9 ms·
I don't really understand the privacy concern here. To wit: insurers can demand actual inspection of your home when making underwriting decisions. The condition
by tptacek 3y ago
I don't really understand the privacy concern here. To wit: insurers can demand actual inspection of your home when making underwriting decisions. The condition of your house is very much their business. Why is an aerial photograph of your roof, which everybody in the world already has on Google Maps, such a big deal?
- worik 3y agoThe problem is the culling Insurance companies are very keen to get as much risk as possible off their books before the climate gets even more extreme in its volatility Good goes with bad, so long as the bad goes, some good going too is undesirable but OK because they are aware if the catastrophic climate events looming The insurance companies are behaving logically, probably legally IANAL, but for people who are simply caught in the wash it is unfair This is part of the huge systematic disruptions we are all going to have to adapt to, or die from, due to climate change Worrying times
- Nifty3929 3y agoInsurance companies are keen to align risks with premiums. The more accurately they do so, the less volatility they will have. And in the short run, probably more profit as well. This also helps consumers, where lower-risk folks will overpay less, and higher-risk folks will be required to lower their risk or contribute more in premiums.
- tptacek 3y agoYou (say) have a trampoline. I do not. We share an insurer. Our insurer asked, when you applied, if you had a trampoline. Your trampoline materially increases the risk that insurance is going to have to pay to cover a lawsuit on your property. You lied, and said you didn't. I am now paying to subsidize your trampoline. Why shouldn't I want them to be running drones over our houses? Worrying times... for pirate trampolines!
- RomanAlexander 3y agoWouldn't said trampoline simply not be covered by the policy since you lied about it? The agents are checking a box and the underwriter is sticking in a boilerplate "Customer said no trampoline therefore trampolines are excluded from this policy" text
- tptacek 3y agoIt depends on the policy, but either way, this is the kind of risk we're talking about managing with culls: trampolines, and bad roofs. I pay to keep my house up. You (say) don't. Why should I be OK with subsidizing your resulting claims with higher rates? I think there's a sort of weird subtext in the "risk pooling" discussions on this thread that "risk pooling" is a way for people who don't replace their old roofs to get protection from the people who do. But that's not at all the concept! You refusing you repair your roof isn't an act of god; it's just recklessness.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoYou seem to be forgetting that this avoidance can work at two times: 1. pre-emptively dropping or refusing coverage 2. claim inspectors concluding the company has no liability for a particular incident. It doesn't all need to be #2 (and probably should not be), but it also doesn't all need to be #1 either.
- hattmall 3y ago#2 is less successful and incurs more costs. Trampolines are a good one because let's say you lie about a trampoline. Ok, great, we don't have to cover any trampoline related injuries. What are the chances that you would then lie and say that a broken arm occured on the steps instead and simply fail to mention the trampoline like you already did.
- tptacek 3y agoYou, the rogue trampoline owner, aren't really the party that the insurer is worried about. Your kid's best friend's parents are. (And it's not a broken arm they're really freaked out about --- don't make a homeowners claim over a broken arm, probably; it'll cost you more in the medium term --- it's death or paralysis, both of which will put millions of dollars on the line).
- wombatpm 3y agoInsurance companies want money to come in and never go out. If they could they would sell life insurance to dead people and homeowners insurance to the homeless.
- tptacek 3y agoThe irony here is that's what insurance customers want, too: to incur arbitrary risks and have other more responsible customers pay for them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nothercastle 3y agoCustomers want to pool risks with other customers that are lower risk than they are. Florida homeowner want to be on a national market because they are the highest risk group. Obviously the rest of us want Florida to be separate.
- tptacek 3y agoIt's good to want things! But if you're a bad driver, you don't get to pool with people with zero accidents and tickets.
- lobsterthief 3y agoThis is a really bad analogy that doesn’t hold water. There are good drivers and bad drivers. There are also good homeowners and bad homeowners. I live in Florida, but chose not to live in a flood-prone area. We also have hurricane clips on our roof, and we just changed all our windows to impact-resistant windows (with the help of a state-sponsored program, actually). Our insurance isn’t that high at all. Could it be lower? Sure, I’d love that. And maybe a national program would do that. Modern building codes require things like impact windows and that the building be rated for high winds. Older buildings should be retrofitted with things like impact windows, but I would only call those homeowners “bad drivers” if they can afford to do so but don’t. I wouldn’t blame an elderly person on fixed income for not affording to do this and call them a “bad driver”. I’ve walked around San Francisco quite a bit since my company is based out of there, and I’ve seen a lot of people retrofitting their houses with those diagonal beams for earthquakes. San Francisco is waiting for the “big one”; is anyone who can’t dump money into living in a safer building, or retrofitting the one they own, the equivalent of a “bad driver”? Obviously not. FYI in Tampa, also called the “Bay Area” to locals, we’re also waiting for “the big one” (a CAT-4 or CAT-5 coming directly into shallow Tampa Bay, which would cause an enormous storm surge). That last happened in 1918 or so and it actually permanently changed the geography where it came in, creating an area known as Hurricane Pass. All we can do is prepare and be responsible to our communities. Anyways, you can’t lump all people in a geography, regardless of behavior, into one group. It does a disservice to the people who are doing the right thing. Unless your building has been fully retrofitted for [insert local disaster] or you chose to live outside of [insert worst geography in your area to live with regards to local disaster], then you’re a “bad driver” too.
- delfinom 3y agoLol my dude, trampolines in backyards being a rejection reason has nothing to do with climate change. Yes climate change has caused an upheaval in some geographical regions. But there are many economic forces at play, from the treatment of real estate as an investment making every home a million dollars to insurers all being reinsured by a ever smaller pool of reinsurers.
- xyzelement 3y agoat least in the United States, home insurance is issued a year at a time. So it doesn’t make sense to cull today in anticipation of some hypothetical future shift towards cataclysm. Also, what is the aerial photo of a roof going to indicate in terms of “cataclysmic climate events looming”? Also is it a coincidence or a pun that your name is worik and it is common for you to sign your posts with something about worrying?
- sarchertech 3y agoIt’s an issue of scale. Similar to police tracking phones. Police have always been able to assign an officer to follow a suspect, but it’s expensive and therefore rarely done. If insurance companies can cheaply inspect everyone’s house from space, the end result will be to lower prices for people with homes in perfect condition and raise them for everyone else. This is potentially problematic because the people with houses in poor condition are the least able to afford added costs in general.
- tptacek 3y agoWhy is it not a good thing if insurance is more accurately priced? Insurance isn't a redistribution mechanism. And dilapidated roofs aren't a social good. Municipalities have actual redistribution schemes to make these kinds of repairs. I'll note that there's nothing at all redistributive about sneaking a trampoline onto your property, too. Further, I'll note that working class people also take pride in their houses and pay to keep them up, and they too are being asked to subsidize people who are getting rate breaks from false assessments. Later My municipality will make an interest-free loan of up to $25,000 to cover the kinds of property repairs we're discussing, if you're income-qualified (ie: not too rich to just pay to replace your own roof).
- drekipus 3y agoIsn't insurance entirely a redistribution mechanism?
- tptacek 3y agoNot in the sense evoked by customer purchasing power.
- compiler-guy 3y agoNo. It’s a risk pooling mechanism. If a group of ten people all have a one in one-thousand per year chance of a million-dollar loss each year, then their annual premium will be: 10 x 0.001 x $1,000,000 = $10,000 (plus some administrative overhead and assuming a very basic risk model) It has nothing to do with who is rich and who is poor or making anyone come out ahead of their own losses.
- imgabe 3y agoI think the issue is that in some cases the information is inaccurate and there are sometimes limited avenues for a customer to object if their insurance is cancelled based on inaccurate information. To the extent that the information is accurate, I agree. If you make an agreement with a company and buy insurance based on your statement that you don't have a pool, but then you do have a pool, I don't see any reason why we should be upset that you didn't get away with lying to the insurance company.
- londons_explore 3y agoThey can also use the info to decide if they allow a renewal. They can decide not to renew for any reason - including that they just decided not to do house insurance at all anymore.
- tptacek 3y agoThey can generally decline coverage for any reason, for what it's worth; they could cancel without aerial footage just on the hunch that you didn't replace your roof, or they could mass-mail their customers demanding proof of roof replacements. (The article and other things I'm reading suggest that cancellations are because footage finds trampolines and pools --- in which case I don't even understand how anybody can have sympathy. It's fine to have insurance risks on your property! But disclose them!)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- everybodyknows 3y agoIt's interesting that insurers will spend money to discover this rather than rely on the pro forma clause that claims proceeding from an undisclosed risk are invalid. I'm guessing they calculate that a jury may not respect that part of the contract when confronted in court by grieving parents of an accident victim.
- ssl-3 3y ago
- gxs 3y agoIn these cases, the argument is always of the type you just mentioned. “What’s the big deal the data is already available, relax”. On top of that, it comes with an air of condescension as if no one had ever thought about that before. One concern with things like this is that it’s different when you have to send someone out to inspect a home vs inspecting thousands of homes at a time. Once you have data in that volume, you can start to infer things that do borderline encroach on privacy. What is the case here, and it might be what you were trying to point out, is that this kind of data is already collected regularly and is by the books legal. The concern here is simply at the application. At this point the cats out of the bag and the best we can hope for is at least some level of protection through legislation.
- tptacek 3y agoAgain: insurers can and do demand home inspections when underwriting. This is strictly less intrusive than common existing practices in insurance.
- gxs 3y agoThe irony of starting a comment with again when you yourself didn’t read the reply. I acknowledged that all this info is already out there. That insurance companies can demand to inspect your home. And even further that that this aerial footage is already widely available. My comment was specifically calling out that collecting data one house inspection at a time is different than collecting data at high volumes. But let’s gloss over the fact that someone didn’t even fully disagree with you, but even then you couldn’t get over that one point that you didn’t like.
- bsder 3y agoAn insurance company should be required to go through a legal process before they are able to drop people. Sure, an undeclared pool is a problem. However, the insurance company should have to put the pictures into evidence and allow a legal rebuttal. Bureaucracies get things incorrect like "wrong address" all the time. People need the right to challenge these behemoths. We've been through this once already in the US--it was called "rescission" in healthcare until the ACA made it moot by requiring coverage of preexisting conditions. It's a bad thing and invariably needs to be made illegal.
- tptacek 3y agoWe require coverage of preexisting conditions in a bargain that involves coverage mandates (since struck down) and continuous coverage / enrollment periods. And health insurance is the primary payment gateway to a deeply distorted market that relies utterly on insurers to take payments, which is not something that is true of the housing market. I don't think I have too much of my identity invested in whether homeowners insurers need due process to not renew contracts, but I guess I'd argue the other side of that one. Either way: hard to see the privacy issue.
- el_benhameen 3y agoI saw one case where a guy was dropped because of an aerial photo of a pile of junk in his yard. I’ve had piles of junk in my yard during various remodeling projects. If the satellite passes over the day before the dump run, there’s no way to tell that the junk was gone the next day. If there’s an inspection, it’s easily explained. I suppose you could offer an explanation for the satellite photo, but in that case you’ve already been dropped, so getting your policy reinstated is going to be a much bigger lift.
- tptacek 3y agoYou're supposed to notify your insurer when you remodel!
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoGiven that my insurer has never once stepped foot in any property of mine they've ever insured, the idea that I have to tell them when I replace the tiles in the bathroom seems a little ... crazy. Obviously, if I add rooms or extend vertically, they need to know. But "remodel" covers a lot.
- el_benhameen 3y agoOk, “remodel” was maybe not the right word here. Projects large enough to generate a sizable pile of junk, but not ones that materially altered the structure of the house. Replacing built-in shelves with a built-in desk, replacing a non-elevated deck without altering the footprint, etc. My point is more that a totally reasonable and brief occurrence becomes permanent and without context in satellite imagery.
- harimau777 3y agoI think that one difference might be that physical inspections don't scale. It seems to me that the current systems working (for regular people) requires that insurers not be too good at assessing risks. The better the insurer is at assessing risk the closer insurance gets to providing no value to the insured.
- wisty 3y agoInsurers don't on average provide value. If a risk can't be assessed, they will only offer a policy if they think it's value to them at the price they charge.
- spoonjim 3y agoInsurance can provide value even when risk is assessed perfectly! If everyone has a 1 in 100,000 chance of a $100,000 damage incident, they will have to keep $100,000 of savings to make sure they can avoid becoming homeless from an accident. But by paying $1.25 in insurance, (25% profit to the insurer), they can use their $100,000 for other purposes and generate much more than $1.25 in income from it.
- toss1 3y agoNot Quite - only if risk is spread across the whole pool does it provide the value you describe. If risk is assessed perfectly, they know that Alan's & Charles' houses will not have a fire, but Bob's house will burn. Alan and Charles (and all the others) pay only the $0.25 overhead/profit, while Bob must pay the $125,000 ratings +profit. Insurance basically disappears, as it adds no value, and we go back to being self-insured.
- squidgyhead 3y agoIn terms of sheer game-theoretic value, sure, perfect knowledge will reduce value gaps. However, the thing with having your house insured is that you will have somewhere to live if you have a house fire. The +/- for the insurer might be close, but going from having a house to having no house is a bigger deal than going from one house to a twice-as-expensive house.
- 3y ago
- barrysteve 3y agoDemanding an inspection is a process that can be organized and scheduled around. Your friend brings over a trampoline for Timmy's birthday party, you can take the risk of injury with no intent to claim on insurance. You can remove it before inspection. Now you get pinged out of the blue by a satellite. Adults don't need constant supervision. Should you believe they do, why not leave a multi-camera drone above your suburb and every insured house can be monitored for infractions 24/7. There is no reason for the insurance company to withhold the image as evidence of a problem. Google Maps knows where my trampolines are, why is the insurance company hiding their cards? An insurance company that surveils you 24/7 and makes sure you comply, is not covering any risk, it's a protection racket.
- tptacek 3y agoYou can remove it before inspection Yes, if they do a scheduled inspection, it is easier to defraud them.
- barrysteve 3y agoA trampoline used with no injury, is not defrauding the insurance company.
- windexh8er 3y agoI'm sorry but this comment makes no sense. Where did you get that insurance companies are now "surveiling you 24/7"? If my insurance goes up, and it has, because of people defrauding insurance companies then I would fully expect my insurer to protect their bottom line and my rates by dropping those customers playing unfairly. What I don't agree with is insurance companies punting the decision making process to an algorithm. At that rate we end up with Google "support" from a company that, as paying customers, we should be able to have a conversation with. The last thing I'll mention is that it goes a long way to know your insurance broker. As an example I've known mine for the last ~15 years and they have helped remediate a number of, what I'll describe as standard process issues, when I've contacted them and in a few cases even proactively.
- 3y ago