10 ms·
Doubts grow about the biosignature approach to alien-hunting
- throwaway63467 3y agoLet’s just hope it’s not the “dark forest” theory that’s correct, although it would make a lot of sense to me assuming the universe is teeming with life.
- TomSwirly 3y agoThe most likely theory is that the universe is much like it appears to be and the speed of light is an absolute barrier, and that in practice means that interstellar civilizations never form, because it's simply far, far too expensive and difficult. If alien civilizations lasted indefinitely, that wouldn't be a barrier, but in the one sample of a civilization we have, we are consuming our resources and generating waste at an exponentially increasing rate, and will crash and burn leaving us without the quadrillions of "dollars" it would take to even start colonizing the stars.
- fredsmith219 3y agoEven in this scenario I would still expect to see Von Neumann machines at some point.
- palata 3y agoYou mean a civilization that can produce machines able to survive indefinitely in isolation, but that isn't capable of surviving itself? Doesn't sound particularly obvious to me...
- cyberlurker 3y agoKurzgesagt has many videos on this topic. In one video, they point out we may actually be in the right place at the right time and could be one of the first civilizations. This seems egocentric at first, but if you consider how chaotic the early universe has been and how relatively calm things are in the last billion years, it does make sense. Also, I learned recently that we don’t have as much time with Earth as I originally thought. We have a few hundred million years to figure out how to colonize other planets or live in space before Earth becomes radically different and potentially unlivable. I imagine most civilizations get snuffed out like this.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe past survival of livable conditions on Earth is no guarantee they will persist for very long in the future. There's observer selection bias to consider. For example, the O2 level in the atmosphere could drop below that needed to sustain higher life. As I understand it, there's been no feedback mechanism identified that stabilizes O2 at current levels, so the persistence of adequate oxygen over the last 500 million years could just be an unlikely accident. In the absence of burial of photosynthesized materials atmospheric O2 will disappear in a few million years as reduced materials are exposed by geological processes and then oxidized. So, the time constant for O2 fluctuations is rather short. If and when we spread into the galaxy, we may find many planets where livable conditions were snuffed out before intelligence could arise. In our own solar system, both Mars and Venus may have been more habitable than Earth earlier in the history of the solar system, but now are forever ruined.
- palata 3y ago> We have a few hundred million years to figure out how to colonize other planets or live in space before Earth becomes radically different and potentially unlivable. Hmm... at the rate we are going, big parts of the Earth (a big slice around the Equator) may well become unlivable for human beings in a couple of decades. I get the idea that it won't mean that the Earth will be unlivable for all organisms, but from what we know, a sufficiently advanced civilization only needs a couple hundred years to destroy itself.
- richardw 3y agoAnd AI is likely a binary outcome. It’s either very good for us or not, and it won’t take a million years to figure out which. We were in caves not long ago.
- bamboozled 3y agoVery little to no evidence that AI is a “binary outcome”.
- 3y ago
- pfdietz 3y agoNeither FTL travel nor unitary interstellar civilizations are necessary for the Fermi argument to bite.
- palata 3y agoNot sure why you got downvoted :-/. I am always surprised by how people tend to completely ignore the scale of the universe. People get excited by claims to "go back to the Moon, then Mars, then who knows?", but the truth is that given our current understanding of the world, sending humans on another solar system is theoretically impossible. Just look at those distances: we just can't, period. Of course, we may discover new fundamental physics that would change that. But that's a fundamental problem, not an engineering problem. Instead of wasting money and energy on the engineering required to send humans to Mars (which is an artistic performance at this point), we should pay fundamental physicists to attempt to revolutionize our understanding of the world (wishing them luck) and spend those resources into something that is actually important for life: preserving life on Earth. Right now we as a civilization are failing to survive on Earth. It seems reasonable to consider that other civilizations may have the same problems.
- nojs 3y agoIt’s not theoretically impossible, it’s just really hard. If we go fast enough, we can even do it within the current lifespan of a human (from the perspective of that human). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Roundtriptimes.png https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Roundtriptimes.png
- palata 3y agoWell, it starts with "assuming we had something we don't have (i.e. the capability to accelerate at 1G for 100 years)"... I meant it's theoretically impossible with the theory that we have now. Of course if we make breakthroughs in the theory, then the theory will change and it may become possible. But SpaceX going to Mars is not exactly revisiting this theory. They are just having fun with the current state of the theory, which says that they won't bring humans further, period.
- jonahrd 3y agoI don't mean to be nitpicky, but you specified the difference between a theoretical impossibility and an engineering impossibility in your parent comment. I assume the reply is just referring to the fact that technically getting to a star system within the 10s of light-years away is an engineering feat, not a break-the-known-rules-of-the-universe feat. I don't take it that they're actually claiming it's a realistic feat that may be accomplished soon.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoIf you have silicon/AI/computer-based intelligence, then it's a lot more durable in space and lasts a lot longer. That's a totally different ballgame. You don't even need habitable worlds, arguably what would be valuable is asteroids since you don't have gravity wells. 200 year transits isn't a big deal then. They could tolerate the G-forces of an Orion pulse nuclear ship a lot better too. That's 1960s tech, if you have some antimatter collectors in space (my idea for a starship-based startup, how valuable is antimatter?), then you get to have even more fun. Orion can do .1c with fission. One of the big problems was getting it off the ground and the fallout was unacceptable. BUT, with starship doing 150-250 tons, that means 8 flights for a 4,000 ton low-end orion, or ... a lot more for the high end 1,000,000 ton orion.
- smallmancontrov 3y agoThree Body Problem is a lot of fun, but if you are that concerned by it you should seek out the broader Fermi Paradox dialogue which does not favor this solution, and not just because it's unwanted. Isaac Arthur's Fermi Paradox Compendium on youtube is probably a good place to start and I'm pretty sure his Dark Forest video covers the major points. In any case, I have them here too: If the universe is teeming with alien life, why isn't it here? It looks like it will take millions of years to colonize the galaxy but the likely variation in emergence/evolutionary timelines is some decent fraction of billions of years (considerably more than 4 billion years, the starting gun is metallicity not the formation of Earth). In particular, if there is highly capable space-faring life at Alpha Centauri, why haven't they probed their neighboring star system in a billion years even though it was completely trivial to do so relative to subsequently displayed technological feats? Also: it's really hard to configure the rules of a Dark Forest so that the optimal strategy is "hide" rather than "grow, grow, grow -- and hope you grow fast enough by the time it matters," and it's spectacularly hard to make that so universal across all aliens that none of them "wins" and colonizes the galaxy per the previous paragraph. Finally, Cixin Liu had to break the speed of light to make his story work (and then carefully avoid the implications to #1 and #2 above, which both get worse if c is no longer a constraint). I am all for doing what it takes to tell the story, and even more delighted by his deeper exploration of this concept further down the line, but one must remember to adjust the likelihoods of it all according to the likelihood of the premise, which seems quite low according to our present understanding.
- pfdietz 3y agoThis is a nit pick and doesn't change your argument, but Alpha Centauri would not have been our neighboring star system for a billion years. Stars move relative to each other in our stellar neighborhood at about 30 km/s, or one light year every 10,000 years.
- smallmancontrov 3y agoYep, good reminder! Of course, as you point out, it doesn't change the argument because probing (or simply direct observation, if they must hide) would still be trivial, both at larger distances when we weren't quite neighbors and on the shorter timescale when we were. Trivial next to mustering an interstellar invasion fleet on the turn of a dime, at any rate. Besides, if they were itching for a fight then the original "decent fraction of billions of years" timeline still applies to the question of "why didn't they grow and colonize?"
- NegativeLatency 3y agoPersonally I would rather take the chance of being destroyed than destroy other life. That whole idea is also based on IMO the worst instincts of our race. For all we know making it past the great filter involves developing an increased empathy for all life.
- foobar1962 3y ago> Personally I would rather take the chance of being destroyed than destroy other life. Great. So don't wash your hands before eating... and don't eat.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoIt is based on instincts, which are tied to survival, which is inherent to biological competition, which is inherent to evolution. It is unlikely life elsewhere won't involve the same fundamental game theory.
- lannisterstark 3y agoCixin straight up borrowed this from The Killing Star. You should read that. It's also pretty fun but goes 0-100 in chapter 1.
- wouldbecouldbe 3y agoI understand it would be super interesting to find biological processes similar to earth like life similar to our light, water & dioxide cycle (im sure there's a name for it) But sometimes it sound like many people think that's the only way life can start, yet we have no idea how it really works. Also on earth there are organisms in the deep sea that have completely different biology. We might find life, even sentient one, in places we haven't thought to look.
- Kalium 3y agoYes. You're right. Absolutely, completely correct. There's almost certainly other ways life can start. Other processes that can result in intelligence. Other paths of technological development. The issue, as I understand is, is that all of those are completely unknown. We have absolutely no useful idea of how to look for wildly different life in places we haven't thought to look. What we do know with certainty is that Earth's chemistry can result in life. We do know that it can result in intelligence. We do know what paths our technological development took. We even have some idea what these things might look like from afar. All together, we have exactly one data point that lets us search for similar data points. Are there other, different world, with different life? Very possibly. We humans are well aware of this. We just don't have a way of knowing if we've found anything. So as a matter of managing limited resources, there's a tendency to stick to what we know can work.
- card_zero 3y agoIt may just be a failure of the imagination, but on the face of it the only chemistry that could feasibly make organisms is organic chemistry. That's not because it's Earth's chemistry, but because carbon is a very useful lego brick. This leaves us looking for alternatives beyond chemistry, something like Douglas Adams's "sentient shade of blue", except imaginable and not nonsense. So your certainty about this is ... staunch, let's say. Inevitable Wikipedia article about this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothetical_types_of_biochemistry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothetical_types_of_biochemi...
- 3y ago
- derelicta 3y agoI hope I will grow old enough for one to see a proper confirmation of life out there
- pfdietz 3y agoThat would be bad news. I hope we never have proper confirmation of independently arisen life out there (or, worse, intelligent life out there.) It would imply the Great Filter is likely to be ahead of us, so humanity would likely be doomed.
- NegativeLatency 3y agoYou can choose to believe that we’ll make it past that event, and even do things to help your community and neighborhood in that spirit.
- pfdietz 3y agoIf we run into another intelligence it is strong evidence we haven't made it past the Great Filter. Sure, you can choose to believe the opposite, but that's pure wishful thinking.
- contravariant 3y agoThat makes no sense to me. If there wasn't a great filter we would expect to find more intelligent life, if there were we would expect a much smaller probability of intelligent life. If an event makes an observation less likely then conversely such an observation also makes that event less likely, not the other way around.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe thing that has to be explained was why Earth was left alone for 4.55 billion years so we could evolve. Something prevented intelligences from colonizing it and exploiting it (and everywhere else we can see in the universe, as far as we can tell). That thing is called the Great Filter. Its existence is not in question, since we evolved. If we run into ETs that means intelligence must be extremely common (and mobile, since we ran into it) so the filter has to be very VERY effective. The most benign Great Filter would be in our past, if life or intelligence is very difficult for the universe to create. If it's not in our past, it's in our future, and it's going to clobber us with almost no chance of escape (after all, if we're not special, we have no better chance than any of the potentially vast number of ET civilizations it has already hit.)
- jajag 3y agoAssembly theory might eventually provide some useful tools in this area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assembly_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assembly_theory
- HarHarVeryFunny 3y agoYes - seem a much better, more general, approach. There was an interesting interview of Lee Cronin on Lex Fridman's podcast a while ago. For anyone unfamiliar, Assembly Theory is based on the idea that the more structurally complex something is, such as a molecule, the less likely it was created by chance, and the more likely it was created by an assembly factory of sorts, one type of which is life in it's potentially diverse forms.
- gradus_ad 3y agoI was never very impressed by assembly "theory" (what are its testable predictions?)... If we find a refrigerator floating in space I don't need an Assembly Theorist to tell me there's some intelligent/intentional process behind it. Seriously, what is it other than a potent source of pop sci clickbait?
- HarHarVeryFunny 3y agoThe essential prediction is that complex things are made by some sort of repeatable assembly process/factory, not by chance (with increased confidence when multiple copies have been seen). There is an idea of an "assembly index" for objects (e.g. molecules) as a measure/bound of how many steps they took to assemble - the level of complexity. There is also a prediction (or definition?) that things with a high assembly index are produced by some form of life, so if one can measure the assembly index of molecules and find ones of high index/complexity, then this indicates they were created by some form of life, and so this can be used as a test for life without having to make any assumptions of it being like life on earth (and therefore only looking for biosignatures of life we know of). Assembly theory seems most interesting when applied to molecules, although it's not limited to that in scope. There are constraints on how complex molecules are formed in terms of what reacts with what, as well as some intuitive measure of complexity in terms of their size and variety of components and atomic bonds. One thing that Lee Cronin has discovered/noted is that mass spectrometry can be used as a crude way to measure complexity of molecules, and hence give an idea of their "assembly index", since different chemical bonds have different fingerprints in terms of how they absorb energy (diff. frequencies of UV or IR light absorbed in the mass spec.). There's a couple of different applications of this use of mass spectroscopy as a proxy for assembly index that Cronin mentions in his interview with Lex Fridman, which do seem to provide some proof of it's predictions of high assembly index being an indicator of life, and relative assembly index and indicator of which came first. 1) NASA, wanting Cronin to prove the value of this as a potential life-detector, gave him a variety of unlabeled organic and inorganic samples, and Cronin was able to classify them all correctly based just on their mass spec. signatures. 2) By analyzing a variety of biological samples, again via his mass spec. technique, Cronin was able to reconstruct the evolutionary tree of life in agreement with other ways of doing this. He goes into a little detail on the Lex interview, but it sounds complex and he does not fully describe the technique/analysis.
- itissid 3y agoWould that also throw projects like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_Interferometer_For_Exoplanets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_Interferometer_For_Exopl... also into question?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- heroic 3y agoQuestion is to people who say if universe is teeming with life, then why is it not visible close by: We don't know how large the universe is. If say life is "teeming" means it's found every 1M Parsec on the size of 10^100M Parsec, wouldn't it be teeming, and yet nothing in our vicinity? I'm being genuinely curious, not dissing on anyone.
- dsq 3y agoLife every million parsecs means less than one life form per galaxy, so hardly teeming.
- zaphirplane 3y agoFWIW there are 2 trillion galaxies in the universe So says Wikipedia
- ryandrake 3y agoAnd it's not just the size of the distance we can see, it's the size of the slice of time when we are looking. We've had the tools to sorta-kinda detect life signatures for what, 10-20 years? Maybe we can keep that up for another (at best) 100-1000 years until we destroy ourselves? The universe is on the order of 10^10 years old. Star formation will end ~10^14 years from now The last black holes will evaporate ~10^100 years from now. So our temporal search window is astronomically small, too.
- smegger001 3y agoWhy do you assume we distroy ourselves? If we can make spacecolonies at somepoint between now and your 1000 year figure why kill ourselves when we can leave for another star. It doesn't even have to be a popular strategy just one that a nonzero number choose to take rather that self distruction.
- peddling-brink 3y agoHow long can we teeter on the knife edge of global annihilation without someone pushing the wrong button?
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoRegarding alien life and search for it, I have really big problem with concept of Dyson Sphere/Swarm. The moment when human race will be able to build such megastructures, it is very likely that long time before that fusion generators will be about as common as a smart phone and probably with a same size. Furthermore matter is just condensed energy, so why bother with some wonky immobile megastructure when you can just decay your everyday trash into pure energy.
- randomname93857 3y ago>> Furthermore matter is just condensed energy, so why bother with some wonky immobile megastructure when you can just decay your everyday trash into pure energy. True, matter is an energy... however the only known way to convert matter into pure energy is to make it annihilate with antimatter ( akin to electron-positron). We first have to have a good and cheap source of antimatter! And the matter annihilation may still generate a lot of particles/matter - that may be a waste (or not) depending what you do with that further. A Partial conversion of a matter into energy is also fusion and fission reactions, but they are limited by the difference between source and end element of reaction here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_peak#/media/File:Binding_energy_curve_-_common_isotopes.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_peak#/media/File:Binding_... - e.g. H2 -> He3, That uses only a tiny portion of matter, no energy that can be extracted from Fe56 (max), and all its close elements are also useless for either fusion or fission energy extraction.
- XorNot 3y agoWe're closer to building a Dyson swarm today then we are to workable fusion reactors though - as in, we technically have the technology and means to start building one right now - a series of solar-harvesting satellites in Earth-halo orbits beaming microwave power back towards us. It would be inefficient, but there is no physical reason we couldn't do it. The other problem is scale: Dyson swarm power levels are orders of magnitude greater then the amount of deuterium in the Earth's oceans. At those sort of levels, you can't use fusion because you don't have the fuel. Finally, based on what we know there's some real problems with compact fusion: ITER and other big vacuum vessels are because we're at the materials science limits of how strong magnets can be without destroying themselves.
- gentleman11 3y agoBecause there’s nothing out there but swarms of paperclip optimizer ai drones, converting all the universes mass into paperclip fueled war machines for when they encounter a competing paperclip swarm
- polycaster 3y agohttps://www.decisionproblem.com/paperclips/index2.html https://www.decisionproblem.com/paperclips/index2.html
- guybedo 3y agoit sometimes is a bit sad to realize we will probably never confirm the existence of intelligent life forms somewhere else in the universe. Given the size of the universe, billions of galaxies, and each galaxy having billions and billions of stars, life obviously exists somewhere else, and we can safely say it exists in many places and intelligent life forms have emerged and have built civilizations somewhere else. Given the age of the universe, it's highly probable that other intelligent life forms have built civilizations way more advanced than the human civilization. Most of human scientific and technological progress happened in the last 200 hundred years. We can only imagine what a society with a 100 000 years head start would look like. I can't imagine what the human race will look like and will be able to do in 10 000 years. Our galaxy has a 100 000 light years diameter, even if an advanced civilization somewhere in the galaxy, on a planet 20 000 light years away had invented radio 10 000 years ago, we still wouldn't be able to detect it. By the time we detect it, who knows what technological progress they'd made by then. I tend to think that the answer to the Fermi paradox is that the universe is so big. Even if we could travel at the speed of light, the universe would still be huge and we would probably not be able to detect other intelligent life forms / civilizations. EDIT: Oops, looks like i got this Proxima Centauri distance a bit off :-) Updated the comment to remove this error, as the main point still stands.
- verve_rat 3y agoUm, Proxima Centauri is about 4 light-years away.
- eindiran 3y agoYeah, not sure where the other figure came from. There is literally a project to build unmanned craft to visit Proxima Centauri sometime in the next 50 years or so: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_Starshot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_Starshot
- m3kw9 3y ago“Knowing of no way that phosphine could be produced except through biological processes..” This type of logic is what is limiting scientists and human progress in general, they cannot think past their egos.
- fbdab103 3y agoThe actual publications were far less definitive. The NY times article[0] The astronomers, who reported the finding on Monday in a pair of papers, have not collected specimens of Venusian microbes, nor have they snapped any pictures of them. But with powerful telescopes, they have detected a chemical — phosphine — in the thick Venus atmosphere. After much analysis, the scientists assert that something now alive is the only explanation for the chemical’s source. Later in the same article On such worlds, “as far as we can tell, only life can make phosphine,” Dr. Sousa-Silva said. She has long studied the gas, on the theory that finding it being emitted from rocky planets that orbit distant stars could be proof that life exists elsewhere in the Milky Way. The actual publication abstract[1] ...If PH3 ’s presence in Venus’ atmosphere is confirmed, it therefore is highly likely to be the result of a process not previously considered plausible for Venusian conditions. The process could be unknown geochemistry, photochemistry, or even aerial microbial life, given that on Earth phosphine is exclusively associated with anthropogenic and biological sources. Which reads to me like a, "We saw something funny" result. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/14/science/venus-life-clouds.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/14/science/venus-life-clouds... [1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/2009.06499.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2009.06499.pdf
- wnc3141 3y agoAre there any trickle down technologies or scientific discoveries making the search itself worthwhile? In terms of an economic development perspective?
- alfiedotwtf 3y agoDiscovering life outside of earth would be the greatest human achievement for the next 5000 years, but you’re worried about if it’s worthwhile?
- yen223 3y ago"Is it worthwhile?" is not a bad question to ask. If someone proposed to use all of our resources to discover life outside of Earth, we would probably agree that's not the best use of our resources. But this means there's an upper bound to the cost we're willing to bear. Which leads to the question, how much resources should we devote to finding life outside of Earth? The answer to that question is, yes, dependent on the expected economic outcome of finding extraterrestrial life.
- wnc3141 3y agoAbsolutely in that sense the ends justify the means. I was just wondering what we can get from the means themselves given how far off achieving that end appears.
- zaphirplane 3y agoWhat if they treated humans the same way human empires treated other humans in America, Canada, Australia, South America , New Zealand
- peddling-brink 3y agoA common enemy to unite all of humanity will certainly provide economic development.
- somenameforme 3y agoI think your comment is sarcastic, but Poe's Law in the age of $ > all makes it impossible to tell. If it's genuine I'd only emphasize that the point of money is to be able to do great things. GDP doesn't matter whatsoever, but the betterment of lifestyles and civilization that it's supposed to* correlate against does. And discovering a species, regardless of how simply or complex, on another planet would be one of the greatest discoveries and achievements in human history, with immense scientific and philosophical value. --- * - kind of funny, but the reason GDP was invented was a local jurisdiction claiming it was being overtaxed. But needless to say the reason countries obsess over it today is not to try to reduce their tax burden.
- HideousKojima 3y agoIt seems strange to me that life is the default assumption instead of "new chemical process for creating phosphine/whatever that we weren't aware of before." The latter seems to me like it would require far fewer assumptions