8 ms·
Mars Has Influence on Earth's Oceans and Climate, Repeating Every 2.4M Years
- a_gnostic 3y agoMilankovitch cycles describe the collective effects of changes in the Earth's movements on its climate over thousands of years. The term was coined and named after the Serbian geophysicist and astronomer Milutin Milanković. In the 1920s, he hypothesized that variations in eccentricity, axial tilt, and precession combined to result in cyclical variations in the intra-annual and latitudinal distribution of solar radiation at the Earth's surface, and that this orbital forcing strongly influenced the Earth's climatic patterns.[1] 1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milankovitch_cycles https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milankovitch_cycles
- davidw 3y agoDisappointed to not see any Pern references. "Get off my lawn", I guess?
- yieldcrv 3y agoThis undermines my understanding of gravity, gravity is really fickle then as even this article says Mars is too small for the results I think the article exaggerates the correlation as causation until we can absolutely model this repeatedly, Martian presence is not the only answer as the article suggests
- narush 3y ago[flagged]
- LegibleCrimson 3y agoThis is a 2.4 million year cycle, not something that can lend any credence to the idea that the arrangement of the planets at birth has any effect on a person. The arrangement of your house or neighborhood has a stronger gravitational effect on you at a young age than the planets. Feng shui would be a better predictor of people's personalities than astrology.
- explaininjs 3y agoAstronomical signs (in the west) are entirely related to the time of year when you were born and not at all related to the "arrangement of the planets", besides of course the position of the earth relative to the sun. The idea that some voodoo around the position of your bed relative to your chair relative to your door has more impact on your life than your spawning phase shift in the (second?) most significant cycle of our existence is pure absurdity. As a simple test: ask N self-proclaimed astrology experts to guess your sign, and perhaps the signs of some others around you. Run a Chi-squared on the results. Come to your own conclusions. Alternatively, plot some user data against birth month. Observe dependence.
- mistermann 3y agoFair criticism, but then look how many Scientific Materialist fundamentalists in this and other threads would have you believe they are omniscient Oracles, but then cry foul if one dares to critique or have a bit of a laugh at their hallucinations. The only saving grace of this simulation that I can see is how absolutely hilarious it is, it's like living in one of those old British sitcoms.
- LegibleCrimson 3y agoYou could also provide some evidence instead of telling me to gather my own. I'd happily read some more double blind studies on the effectiveness of astrology, most of what I've read points to it all being complete bunk.
- explaininjs 3y agoScience is observation, not consumption. I ran the experiments, I got the data I needed to inform my opinion. You're more than welcome to do the same. But if all you will listen to is what scientific journals want to publish, you've already made up your mind, and there's little use pretending otherwise. If you ask me, nothing could be more "complete bunk" than some "scientist" claiming they've somehow blinded someone to their own birthday.
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> But the more general idea that the arrangement of the solar system when you were born affects your personality (among other things) -- this is obviously reasonable. It is not, in any way, reasonable.
- pests 3y agoThe arrangement of the solar system -> birth month -> time of the year your mother was gestating you -> different conditions for different people during key growth phases (summer abundance vs harsher winters) Only way I could see it.
- samatman 3y agoReasonable is not a synonym for true.
- lukan 3y agoWell, the gravity alone definitely affects us, so also our personality. But whether it affects us in any meaningful way, is doubtful, since the force is really, really small. What definitely has an impact is, in what season you were born(if there are seasons). Whether your first steps outside are in snow, or in warm sun. That has an effect on development. Still, I always loved Astronomy and could never understand the appeal of Astrology in the first place. It never made the slightest sense. So if I am born on day X, I am supposed to have trait A, but if I would be born some hours later I should be personality Y? (besides the fact, that the baby was alive and conscious before the birth). The reason why people take it serious, is probably to find guidance in a chaotic world and they seem to think some guidance is better than none (but I rather have no guiding, than one that makes no sense to me in the first place).
- icepat 3y ago> Well, the gravity alone definitely affects us, so also our personality. You're talking absolute micro-units of G force difference. Within a margin of error of most sensors. Orders of magnitude lower than we can detect as humans physically. And even if we were not, how is there an obvious correlation between these two? This is the exact sort of pseudo-scientific nonsense that's being spewed everywhere these days.
- u32480932048 3y agoWe accept that the moon affects bodies of water We accept that our bodies are mostly water But the idea that the position of the moon or planets affects us is insane (There have been several small-N studies looking at various folk beliefs about higher incidences of certain events during full moons, but I don't believe any of the studies found a significant correlation)
- dotancohen 3y agoThe moon does not affect bodies of water. The moon's gravity pulls every mass equally. The water being closest to the moon is pulled more strongly than the earth whose center is 6300 KM away from that water - so the water creeps closer to the moon than does the center of the earth. Same thing on the other side - the water is 6300 KM further away from the moon than is the (center of) the earth. So it is pulled less strongly, and thus to an observer on the earth it looks like that water is being pulled away.
- u32480932048 3y ago"The moon does not affect bodies of water. [description of how bodies of water are affected by the moon]" lmao fucking nerds, man. So, hypothetically, if our blood or CSF had a different mass-slash-density than our bones, and our skulls were further from the earth's surface than the rest of our bodies, they could conceivably be pulled more-or-less strongly than the rest of it?
- dotancohen 3y agoIt actually does not depend on the density, because mass is on both sides of the equation. Your head is in fact pulled on less than your feet. For an extreme example, look up "spaghettification".
- airstrike 3y agohow did you go from Mars possibly having an effect on oceans to arbitrarily defined constellations having a predictive effect on people's personalities?
- lm28469 3y agoIt's like saying the entire biblical story is true because it has a few accurate events and a few real people in it...
- michaelmrose 3y agoIt's not even clear to what degree many of the people exist! One thing that really blew my mind is that there is no reason to believe anything even resembling the events of exodus exist for example. That is to say not just the personage of Moses. There is no reason to believe the jewish people were ever in bondage in Egypt at all for instance. Reading from that huge chunks of the old testament cease to make sense in the context of the real history of the region. It's not even absolutely clear that Jesus was a historical personage.
- wizzwizz4 3y ago> It's not even absolutely clear that Jesus was a historical personage. It is pretty certain that Jesus was historically a personage, since we have historical evidence that people had a text (often called The Holy Bible, or some variation) with a character in it called Jesus. There's also lots of evidence that Jesus was a historical person. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historicity_of_Jesus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historicity_of_Jesus for an introduction.
- michaelmrose 3y agoI would suggest not using wikipedia as a source especially one full of insufficient arguments as that one. > Only two accepted facts of a historical Jesus Main article: Historical Jesus Part of the ancient Madaba Map showing two possible baptism locations Bronzino's depiction of the Crucifixion with three nails, no ropes, and a hypopodium standing support, c. 1545 > There is no scholarly consensus concerning most elements of Jesus's life as described in the Christian and non-Christian sources, and the only two events of this historical Jesus subject to "almost universal assent" are that Jesus was baptized by John the Baptist and was crucified by order of the Roman Prefect Pontius Pilate (who officiated 26–36 AD).[14][4][5][6][7][note 5] The criterion of embarrassment has been used to argue for the historicity of the baptism of Jesus, shown here in The Baptism of Christ by Juan Fernández Navarrete. > Based on the criterion of embarrassment, scholars argue that the early Christian Church would not have invented the painful death of their leader.[15] The criterion of embarrassment is also used to argue in favor of the historicity of the baptism of Jesus,[16][17][18] given that John baptised for the remission of sins, although Jesus was viewed as without sin and this positioned John above Jesus Neither is even a kind of good argument. In place of actual evidence we are making impossible to disprove psychological arguments to the motivation of believers. There is no contemporary as in at the time evidence of Jesus or reason to believe that the parties that wrote down accounts long after his death were actually recordings of first person accounts. If the bible can make up exodus and fabricate Noah I have no reason to believe fabricating Jesus is beyond the pale. Here is what I think a better write up looks like it is admittedly biased https://www.atheists.org/activism/resources/did-jesus-exist/ https://www.atheists.org/activism/resources/did-jesus-exist/ Another reasonable challenge to the use of something like the Bible is that normally when a work contains thousands of clear fabrications and myths it tends to diminish its worth as a source. For instance if I wrote a biography of wizzwizz4 and in the course of my writings claimed you were a godlike being from pluto who came to earth in the middle ages it would not only be dubious it would cast doubt on myself as a credible source. Even true things I wrote which were not corroborated elsewhere would be reasonably deemed dubious.
- 1270018080 3y ago> But the more general idea that the arrangement of the solar system when you were born affects your personality (among other things) -- this is obviously reasonable. Not even remotely reasonable in any capacity.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThe paper for this was published a few days ago here to no response: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39729053 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39729053 Admittedly I struggled on my first read through, but it’s one of the bigger discoveries in climate research in a while It might give us some answers on why the Younger-Dryas happened argubly leading to the Quaternary Extinction event, as there’s some dissent around the causes If it was a concurrent epicycle that stacked up that could be a pretty compelling argument https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Younger_Dryas https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Younger_Dryas
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jimmytucson 3y agoJury is still out on an astronomical explanation for the apparent 26M year periodicity[0] of mass extinction events. Lisa Randall has an entertaining theory[1] that it’s due to the sun passing through dark matter in its orbit around the galaxy. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC344925/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC344925/ [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Matter_and_the_Dinosaurs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Matter_and_the_Dinosaur...
- indigobunting 3y agoExcept that the orbital period around the galaxy is ~230M years.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoMaybe dark matter bodies orbit faster.
- exe34 3y agoOrbital speed is a fixed function of central mass and distance from that mass.
- thfuran 3y agoIn theory. On the other hand, dark matter is pretty much just a name we give to a discrepancy in current theory.
- 4ad 3y agoNo, that is dark energy. From the pov. of gravity dark matter is simply regular matter that we can't see.
- exe34 3y agoNot quite. Dark matter is the hypothesis that the discrepancy between theory and observation is due to a form of matter that interacts gravitationally but not electromagnetically. So we can't see it, and thus "dark". There are other competing ideas including a family of modified Newtonian dynamics models, but nothing comes as close as explaining the observations as dark matter does. There was a paper recently that showed that the discrepancy may be the higher order terms from general relativity that is often neglected because they are believed to be small - but that idea still needs to be proven to work for a large variety of cases. The observations in question for this Dark matter hypothesis include the rotation velocity of stars in galaxies and a few other things like gravitational lensing. Dark energy is a different discrepancy with theory. It's a term that we have to add to Einstein's field equations to account for the observation that the universal expansion is accelerating instead of slowing down. Again there are competing hypotheses, like non uniform density on the largest scales, but nothing quite explains everything as dark energy.
- ilove_banh_mi 3y agoHaving read the Nature article [0] it looks like we're near a local maximum of that cycle [1]. [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-46171-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-46171-5 [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-46171-5/figures/2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-46171-5/figures/2
- frame_ranger 3y agoMayan Doomsday Calendar, now with 200% more Science!
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y ago[flagged]
- lazyninja987 3y ago[dead]
- vincengomes 3y agoMan, this study is going to be paraded as the proof that astrology is scientific and ancient people were more knowledgeable than us.
- readyplayernull 3y agoPeople is born in seasons, constellations and planets appear in seasons, and so ancient smart people made a connection. Then the largest actor interested in destroying Astrology is the Catholic Church for reasons. The church also had wrong astronomical theories. Science evolved, but we inherited a dead horse to beat.
- somenameforme 3y agoThe reasons the Catholic Church did away with astrology can be explained in a one liner. Catholicism assumes a belief in free will, and the claimed predictive power of astrology contradicted this, and so was deemed blasphemous.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 1letterunixname 3y agoEvery conspiracy theory and whacky magical thinking cult boils down to "See? I'm smarter than NURDS and GUBBERMENT!"
- mistermann 3y agoWhat methodology could one even use to know such a thing? What methodology did you use to come to know this?
- somenameforme 3y agoConspiracy theories don't come from thinking one is smarter, but rather from a lack of trust. When somebody (or some entity) says something, how you respond to them is not only based on your perception of their knowledge, but also on your perception of the trustworthiness. It's somewhat of a tautology to say that as decline in trust of US institutions declines, lack of believing in what these institutions says also declines. And trust in US institutions is not just randomly declining either. We just seem to have largely removed the social mores on lying and manipulation, so long as it can be used to push an agenda. If the powers that be want to reclaim public trust then there needs to be a much greater effort to increase transparency, honesty, hold open debate on all topics, and also hold groups accountable for misleading or lying to individuals. Instead we seem to be going rapidly in the exact opposite direction, and it's not difficult to predict the outcome.
- dakom 3y agoAsimov and Silverberg's Nightfall novel seems related- a great sci-fi story about a civilization on an alien planet that isn't prepared for the long cycle of astronomical movements (they go crazy during an eclipse every 2000 years or so). Fun read :)
- KineticLensman 3y agoAsimov and Silverberg confused me for a moment - Nightfall was an Asimov-only short story from 1941. Still think it's one of his best. TIL there was a collaborative novel as well, which carried on after the events of the short story. * * * If you like novels that explore civilisations that have long astronomical cycles, the other classic is the Helliconia trilogy by Brian Aldiss. It's set in a double star system where the main planetary orbit takes 2500 Earth years, and the seasons last for Earth centuries. Civilisation tends to collapse when winter comes, but gradually approaches semi-industrial levels of technology by autumn.