6 ms·
Playboy image from 1972 gets ban from IEEE computer journals
- matt3210 3y agoWhy is it now suddenly a problem? I recall this from many of my DSP books
- brokensegue 3y agoSuddenly? People have been talking about this as an issue for a long time
- ecmascript 3y ago[flagged]
- dalanmiller 3y agoShe asked for her image to stop being used.
- Biganon 3y ago[flagged]
- wizerdrobe 3y agoThe entire article presses the social angle and buries the ask from Lena, in all fairness to ‘ecmascript
- lostlogin 3y agoBuried? Is the second paragraph too deep?
- unethical_ban 3y agoRespecting the wishes of the subject of the image has nothing to do with diversity statements. Maybe it's right to retire the image if she doesn't like it being used, but shame on IEEE for turning into a sham diversity stunt.
- ecmascript 3y agoAs I've mentioned above, I did read the article but I don't see how it makes a difference.
- ecmascript 3y agoI know, I read the article. So what? She got paid for the image (according to the article) and she was a model. If you sell a picture to me you can't come back 40 years later demanding me to stop using it just because it was successful, even if the picture is of you. People accuse me of not reading, while seemingly not reading the entire thing themselves.
- wizerdrobe 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DonHopkins 3y ago[flagged]
- userbinator 3y ago[flagged]
- matt3210 3y ago[flagged]
- pgeorgi 3y agoShe's a lady who asked that this image is taken out of circulation.
- akoboldfrying 3y agoTrue. In 2019, at the prompting of a film crew making a documentary about how damaging it was for her image to be in wide circulation, and who presumably paid for her time, Lena asked for her picture to be taken out of circulation. As recently as earlier that year, her views were much closer to my own [0]: >When I asked [Lena] if she had heard anything about the recent controversy around her image, she seemed alarmed at the thought that she could have a part in hurting or discouraging young women. I sent her some articles about the Lenna and later gave her a call to see what she made of them. The photo, she said, doesn’t show very much—just down to her shoulders—so it was hard for her to see what the big deal was. [0]: https://www.wired.com/story/finding-lena-the-patron-saint-of-jpegs/ https://www.wired.com/story/finding-lena-the-patron-saint-of...
- pgeorgi 3y agoShe still doesn't say that the photo is a big deal. "presumably paid for her time" is an interesting insinuation, as it disenfranchises her of her voice just because somebody put a camera in front of her. Do you think she wasn't paid some consultancy fee for dealing with that Wired journo? Do we have to figure out now who paid more? One of the reasons IEEE mentioned is that it's a bad representative for contemporary digital imagery (resolution, color range, etc), so that alone is reason enough to look for alternatives. The most recent statement of the model is "let's retire [it]," even before she didn't seem to care much. I suppose the interesting question is why you're so hung up on having that photo in new scientific publications.
- akoboldfrying 3y ago
- kalleboo 3y agoThey should ban it just because it's a poor image. The colors are unnatural, it is low resolution (blurry) and has a bunch of weird line noise, it's just not representative. The obsession with sticking to it has always seemed odd to me.
- sitkack 3y agoethically sourced https://mortenhannemose.github.io/lena/ https://mortenhannemose.github.io/lena/ from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35010229 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35010229
- roenxi 3y agoYou're probably jesting; but it'd be more representative of the computing industry if we used a picture of a male. It is an interesting philosophical question of whether that would be an improvement.
- bitwize 3y agoI think the most appropriate response to this kerfuffle was when an all-female team of researchers published an image processing paper... using Fabio as a test image.
- sitkack 3y agoThat was a great paper Stable image reconstruction using total variation minimization https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Stable-Image-Reconstruction-Using-Total-Variation-Needell-Ward/99a2a73c43962cf3c69a57db3b1f95e72a48e33e https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Stable-Image-Reconstru...
- Shawnj2 3y agoThe issue with Lena is objectification, the equivalent male photo would be like a picture of the chest of a bodybuilder.
- ml-anon 3y ago[flagged]
- gregoriol 3y agoNot so different from the "main" branch story
- realjhol 3y agoThen main branch story was utterly ludicrous. Imagine thinking that you were helping the world in any way by changing the name of a git branch
- MaKey 3y agoKubernetes changing terminology from master to control-plane actually caused a reddit outage. It's ridiculous.
- pgeorgi 3y agoThere have been issues with git's master->main transition as well, once automated systems came into play that expected to find a master branch. This is also my main complaint about that particular episode: Too much "somebody needs to do something" mandates, and too little "how to do it properly" (which would provide benefits for other situations as well.) When the two parts of the activity are split between two different groups, there's no incentive, either: The mandate group checks a box and walks away happily, having reached their OKR. The implementation group doesn't get the devops time to implement proper aliasing and what-have-you, so they just wing it until everything works again. That said, it's mostly water under the bridge right now, and it isn't applicable at all for the "reference image for computer graphics papers" situation unless somebody starts rewriting all the old papers to reference a different image: A "somebody needs to do something" mandate would likely lead to new versions of the old papers in which the image is removed without replacement. The "do it right" solution would lead to people replicating the research with different material, which might not even be for the worst - but I see no chance that will happen at scale.
- lmpdev 3y agoJustice aside: Aren’t there more technical solutions to DSP/image processing reference images that enable readers to get a more accurate assessment of results in a shorter time span? Or are humans naturally that hard-wired to commonplace imagery? I know colour perception for instance is extremely biased based on the context around it, so a Monet is perceived radically differently than for instance, a Pantone Catalogue in isolation
- a_e_k 3y agoMakes sense to me, though I've noticed that it's surprisingly hard to find a good alternative test image. This one has: - Fine directional texture (the weave of the hat, hair) - Fine non-directed texture (the feathers) - Fine detail (eye glint, lashes) - Medium texture (reflected hair) - Sharp edges - Curved edges (mirror frame, shoulder) - Smooth gradients (skin, blurred beams on left) - A closeup face - Color - Strong contrasts I'd love to see a consensus around a good alternative high-resolution test image that has a bit of all of that (and maybe with a Macbeth chart thrown in somewhere too) with appropriate licensing, but none of the suggested alternatives (e.g., cameraman, mandrill) that I've seen quite have everything or are of any better resolution. One source that I have recently been using for test images for my experiments, though, is the Wikimedia Commons Picture of the Year finalists collection: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Picture_of_the_Year https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Picture_of_the_Ye...
- kakakiki 3y agoI am just making a wild suggestion here. May be ask AI to generate one with the above prompt?
- Shawnj2 3y agoIf you want your image processing algorithm to be optimized for the real world you should test against real photos. It’s not like we have a shortage of photos so synthetic data is absolutely necessary
- barfbagginus 3y agoGive me ten k and I'll make the AI take the prompt and return the best stock image, guaranteed The optimal lenna replacer, for boomers who think they can reasonably belabor this point Just pay me up front, papi needs a quick cash fix scratches their neck and tries to swivel their head 360 degrees
- Shawnj2 3y ago
- mongol 3y agoWhat would the ideal image be? Perhaps not a human, but an animal? A cat perhaps? White with dark spots, and thin whiskers.
- ggm 3y agoRetrospective testing of old image sw with a new image and ux through CAPTCHA "are these images the same"
- low_tech_love 3y agoIn the spectrum of postmodern quasi-meaningless decisions made to give some appearance of action to appease people who are more likely to complain than do something useful, this is on the harmless side. What really bothers me is the underlying idea that a picture of a beautiful woman is offensive. It seems like we’re on a path of “regression to the mean” where only mediocrity is acceptable, and anything remarkable is offensive. If I felt offended every time I saw a picture of a man more beautiful (and attractive) than me I might as well disconnect and go live in the woods.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoIt’s not about the woman being beautiful. It’s about the in-joke where the cropped image itself is tame but the implicit context is pornographic. This in joke makes (many) women uncomfortable, I think. Personally I don’t care either way, I just like to understand differing perspectives. Being offended by this one seems fairly reasonable as far as things go though.
- low_tech_love 3y agoI guess being offended or not by this is entirely subjective, as we can see from our wildly different perspectives on the matter. I guess that’s why we should never base a ban on it, right?
- ml-anon 3y agoReplace Lena.jpg with calm.jpg
- politelemon 3y agoTrying to imagine the reverse, if I were in a field dominated by women and there were "Lenny" images used frequently and used as an in joke or commonality, I think I'd feel uncomfortable too as would many of us. From the comments I'm seeing though, I don't believe we're exercising the empathy needed to understand.
- roenxi 3y ago
- anonymousiam 3y agoLena is a mainstay of computer imaging calibration. It's silly and stupid to make any claims of harm to anyone from use of the image. Don't let the culture overlords tell you what is right and wrong. Use your common sense.
- PlunderBunny 3y agoMy common sense says that if a woman doesn’t want a photograph of herself used in a particular way, then continuing to use it is clearly wrong.
- xdennis 3y agoNothing works that way. Any politician could dodge criticism by saying "I don't myself depicted in that particular way".
- PlunderBunny 3y agoOk, I think it’s fair to say it’s not an absolute rule. But there’s a big difference between publishing a picture of a politician against their wishes and a model’s glamour shot. There’s often a legitimate public interest in documenting the activities of politicians, sometimes even their private lives.
- GaryNumanVevo 3y agoDon't contort this narrative into a "culture overlords" conspiracy. The original model, Lena Forsén, has asked that the image be retired.
- ralfd 3y agoAnd before that Forsén was a long time fine with it, but this didn’t stop the push to ban the image.
- GaryNumanVevo 3y ago
- keepamovin 3y agoThis is not enough. They need to travel back in time to 1972 and make sure this history never existed. /S I like the alt ones where people have created a guy version of this photo. Super cute! https://mortenhannemose.github.io/lena/ https://mortenhannemose.github.io/lena/ Hahaha! :)
- SpecialistK 3y agoI think it's a reflection of a lot of culture war stuff that so many comments are about the ethics of the image and the opinions of the subject of a photograph and all this other really difficult philosophical argument stuff when it really seems much more simple than that: 40 years ago we used one particular image to test compression and certain DSP operations. Now in the age of CGI, TBs rather than KBs of storage / bandwidth, and the internet, we can use a suite of examples. These can be more varied, more controlled, and less encumbered by copyright or being from an erotic publication. MP3 was apparently tested against the a capella song "Tom's Diner." Nice song, lots of detail on the voice. But is the benchmark I want to be using nowadays for Opus and AAC? Probably not. It's a shame rules have to be made to force behavior. But whatever people's philosophical views, it should be a prompt to ensure we do have things to fill this role that have benefited from those last 40 years of development.
- ralfd 3y agoI mostly agree, but: > It's a shame rules have to be made to force behavior. „Have to“ is doing a lot of heavy lifting in the sentence. Is this rule really necessary (because Lena’s gaze is just to enticing and leading the whole field astray)? Or is it just a method for moral crusaders to declare victory and their morals as supreme?
- low_tech_love 3y agoIt is not as simple as you put because the decision was not technical, it was political/ideological. To discuss its technical relevance is meaningless; everybody knows the image is bad and should not be used in 2024. The fact that it is still used is a testament to the deplorable situation of academia itself, but has nothing to do with this ban. They banned it because (a few, very loud) women felt uncomfortable about it and decided to turn it into a crusade. And IEEE (as with most other organizations nowadays) are rightfully scared to make a fuss over something so small and petty. It's a small, almost meaningless loss for the IEEE, and a big meaningful win for those who actually care about something like this. And so it goes, little by little, they win.
- SpecialistK 3y ago
- lordfrito 3y agoWhat the heck is an advertising documentary? Sounds like Orwellian Newspeak for plain old propaganda / astroturfing. Nothing of importance has changed here. Looking at the picture, I fail to see why this is so controversial. I guess somebody doesn't like that it was in Playboy at one point? This is a picture people, not a mountain to die on. Who paid $$$ to send this message? Why?
- foverzar 3y agoWhat a sad instance of pointless puritanism.