9 ms·
In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize winner grows disenchanted
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pseudolus 3y agoRepublished from Finance & Development (no paywall): https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2024/03/Symposium-Rethinking-Economics-Angus-Deaton https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2024/03/Sym... Also: https://archive.ph/1F2Iy https://archive.ph/1F2Iy
- gwd 3y agoMost of it seems pretty good, but I'm not sure what to make of this one: "It has also been plausibly argued that the Great Migration of millions of African Americans from the rural South to the factories in the North would not have happened if factory owners had been able to hire the European migrants they preferred." In context, this is more than just an observation of potential cause and effect; the whole paragraph is about revising his previously-advocated policy positions: he used to think immigration was good, but he now sees a correlation between equality and low immigration. So what policy did he advocate re racist hiring policies at factories before, and what has it been changed to? Is he saying he used to be opposed to letting Detroit factory owners hire only whites, but now he thinks they should have been allowed to, because the Great Migration was a bad thing? Or is he saying he used to support letting Detroit factory owners hire only whites, but now he opposes it because the Great Migration was a good thing? EDIT: OK, I think he was actually saying something else: the Great Migration happened in part because factories needed black workers; they wouldn't have hired black workers if immigration from Europe had been as open as it had been previously. So the Great Migration was good, and that good was partially caused by a clamp-down on migration.
- bux93 3y agoHe's saying that if borders at the time had been more open to immigration from Europe, the European workers could have displaced black workers who migrated internally (within the US that is). I should not think he ever supported 'letting Detroit factory owners hire only whites', but rather he's saying that his previous position that immigration (from abroad) has little or no disadvantages to domestic workers did not take into account this example and he has adjusted his position accordingly. That an economist, even one of great stature such as himself, would have been blind to endemic racism within the power structures of society is, well, the point of his article.
- boxed 3y agoJust because it was good for the blacks who migrated north, doesn't mean it was good overall for the entire world. Or even for most blacks honestly. Maybe we would have seen bigger change in the south if the driven people didn't leave but instead stayed and fought the oppression. It's hard to argue good or bad when we don't have a control group...
- JoshGG 3y agoThanks!!! @dang - This should be the primary headline link
- makerdiety 3y agoNot Keyesian or Austrian economicists.
- ddtaylor 3y agoKenzians believe that they can accomplish anything with enough knob twiddling. I appreciate the straightforward principles of Austrian economics.
- skhunted 3y agoIs it possible that what you call knob twiddling is more effective/humane than the effect of Austrian economics when those principles are followed?
- once_inc 3y agoThat would be very difficult to say since we've never really been in an Austrian economic system. Austrians will point out that the knob twiddling done by Keynesians is a method of postponing or spreading out the pain of a recession over a large number of years. You can only do that so often before this creates a self-reinforcing mother-of-all-recessions where the accumulated debt and unhealthy investment comes crashing down. We have pushed our debt forward to our grandchildren since 1971. This is morally repugnant and hardly humane.
- RandomLensman 3y agoGiven how heterodox the Austrian school is: what would it even mean to have an Austrian economic system and how would it differ (and some Austrian ideas are part of "mainstream" economics anyway)?
- nyokodo 3y ago> what would it even mean to have an Austrian economic system and how would it differ It’s difficult to know exactly, but you would have an unmanaged system. No reserve bank, no stimulus, no regulation, minimum to no restraint on trade depending on how anarchist the Austrian Economist happens to be.
- bdastous 3y agoMeanwhile, there are plenty of disciplines in which practitioners would never seriously consider posing this question.
- bowsamic 3y agoI’m a physicist and I can tell you that physics is not one of them, we consider this question all the time
- sseagull 3y agoYeah, I regularly see (and attend) talks on reproducibility, repeatability, and replicability. It’s a problem in some areas, but not exactly hidden away. It is openly discussed and people are actively seeking solutions.
- timnf 3y agoTo which disciplines are you referring?
- master-lincoln 3y agoyour comment is just unfounded Whataboutism
- DrNosferatu 3y agoIt’s a very fair question - why all the downvotes? - Never heard of the replication crisis in science? [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis] This “quickness to put the knives out” is an unfortunate - but very prevalent - response pattern in HN. Hypothesis: could it be a protection mechanism against the discomfort of cognitive dissonance? - Why so or why not so?
- master-lincoln 3y agoThe downvotes are because the comment is not contributing to the topic at hand. It tries to derail the topic by saying the same applies to other unrelated things. And then it also fails to materialize that unrelated claim by not mentioning which other fields they are referring to or giving any evidence for the claim.
- bsenftner 3y agoThere is a major problem with economics: only Economists care about economics, while all media cares to use economics as propaganda, and that is it's effective purpose in our society, not economics and the study thereof, but to use as a conforming society utility.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smugglerFlynn 3y agoMass media caters to the popular demand, so what you see is likely a mirror of average lay interest in the economics (or, broader, in any knowledge about how the world works). For example, if a person believes that government is ought to get him, he will only read and watch the information that fits his belief, because chasing other opinions will just emotionally ruin his breakfast or a coffee break. Media is the entertainment, not the university where you go to change your world view. The reason some peope try to use media for non-entertainment is because other forms of knowledge lag months and years behind the present moment - so we have to extract knowledge from the entertainment. You can see it even on HN, where opinionated and anecdotal articles are regularly submitted and get to the top. There is no way to filter out accurately reported data from the entertainment pieces which were upvoted because they are relateable and fun.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoMedia and Politics. If the economist says what the politician already agrees with, then the politician doesn't need to look for another economist. Also can replace "economist" with "think tank organisation".
- bell-cot 3y agoJust like priests and counselors in the courts of ancient kings, modern economists are masters of telling those with power and wealth what they want to hear. And beautifully wrapped, in the trappings of moral legitimacy and learned wisdom. Sure, economists actually know some basics - just as the ancient priest knew that a cartload of grain burned as an offering to his god would not be available to feed the poor. But it ain't enough that you'd want to trust anything they say. (Vs. - ask any competent engineer about the sort of control inputs which are needed to maintain smooth-ish operation of a half-decent system (be it an airplane in flight, sewage treatment plant, blast furnace, whatever) which is actually understood. And compare to (say) the Federal Reserve's handling of the economy in recent decades.)
- master-lincoln 3y agoAnd just like the foundation knowledge of priests is made up, economist theories have turned out to be non-reproducible many times...
- yawpitch 3y agoI don’t think even supply and demand is reliably reproducible in real world conditions, at least not in the way vinegar + baking soda is reliable.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoPeople expect supply and demand to show its effects immediately, whereas it takes years in some markets due to things like sticky prices in things like wages or overwhelming demand relative to supply and hence underestimating the amount of additional supply needed.
- sumtechguy 3y agoThat is in next years budget
- flakeoil 3y ago
- tgv 3y ago> Efficiency is important, but we valorize it over other ends. Many subscribe ... to the stronger version that says that economists should focus on efficiency and leave equity to others, to politicians or administrators. But the others regularly fail to materialize, so that when efficiency comes with upward redistribution ... our recommendations become little more than a license for plunder. I would say: the others do not only fail to materialize, they often point back at economists. If a politician wants to raise taxes, wellfare, or nurses' salaries, the opposing arguments are more often than not economic in nature, and rely on the invisible hand. It does not follow that economists should take the place of politicians, though. Instead, they should be much more honest, open and direct about their claims, and also point out alternatives. They should, so to speak, grow a conscience.
- creshal 3y agoIndeed. Politicians point back at economists, and economists usually answer "oh, it's fine, just deregulate everything and manna will trickle down from the heavens eventually". It would do them good to be a bit less full of themselves.
- Findeton 3y agoI wish they said that. Unfortunately economists are usually keynsian and prefer to believe that war or burying money create wealth.
- flakeoil 3y agoJust this notion of Keynesian vs. Austrian and what have you is proof that Economics is not a science and closer to religion.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> this notion of Keynesian vs. Austrian and what have you is proof This is like taking the existence of Darwinian and Lamarkian evolution as proof that biology is not a science. You're quoting caricatures of old ideas.
- chasd00 3y agoThe author never mentions the straw that broke the camels back. They talk a little bit about AI but not enough to make it seem like that’s what changed their mind. They talk some about immigration, free trade, social justice but not really at length. I wonder what changed their mind.
- RandomLensman 3y agoI would venture it wasn't AI but the slowly declining relevance of academic economics in the policy sphere.
- lioeters 3y ago> ..Economists, who have prospered mightily over the past half century, might fairly be accused of having a vested interest in capitalism as it currently operates. > Without an analysis of power, it is hard to understand inequality or much else in modern capitalism. > After economists on the left bought into the Chicago School’s deference to markets—“we are all Friedmanites now”—social justice became subservient to markets > ..We have largely stopped thinking about ethics and about what constitutes human well-being. We often equate well-being with money or consumption > currently approved methods, randomized controlled trials, differences in differences, or regression discontinuity designs, have the effect of focusing attention on local effects, and away from potentially important but slow-acting mechanisms that operate with long and variable lags > today large corporations have too much power over working conditions, wages, and decisions in Washington, where unions currently have little say compared with corporate lobbyists. > Economists’ enthusiasm for technical change as the instrument of universal enrichment is no longer tenable (if it ever was). > [I] am even skeptical of the claim..that globalization was responsible for the vast reduction in global poverty.. I also no longer defend the idea that the harm done to working Americans by globalization was a reasonable price to pay for global poverty reduction
- GardenLetter27 3y ago> [I] am even skeptical of the claim..that globalization was responsible for the vast reduction in global poverty.. I also no longer defend the idea that the harm done to working Americans by globalization was a reasonable price to pay for global poverty reduction But that "harm" was coming regardless. The rest of the world had rebuilt after WW2 and is going to compete. Now those working Americans can enjoy cheaper goods from globalisation and everyone becomes richer. Protectionism just keeps everyone poorer in the long run. It only makes sense when you need to build or maintain specific local industry due to geopolitical concerns or to improve the general level of education and productivity - like in China in building their own Tech industry.
- DrNosferatu 3y ago“is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it” - Upton Sinclair? Specially evident during the Euro Crisis and the Austerity debacle.
- jimmySixDOF 3y agoQuoting from the link [1]: Milton Friedman's Thermostat If a house has a good thermostat, we should observe a strong negative correlation between the amount of oil burned in the furnace (M), and the outside temperature (V). But we should observe no correlation between the amount of oil burned in the furnace (M) and the inside temperature (P). And we should observe no correlation between the outside temperature (V) and the inside temperature (P). An econometrician, observing the data, concludes that the amount of oil burned had no effect on the inside temperature. Neither did the outside temperature. The only effect of burning oil seemed to be that it reduced the outside temperature. An increase in M will cause a decline in V, and have no effect on P. A second econometrician, observing the same data, concludes that causality runs in the opposite direction. The only effect of an increase in outside temperature is to reduce the amount of oil burned. An increase in V will cause a decline in M, and have no effect on P. But both agree that M and V are irrelevant for P. They switch off the furnace, and stop wasting their money on oil. [1]https://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2010/12/milton-friedmans-thermostat.html https://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/201...
- WhitneyLand 3y agoRelevant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique
- GardenLetter27 3y agoEconometrics without interventions is useless due to stuff like this. At least with instrumental variables for example you could tax the oil and see the real impact of less oil burned. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instrumental_variables_estimation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instrumental_variables_estimat...
- pcwelder 3y agoBut this is textbook multi-collinearity that any student of economics should be able to observe and account for? The article discusses much grander issues than these easy to identify problems with causal analysis.
- amatic 3y ago
- FergusArgyll 3y agoI might be old-fashioned but I think being able to read a simple supply and demand curve is still worth the time spent learning it. You can deduce (obviously not with 100% accuracy, obviously) the effects taxes, subsidies, shortages and surpluses will have on the price, supply and demand. But I think most importantly, it gives you another tool for analysis of a situation. To be used along with all the other tools you're familiar with
- soVeryTired 3y agoSupply and demand aren’t observable though. Only their intersections, price and quantity, are observable. Honest question: if we don’t know the shape of the curves, if we can’t observe them, and if they shift around according to unknown dynamics, what good are they?
- RandomLensman 3y agoSometimes we can get quite close to getting the curves (could always be different tomorrow, some measurement and modelling issues etc.), but they are not always as inaccessible as you make them out to be. For example:https://www.nber.org/papers/w22627 https://www.nber.org/papers/w22627 ; (financial) markets with a CLOB also give a somewhat direct view on at least parts of the curve.
- soVeryTired 3y agoIn some situations I agree you can get a rough and ready sense of one curve or other. Certain types of auctions, and order books for financial markets are examples (though I think your link is broken!). Even with order books though, they just provide point-in-time snapshots. It’s well-known that buyers will get a better fill than what’s shown in the book if they break their order up over time: that’s why it’s normally to trade VWAP. These are definitely the exception rather than the rule. I work for a financial services firm and I can confidently say we have no idea what would happen to demand if we cut our fees.
- 3y ago
- m-s-y 3y agoDo we know what we’re doing? Maybe we should stop calling the “Nobel Prize in Economics” a Nobel Prize. It’s an award financed by “Finance”, not the Nobel foundation. The existence of the prize is was a public relations coup for banking, that’s it.
- tomoyoirl 3y agoIt’s the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel. There’s a reason people will always call it something shorter; personally I don’t trust myself to spell Riksbank properly (I keep wanting to put a j in there like it’s Dutch or something), and the media have zero incentive to report on it as something like a “Riksbank Prize” because no one will pay attention.
- pydry 3y agoMaybe we should start calling it the fauxbel prize.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoFo-Sho!
- pgeorgi 3y agoHow about the "Bankers awarding Bankers award, inspired by Nobel"?
- guappa 3y agoMaybe we could call it the Riksbank Prize? edit: For the english speakers, maybe a literal translation helps? "The rich's bank prize"
- dpnmn 3y agojust in case anyone think this is serious, the literal translation is of course "National bank" (Riks refering to Riket / "Reich" in German, meaning the nation).
- megamix 3y agoIsn't this why Taleb dislikes economists?
- jacknews 3y agoThe problem isn't so much that economists don't know what they're doing. There are many questions which economists can answer quite clearly. The problem is that economics has become the center of the entire operation of society, and is used inappropriately or where it is just irrelevant. It should be self-evident that this is wrong; people don't care so much about being rich, as being richer than those around them. Far from being rational actors, human desires are easily manipulated. People who do not have anything to offer the market can't just 'cease trading', just as workers generally can't choose not to participate in the labor 'market'. Etc. We need to operate society for the good of humanity, not for the benefit of 'the market' and 'profits'.
- polygamous_bat 3y ago> We need to operate society for the good of humanity, not for the benefit of 'the market' and 'profits'. Good of humanity is a hard to achieve/track goal, so we traded that in for an easier to track metric called GDP without realizing and caring how severely and violently the backlash from Goodharts law will screw us over. All you see today is a result of that.
- pif 3y ago> There are many questions which economists can answer quite clearly. Yes, and they always concern the past. Ask an economist about the future, and he'll show their actual value: zero.
- roenxi 3y agoArticle is paywalled, but in the introductory paragraph it says "we did not collectively predict the financial crisis" - that isn't the job of an academic economist and I'd bet that most economists could see the crisis coming a mile away. It is rather obvious that any number of crisis are coming towards us at any given time. Trillions in misallocated resources are not hard to spot. The public, politicians, and to a lesser extent the media have very little time for anyone who is pointing out the obvious negative consequences of bad economic management. There are still regular fights over the minimum wage, which shows how much of an influence economists have over the public discourse. Whatever stance someone prefers, it is near certain that the economists have figured out a consensus position. The real issue is that when the government is doing something poorly advised, there is a lot of money floating around for economists who will give poor advice that the politicians want to hear. They're Keynsianists when the Kaynesiyan strategy is printing money. Their all believers in MMT when MMT says print money. They aren't believers when rates go up, they're generally against economics then.
- nprateem 3y agoA crisis is always coming if you wait long enough, but how far off is it, and how severe will it be? Where's the bottom of the crisis and when does the recovery start, etc? Economists only ever justify history. They have no predictive power.
- incomingpain 3y agoSomething which happened post 2009 was the economists, especially krugman's major failed predictions, was that we do not live in a free market. The entire 'gamestop' thing was about proving this and they utterly destroyed a few brokerages. ESG is basically dead at this point. There's a political movement which has failed, it's crescendo was in 1989 but is strong even today. It's the movement which is destroying South Korea and Japan. Some of Europe, especially Canada. We're watching the last bit of their existence in politics. They will soon migrate to being a religion where they belong. Its not that the economists dont know what they are doing, they have a martyr political movement ready to burn everything down as they stop existing and this makes economics quite hard when you dont account for this. Luckily, it appears that Canada will be the beacon of freedom in the future.
- anentropic 3y agoWhat's happening in Canada?
- pjc50 3y ago> The entire 'gamestop' thing was about proving this and they utterly destroyed a few brokerages. ESG is basically dead at this point. This is incoherent; people getting memed into buying a dying retailer and losing money in the process proves nothing, and ESG is now pretty deeply ingrained as it becomes impossible to ignore the side effects of not caring.
- incomingpain 3y ago>This is incoherent; people getting memed into buying a dying retailer and losing money in the process proves nothing, It originally started when someone noticed that there was more shorts then actual issued stock. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-retail-trading-shortselling-explainer/explainer-how-were-more-than-100-of-gamestops-shares-shorted-idUSKBN2AI2DD/ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-retail-trading-shortselli... >According to financial analytics firm S3, GameStop's peak short interest was 141.8% of its float on Jan. 4. So what was discovered was that the system was rigged. It should literally not possible to do this. So you buy in and those shorts eventually have to buy your stock from you and you get to decide how much $ they owe you. Aka infinite money. turns out it was a problem unique to the USA markets. The government enabled this, the government broke the free market. But why? Who did this? People needed to investigate. >nd ESG is now pretty deeply ingrained as it becomes impossible to ignore the side effects of not caring. Turns out this ending of the free market was done in the name of ESG. So you have the government picking winners and losers intentionally. When Russia declared war on Ukraine. ESG pretty much died. Europe pretty much signed up for decades of fossil fuels. https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/sustainable-finance-reporting/comment-pushback-against-esg-has-hit-europe-heres-how-investors-can-ride-out-2024-03-14/ https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/sustainable-finance-r... https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-02-28/climate-investors-warn-the-right-is-winning-the-war-on-esg https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-02-28/climate-i... But this last article is incorrect. A political movement that isn't in power is not winning the war. ESG is losing the war and taking massive losses on their own. This is the huge fear of elections. If free markets are re-enabled, ESG takes even bigger losses. I dont know if Trump winning later this year will have major impacts on this at all. As far as Im aware he isnt aware of any of this because he could have fixed it during his 4 years. >impossible to ignore the side effects of not caring. When you acknowledge that the free market is broken. Economists know this as fact now. It's a government manipulated market. You can look into what those side effects really are and the political movements producing what you believe is 'impossible to ignore' But as I said, we're in the last hurrah of a major political movement. Gen Z has rejected them and should usher in solution to political polarization and the echo chamber problems. This political movement will shift to become a religion and that's where it will last.
- Yusefmosiah 3y agoOne structural problem with macroeconomics as a discipline is that if you really understand reality better than prevailing macroeconomic theory, you have many better opportunities than being a theorist or commentator. And the value of these opportunities depend on you not disclosing your insights. Eg trading, investing, entrepreneurship, working as an in-house economist bound by NDAs.
- gonzo41 3y agoI can't believe that this person didn't have these doubts the whole time and just kept towing the party line because it was easy and popular. Now in their winter years, there's feeling of remorse. This sort of self serving reflection is nothing more than trying to have the cake and eat it too. Economic theorists have done so much damage to real people. They don't know what's going on and they don't act in good faith.
- neilwilson 3y agoIt is said Economics exists to make astrology look respectable. When Powel goes around saying he is “guided by the stars” he’s not really helping to dispel that meme. Particularly as the stars in question and non-observable and non-measurable
- padjo 3y agoEconomics is more a branch of arts or humanities than a branch of science. Sadly many economists take that as a negative and over compensate with ever more elaborate nonsense.
- ashergill 3y agohttps://archive.is/1F2Iy https://archive.is/1F2Iy
- Ludwigvonmises 3y ago[flagged]
- vegetablepotpie 3y agoEconomics has an ideological assumption that equilibriums exist and that “markets” will tend towards them. Although this has some predictive capacity in a class of specific cases, it fails to explain observed phenomena in our world. * Rise of social media. Classical economics would predict, that through low barriers to entry, there should be a nearly unlimited variety of social media platforms to choose from. In reality a few platforms dominate. Classical economics fails to account for network effects. * Technological innovation. Classical economics treats technological innovation as a Deus ex Machima proofing into existence from nowhere. It has no predictive capacity over what and how people choose to develop new technology, such as the personal computer, networking, and smartphones. * California energy crisis. After energy deregulation Enron, correctly realized, that if they shutdown one electricity generation plant, the demand for electricity would be so high, the profit margins on the remaining plants would overcome the profits lost from shutting the one plant down. Although this caused people to lose power, it made Enron substantial profits. Classical economics would predict that the higher demand would stimulate more production through higher prices. Classical economics does not account for long feedback loops. As a result, we have entire subfields of economics devoted to the things that classical economics cannot deal with, such as Behavioral economics, or environmental economics. At a certain point this feels like the Ptolemaic model trying to make geocentrism work in the face of new astrological observations by making planets rotate within spheres in their orbits. By the time you get to 9 embedded spheres, each rotating within each other, you have to say the earth is not the center of the solar system and go with a different model.
- adolph 3y agoCalifornia energy crisis. . . . Classical economics would predict that the higher demand would stimulate more production through higher prices. But since retail prices were capped, there no market method to stimulate more production, of which even unlimited demand could not stimulate construction due to regulatory delays. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000%E2%80%932001_California_electricity_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000%E2%80%932001_California_e...
- prewett 3y agoRegarding social media, there are rather a lot of social media platforms: FB-Instagram-WhatsApp, TikTok, Reddit, Snapchat, LinkedIn, StackOverflow, plus platforms like the neighborhood app whose name I can't remember. A new social media platform can get rapid adoption, too, like TikTok. So I'm not sure that the barriers to entry are actually all that high, even with the network effect. The barrier to entry to building New FB is pretty high even without the network effect (knowledge, code, and worldwide servers to maintain a high reliability, always-available worldwide app, along with the sales/marketing to support the ad revenue). But even in an industry with obviously low barriers, soft drinks, nobody makes New Coke, you make a drink with a different flavor. (Even Coke could get New Coke to work!)
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoA great article about how economics, economists, and econospeak are political tools used to mean anything at anytime, including opposite things at the same time (Australian political examples): https://www.themonthly.com.au/issue/2015/july/1435672800/richard-denniss/clowns-and-treasurers https://www.themonthly.com.au/issue/2015/july/1435672800/ric...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DebtDeflation 3y agoMy undergraduate degree is in Economics. Here's my $0.02 on this topic: You can divide the field of Economics into two branches, Microeconomics (the study of how prices and produced quantities are determined in an individual market, for example the market for cars) and Macroeconomics (the study of the overall economy, particularly concerned with overall price level and employment level determination). Microeconomics can be subdivided into partial equilibrium (the "ceteris parabus" assumption, no feedback effects from related markets) and general equilibrium (incorporates feedback effects from related markets). Macroeconomics is then just general equilibrium microeconomics for all markets in an economy + the market for money (MV=PQ equation from the blog). Most of (partial equilibrium) microeconomics was developed by a handful of engineers in the mid 1800s. The math is pretty simple, just differential calculus really, and there are only a few variables - supply is determined by marginal production costs in a production function, demand is determined by individual preferences subject to a budget constraint (income) and the presence of substitute goods. General equilibrium microeconomics came 100 years later and required far more advanced math - the Brouwer fixed point theorem and convex set theory from topology. It was a pretty remarkable achievement. But almost immediately, mathematicians working in economics started finding problems. In a nutshell, the conditions required for an equilibrium to exist, to be unique, and to be stable were incredibly restrictive and almost certainly never met in the real world. If you want to see the math behind this, search for the Sonnenschein–Mantel–Debreu theorem (Debreu was one of the people who developed the original general equilibrium model). Macroeconomics developed alongside microeconomics and much of it was developed before the math behind general equilibrium micro was known. Macro adds the additional complexity of markets for labor (which have several unique qualities vs the market for goods) and more importantly the existence of money (traditional micro models are all barter models). It also adds a time dimension (traditional micro models are non-dynamic equilibrium models with just a short term and long term distinction). Even the most advanced macro models today are still extremely primitive in their assumptions - money is treated simply as a token like any other good or as an advance constraint, time is treated as discrete, etc. Note that I am talking about the core models themselves here. The presence of "market imperfections" such as externalities, monopoly (pricing) power, and asymmetric information (all of which are ubiquitous) have long been known to render the models useless even if all of the impossible to attain core assumptions were met. TLDR: The most advanced economic models all make assumptions that are never actually satisfied in the real world and the math to try and resolve these issues is completely intractable.
- feedforward 3y agoThere is no Nobel Prize in Economics. 67 years after the Nobel Prizes were given out, the bank that Alfred Nobel entrusted his estate to started handing out prizes to Milton Friedman, Fredrick Hayek and so forth. Even the bank doesn't call it a Nobel Prize, it calls it the Bank Prize in Nobel's memory. Prizes are given to people like Fleming for discovering penicillin, then over a half century later it's accolades are diverted to these fabulists.
- gilbetron 3y agoI started to heavily pay attention to economics about 15 years ago. I thought economists had a decent grasp on things, given the massive complexity of it all. Going through the pandemic and post-pandemic era, I can only conclude that economists and their ilk have no idea what they are doing. Nobody is getting anything near correct anymore. I don't really care anymore to try to predict things, and I don't really care what other people predict, because while there is a small chance the guess correctly, it is only a guess. Instead, I just read and watch mostly factual information to just pay attention as it plays out. So now I'll read Freightwaves or Wolf Street or mining.com just to see what is actually happening, and care less about any commentary that isn't explanatory.