5 ms·
The AI tags are fundamentally useless. The premise is that it would prevent someone from misleading you by thinking that something happened when it didn't, but
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
The AI tags are fundamentally useless. The premise is that it would prevent someone from misleading you by thinking that something happened when it didn't, but someone who wants to do that would just not tag it then.
Which is where the real abuse comes in: You post footage of a real event and they say it was AI, and ban you for it etc., because what actually happened is politically inconvenient.
And the only way to prevent that would be a reliable way to detect AI-generated content which, if it existed, would obviate any need to tag anything because then it could be automated.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 3y agoNot convinced by this. Camera sensors have measurable individual noise, if you record RAW that won't be fakeable without prior access to the device. You'd have a straightforward case for defamation if your real footage were falsely labeled, and it would be easy to demonstrate in court.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Camera sensors have measurable individual noise, if you record RAW that won't be fakeable without prior access to the device. Which doesn't help you unless non-AI images are all required to be RAW. Moreover, someone who is trying to fabricate something could obviously obtain access to a real camera to emulate. > You'd have a straightforward case for defamation if your real footage were falsely labeled, and it would be easy to demonstrate in court. Defamation typically requires you to prove that the person making the claim knew it was false. They'll, of course, claim that they thought it was actually fake. Also, most people don't have the resources to sue YouTube for their screw ups.
- anigbrowl 3y agoMoreover, someone who is trying to fabricate something could obviously obtain access to a real camera to emulate. Yes, but not to your camera. Sorry for not phrasing it more clearly: individual cameras have measurable noise signatures distinct from otherwise identical models. On the lawsuit side, you just need to aver that you are the author of the original footage and are willing to prove it. As long as you are in possession of both the device and the footage, you have two pieces of solid evidence vs. someone elses feels/half-assed AI detection algorithm. There will be no shortage of tech-savvy media lawyers willing to take this case on contingency.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Yes, but not to your camera. But who is the "you" in this case? There can be footage of you that wasn't taken with your camera. The person falsifying it would just claim they used their own camera. Which they would have access to ahead of time in order to incorporate its fingerprint into the video before publishing it.
- Gregaros 3y agoDMCA abuse begs to differ.
- anigbrowl 3y agoThat's because of safe harbor provisions, which don't exist in this context.
- VelesDude 3y agoUnfortunately video codecs love to crush that fine detail.
- nomel 3y agoMost consumer cameras require access menus to enable raw because dealing with RAW is a truly terrible user experience. The vast majority of image/video sensors out there don't even support raw recordings, out of the box.
- anigbrowl 3y agoAnyone with a mid-to-upper range phone or better-than-entry level DSLR/bridge camera has access to this, and anyone who uses that camera to make a living (eg shooting footage of protests) understands how to use RAW. I have friends who are complete technophobes but have figured this out because they want to be able to sell their footage from time to time.
- fennecbutt 3y ago"Dealing with raw" is one of the major reasons to use an actual camera these days.
- MBCook 3y agoThat’s what I was thinking. Why don’t we just ask all scam videos to label themselves as scams while we’re at it? It’s nice honest users will do that but they’re not really the problem are they.
- makeitdouble 3y ago> Why don’t we just ask all scam videos to label themselves as scams while we’re at it? We do, we ask paid endorsements to be disclaimed.
- mazlix 3y agoI think you have a bit backwards. If you want to publish pixels on a screen there should be no assumption that they represent real events. If you want to publish proof of an event, you should have some pixels on a screen along with some cryptographic signature from a device sensor that would necessitate atleast a big corporation like Nikon / Sony / etc. being "in on it" to fake. Also since no one likes RAW footage it should probably just be you post your edited version which may have "AI" upscaling / de-noising / motion blur fixing etc, AND you can post a link to your cryptographically signed verifiable RAW footage. Of course there's still ways around that like your footage could just be a camera being pointed at an 8k screen or something but at least you make some serious hurdles and have a reasonable argument to the video being a result of photons bouncing off real objects hitting your camera sensor.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> If you want to publish proof of an event, you should have some pixels on a screen along with some cryptographic signature from a device sensor that would necessitate atleast a big corporation like Nikon / Sony / etc. being "in on it" to fake. At which point nobody could verify anything that happened with any existing camera, including all past events as of today and all future events captured with any existing camera. Then someone will publish a way to extract the key from some new camera model, both allowing anyone to forge anything by extracting a key and using it to sign whatever they want, and calling into question everything actually taken with that camera model/manufacturer. Meanwhile cheap cameras will continue to be made that don't even support RAW, and people will capture real events with them because they were in hand when the events unexpectedly happened. Which is the most important use case because footage taken by a staff photographer at a large media company with a professional camera can already be authenticated by a big corporation, specifically the large media company.
- robertlagrant 3y agoI think at minimum YouTube could tag existing footage uploaded before 2015 as very unlikely to be AI generated.
- kube-system 3y ago> The premise is that it would prevent someone from misleading you by thinking that something happened when it didn't, but someone who wants to do that would just not tag it then. And when they do that, the video is now against Google's policy and can be removed. That's the point of this policy.
- towelpluswater 3y agoI mean they’re building the labeled dataset right now by having creators label it for them. I would suspect this helps make moderation models better at estimating confidence levels of ai generated content that isn’t labeled as such (ie for deception). Surprised we aren’t seeing more of this in labeling datasets for this new world (outside of captchas)
- mr_toad 3y ago> The AI tags are fundamentally useless. To the extent that they allow Google to exclude AI video from training sets they’re obviously useful to Google.
- makeitdouble 3y agoAI tags are to cover issues in the other direction: you publish an event as real, but they can prove it wasn't. If you didn't put the tag on it, malice can be inferred from your post (and further legal proceeding/moderation can happen) It's the same as paid reviews: tags and disclaimers exist to make it easier to handle cases where you intentionally didn't put them. It's not perfect and can be abused in other ways, but at least it's something.
- cottsak 3y agoagreed! this is another censorship tool.
- valval 3y agoThey’re just gathering training data to train their AI-detection models.
- themoonisachees 3y agoThe do have some use. Take for example the AI images of the pope wearing luxury brands that someone made about last year. They clearly wanted to make it as a joke, not to purposefully misinform people, and as long as everybody is in on the joke then I see no issue with that. But some people who weren't aware of current AIgen capabilities took it as real and an AI tag would have avoided the discussion of "has AI art gone too far" while still allowing that person to make their joke.