7 ms·
A muon collider could revolutionize particle physics, if it can be built
- rrix2 3y agojust one more accelerator bro. just one slightly larger accelerator than the one we just got online. we can revolutinize physics with just one more accelerator bro
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe article is about a much smaller accelerator. > A muon collider could be much smaller and cheaper than a functionally equivalent proton collider, advocates say. It could fit on the 2750-hectare campus of the United States’s dedicated particle physics lab, Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (Fermilab), enabling the U.S. to reclaim the lead in the continuing competition for the highest energy collider. Most important, younger physicists say, it might be built sooner than a more conventional competitor, perhaps in as few as 25 years. “If you want you can add 10 years to that, that’s still a lot better than when I’m dead,” Holmes says.
- rrix2 3y ago:) When I made the joke I was thinking about energy levels and theoretical physicists'/string theorists insistence that we're just a bit more energy away from evidence of the grand unified theory
- Dylan16807 3y agoI'm pretty sure they don't insist on that. Also we haven't built a collider that's even close to the collision energies of the SSC, which was cancelled mid-construction over 30 years ago. We're still playing catch-up.
- PaulHoule 3y agoOne interesting thing about muon accelerators is that they could produce enough neutrinos to be dangerous: https://accelconf.web.cern.ch/p99/PAPERS/WEBR6.PDF https://accelconf.web.cern.ch/p99/PAPERS/WEBR6.PDF which might be a good thing in that the neutrino mass is a "missing part of the standard model" as opposed to "possible physics beyond the standard model". The neutrino mass term could explain dark matter, dark energy and the matter-antimatter asymmetry https://arxiv.org/abs/1303.6912 https://arxiv.org/abs/1303.6912 whereas a Higgs Factory or top factory seems likely to be a big disappointment because all the evidence we have is that the Higgs field is as simple as it could possibly be and a top factory might end up just verifying that complex calculations people did 40 years ago (by the time the machine comes up) were right. Muon colliders are a possible path to a Higgs factory or top factory but the path to a muon accelerator that can revolutionize precise neutrino physics is much shorter and I think more rewarding. Notably neutrino physics is win-win. Either the right-handed neutrino exists as a heavy particle and is very likely to be the darkon or the neutrino is a Majorana fermion (is its own antiparticle) which is certainly a weird and interesting result. Contrast that to all the other poorly motivated darkon candidates such as sparticles, axions, etc. I remember reading a lot of papers about muon accelerators about 20 years ago, they have been a big research topic in the US and Japan because we didn't have CERN.
- rbanffy 3y ago> enough neutrinos to be dangerous That would have to be a huge amount of these little things.
- 3y ago
- f6v 3y agoI’m doing a PhD in quantitative field, not stupid by any means. But people doing physics seem out of this world to me. I feel like they’re just orders of magnitude smarter. It’s a shame the field seems a bit stagnant now. I hope they find a way to advance the knowledge without planet-scale accelerators. There should be a feasible and elegant compact solution.
- whatever1 3y agoThey do have insane pattern recognition skills when it comes to models. Good mathematicians also have this. But the good ones are very hard working too, in order to build a big enough library of building blocks.
- Jensson 3y ago> They do have insane pattern recognition skills when it comes to models. Good mathematicians also have this. The skills physicists and mathematicians build aren't very comparable. Physicists has the more complex equations and models, probably most complex of any field since physicists often invent new math to model things. Quantum field theory is insanely complicated math wise with infinite number of infinite integrals, mathematicians has still not figured out how to formalize that. Mathematicians focuses much less on modeling and equations so they aren't as good at that, instead they are much better at formal proofs and theorems. The skills are very different and doesn't translate well. Or in other words, physicists are experts at making complex math tools to model things. Mathematicians are experts at verifying tools that exists. Those two skills has less overlap than you might think.
- dylan604 3y agoTFA: The P5 report calls for R&D on a muon collider, stating, “This is our muon shot.” That just doesn't have the same ring to it as "moon shot". I hope they do not continue using this phrase. It doesn't have the same gravitas nor is it awe inspiring. I highly doubt it help earn funding. In fact, it leaves me with a negative charge.
- jjtheblunt 3y agoIt's just physicists and their quarky humor.
- Sharlin 3y ago> It doesn't have the same gravitas This just in: Physicists now refer to the proposed muon collider project as their "Sorry, We're Fresh Out Of Gravitas" shot.
- kjs3 3y ago"Sorry, We're Fresh Out Of Gravitas" is going to be the GSV name in my Ian Banks Culture fanfic.
- ok_dad 3y agoPeople should have more fun while doing important work. Being too serious when on the cutting edge leads to an overinflated ego.
- lapetitejort 3y agoI'm neutrino on the phrase
- bashinator 3y agoI think if you can find a way to reconcile gravitas with quantum field theory, you're in for several igNobel prizes.
- dylan604 3y agoNot any where close, but I do think I can save them money for building the new collider if they were to just use particle board.
- bell-cot 3y agoYou know you've read too much SF when...your first reaction to the title is "A time machine could revolutionize physics, if it can be built".
- rbanffy 3y agoWell... It could.
- perihelions 3y ago- "Decaying muons also radiate energetic neutrinos, creating a novel radiation safety challenge. Shooting horizontally from the collider ring, these elusive particles would zip through the earth and emerge dozens of kilometers away." I understand you have neutrinos leaking from the entire collider ring, along all the tangent rays? That fills out an entire geometric plane!
- delichon 3y agoMaybe the collider is the basis of a neutrino transmitter. The purpose of this study was to inspect the possibility of using neutrinos for communications for military submarines ... Because neutrinos are nearly unaffected by matter, a neutrino beam could traverse directly through the earth from the transmission site to the submarine. A directional beam would allow confidential information to be passed only to the intended recipient. Neutrino communications would also be totally jam-proof. As an additional benefit, a neutrino message could be received in the deepest of waters, leaving a submarine less vulnerable to enemy attacks. -- https://www.physics.ucla.edu/~hauser/neutrino_communication_paper/siljah_mod.htm But the conclusion isn't optimistic about the receiver.
- PaulHoule 3y agoAlready people do experiments where they shoot a proton beam at a target and then detect the resulting neutrino beam at a far distance, for instance https://www.dunescience.org/ https://www.dunescience.org/ and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_OPERA_faster-than-light_neutrino_anomaly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_OPERA_faster-than-light_n... A muon storage ring with straight sections would produce powerful beams in the direction of the straight sections when the muons decay which would produce orders of magnitude higher flux than existing accelerator neutrino experiments not to mention a highly collimated beam. (I am still amused by the superluminal neutrino flap because (a) it wasn't the first case where people thought they saw superluminal neutrinos, I remember seeing an experiment at Los Alamos Lab where curve fitting the neutrino mass was giving an imaginary (superluminal) number in the 1990s, and (b) it sounds so much like something out of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steins;Gate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steins;Gate) The OPERA experiment does show that if your equipment was calibrated properly you could possibly get a high data rate from turning your source on and off rapidly, however, I don't think you can turn a muon storage ring on and off.
- karol 3y agoI'll try without it.
- m0llusk 3y agoIt might be worth considering just how much other physics could be done with these resources. Improve education and experimentation for many other investigations instead. There is still much to learn about fluid dynamics, the chemistry of water, alternative plastics, and many other open questions. The vast amounts of resources poured into exotic reactors could educate many more physicists, launch many more satellites, and operate many more laboratories. Moving forward with very large projects may effectively starve out other investigations that might ultimately have far more practical applications. In some ways this proposal seems more like a lack of imagination than a positive surplus of imagination.
- bigbillheck 3y agoThat's all true, but they wouldn't spend the money on those kinds of things, they'd just buy more fighter jets.
- PaulHoule 3y agoI'd say that the "missing" neutrino mass term and the identity of the dark matter particle (quite likely a neutrino) are two of the most interesting problems in physics and I'm afraid that Team LHC's interest in (I think boring) Higgs and Top factories could crowd out investment in the much more interesting area of neutrino physics the way that you say. The good news is that going down the muon accelerator route you probably need to build a neutrino factory to validate the technology long before you can build those other things.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 3y agoWasn't that what was said for the LHC?
- vouaobrasil 3y agoI feel like this sort of research cannot be good in either direction: it seems like a waste of money and resources for society to fund this and other abstract things which can only lead to amusing mathematical models that will have zero impact on society, which is a bad thing because we have very real problems. But, if it DOES lead anywhere, the technology could be devastating and we're probably too stupid to use it. Seems pointless to me.
- jstummbillig 3y agoThat's one too many conditionals in the title to not be a little suspicious. Exciting, still.
- casey2 3y agoBuilding more colliders isn't what I would call a revolution, more like status quo. What would be a revolution is if a series of scientifically sound (tabletop) experiments started advancing the field.
- parhamn 3y ago> if a series of scientifically sound (tabletop) experiments Does fruit hanging this low still exist?
- floxy 3y agohttps://news.stanford.edu/2019/09/25/precision-physics-tabletop-experiments/ https://news.stanford.edu/2019/09/25/precision-physics-table... https://phys.org/news/2014-12-world-compact-tabletop-particle.html https://phys.org/news/2014-12-world-compact-tabletop-particl...
- peterfirefly 3y agoFor a sufficiently long table: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AWAKE https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AWAKE https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_acceleration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_acceleration Nobody knows if wakefield accelerators will be good enough but they are improving fast and they aren't too expensive to build.
- ndngmfksk 3y agoThere is a recent e+e- Higgs factory proposal called HALHF, with the e-'s accelerated by plasma and the e+'s by a conventional accelerator. https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10150 https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10150
- ndngmfksk 3y agoIf such tabletop experiments were possible, then surely the particle physicists who use these colliders would be building them? As far as I can see, they're requesting colliders because to the best of their knowledge, colliders are necessary. A muon collider would be revolutionary in the sense that it would open up a new energy range for lepton collisions. It would also be a technological marvel.
- nlavezzo 3y agoThis is very cool. That said, it reminded me of a funny collider meme I saw recently: https://tinyurl.com/2k8u4dk6 https://tinyurl.com/2k8u4dk6
- UberFly 3y ago22 billion would be a bargain bro :)
- admissionsguy 3y agoWho needs sophons with people like that.
- audunw 3y agoSabine Hossenfelder would approve this meme
- manojlds 3y agoThe Trisolarans won't allow us to.
- sp332 3y agoThe LHC has been doing lead-lead collisions (occasionally) for a few years now. How much more energetic would this smaller muon reactor be?
- T-A 3y agoThe record energy reported last year was 5.36 TeV per nucleon pair [1]. That sounds like a lot until you remember that a nucleon is a bag of quarks held together by gluons. Having two of these things collide spends the per-nucleon energy on all of them, and produces a magnificent mess of strongly interacting particles which is very hard to analyze. So when the posted article says, muons are fundamental particles that put all their energy into a collision, enabling a muon collider to compete with a hadron collider running at 10 times the energy. So the muon collider could be much smaller and, hence, cheaper. A 10-TeV muon collider could be had for $18 billion, advocates estimate. it actually understates the case for a muon collider. It is not just more efficient, it's also cleaner, since muons, like electrons, don't do strong interactions. [1] https://inspirehep.net/literature/2716566 https://inspirehep.net/literature/2716566
- KingOfCoders 3y agoGive us more money.
- ungreased0675 3y agoI assume this will cost billions in government funding to create, which begs the question: What is the benefit to the ordinary person here? What kind of scientific discoveries could be unlocked? New devices that could be made? How would it improve society?