6 ms·
The wealth of the 1% just hit a record $44T
- coldtea 3y agoThe rest, however, will own nothing and (be forced to) be happy about it, or at least ok with it. Those margins have to come from somewhere... Nothing as in, no house because the prices are out of reach, no stable jobs because late stage capitalism/AI/the current crisis/whatever, no good furniture (IKEA, if we're lucky), no quality goods (because enshitification), no public infrastructure (becase late stage capitalism), no healthcare (because exorbitant charges and, in countries that had it, the slow killing of public healthcare), no voice (because politicians could not give less fucks for anybody who is not a sponsor), and even our software we don't increasingly own, we just rent... But some on HN make $250K/month and higher, so "everything is fine", it's not like there is a huge majority in the situation I describe. Why even acknowlegde the rest of the population exists, unless it's for virtue signalling about caring for the underprivileged on some status update?
- bamboozled 3y agoI think people are so much more capable then we're told we are. I know that it's easy for me to say this because I do have a decent job, I don't make anywhere near ($250k a month btw) but I came from a family who lost everything in World War II and rebuilt their lives in another country with practically no money. They were resourceful. They could build furniture, houses, restore and fix things, grow food raise chickens etc. Mostly they learned this out of necessity because prior to the war, they were farmers and living pretty self sufficient lives. I'm not saying everyone can do this but I think a LOT of people, no matter their situation, can improve things a lot out of their own hard work, ingenuity and determination. Your comment about relying on rubbish like IKEA is what spurred my comment. There is so many cheap second hand super high quality tools and building materials available now that you can practically build anything you need for very cheap. So much knowledge available for nearly free about how to stay healthy that it's ridiculous. Just because most people rely on modern convenience and buy into that system, doesn't mean you need to.
- pixelatedindex 3y agoWhen it comes to housing the problem is land in an area where you get jobs. Hopefully remote work will spread that out more fairly. > I don't make anywhere near ($250k a month btw) Is this a typo? 250K/mo is filthy rich money.
- imposterr 3y agoThere are, in fact, many filthy rich folks on here.
- bamboozled 3y agoI make a fraction of that, so don't try apply it to me.
- bamboozled 3y agoThe parent wrote that, not me. I was replying to that.
- up2isomorphism 3y agoThe strategy is very simple: since if you are poor, you can not hold your money because you can not afford to invest, and your money eventually goes to the richest. So the government just tax the middle class, keep inflation high, which effectively transfers the money from them to the richest.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- forgotmyinfo 3y agoAnxiously awaiting all of the "this is good, akshually" posts while ten more people file for bankruptcy because they took an ill-timed ambulance ride to the ER.
- elevatedastalt 3y agoI know your post is incorrect, because there is no good timing for an ambulance ride. It will always bankrupt you.
- defrost 3y agoIn G20 countries other than the USofA with <gasp> social policies this is not the case. Ambulances are either free (if part of a low annual fee Ambulance cover network) or capped at affordable, or subsidised if unemployed | disability | etc. In Australia my brothers trip to hospital for an emergancy stent following a blocked heart artery involved an ambulance, two and days in hospital, and keyhole surgery. Total cost to him, $400 for ambulance due to no cover, hospital + surgery free via public cover (from his taxes).
- speff 3y agoWife had to get an ambulance ride a few years ago in the US. She was apprehensive of getting it because this - wrong - information is repeated over and over online. It and the hospital trip cost a few hundred with insurance. This is why we don't listen to people on the internet.
- subharmonicon 3y agoSounds like pure luck. My ambulance was “out of network” (as if I had any choice in the matter) and the charges were “unreasonable” for the services provided per the insurance company. They initially billed me for $7k. I eventually got the insurance to pay $3k of that. So $4k out of pocket. [edit to add this] I did hear on the radio that a bill was passed in California recently to help fix this to some extent but I don’t recall the details. I believe it goes into effect mid-2024.
- bamboozled 3y agoAt some stage, it needs to stop. Whether by some type of natural economic disaster or political intervention. This is wild. Seems like an out of control infection at the moment.
- pixelatedindex 3y agoIt needs to stop but won’t be by either of those methods. They have enough money to build shelters to evade the economic disasters, and if they can’t evade it then regular folk don’t really stand a chance either. Political intervention is also unlikely because they bankroll the politicians and money is not coming out of politics due to citizens united. A revolution might be a good bet, but it probably will be thwarted like in China or Russia. Too many people also believe the money is well earned.
- bamboozled 3y agoWell the only thing that protects the top 1% wealth is the poorer people that will continuously be affected by this. By poorer people I mean police and all of the delicate systems that enables police to exist. Without law enforcement, there is absolutely no way these people could hang on to their wealth.
- latency-guy2 3y agoYou're not winning hearts and minds by implying poor people would be violent lawless creatures raping and pillaging the world on a whim.
- bamboozled 3y agoI'm not implying this, but there is no way that one guy should have hundreds of billions and the next person should have zilch and starve. The only thing that protects such an unfair system is the law. If those enforcing the law are poor enough, they will take what they require. So they should IMO.
- tryptophan 3y agoThank you, central banking for printing money all day to give to investors and making sure to "protect" the markets with timely interventions.
- mjfl 3y agoif you taxed Elon Musk, Warren Buffet, and Bill Gates at 100% including all their wealth, assets, you would barely reduce the US deficit in one year. You would also be shit out of luck in the next year. I'm sick of the thought process which essentially says we would be in a mode of 'post-scarcity' if we simply ate the rich.
- specialist 3y agoWhat should the effective tax rate on wealth (assets) be?
- hyperhello 3y agoThe deficit is a red herring. We issue capital in the form of bonds. We don’t “pay it off” or there would be no money or we’d have to structure the whole system differently.
- mjfl 3y agoI am just comparing the potential revenue from taxation to the overall size of government spending via the deficit. I don't really understand what you are saying with this comment. Do you think government spending can be unbounded? Why tax at all?
- Rury 3y ago> You would also be shit out of luck in the next year Nonsense. In theory, any one person can pay off all the debt, given enough favors. For example, if I was hypothetically $2 in debt to you, but there is only $1 in existence (which was owned by you), I can do you a favor in exchange for that $1, and immediately pay you it back for 50% of the debt. I can repeat this a second time with a second favor, and there is now 0 debt. (It doesn't matter if I started with the $1). In other words, having less money than the debt owed doesn't really matter. Debt is really just the flip side of money; both a measure of who owes whom a favor. Now that said, we could go on to debate who owes what and what is fair, but we all know that won't get anywhere...
- fifilura 3y agoSometimes I think about the 16th century monarchs in France and England. About the people they were surrounded with, the rituals, and primarily about the inequality and unfairness. Map that to today and I am sure 500 years from now, people will look with the same disgust on todays society. I am pretty curious what will come in between.
- specialist 3y agoSociety should pick a target gini coefficient and manage towards that. Today, in the USA, it's roughly ~40. Versus ~35 in the 1970s. ~35 would be pretty sweet. GINI Index for the United States https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SIPOVGINIUSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SIPOVGINIUSA
- refurb 3y agoThe Gini coefficient is a terrible measure to target. It measures income distribution without regards to absolute measure. For example, Tunisia has a much better Gini coefficient at 33, than the US which is 40. As a poor person, or even middle class, would you prefer to be in Tunisia or the US?
- specialist 3y agoPerhaps Tunisia and the USA would choose different target values, to better reflect their own circumstances. What is a better measure? More importantly, how would you address inequity?
- Aerroon 3y agoNone of them. The article (the title) is political propaganda that people like hearing. They can blame all their problems on the rich. The article even says: >Since 2020, the wealth of the top 1% has increased by /.../ 49%. >Middle-class Americans have also seen a rising wealth tide, with the middle 50% to 90% of Americans seeing their wealth increase [by] 50%. What really matters is absolute wealth, specifically what goods and services you have access to.
- specialist 3y agoWho else should we blame, if not the rich?
- refurb 3y agoOne could argue that Gini coefficient can be one of many important measures. Median income is a very important one. As well as cost of living.
- refurb 3y agoWith inflation and economic growth, won't the wealth held by the top 1% always be a new "record"? Even if wealth distribution doesn't change?
- Supermancho 3y agoYes. The "record" part, is beside the point. * Most people are unaware of the scale of disproportionality at all. * The average income of Americans has not scaled at the same rate. * What kind of (purchasing) power that is at odds with any sort of social reform. There is an implication that US capitalism has bred what economic models always do. A caste system. You can't expect the content of an article to be summarized completely in a short title, or this response. I have not summarized the article either, just some casual implications. There's an expectation that you read about the article to understand the context, but I can understand not wanting to read a CNBC article.
- refurb 3y ago> Yes. The "record" part, is beside the point. If it's besides the point why make it the headline? > Most people are unaware of the scale of disproportionality at all The biggest issue is that the top 1% is not a static group! People move into it and out of it all the time - the churn is quite high. There was an analysis of US tax payers and most people will only enter the top 1% for one year out of their entire life.
- refurb 3y agoIf do some rough math, 1% of the world's population is 81 million. So at $44T, if you took that $44T and split it up equally, each person would have ~$550,000 USD. Doesn't seem like such a big number any more. I'd bet many people on HN have more wealth than that. Actually, I'd bet many people on HN are in the top 1% of wealth globally.
- voganmother42 3y agoFeeding, housing, healing people - so lame, I’ve got my golden sneakers and I just need to invest the rest in a really terrific bunker
- ksec 3y ago>each person would have ~$550,000 USD. I think many would earn that much if they work in Magnificent 7. And it is surprising because frankly speaking $550K isn't a lot.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- p00b 3y agoThat is not how this article explicitly defines “the 1%” in the first few sentences. > the top 1%, defined by the Fed as those with wealth over $11 million
- blackbear_ 3y agoThe article is talking about the top 1% in the US, not worldwide. That makes for about 335k people, having 130M USD each on average.
- somedude895 3y agoReducing poverty is a commendable goal, but I'll never understand why people care so much about the 1%. Is it just envy? Is the idea of cutting others down to size so appealing?
- postpawl 3y agoThe critique of the 1% is more of a call for a system that is doing less exploiting of labor of the many for the benefit of a few, which has been leading to these huge social, economic, and political disparities.
- sandspar 3y agoI've found that envy is like faith. If you haven't experienced it then you can't grasp why other people do.
- GaryNumanVevo 3y agoThose in the 1% got rich via cutting millions of others down to size.