10 ms·
Google: Angular and Wiz Are Merging
- TechTechTech 3y agoAnyone has any non video source with more info on this?
- mgechev 3y agoWe’re going to share a blog post with more details in the next couple of days.
- ts330 3y agoExciting? Possibly for those involved. I hate to say this, as I'm generally optimistic towards most developments like this, but over the last decade I've become so apathetic towards anything and everything from Google. They've lost so much mindshare and credibility. Their org structure leads to stagnation left, right and centre. I'd rather tolerate the poor status quo in React land than take any sort of bet on Google getting something "newish" right. It wasn't always like this.
- kilroy123 3y agoI agree as someone who has spent the past decade working in Angular all day and then React. And I don't love React.
- vasco 3y agoGoogle was too innovative and successful to use external consultants and so the consultants joined the company as employees and did it from the inside!
- pavlov 3y agoGoogle today feels like Nokia of the mid-2000s. Victim of its own massive success, taken over by internal politics and divisions. Employs lots of smart people who figured out key ideas for next-gen tech early, but the organization is unable to take any of those innovations to market. And so it’s just stuck milking its cash cow. Google’s AI strategy is as clear as Nokia’s smartphone software strategy was.
- ta988 3y agoThey took some of the best brains, spoiled them with high salaries and glory and took their best years to make them work on dumb problems and projects that were cancelled at various stages of their life.
- adrianmsmith 3y agoThose best brains did produce lots of interesting things, back in the day (not recently). The Google search algorithm, the ads auctioning system, Gmail, Golang, certain parts of Google Cloud like BigQuery (create relational tables, just stuff data in there, just scales by itself without "provisioning", write SQL queries including joins e.g. over hundreds of billions of rows...)
- unclebucknasty 3y agoDon't forget Google Wave. May 2010 - August 2010. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Wave https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Wave
- pookha 3y agoIt was mostly always like this. You might go back further, but since 2008 I've been dealing with google snake-oil. They sold a customer I worked with a "search appliance" in 2007 that was more or less a paperweight. They packaged up "commodity hardware" in a fancy yellow google case and overcharged this military unit out the ass for what was a half-assed map-reduce algorithm with no security and no means of compartmentalizing the data that was stored on the appliance. This was years before the elk-stack. I can still distinctly remember the commander - an old special forces guy - telling the google-rep that he wanted to do a Roshambo game (Cartman nut kicking contest). A year or so later I cracked open their case and saw that they'd essentially packaged up an old dell poweredge 6K series with slow magnetic drives (and raid-5 lol). Maybe that fly's if you'd chained fifteen of these things into a cluster but that's not how they sold them to their customers. Google is a dishonest company filled with immoral lechers.
- bheadmaster 3y agoGolang is one of the Google products that I consider revolutionary in programming. But then again, it may just be because they employed the rockstars (Rob Pike, Ken Thomson, and Robert Griesemer) to work on it. I suppose it's less about the company, and more about who the company chooses to work on the project.
- kardianos 3y agoExactly, but the Go team appears to have the exact opposite mindset as Google product managers. They care about maintaining a product and compatibility, without major API revisions. They appear to care about first principle engineering, not "let's make a new product!". Okay, watching this video, and they just infantized their audience "if someone makes you uncomfortable, come find a staff" as if the conference goers aren't adults. That makes me really uncomfortable that they think adults can't handle themselves and work things out.
- twelfthnight 3y agoI hear "revolutionary" claimed about languages like Rust, Haskell and Zig, but rarely about Go. What about Golang is revolutionary to you?
- adrianmsmith 3y agoThe way concurrency works is pretty unique amongst mainstream languages. Java has just copied some parts of how concurrency works in Go, but that's nearly 20 years after Go was released. It's extremely easy to start up code concurrently with "go foo()". You can start up lots of such functions concurrently, as it works in userspace. Like async code, but no "colored functions" problem.
- Workaccount2 3y agoEveryday that Sundar is still CEO leaves me more and more bewildered. I cannot figure out how Brin and Page (who together own voting majority) look at google of 2024 and say "Yup, this is what we want Google to be".
- lgleason 3y agoThey have essentially retired and are just enjoying the money they made from it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- agotterer 3y agoThe goal of a public company is to increase shareholder value. Hard to argue that Sundar hasn’t done that. Revenue has increased 5 years straight. Market cap with the exception of a dip during Covid is strong and is approaching its all time high. As a Goolgle user and long time admirer, there have certainly been some disappointments and mistakes over the years. But there’s also been some major accomplishments which people sometimes overlook. While still early, Waymo seems to be on the right trajectory and may be a key player in autonomous vehicles. Let’s not forget Googles work on transformers, which is heavily responsible for the current AI boom. That’s just two that come to mind, I’m sure there are others. Maybe these were started before Sundar, but he’s been CEO for almost 9 years now. So he gets credit. Google may have some culture challenges to work through, brain drain, and identity issues. But I don’t think their story is written just yet. With a giant stock pile of cash they have plenty of time and resources to buy or figure their way out of any perceived issues (if that’s even what they need to do). Microsoft did it. And if you really want to have your mind blown, go take a look at IBMs stock chart. I didn’t expect to see it approaching an all time high.
- twelfthnight 3y agoWhat choice can you point to that has increased Google's market cap? Google's search quality is deteriorating, Waymo is yet to make a profit, GCP is struggling, "Attention is all you need" was too early on to credit Sundar, and since then Google's reputation is flagging due to embarrassing AI models... I think Google's market cap is increase _despite_ Sundar, not because. That said, Google does have enough resources to turn it around, I just don't think Sundar is the right person to do it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- easton 3y agoFor people who didn't know: Wiz is apparently a internal framework that Google uses for their apps that wasn't ever open sourced (at least, not completely, based on a quick search). At least they'll be dogfooding Angular now hopefully.
- throwaway290 3y agoI thought some teams at Google were dogfooding Angular for many years now?
- nness 3y agoI can say from experience that Google requires third-parties use Angular when they are developing experiences on behalf of Google — i.e. through their agency partners.
- brianzelip 3y agoLots have been [0,1] 0, https://changelog.com/jsparty/310 https://changelog.com/jsparty/310 1, https://changelog.com/jsparty/312 https://changelog.com/jsparty/312
- throwaway290 3y agoYeah. I distinctly remember Google using it itself a big motivator to go with AngularJS and then Angular in side projects, so I was not wrong...
- danpalmer 3y agoBasically all web frontends I've seen here are either Angular or Wiz, depending on latency requirements, or they're some legacy technology that is being moved to Angular or Wiz.
- montgomeryburns 3y agoAny tips on preparing to work with Wiz as an incoming intern. I heard its identical to Stimulus: https://stimulus.hotwired.dev/ https://stimulus.hotwired.dev/
- nvahalik 3y agoAngular I know… but what the heck is Wiz?
- jitl 3y agoIt’s the internal framework they use for Search and YouTube. I’ve heard of it from Xooglers but besides them I don’t think it’s well known.
- brabel 3y agoApparently another Google web framework... I had never heard of it, but I know this company called Wiz and thought it may be related for a second: https://www.wiz.io/ https://www.wiz.io/
- ljoshua 3y agoNo relation.
- jgalt212 3y agoCan anyone recommend a good resource discussing the interplay between highly optimized js bundles and code caching? i.e. it seems to be me that one would benefit by serving the same js blob on most / all pages even if it includes unused code because then you pretty much always utilize the code cache.
- rimunroe 3y agoMaybe I’m misunderstanding your question but why would you want a single bundle vs multiple bundles? If you have a single blob you have to invalidate the whole thing when it updates. If you split your code out into multiple bundles you can invalidate only the bundles which contain changes. As far as I know this has been standard practice for the last decade at least.
- iainmerrick 3y agoI think it’s a good question, and the answer isn’t quite as straightforward as you suggest. The advantage of bundling is that you can do cross-module minification and dead-strip unused code. The extreme version of “multiple bundles” would be to minify each JS module individually, but don’t bundle them. That would clearly miss a lot of size optimisations. (And as I understand it, this is how Deno’s new package manager is meant to work, which makes me a bit suspicious.) The opposite extreme of one bundle for the entire app is great for optimisation, but as you say, then you have to invalidate the whole thing if anything changes. One bundle per route is tempting but then common code gets duplicated. Vite’s default behavior (via Rollup) is to make one bundle per common module. That works pretty well but I’ve found the number of output bundles can explode in surprising ways. In a recent project I manually split the code into chunks and loaded them via dynamic import() and that worked pretty well -- good balance of size optimisation, caching and manual control.
- jgalt212 3y agoThis is probably some big hairy statistical optimization problem. 100 bundles across 1,000 routes. How to you pack up the 100 bundles into n (n<100) larger bundles such that average time to interactive is smallest. Of course, you get different answers depending on first time vs returning site visitors.
- hiddencost 3y agoI hate wiz. But maybe having a public facing user base will force basic usability.
- bossyTeacher 3y agoThis is not Wiz the web builder product you know about. It's an internal framework used by Google.
- montgomeryburns 3y agoAny tips on preparing to work with Wiz as an incoming intern. I heard its identical to Stimulus: https://stimulus.hotwired.dev/ https://stimulus.hotwired.dev/
- ecmascript 3y agoI hate Angular with a passion. It's easily the most verbose, overly complex front end framework I've ever used which just takes the fun out of building web apps and make it a pure pain. I would rather work on a farm and shovel pig shit all day than work in Angular again. My last job forced Angular on me, I quit after a while (not because of solely that reason) but I told them Angular was a bad choice and they chose to overrule me. Pretty funny now, they will have to endure the pain of migrating a large app which makes me feel good. Make stupid choices, win stupid prizes.
- approxim8ion 3y agoTo offer a differing experience, I've been working in Angular for a couple of years now and personally like it quite a bit. I don't like frontend frameworks in general, but given the choice I prefer Angular over React.
- Andrex 3y agoAngular was made for you, basically. I've always seen that as the use case. It never seemed suitable for mostly-frontend devs, but it's probably perfect for mostly-backend ones.
- approxim8ion 3y agoYeah, that makes sense I suppose. My Java background also means the verbosity and structure doesn't bother me much.
- usui 3y agoI seldom see this opinion but I'm glad to read it. People complain about JSX on the React side but what on Earth am I reading when I see the templating language that Angular came up with? ngIf, ngBlah. Much worse than JSX, which is subordinate to JavaScript code, not equal. I also have been forced to use Angular at the workplace and it killed any fun making web apps had. People say Angular is great for enterprise because it removes the burden of deciding things, but this indicates an organizational problem being solved technologically. In other words: Never a good thing. Similar conversation 10 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35811256 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35811256
- bruh2 3y agoOff topic, but is there any chance to avoid sharing Twitter links? Would rather not log in to the site
- spamtarget 3y agoi'm with you, i used to use nitter with the firefox extension, but it seems to be dying, is there any alternative?
- pabs3 3y agoThere is https://twstalker.com/ https://twstalker.com/ but the site is very very dodgy.
- spamtarget 3y agothanks, maybe that will become something later, but i am looking for an browser extension that doing the work for me
- pabs3 3y agoMaybe one of these: https://libredirect.github.io/ https://libredirect.github.io/ https://einaregilsson.com/redirector/ https://einaregilsson.com/redirector/ Note the site I linked is very dodgy, so probably not trustworthy.
- spamtarget 3y agoi checked them, but libredirect removed the twitter option from the config menu (i guess because of the changes in the twitter api) and the other just a generic url to url redirect. but thanks anyway
- pabs3 3y agoYou can easily add twstalker to the generic one.
- throwaway4good 3y agoI hear most Angular projects being stuck at around version 15 due not being able to migrate away from Angular Material "Legacy".
- tietjens 3y agoThis seems to be true for many and happened to me. It is an absolute nightmare trying to upgrade Material. Now I’ve convinced my team to move to a different framework.
- the_cramer 3y agoThere are still issues with density not working well with some angular Material controls. This forced us to do some hacky css stuff. Some of the github issues have been open a long time now...
- peer2pay 3y agoYou can upgrade all the way to Angular 17 without having to adopt the new MDC components. Only this May with Angular 18 support for the legacy components will be dropped completely. That’s the reason we’re currently migrating all our remaining usages of Material components to ng-zorro.
- tubthumper8 3y agoThey previously announced [1] these would be removed in v17, did that change? [1] https://blog.angular.io/angular-v16-is-here-4d7a28ec680d https://blog.angular.io/angular-v16-is-here-4d7a28ec680d
- peer2pay 3y agoNo but Angular 17 is backwards compatible with @angular/material@16 so you can upgrade Angular without having to upgrade Material [1]. We currently run @angular/core@17.0.8 and @angular/material@16.2.12 in production without problems. In the end this only buys you another 6 months but helped us get ready for Angular 18 in May. [1] https://blog.angular.io/introducing-angular-v17-4d7033312e4b https://blog.angular.io/introducing-angular-v17-4d7033312e4b
- JamesonNetworks 3y agoUgh, this isn’t Angular anymore. This will be just like the v1 -> v2 transition. Presignal -> signal. The second they start deprecating the previous syntax, we will hit very difficult migrations
- baggachipz 3y agoWe just got done porting everything from AngularJS to Angular D:
- wentin 3y agoA joke or really? At this point, I would just port it into Svelte, it is the same amount of effort anyway and it has been so long!
- baggachipz 3y agoWe started the transition years ago; large codebase to port. Trust me, if it was my choice it wouldn't be Angular. I trust no google product.
- b15h0p 3y agoThere is a pretty usable migration tool built into Angular CLI at least for switching over to the new template syntax. Requires some manual cleanup here and there but overall it’s not painful at all.
- pquki4 3y agoHow "not painful" would it be for a codebase with thousands of files, hundreds of which are widgets?
- miiiiiike 3y agoFor years I’ve been saying “Angular is the wrong choice now but it will be the right one someday…” I didn’t think it would take 5 years to get there. The Angular team has been doing incredible work lately. The only thing that I still don’t like about Angular is trying to learn anything from the reference docs. Have a reasonable developer tell me what a component viewProvider is and how it’s different from a provider using the @Component docs. It’s impossible. https://angular.io/api/core/Component#viewProviders https://angular.io/api/core/Component#viewProviders Whatever committee decided to silo the Angular reference docs from the usage docs has caused more harm than most of the hyperbolic non-examples I can come up with. If you’re writing docs, please, please do me a favor and study the structure of the Django and Python docs.
- sieabahlpark 3y ago[dead]
- dgellow 3y agoWhat makes it the right choice in your opinion?
- hmcdona1 3y ago> Have a reasonable developer tell me what a component viewProvider is and how it’s different from a provider using the @Component docs. It’s impossible. https://angular.io/api/core/Component#viewProviders https://angular.io/api/core/Component#viewProviders Like this? - https://angular.io/guide/hierarchical-dependency-injection#using-the-viewproviders-array https://angular.io/guide/hierarchical-dependency-injection#u... - (new docs site) https://angular.dev/guide/di/hierarchical-dependency-injection#using-the-viewproviders-array https://angular.dev/guide/di/hierarchical-dependency-injecti...
- miiiiiike 3y agoExactly my point. I linked to the reference docs, you linked to the usage docs. They're completely divorced from each other. There's not even a link from reference to usage docs. For the reference docs to be useful you already have to know what the thing is, what it does, why you'd need it. You can be on the component page where `viewProviders` is documented and get nothing from it if you're coming in fresh. Why would ever design docs like that? Angular is the only framework I've ever struggled to learn. It's a complicated framework but that's not the problem. The docs are the problem.
- Klaster_1 3y agoNot as exciting as the title might imply. Short story, they put Angular signals into Wiz, which powers YouTube among others. No concrete Wiz announcements besides that. If you follow the Angular changelogs and plans, the video basically recaps these in a less dry manner - the same as seen during previous ng-confs. There's a short section at the end [0] showcasing a preview of what's in the pipeline but didn't receive much coverage yet, such as less boilerplate when authoring components. [0] https://youtu.be/nIBseTi6RVk?t=4790 https://youtu.be/nIBseTi6RVk?t=4790
- lakomen 3y agoI've been working with Angular for 2 years, then moved to Vue and have been with it for, idk 3-4 years now. I like the theory of Angular, the modularity, the way it works, but I HATE rxjs and the complexity of it. And the whole thing on top of rxjs, ngrx. You can't just simply take one value and compare it, no you have to use pipes and rxjs. Also there's an Angular discord and they're very hostile towards anyone not fanboi-ing Angular. I was about 6 months into Vue and wrote how I prefer it, for its simplicity. Then I was constantly harassed until I was kick/banned. With another account I saw, "HEIL ANGULAR o/" written in the chat. That's just stupid. You have to be open minded. Angular has good things, but Vue has good things too and even React does. Never heard of Wiz before. Almost a year ago I created an Android developer account I believe it's called and paid the bill. The name on the invoice was wrong. I wanted them to update the invoice They responded with, "This is America, we do what we like" more or less. Ok, no problem, I have better things to do. Since I haven't published anything in almost 1 year, they're now threatening to close the account, I paid the $25 for. My adsense account, no new sites are being approved anymore, previously I could add any site without confirmation, even if it was new. I had a site that made them and me over 150k, but I got into a fight with my partner of that site and the main domain was shut down. I took the content and published it on another domain. Over 7 years of daily mp3 files and images. The 1st domain had adsense approval, the new one didn't. They didn't approve the 2nd domain. Talking to them is not possible. Google is spiraling downward. They're essentially cutting into their own flesh. Since Darth Sundar took over it's become progressively worse. All the wrong and used hostile decisions. I still use and like Go, but I'm afraid what will become of it in the future. It's unlikely I'll return to Angular. It's just too time inefficient and also slower compared to the other frameworks.
- mgechev 3y ago>...but I HATE rxjs and the complexity of it. And the whole thing on top of rxjs, ngrx. You can't just simply take one value and compare it, no you have to use pipes and rxjs. We're working on making RxJS optional. In v17.3 `@angular/core` no longer has a dependency on RxJS. In the long-term we'll enable a path forward without RxJS for other core modules as well. That said, we're providing an interop package that enables even better RxJS support for people who make the decision to use it.
- pier25 3y agoThis is great. Angular is getting partial hydration (seems automatic from the keynote but it's not clear) and deferred views which are like components that don't load until something happens (eg entering the viewport). Performance has increased considerably too thanks to the use of signals. Honestly I'm quite impressed. I wish Svelte had partial hydration but the team keeps arguing against it.
- benmccann 3y agoWe're not arguing against it, but simply haven't committed to doing or not doing it as Svelte 5 has been higher priority. We would rather be deliberative than introduce a feature where we don't have the developer experience fully thought out. We want to understand what the experience would be for Svelte users both with and without SvelteKit and have good guidance around the trade-offs of different rendering modes.
- pier25 3y ago> We're not arguing against it, but simply haven't committed to doing or not doing it as Svelte 5 has been higher priority. Please. This discussion has been going on for years Ben. Even before SvelteKit or Svelte 4 existed.
- pjmlp 3y agoI wasn't even aware Wiz exists!
- refulgentis 3y agoIt's hard to ask this without sounding like a jerk: does this matter to anyone externally? When I was still at Google, the web dev I knew who was in touch with outside stuff, talked about Angular as if its day had passed
- mgechev 3y agoHey everyone, I'm working on this at Google and would be happy to answer your questions :) The tldr; is that we see a lot of similar requirements from developers across Angular and Wiz, so we're looking for opportunities to reuse work. Good example is the Angular Signals library that's now used in all the YouTube Mobile Web. In a similar way, Angular is bringing more fine-grained code loading that Wiz offers. Over time, we'll continue focusing on what's best for developers and incorporating the best from Wiz in Angular, and vice versa. At the end we can end up with one framework, or continue to coexist. In the next couple of weeks we'll follow up with a blog post that explains our plan in more details.
- skybrian 3y agoI’m more familiar with Preact Signals. How does Angular Signals compare?
- mgechev 3y agoFundamentally they are similar to Preact Signals, Solid Signals, Vue signals, etc. We took some different trade-offs and listed the details here https://github.com/angular/angular/discussions/49683 https://github.com/angular/angular/discussions/49683
- RunSet 3y agoQuestion (you might need to pass this one up the chain of command): Was basic HTML gmail deprecated because users so overwhelmingly preferred slow, bloated UIs that there was no demand for an alternative?
- ktosobcy 3y agotbh - killing of basic html Gmail was the last straw that pushed me to other mail provider... I usually use imap but once in a blue moon I need to access mailbox via browser and regular Gmail client is just abysmal...
- mgechev 3y agoWe’re building infrastructure for these products rather than the products themselves. I’ll be happy to answer questions about Angular and our collaboration with Wiz :)
- mcgl 3y agoAngular is my favorite framework among the front-end frameworks I use.
- Alifatisk 3y agoI hope someone manages to extract Wiz out ouf Angular later on.