4 ms·
'Is monetary policy even working?'
- belter 3y agohttps://archive.is/Cm8MK https://archive.is/Cm8MK
- alephnerd 3y agoThe core point from the article (because no one will actually read it): "Higher interest rates have proved a lot less destructive than investors feared in 2022, when the world’s central banks embarked on one of the most aggressive episodes of monetary tightening in history. Nothing has “broken”, contrary to the prevailing view two years ago; and this has even sparked a lively debate about why mainstream macro exaggerated the dangers of higher rates." Basically, a lot of people assumed (high interest rates = slowing economy), but the current status quo reflects otherwise. Personally, I'm happy that it has now re-incentivized saving, and a much more mercenary and productivity driven outlook.
- lenerdenator 3y agoUsually, it does equal a slowing economy. But IMO there's a difference this time in that a lot of economic "growth" was being carried out by businesses that couldn't exist in a reasonable interest rate environment (which is exactly what Jerry Powell's environment is) and honestly just wanted to cash out. Think of how many startups only existed to set money on fire until they completely captured a market, or how many got bought by the likes of FAANG+MS just to only kind-of have an integration into products/services that were made. This has just been a return to the normal rules of business: you need to be able to create a return on investment in a reasonable amount of time, and with a reasonable amount of resources.
- alephnerd 3y agoLargely it's this point below from the article: "The obvious one is fiscal policy, with governments everywhere using budgetary stimulus more actively since the pandemic. The impact of higher interest rates has been dampened in two ways. First, consumers had high levels of liquid assets (sometimes called “excess savings”) left over from the pandemic, which provided a financial cushion that protected their spending power. Second, governments have been deploying additional funds since COVID-19, such as the large energy support programmes in Europe and Bidenomics in the US (big tax subsidies that encouraged US companies to invest heavily in green energies). These funds have supported incomes and employment, even as monetary policy engineered a squeeze" ----- People on here are overstating the impact of a handful of software companies and buzzwords on the larger economy.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThis wasn't "one of the most aggressive episodes". This was nothing compared to Volcker in 1979-1981. And the fact that nothing has broken indicates that they didn't go overly aggressive. They stopped inflation from getting worse without driving the country into a recession. That's a pretty decent balancing act.
- alephnerd 3y agoPedantry and HN. Name a better combo. But yea I agree with ya on the 2nd half.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smallmancontrov 3y agoThe economy that Volcker hiked into wasn't nearly as leveraged (because the debt had been inflated away / soft defaulted upon). A small rate increase on a lot of debt vacuums up as much money as a large increase on a small amount of debt. However, the duration on most household/corporate debt at the moment is such that it hasn't felt the sting of rate increases yet. As usual, it's complicated.
- Temporary_31337 3y agoToo early to tell IMO. The fact that inflation is going up again tells me they may have played too safe with the only blunt instrument that they have
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoThey did slow it down ( including the form of couple banks going under and Summers begging for a bailout ). It just so happens that federal government also managed to pass some corporate stimulus in the form of 'green new deal' or whatever they ended up calling it and war of Ukraine, which helps domestic warmachine ( billions from misnamed foreign aid ). edit: Oh, and the Summeers did manage to scare enough people to rescue SVB so that impact was absorbed, amusingly, by other banks via extraordinary FDIC fee ( most banks have it listed now on their quarterly statement in case you are inclined to check ).
- alephnerd 3y agoForeign Aid for Ukraine is overstated. It's just $5bil, which is a drop in the bucket for even state governments in the US. If that's the cost to fight a proxy war, it's fairly cheap. That's how much it costs to build a highway from Pittsburgh to Morgantown (Mon–Fayette Expressway). > managed to pass some corporate stimulus This is the key point, and a critical one at that. That corporate stimulus suddenly made swathes of American manufacturing, construction, etc cost effective again.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoYou know.. if I could only get a small fraction of that $5b instead of contributing to it being send to everyone but me, I would be a happier man. edit: I will make a less convoluted statement. Ideally, the amount of that small 5b donation abroad would be zero.
- cl0ckt0wer 3y agoThat's called universal basic income.
- nradov 3y agoYou probably wouldn't be happier in the long run if Russia succeeds in their goal of reconquering much of Eastern Europe. That will make the entire world poorer and more violent. A few billion dollars is a cheap price to contain Russian expansionism.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- randomdata 3y ago> a lot of people assumed (high interest rates = slowing economy) A fair assumption. It is extremely likely that the economy is slower than it would have been if interest rates remained low. Things were starting to get extremely hot – which is why we saw higher interest rates arrive in reaction. There was a lot of concern floating around that rates would overcorrect (which, to be fair, may still prove to be the case – it is still early days), leading to an economy slowing more than needed, but the so-called "soft landing" was always the goal. Explicitly so. The status quo is in quite in line with what we were hoping to see come out of the higher rates, slowing the economy just enough, but not too much.
- nostromo 3y agoThey can't stay this high for long without a federal debt crisis, which is a key reason the Fed is hoping to get interest rates back down. If we weren't so indebted, interest rates could indeed stay high for a long time without much concern. But there's a point in the not-so-distant future where our government will need to print even more money to pay the debt (which will spark more inflation) or we'll need to cut all spending that isn't interest on the debt.
- orwin 3y agoIf so, there is a way to destroy inflation, its raising taxes. Put taxes on wealth and on secondary homes and non-commercial renting, destroy the money, less inflation. Easy.
- jajko 3y agoNo politician is ever going to do that, not with that reasoning, not so much it would actually matter. Way too many people's wealth would be burned to the ground. We talk avout tens of percents of every populatiin in literally every country. It may be a reasonable advice when isolated from complexity of reality, but at the end its a bit like saying for example: solve all evil by separating / killing all evil people.
- skeeter2020 3y ago>> Central bankers have long argued that changes in interest rates affect global economies with “long and variable lags”. Which is another way of saying if there's a link it is very weak, and those not very useful for driving anything behind long-term strategic direction, certainly not day-to-day policy.
- alecsm 3y agoWhat bothers me is that in Europe it was expected to affect the real estate prices. The higher the interest, the lower the prices, which sounds logical but...the prices kept increasing. So what's going to happen when Lagarde decides to lower them? The demand is way to high and the offer is almost non existent. And it seems that it didn't affect the inflation either. Bad years for everybody who's not getting a 10% raise every year.
- r00fus 3y agoBasically most humans. Hedge funds are doing great.
- ASinclair 3y agoOne problem is that housing is supply constrained in many places. Homebuilders need loans too. So high rates increase homebuilders costs as well.
- Temporary_31337 3y agoHomebuilders are hesitant to set up new projects as the new builds will be more expensive than the already elevated house prices- higher labour and materials costs higher interest payments for the home builders And finally More expensive mortgages for the end clients. This kills supply and it will send prices into the stratosphere.
- MuffinFlavored 3y ago> The higher the interest, the lower the prices, which sounds logical but...the prices kept increasing. This is a side effect of "demand" I think. Higher interest rates increase mortgage/financing costs. This is supposed to "destroy" demand. Except, there's so much demand (and so little supply) that it didn't, and we're getting the worst of both worlds. In the US: A $500k 3/2 house at 2.75% 30-year fixed in 2020 is now $750k at 6.75% It "shouldn't" have played out that way but my theory is Home buyers from before ~2015 (random guess) are "up so much" in equity from this quiet "real estate inflation/demand appreciation boom" that they don't care to "overpay" $200k compared to what they would've paid 4 years ago because they were "gifted/given" $200k+ in equity out of the sky. They're just moving the money from one property to the next.
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoIsn't effective tightening for global multinationals a function of tightening the lowest global interest rate? Which refers to Japan, and Japan only just a few weeks ago exited negative territory and has not tightened meaningfully at all.
- naniwaduni 3y agoWell, it's affected by the marginal interest rate available to them. The supply of liquidity for global multinationals isn't unlimited.
- ponymontana 3y ago[flagged]
- throw0101b 3y agoSee perhaps: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_transmission_mechanism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_transmission_mechanis... Cullen Roche is always worth checking out: > Monetary Policy is the various set of policies initiated by the Central Bank to try to stimulate or slow the economy. This typically includes changing interest rates, altering the size of the balance sheet and communicating via “open mouth policy”. The transmission mechanism of these policies are controversial and the goal of this post is to add some clarity to the ways in which this works. * https://www.pragcap.com/monetary-policy-transmission-mechanism/ https://www.pragcap.com/monetary-policy-transmission-mechani... It should also be asked "working at doing what, exactly?". If you have an hot economy because of a lot of demand because of easy credit creation, then clamping down on credit creation can help in slowing things down: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demand-pull_inflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demand-pull_inflation If however you have (e.g.) a geopolitical event that causes (say) a spike in food and energy prices, then that's not really an issue that is largely controlled through credit creation: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost-push_inflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost-push_inflation Then there are other scenarios, like sudden changes in consumer behaviours that cause problems: * https://ritholtz.com/2022/06/goods-versus-services/ https://ritholtz.com/2022/06/goods-versus-services/ * https://www.detroitnews.com/story/business/2021/04/19/global-ports-clogged-unprecedented-shipping-volume/7289033002/ https://www.detroitnews.com/story/business/2021/04/19/global... * https://www.cnbc.com/2022/02/18/whats-behind-the-congestion-at-us-ports.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/02/18/whats-behind-the-congestion-... * https://www.frbsf.org/research-and-insights/publications/economic-letter/2022/06/how-much-do-supply-and-demand-drive-inflation/ https://www.frbsf.org/research-and-insights/publications/eco... Some of these things monetary policy can deal with better than others, but a lot of folks expect monetary to do something (anything!), and if it doesn't make an attempt than there's all sort of other drama.
- Jrjrir48 3y ago> lack of any significant economic slowdown. If you believe data, monetary policy clearly does not work. We are doing better than ever! If you do not believe data....
- kypro 3y agoFor monetary policy to work it requires rate sensitive borrowers. If borrowers don't care what rates are then it's not going to have much impact. US households have fixed mortgages so most don't care what interest rates are and the US government obviously doesn't give a damn what interest rates are and will continue borrowing regardless. Another thing to consider is that counter intuitively higher interest rates might be acting as a form of stimulus for many US households. If you've got a fixed mortgage and the government is now paying you for your savings your total disposable income might actually be increasing with rate hikes.
- NEETPILLED 3y agolol, except for all the bank failures that required BTFP / another bailout. Commercial real estate meltdown anyone? Imagine if the FT didn't publish economist propaganda for once.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoNo Javascript or cookies needed: https://cc.bingj.com/cache.aspx?d=3253415984894&w=vvUrvYG7JT02PLwM4jUCvBS2HsS-5ESw https://cc.bingj.com/cache.aspx?d=3253415984894&w=vvUrvYG7JT...