a tax in a way that likely was not anticipated by that law's creators.
- refurb 3y ago> Planting a seed 40 years ago may, in part, cause a tree to fall on my house at some point. Sure, and a butterfly beating it's wings may have lead to JFK's assassination, but there are way more important factors. > which can be used to circumvent or otherwise avoid the purpose, implied or explicitly stated, of the system Did you read the law? It explicitly excluded luggage from the tax. Because the tax was never intended to apply to luggage. So it sounds like the opposite of a loophole, by your definition.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe implied purpose of taxing airline tickets is to collect taxes on flights. As you noted, baggage fees for all bags was not standard practice at the time, nor for decades later. (I wouldn't know where to start with researching the original intent of this carve-out of the law.) The loophole's theoretical existence and the loophole's widespread usage needn't correspond temporarily for it to be a loophole. If I find a loophole in "don't murder" laws that've been around for 200 years, it's still a loophole if I start offing people with impunity. (For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zone_of_Death_(Yellowstone) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zone_of_Death_(Yellowstone) is a potential loophole that existed since 1890, but discovered in 2005, that clearly conflicts with the intent of the Sixth Amendment) Some airline might try "free ticket if you pay for a bag" style setups at some point, if they're daring enough to risk its being closed as a response.
- refurb 3y ago> The implied purpose of taxing airline tickets is to collect taxes on flights. Sure, but the people who wrote the law specifically excluded baggage fees along with (looks at law) about a dozen other charges that airline levy. So how can one argue that it wasn't the intent of the law if it's written plainly in the law? It's not like the law says "this tax applies to baggage", then airlines created a new definition of baggage and then claimed their fee isn't taxable. It seems like you use "loophole" as a synonym for "things I don't like but are permitted".
- ceejayoz 3y ago> So how can one argue that it wasn't the intent of the law if it's written plainly in the law? Again, in this case, that exception seems highly likely to have been crafted to permit a practice common at the time, not a practice that became common 40 years later. You pointed that gap out; you can't have it both ways. Bills being passed that don't reflect legislative intent is hardly unheard of: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2022/07/minnesota-legalized-edibles-after-a-republican-didnt-read-the-bill/ https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2022/07/minnesota-legal... "Here’s something you don’t see every day: On Friday, THC-infused edibles and beverages became legal in the great state of Minnesota, after a law containing the legalization measure was included in a health and human services funding bill. How did this measure get through? Critically, a key Republican state senator who co-chaired the committee that passed it didn’t read the text closely enough." Or when TN almost accidentally legalized child marriage: https://www.wkrn.com/news/tennessee-politics/a-get-out-of-jail-free-card-gop-bill-would-eliminate-age-requirements-for-marriages-in-tennessee/?ipid=inline-link https://www.wkrn.com/news/tennessee-politics/a-get-out-of-ja... > It seems like you use "loophole" as a synonym for "things I don't like but are permitted". Yes, that's precisely the definition of one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loophole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loophole "In a loophole, a law addressing a certain issue exists, but can be legally circumvented due to a technical defect in the law, such as a situation where the details are under-specified."
- amelius 3y agoIt's all because opaque pricing allows airline companies to make more profits.
- matwood 3y agoMaybe I just fly a lot, but baggage fees are pretty clear along with limits.
- dartos 3y agoRight, but if you’re not a frequent flier and are trying to just plan a trip, the amount of extra work it takes to determine the actual round trip price (incl. baggage fees) for several different airline is prohibitive. Many people just pick the cheapest price on cheap tickets or something (which is usually spirit. They famously charge so much for baggage that they end up being more expensive than other airlines)
- afavour 3y agoBut they don’t appear on price comparison sites. So if you’re shopping around and you see a Delta flight for $300 and a Spirit flight for $200 you have no idea which is actually cheaper. Every time I’ve flown Spirit the baggage price has been variable (based on miles flown maybe? No idea) so it’s not like comparison sites could even add it if they wanted to.
- airtag 3y agoIt's not only that - the bag prices mess with price comparison web sites so much, that it's impossible to find the best deal. Win-Win for the airlines.
- jessriedel 3y agoKayak has mostly solved this. You select number of carry-on and checked bags, and it uses the inclusive price.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoKayak/Google flights/expedia all allow you to select number of carry on and checked bags.
- danpalmer 3y agoThe US tax code.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoThis isn't it at all. It always comes down to people wanting the lowest fare possible for their flight and the bean counters realized it was possible to pull it off by charging for it.
- Waterluvian 3y agoMy city requires these $2 stickers per can of garbage. On the surface some people complain, but it’s a way to encourage people to produce less. I have no idea what the per-bag fee should be, but it seems like a great way to get people thinking about what they actually need to bring and not socializing the cost of those who decide to bring a lot.
- kalleboo 3y agoAnother example is that in many places, the ban on plastic bags wasn't a ban on plastic bags, it was a ban on free plastic bags. Just charging a couple cents per bag makes people reconsider it, even when they're buying $100 worth of groceries and alcohol.
- onemoresoop 3y agoIn the US people use the same amount of plastic is being used and most are not shy to pay a few cents for per bag except for the same minority who are conscientious and bring their onw reusable bags. Imo the cost of comfort is too cheap. If bags costed $1 people would start to bring their own reusable bags in larger numbers.
- Our_Benefactors 3y agoIt’s fundamentally a regressive tax. Increasing it would just exacerbate this inequality.
- kalleboo 3y agoI guess this is just another way that Americans are just very different from the rest of the world hah
- onemoresoop 3y agoI've seen a recent documentary about Lausanne (Swiss) I think where people were ticketed 150 euro for throwing household trash into the public bins (though it wasn't clear how it was determined it was household trash). It seemed excessive but I understand how this could teach people quickly to do the right thing. And yes, the household bags had to have stickers or a special bag that cost around 2 euro.
- spencerflem 3y agoI've always thought it was price discrimination, so the people who really want a cheap flight can put up with less bags instead of not flying at all
- Aurornis 3y agoIt can be both. As someone who travels light (even with kids) I appreciate it. I check 1 bag at most and it incentivizes us to pack smartly. The people who want to bring a lot of bags can pay for it as needed.
- rand0mx1 3y agoCan you share your strategy regarding smart packing?
- ethagknight 3y agoDiscrimination? Or just charging for service/capacity?
- CubsFan1060 3y agoI would guess OP is using the other definition [1] "DISCERNING, JUDICIOUS discriminating buyers" [1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/discriminating https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/discriminating
- spencerflem 3y agoIts a specific term, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_discrimination https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_discrimination
- Aurornis 3y ago“Price discrimination” is an economic term. It doesn’t carry the same negative connotations as “discrimination” in a social sense.
- lenerdenator 3y agoBecause what are you gonna do, drive from NYC to LA? What, and see what the people on the lower tip of Manhattan hath wrought the entire way there? C'mon.
- jmclnx 3y agoWhat an I going to do, take a train. I can get power and a stable internet connection on a train, so I can really work while traveling. Plus no worries about bags, tiny seats, pieces flying off the plane and people dribbling on you. I use to fly regularity many years ago, now, never again. I told my manager over 10 years ago, I will never fly again, so allow me to drive or take a train on company time, or I will not go :) No other way of travel is a bad as flying. 30 years ago it was rather good, now it is 1 or 2 steps away from torture.
- lenerdenator 3y agoIf it arrives on time. Amtrak seems to be hit-or-miss outside of the Northeast Corridor. Which brings us back to "what they have wrought".
- thallium205 3y agoSouthwest Airlines still does not charge a bag fee.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoAnd I don't typically fly Southwest because it's more expensive for me, because I never check a bag.
- vinaypai 3y agoI'm okay with bag fees. There is a real cost to carrying extra bags. I pack light and don't see why I need to subsidize other people if it's bundled. On the other hand, fees for things like seat assignment (regular seats, not just the exit rows and such) are just an annoying cash grab.
- verall 3y agoAA will make you pay extra to "choose your own seat" ($75-$150 extra per ticket for basic economy -> main cabin) and then block off all but 3 rows as "premium seats" so that you can pay $30+/leg/person to sit with your party/travel companion after paying already paying extra. Better get to the airport early and beg the gate attendant or spend an additional $240+ (1 layover, 2 passengers)! If you book a codeshare they don't even try to let you choose, they simply put in the fine print that the choosing your own seat perk "may not apply to partner airlines". I hate it.
- jbandela1 3y agoI actually wish the airlines did the reverse: allow 2 free checked bags but charge for carryons that don’t fit under your seat. It is the carryons that make boarding stressful, where everyone worries that if they are not at the front of the line the bins will be full by the time they board. Also, they slow boarding as people stand in the aisles looking for an empty overhead bin or else trying to play Tetris to fit their luggage into an almost full bin. From reading the article, it seems that may get the same tax benefits as the checked baggage fees.
- bluGill 3y agoI live in a tiny city. I get the best of both worlds by gate-checking my bags. I don't have to find carryone space, and my bags are waiting for me at the gate when I get off the plane. I also get to have both a window and an aisle seat on the plane since the plane is so small.
- highcountess 3y ago[dead]
- xingped 3y agoI've had bags destroyed or lost by baggage handlers more times than I can count. No thanks. I never check bags anymore.
- marssaxman 3y agoIndeed! It only takes a couple rounds of that mess to learn that anything you actually need has to be carried on, and once you're used to packing all of your necessities into carry-ons, it's easy to wonder "why am I bothering to bring all this other stuff"?
- bluGill 3y agoThe only things that need to be carried on are things that you need for the first two days. After that your luggage will be found and you have it again. If you only travel for a 3 day trip then carry everything on. However for longer trips I like to have a weeks worth of clothing (particularly if it is personal so I don't have to spend time and money at a laundromat). It is very nice to have a weeks worth of clothing but not have to carry it all with me on the plane. Actually on the way home I prefer if my luggage is lost as then they deliver it to my house for me instead of my having to carry it.
- josefresco 3y agoRelated: On my last flight there were so many carry-on bags they ran out of room. They forced the people boarding last to check their carry-on bags. What some people consider a "carry-on" is debatable. The enforcement of carry-on sizing limits seems spotty at best.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThat happens every flight.
- romanhn 3y agoThis happened on the last 4-5 flights for me, at least. If flying with family, can be a nice "optimization" to pack into carry-ons and check them all in for free, when offered (sometimes when checking into the flight, sometimes at the gate). Interestingly, I had one such full flight where the overhead bins clearly ended up with a ton of free space so perhaps others went with the same strategy.
- fransje26 3y ago> They forced the people boarding last to check their carry-on bags. For free, I hope?
- paholg 3y agoWhat they describe has happened to me many times. It's always a free gate-check. Sometimes the bags are unloaded at the gate, sometimes you have to go to baggage claim.
- jjav 3y ago> On my last flight there were so many carry-on bags they ran out of room. Not just your last flight, it is now intentional and it happens on just about every flight. They even stopped pretending and now they announce that if you're in the last few boarding groups the space will run out before you get there. It's just another money grab to get people to pay for earlier boarding to have a chance to keep their stuff. Back 20-30 years ago this never happened, there was always room for carryons.
- xnx 3y agoWould be interested to see a formula more like dimensional weight used by shippers: some combination of weight (including passenger), volume, and number of units.
- hollosi 3y agoFocusing solely on taxes misses the point that most people do not fully utilize "included" baggage allowances on domestic trips, and that is pure profit. Let's assume a $40 bag fee: $25 cost to handle the bag, $3 tax, $12 profit. If people pay for the bags separately, in addition to their $220 ticket, they will only pay for utilized bags, so for 1 bag, the profit will be $12. If the $300 ticket bundle includes 2 allowed bags, but people only check 1 bag, then the profit is: $80 - 2$6 (tax) - 1$25 (cost) = $49 profit, more than 4 times bigger! The real reason is the comparison sites as the HN commenters pointed out, but the result is not always bad, because the savings is real in many cases as people indeed would only pay for one bag on average ($220+$40 = $260) instead of $300. I think airlines are much less happy with the separated fees than consumers, but once one airline does it, the others are forced to do it. The same happened with the international trips, which clearly has no tax reason. Many years ago it included 2 pieces of 70-pound bags, then 2 50-pound bags, then 1 50-pound bag, and now in many cases, on basic tickets, nothing at all.
- highcountess 3y ago[dead]
- amelius 3y agoI just wear a coat with insanely large pockets. Good luck charging for that!
- JohnFen 3y agoWhat I like about airlines charging separately for checked bags is that it means people like myself who don't check bags at all[1] don't have to pay for something we aren't using. [1] I ship my luggage ahead to my destination through a parcel carrier service. It's a habit I started a long time ago to ensure that my luggage will get to where I'm going in good condition. It also lets me skip one of the things that makes flying unpleasant. Additionally, post-9/11, it brings the benefit of not having to put up with the TSA pawing through it.