13 ms·
Lifelong Disadvantage: How Socioeconomics Affect Brain Function
- metacritic12 3y agoThe paper just shows the correlation between socioeconomics status (SES) and brain function -- there's no real causality study at all showing these are the results of lower SES. In fact, the reverse path could be true: that differences in brain function cause lower SES. Which when stated that way, seems obvious with a clear mechanism... But framing it the first way makes it seem left-leaning and blank-slatist, and gets you published, while the second reeks of adjacency to genetic determinism that's unfashionable in academia.
- TeaDrunk 3y agoI don't think the paper implies any causality either way. Notice that the title of the paper itself is "The neurobiology of life course socioeconomic conditions and *associated* cognitive performance in middle to late adulthood" Really, this is editorializing on the part of the person who submitted this link to HN.
- metacritic12 3y agoYeah agreed the paper title itself isn't sensationalistic, but the submission title is.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI don't quite agree. While the paper is much less sensational than the submission title, the way the abstract reads clearly sounds like they are at least implying some causality, subconsciously or not. Take the sentence "Individuals from higher income households showed preserved cognitive performance..." That could just as easily be written "Individuals with preserved cognitive performance showed higher levels of income..." There are a bunch of similar examples like that throughout the abstract.
- darby_eight 3y agoIt would be rather odd if causality only pointed in one direction.
- tmoravec 3y agoIsn't that the definition of causality? In life there can be multiple causes and multiple effects, but causality itself has one direction, doesn't it?
- pcthrowaway 3y agoPoor people are more likely to take high-interest loans/advances, and people who take high-interest loans are more likely to be poor. You can suggest causation both ways if say, you study a group of middle-class people who took high-interest loans and find them more likely to be poor years later. If A causes B but B also causes A is it wrong to say causality goes both ways? A is both cause and effect. B is both cause and effect. I think this is nearly as common as causality going one way (like if we found that smoking causes cancer, but cancer causes people to be less likely to smoke).
- darby_eight 3y ago> In life there can be multiple causes and multiple effects, but causality itself has one direction, doesn't it? Causality is an inherently parameterized description of reality. I'm saying that the terms people are using to describe this complex effect are too few and each far too high grained to draw any firm conclusions.
- 2four2 3y agoIt does. That's pretty much the definition of causality.
- darby_eight 3y agoFrom that perspective, surely you can draw no conclusion of causality from this data, or any conclusion you can draw has little predictive power about the direction of effect for a given sample.
- taurath 3y ago> In fact, the reverse path could be true: that differences in brain function cause lower SES. Except the ACE study exists, showing a massive difference in brain function and attainment based on childhood adversity, regardless of SES. https://nhttac.acf.hhs.gov/soar/eguide/stop/adverse_childhood_experiences https://nhttac.acf.hhs.gov/soar/eguide/stop/adverse_childhoo... Oh, and ACE's tend to go up with lower SES: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6872440/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6872440/ Finally please don't elevate eugenics by using the word "unfashionable" when its not only deeply disproven but also has a horrific legacy as the primarily stated justification for some of the world's worst atrocities. https://www.genome.gov/about-genomics/fact-sheets/Eugenics-and-Scientific-Racism https://www.genome.gov/about-genomics/fact-sheets/Eugenics-a...
- pcthrowaway 3y ago[flagged]
- imtringued 3y agoVariance in human ability is smaller than variance in income. Productivity does not explain income in capitalist economies. Instead, most of the changes in income are explained by differences in hierarchy. You might say that more able individuals are more likely to be higher up in the hierarchy, but being higher up doesn't require an increase in ability proportional with the increase in income. You only need to be 1% better than the next guy to win the competition, leading small differences in ability to result in large differences in income. Using genetics to explain the fairness of capitalism is a pretty common lie we tell ourselves to make us feel superior over poor people.
- Jensson 3y agoThe majority of income differences comes from your skill. A doctor earn much more than a cashier due to having a more valuable skill, and that span makes up the bulk of gini coefficient. Ultra wealth can't be explained with skill difference, no, but that isn't very relevant to this discussion. You can get a ton of money just through skill alone, doctors, programmers, lawyers etc aren't poor by any stretch.
- bitwize 3y ago[flagged]
- binary132 3y agoa lot of liberals think poor people are poor because they’re dumb
- giraffe_lady 3y agoYou ever hear the saying "scratch a liberal and a fascist bleeds?"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anonuser123456 3y agoTitle does not reflect findings.
- hyperadvanced 3y agoYeah, sadly, not a lot here. I’m a fan of studies around materialism and capitalism but trying to dress up a study in neuroscience as a cultural critique comes off as disingenuous and vapid
- pessimizer 3y agoHow exactly? If there were a hypothetical study that saw that people who have been homeless, even after homelessness, suffer from more diseases related to parasites, would it be "disingenuous and vapid?" Would it be trying to dress up a study in parasitology as cultural critique? Or, alternatively, could both poverty and homelessness be related to culture?
- hyperadvanced 3y agoI mean, a study like this could deliver meaningful results, it’s just that this one doesn’t imo. Hypothetically, studies on the biology/physiology can be very interesting, but this one comes off as a bit vapid and disingenuous because it’s not longitudinal, has a low sample size, and appears to not even attempt to measure intelligence or select to weed out bias in the sample set (e.g. find people born poor and see if they really do have cognitive impairment into adulthood by studying them over many years, not a backwards looking or self-selecting methodology such as theirs). When they say things like “individuals from lower income households” there’s clearly some “lifelong disadvantage” still in the sample set.
- ghufran_syed 3y agoProbably smoking, alcohol and drug use differences alone would probably account for most of the differences
- JackFr 3y agoTFA: > We adjusted the applied regression analyses and structural equation models for the linear and non-linear effects of age, sex, education, cardiovascular risk factors, and presence of depressive, anxiety, and substance use disorders.
- ghufran_syed 3y agoand you this this correction is valid because people tend to be very open and honest about their use and abuse of substances?
- cupcakecommons 3y ago[flagged]
- netfl0 3y agoSolid gold.
- m3t4man 3y agoI think that's a bad comparison, though I see the point you are making. Height is determined by your genes, yet its also affected by your environment during your development. Something similar could be said about Intelligence, though as far as I know, in reductionist terms, intelligence has a greater window for development (most of our life), and a lot more plastic than height (which is highly dependent upon your bone structure. Bones also being categorically different to our neural systems and its comprising elements). I don't think it'd be outragous to find that your economic situation affects your developmental goals. Given how it affects how much time you spend on, and opportunities for your personal (in this case intellectual) development.
- m3t4man 3y agoNot to mention the effects of chronic drug use on aforementioned neural systems.
- EnigmaFlare 3y ago> intelligence has a greater window for development Any sources for this? Last I heard, there's nothing that can improve intelligence besides removing temporary impediments. I think people do generally tend to attribute far to many disadvantages to poverty when really poverty is just one of the outcomes of underlying disadvantage like low intelligence and emotional and mental health problems.
- roenxi 3y agoDepends what we call 'intelligence'. As far as I know intelligence is remarkably difficult to adjust upwards in the technical sense. But, practically, we can train young people not to do stupid things so they will act more intelligently in the common sense of the word. One fun example might be the anti-usury stance of the Catholics back in the (I'm told) the 12th century. A society that can't charge interest on its debts is a society where people will behave stupidly compared to a society where people can lend money profitably - people will just walk by situations that they can identify as big win-win scenarios and rationally not pursue them. But it isn't linked to individual intelligence as much as how what people are raised to believe.
- EGreg 3y agoWe've known this for a while indirectly: 2018: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/making-sense/analysis-how-poverty-can-drive-down-intelligence https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/making-sense/analysis-h... 2013: https://www.businessinsider.com/poverty-effect-on-intelligence-2013-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/poverty-effect-on-intelligen... 2008: https://jech.bmj.com/content/66/7/624 https://jech.bmj.com/content/66/7/624 (diet) I would argue btw that sub-saharan Africa was held back in terms of average IQ due to poor nutrition as well as the relative lack of empires for hundreds of years
- NoImmatureAdHom 3y agoThere has been a raft of "research" over the last ~decade that purports to show that poverty causes stupidity. My impression (as a scientist, kinda related area) is that it's been discredited. You must draw the distinction between correlational evidence (what this submission is doing) and causal claims, which is what most of the research you're pointing to makes. TL;DR: Poverty doesn't cause lower intelligence. Catastrophically bad diet (to the point of stunting) will, though, in ref to your 2008 link. 2008 study is very weak and doesn't look at starvation, only correlational, they find a very small effect and it's very likely some unmeasured confounds.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- metalforever 3y agoI grew up in a very poor socioeconomic situation and became an SWE. The largest challenge wasn't learning the skills. The hardest challenge was throwing away my culture and hiding who I am to get the bills paid. It was also knowing the "correct" socially-coded answers to things, and being able to keep up the upper-class disguise well-enough over long periods. When people discover or figure it out, they discriminate against you in subconscious ways and exclude you.
- iopq 3y agoI grew up in a family who couldn't afford coffee so we drank roasted barley for years. But then we moved to the US and my family became middle class. I'm fairly well-off now, but I'm not sure if I was advantaged by being an immigrant or not.
- dehrmann 3y agoI'm genuinely curious what things you feel like you have to hide. I'm fortunate enough to come from a decent socioeconomic situation, but I still feel like I'm not my "full self" (whatever that even means) at work in interest of team cohesion.
- metalforever 3y agoPretty much everything. When people ask my opinion on anything, they don't want my opinion, they want an opinion from their class perspective. When they want to know how my holiday was, no they don't. When I am supposed to have visited my family from context (or it's weird if I didn't), yeah I did. I am not allowed to wear things people of my class find professional. I am not allowed to discuss what I really did on my time off (it was a punk show or something like this, probably). This is not even getting into issues where a lot of people let actual class discrimination fly live in the office, overtly insult people from my background, or say things about being scared regarding being near section 8 people. I could go on for a long time.
- NegativeLatency 3y agoI would be interested in hearing about someone’s experience at a punk show.
- whatever1 3y agoWhen you are poor you spend the majority of your brain cycles dealing with your situation. What can I afford to eat today? How am I gonna pay the electricity bill? How am I gonna fix my broken 20yo car? Which grocery has the cheapest diapers? Should I switch on the heating today or are there colder days coming this month? If you are well off none of the above is even a thing.
- MikeTheGreat 3y agoBetween your comment and your username I immediately thought of this: https://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/ https://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/ It's worth a read. And a re-read, come to think of it - I'll go do that now.
- 2four2 3y agoThat was really impactful. I grew up pretty okay, but lots of my friends were very poor. I remember experiencing several of these things but I know for a fact they experienced many of them. They were good people who otherwise didn't deserve that struggle.
- zero_k 3y agoI read that many (10? 15?) years ago and it changed me. It literally, changed me. That blog post, and its comments (including one by the sister of the author... really difficult stuff) is incredibly hard and important to read.
- nelsonfigueroa 3y agoWow, what a read. Thanks for sharing.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoReally poor people don't have electricity, cars, central heating, and have probably never seen a disposable diaper. Source: grew up in that situation.
- 3y ago
- yieldcrv 3y agoLook I’m not trying to exclude groups of people with this observation But it seems like people avoid this observation based on the idea that whoever makes it is going to use it to exclude people How is every trait simply genetic with both humans, and other species, even our pets! but when it comes to cognitive function - in humans - it has to be socioeconomic mish mash that can’t be quantified so don’t ask or do that research. But even with our pets we’re like just kidding I picked this breed because they’re smart. Is it because we’ve proved humans are all too similar? Is it because we’ve annihilated the ones that weren’t similar already? Isn’t that how we got to this point if that’s the case?
- 2four2 3y ago>How is every trait simply genetic with both humans, and other species, even our pets! but when it comes to cognitive function - in humans - it has to be socioeconomic mish mash that can’t be quantified so don’t ask or do that research. There's no need for confusion because it's not so black and white as this. Animal cognitive ability is also heavily related to upbringing and environment. Human cognitive ability is somewhat genetic, but you have to realize that humans weren't bred by another species for thousands of years to exhibit certain phenotypes and behaviors. There's no equivalent to this in humans.
- imtringued 3y agoThe fact that you need an atmosphere to keep your body from falling apart makes me question the idea that every trait is genetic. Also regarding "cognitive function", we happen to have an awfully abundant intelligent population in this century. Coincidence, or do Europeans simply have better genes? Since the environment isn't allowed to improve cognitive functions, we must go down the path of racism and facism. Great!
- yieldcrv 3y agoBut these are strawmen arguments, specifically ones I didn't make to discredit the observation that I did make you’re assuming I’m talking about something eurocentric I think it is a good point about the environment changing over the last century, benefiting everyone, it is also leaves unresolved the cognitive disparities in that benefit too
- dash2 3y agoThis is a wonderful example of how misinterpretations spread into the public domain. The article carefully avoids causal language, appropriately in a study with no genetic control. But on HN it’s become “affect”. Sigh.
- sandspar 3y ago"Affect" is a very common weasel word. It can connect almost anything.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RockCoach 3y agoSo, how does one unlearn "poverty mentality"? Having grown up lower middle class with parents from a former Eastern bloc country, I feel that my mentality has very often held me back from taking risks in career, education and personal life, because there was no safety net to fall back on if the risky move wouldn't pay off. I'm good at surviving with very little money or food, but at the age of 42, I feel now like I had let life pass me by, having never developed ambitions or passions, and living like a "rat", is also very unappealing to potential love interests.
- Jensson 3y ago> living like a "rat", is also very unappealing to potential love interests. Yeah, women really dislike men with a poverty attitude who worry about spending money. Poor men who act as if they are rich seems to do much better than well off men who act as if they are poor.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 082349872349872 3y ago> So, how does one unlearn "poverty mentality"? Take a few risks. Start with risks that aren't real, like going to a restaurant that no one you know has ever heard of. Once you have the experience that nothing bad happens, or if it does, it at most wasted a little money and time, work your way up to more rewarding risks. Don't go as far as the Into the Wild guy though: he never realised how much "nothing bad" happening was due to other people bailing him out until he took risks someplace where that wasn't going to happen. It's like writing a program: do it in small chunks and check each bit of functionality before committing. No hacker ever stopped writing a program because they encountered bugs now and then. Does this make sense?
- euroderf 3y agoPersonal evolution does not require great leaps into the unknown. Move sideways a step or two at a time. Test the ground before you plant your foot.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hedora 3y agoI'd be curious to see this corrected for sleep deprivation. In California, and so also Silicon Valley, the building codes for noise proofing apartment complexes are much weaker than for condos. This means that you're unlikely to be able to reliably sleep through the night if you live in an apartment. For reference, noise proofing a ~ 2000 sq.ft. house in 2020 cost about $2K as it was being built, so it's hard to make an argument about housing affordability, etc. We've had bad luck with older buildings that were renovated into "luxury living" apartments and with older non-renovated buildings. We never rented a unit in a newer building, so I can't comment about those. It's possible that developers just pay the equivalent of two weeks rent per unit now to make the buildings be less miserable. My take (while sleep deprived) was that the situation was just a giant "f--k the poor" on the part of the people that wrote the building codes.
- pstorm 3y agoI’ve never really thought about this before, but it is obvious in hindsight. When I finally made enough money to move into a newer apartment, the noise from neighbors and outside was almost nonexistent. It was a stark contrast, but I never thought about how that affected my sleep/productivity, let alone how it would affect all apartment dwellers.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIts not even a sure bet new ones are like that. I’d guess you have cement walls. A lot of the new 5 story apartments are timber framed with cheap sheetrock.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoMore like fuck everyone not just the poor. New expensive condos and apartments are also built poorly like that. That being said you do get used to hearing footsteps before long. As long as someone isn’t partying with a stereo you eventually tune out all that stuff in my experience although usually the first few days to weeks are rough sleeping in any new place.
- boringg 3y agoThis is is a perfect paper to get ripped apart/defend by everyone. Too many variables and too easy to defend or pull apart. It will line up with your prior beliefs and change nothing.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoI can agree that it's really hard to build good science here. But at the same time, a huge number of the variables seem like they would be directly downstream of socioeconomic status. It affects so much of our lives.
- hackan 3y agoWell, it's not easy to investigate how poverty affects your whole life history xD It would take an investigator their entire life as well, assuming they started super young. And who wants to pay for such investigation?
- boringg 3y agoI don't disagree with you. I don't have a solution either. I also know that the paper linked above put on HN will not make much of a difference to peoples perspectives on the matter since it doesn't have a ton of merit to it. So the question becomes -- whats the point of posting it here other than to inflame commentary?
- its_ethan 3y agoFor what it's worth, I am learning quite a bit from hearing other peoples' perspectives in the comments that this article has spawned. > "whats the point of posting it here other than to inflame commentary?" Maybe look inward on this one my guy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bilater 3y agoI've noticed a lot of people from the middle of America who grew up lower middle class are stingy (even if they are doing well now). Small things like lowering the heating in their house to uncomfortable levels to save 10 bucks a month, not buying a round of drinks. etc It's interesting because ppl in even worse socioeconomic situations in South Asia are the opposite and go above and beyond to be generous. I guess its because being hospitable is a big part of the culture there.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 3y agoThis sounds more like the specific cohort that experienced the Great Depression.
- black_13 3y ago[dead]