8 ms·
I don't understand how either of these are remotely constitutional. They sure aren't what is in the spirit. They asked for information about a video watched 30
by godelski 3y ago
I don't understand how either of these are remotely constitutional. They sure aren't what is in the spirit.
They asked for information about a video watched 30k times. Supposing every person watched that video 10 times AND supposing the target was one of the viewers (it really isn't clear that this is true), that's 2999 people who have had their rights violated to search for one. I believe Blackstone has something to say about this[0]. Literally 30x Blackstone's ratio, who heavily influenced the founding fathers.
I don't think any of this appears legitimate.
Edit: Ops
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio
- changoplatanero 3y agoThe second one seems a lot more narrow and more legitimate
- dirtyhippiefree 3y agoI remember Larry Ellison (Oracle) in the news saying that Privacy Is Dead a quarter century ago, long enough the article merely referred to it as famous (no date needed) in 2018. It was written six years ago... https://securitycurrent.com/privacy-is-dead-long-live-privacy/ https://securitycurrent.com/privacy-is-dead-long-live-privac...
- mingus88 3y agoCell phone tower data has been used for a decade now in pretty much the same way. Did you happen to pass by a cell tower in a major city around the time a crime was committed? We all have. Well, your IEMI was included in a cell tower dump. Probably dozens of times. Did you happen to drive your car over any bridge in the Bay Area lately? Did a municipal vehicle pass you and catch your license plate with their ALPR camera? Guess what? Your name went through a database of an LEO search if they wanted to find a perp for that time/location. Privacy has been dead for a long time. The worst part is people don’t care. The Snowden files changed nothing. If there was ever a point in history where people would have given up their cell phones for their civil liberties, that would have been the time to do it.
- skybrian 3y agoThis sounds scary, and yet I seem to be unharmed.
- ikekkdcjkfke 3y agoA case is criminal gangs buying from data brokers to scam elders
- sriram_malhar 3y agoShall we wait on the laws until you personally come to some harm?
- skybrian 3y agoNo, but the argument did use "you" to imply that the reader was harmed. I consider that an illegitimate scare tactic. It would be better to talk about how someone else might be harmed.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoIf you weren't one of the 30k watching the video, you are the "someone else".
- alt227 3y agoThen they came for me. And there was no one left to speak out for me
- godelski 3y ago> Cell phone tower data has been used for a decade now in pretty much the same way. I was mad then. I'm more mad now. Stop these arguments because it isn't like one implies the other. And who the fuck cares if someone wasn't but is now. What's the argument, that you're a hipster? That's not solving problems. I don't want to gatekeep people from joining the movement to protect rights. I don't care if they joined as a tin foil hat or just yesterday after having literally been complacent in these atrocities. If you're here now, that's what matters. > Privacy has been dead for a long time. The worst part is people don’t care. Bull, and bull. There are plenty of people fighting back. I'm pretty sure me getting ads in languages I don't speaks is at least some good sign. Maybe I can't beat the NSA, sure, but can I beat mass surveillance? Can I beat 10%? 50%? 80%? 1% is better than 0% and privacy will die when we decide everything is binary. People care. People are tired. People feel defeated. These are different things. If people didn't care Apple (and even Google) wouldn't advertise themselves as privacy conscious. Signal wouldn't exist and wouldn't have 50 million users. It's not time to lay down and give up. > mingus88 36 minutes ago | parent | context | flag | on: Google Ordered to Identify Who Watched Certain You... Cell phone tower data has been used for a decade now in pretty much the same way. Did you happen to pass by a cell tower in a major city around the time a crime was committed? We all have. Well, your IEMI was included in a cell tower dump. Probably dozens of times. Did you happen to drive your car over any bridge in the Bay Area lately? Did a municipal vehicle pass you and catch your license plate with their ALPR camera? Guess what? Your name went through a database of an LEO search if they wanted to find a perp for that time/location. Privacy has been dead for a long time. The worst part is people don’t care. > The Snowden files changed nothing. They didn't change enough, but that isn't nothing.
- vages 3y agoDid you forget the link to Blackstone?
- godelski 3y agoyes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio
- CobrastanJorji 3y agoI agree that it's egregious, but Sir Blackstone was talking about punishment, especially relating to execution, and I think perhaps the ratio can be adjusted significantly downward when the cost to the innocent is much lower. Otherwise, the only reasonable search would be when a government official is already certain of your guilt.
- godelski 3y agoI'd consider your rights being violated "punishment." Blackstone was talking in the abstract. Clearly Franklin was too considering many of the other things he's known for saying.
- andsoitis 3y ago> I'd consider your rights being violated "punishment." You are wrong. Punishment is when you impose a penalty as retribution for an offense.
- godelski 3y agoYou can call me wrong, but maybe first ensure you understand negative rights. I understand why you think I'm wrong, but I hope you understand why I think that way. We can disagree, and that is fine, but let's not act as if there are objective answers in social constructs. Because, I do think punishment is an imposed penalty. In this case, on your rights. Rights are abstract, and these are not binary nor clearly discrete. House arrest is not jail, nor are fines. But as communicated to you elsewhere, the 4th amendment is about ensuring friction for removing someone's negative rights. But I disagree that punishment is imposed as a penalty as retribution for an offense. You imply that this requires an actual offense to have been made. I assure you that punishment can be imposed for any arbitrary reason. I can also assure you that punishment is a spectrum, from extremely minor (as I think we'd agree is in this case) and extremely harsh.
- CobrastanJorji 3y agoYou to are having a debate over semantics. Most dictionaries would probably agree that punishment is, definitionally, retribution for an offense. You cannot punish without a reason because that's not punishment, it's just hurting people. Your definition may be different, and that's fine, but you can't logic your way out of a difference of opinion on the definition of the word.
- jameshart 3y agoBlackstone: "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer" So not sure where you got the impression he's okay with up to 100 people being disturbed so we can catch one bad guy. But then, he wasn't really talking about that was he? Better the guilty go free than the innocent suffer what? He was, essentially, talking about the principle of innocent until proven guilty; that innocent people shouldn't suffer by being punished for a crime unjustly. 2999 innocent people, in your formulation, though, are not being punished for a crime. They're not even being accused of a crime.
- godelski 3y agoWell I forgot to link but from the wiki Other commentators have echoed the principle. Benjamin Franklin stated it as: "it is better 100 guilty Persons should escape than that one innocent Person should suffer" I went with Franklin because we are specifically talking America but let's be honest, the number doesn't matter and it seems you agree. Let's focus on that. Because I'm 100% with you, this isn't even people who have been accused. Which even those accused have rights. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio
- jameshart 3y agoYou've still got the ratio backwards. Franklin says if you know 101 people watched a video, and 100 of them are guilty of a crime, you can't just round up all 101 and throw them in jail. I.e., if you have a standard of punishment that would convict even one innocent person for every 100 guilty people it catches, it's not a good standard. Which I think we can all agree with. But that's not what's happening here, is it?
- chii 3y agoso it is considered punishment to have the watch information revealed to the state?
- godelski 3y ago> you can't just round up all 101 and throw them in jail Yes. "100 people" (or whatever) had their rights violated. Sure, not as bad as jail, but it is still in the spirit. I'm not sure why you think I have it backwards, I think we're just using different perspectives. But I'm not into being pedantic if we understand one another.
- naasking 3y ago> Supposing every person watched that video 10 times AND supposing the target was one of the viewers (it really isn't clear that this is true), that's 2999 people who have had their rights violated to search for one I think whether their rights are violated depends entirely on what sort of information is handed over. Consider acquiring surveillance footage that has plenty of foot traffic, but a suspect is known to have passed by. The police are typically permitted to review that footage even though plenty of innocent people were captured on that video.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>depends entirely on what sort of information is handed over. Apparently: >The court orders show the government telling Google to provide the names, addresses, telephone numbers and user activity for all Google account users who accessed the YouTube videos between January 1 and January 8, 2023. The government also wanted the IP addresses of non-Google account owners who viewed the videos. That definitely seems like an overreach.
- okr 3y agoIf it is an order by a court, then i think it is ok. Then it is no mass surveillance and for solving a crime it is useful. I wonder what kind of video it is. Maybe a shared link, so only people who secretly know about it knew about it, and they have become suspects. Is it mentioned in the forbes article? And i wonder if people abuse videos on youtube by encrypting the content with a key and the key is then shared.
- wolverine876 3y ago> If it is an order by a court, then i think it is ok. Then it is no mass surveillance and for solving a crime it is useful. Why can't a court order be mass surveillance? In these cases, the videos were viewed 30,000 times and more than 130,000 times (if I understand the latter correctly). How is that not mass? Nobody suggests that more than a few of those people are suspects.
- okr 3y agoMy understanding of mass surveillance is, that masses are surveilled. :) But here its a court, that allows extracting log data for a specific case and it happened after the fact. I make a difference between leaving loggable traces of living (which we leave all the time, no matter what) and sometimes filtering to recapture the past.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoemphasis on "Specific". This doesn't feel specific at all. Mass surveillance or not, this feels like a failure of the warrant itself passing.
- jll29 3y agoThat's right even if the sample size N=30,000, it is still a one-time point event controlled/approved by the proper legal authority. There will be an audit trail of said approval and the process will be documented. In contrast mass surveillance is just "oh, we have a BIG database, and we query whenever for whatever purpose, and nobody knows who searched for what and when and why, and nobody EXTERNAL TO THE AGENCY needs to approve it (lack of control). And today, Bob, who works for the police, background-searched his new girlfriend as well."
- iteygib 3y agoAny kind of search can be deemed constitutional if it goes through a warrant process, which is the point of warrants. This story is less about the how the information was taken and more about whether or not the warrant process and 4th Amendment rights were properly followed. This would then be mixed in with the question of whether or not new forms of data (like video views) would equate to previous forms of similar data searches that police have obtained warrants for (like reviewing CCTV).
- lolinder 3y agoOP explicitly agrees with you that the 30k is illegitimate, but that's the only one you address. What's your take on the one where the police became aware that they were being watched on a YouTube livestream while responding to a bomb threat and obtained a court order asking for information about who was viewing a set of local livestreams at the specific times where they were searching for the bomb? What makes that one different than a court order demanding that a business release security footage that covers the scene of a crime for the time window in which the crime occurred? Or would you consider such a court order to also be illegitimate?
- mistermann 3y ago> I don't think any of this appears legitimate. It isn't. Democracy is fake. Our justice system is fake. Everything is fake. (Where "fake" = "not what they are advertised or perceived to be.) If all of the same things were occurring in another country, or even better: in a video game, you would have little difficulty and zero aversion to accepting these facts. However: put a person into these things, and the brain malfunctions. If you are a reasonably normal person, your mind will now be filled with objections to this proposition, reasons why I am incorrect. But if you were to state those objections, I can punch holes in every single one of them without even breaking a sweat. We live in a literal simulation, but not the kind that everyone has been hypnotized to believe is the only kind possible - have you ever noticed that when the notion of simulation theory comes up, it is always The simulation theory (Nick Bostrom's)? This is a pretty neat trick eh? And there seems to be nothing that can be done about it, because people will fight tooth and nail (using Meme Magic, aka "The Facts", "The Reality", etc) against being extracted. Thankfully, it is simultaneously hilarious. Well, except the part where millions of children are dying, but nobody cares....but oh boy when a big scary "pandemic" comes along, pull out all the stops. I hope that there is a Hell, because I would like to see every single member of this despicable 21st century society end up there some day. Seeing justice finally being served for once would be worth suffering for eternity.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>Well, except the part where millions of children are dying, but nobody cares....but oh boy when a big scary "pandemic" comes along, pull out all the stops. You MAY have had a point somewhere in those ramblings, but this right here just kind of undoes any credibility.
- mistermann 3y agoA rather bold (yet oh so common) metaphysical & cognitive claim. I think it's fun to imagine that pandemics are some sort of supernatural punishment for human hubris in Western nations.
- singleshot_ 3y agoBetter one person not be crushed to death than two thousand nine hundred ninety nine suffer essentially no harm whatsoever. No, that doesn’t seem very familiar.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoIf we're being honest here: it's money laundering. It's not an inherently harmful crime except to the IRS. so apparently it's the most heinous thing imaginable (meanwhile, every corporation...). No one is in danger, this is an absurd request for an absurd result of... catching a dude using cryptocurrency the way the government doesn't like. Screw the government.