7 ms·
How photos were transmitted by wire in the 1930s
- ikiris 3y agoThat is some electric age magic and is really neat.
- xattt 3y agoTangential, but was there ever some form of fibre or telephony connection for news crews in 1990s? Microwave trucks excluded. I ask this because I swear, as a kid, I’ve seen a cameramen open up a telecom/telephone box and connect something to it. I assumed it was for an uplink back to the station to transmit video.
- ikiris 3y agoI know ISDN was used for this kind of thing for a good while.
- lebuffon 3y agoYes, ISDN was the higher priced product offered by the telcos but ISDN was not available until the 1980s. Radio broadcasting started over 60 years earlier and analogue lines were the only option.
- lebuffon 3y agoAbsolutely. From the advent of radio broadcasting telephone lines were used for everything, audio and even DC signalling to control relays. All remote radio broadcasts used at least two lines. One for sending sound back to the station and a 2nd pair (telephone lines are a balanced pair of wires) for "cue" that came from the master control room to the remote site. Since most transmitters were located outside of city limits, equalized telephone lines were used to send the sound from master control to the transmitter. This was the most common and cheapest way to make the connection to the transmitter until the advent of inexpensive microwave equipment. And microwave links have a nasty habit of fading out during tropospheric inversions so they were actually not as reliable, over long distances, as a phone line with a backup phone line that took an alternate path. (first hand experience here. Ya I'm that old) :-) Most people today have no idea how you transmit analogue audio faithfully and reliably over long distances, via wires. Telephone engineers figured it out over 100 years ago.
- riffic 3y agothey would have had the operator reverse the charges I assume? by the way the old bell system technical journals are a fun read and are generally available at places like archive.org
- xattt 3y agoYou mention two telephony lines were used for comms between station and site. Was the quality of audio for remote broadcasts better than a typical phone call?
- lebuffon 3y agoYes. The audio quality of land line phones was dictated primarily by transducers. This was by design. The TIA published specs for USA, Canada had their own as well as most other countries. The response of a twisted pair was pretty good over 2 to 4 miles as I recall but for a audio grade (50Hz to 5000Hz) various techniques were used that at the simplest involved coils but there were also active equalizers available for long haul circuits and/or "hi-fi" requirements. Remember DSL lines were/are shipping 1..2Mhz carriers over those same old telco lines. :-) Of course some old trunk lines used paper insulation. Really. Which meant noise went up ... when it rained.
- flyinghamster 3y agoSpecially-conditioned circuits for broadcast audio were available at a price. These were point-to-point links, not on the PSTN. Network TV was sent over Bell System transcontinental coaxial cables before it went via satellite or fiber.
- subpixel 3y agoThis is also how live radio broadcasts were made. I'm old enough to have been a part of shows performed at the West End, mixed across the street in the studio, and broadcast from the World Trade Center downtown.
- rightbyte 3y agoIn it's simplicity it is genius. I had no clue this was a thing. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirephoto https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirephoto I really like these old "explaining" films. The pedagogical level is far higher than what seems common today. And the they take their time to convey the message.
- Animats 3y agoThe hard part was synchronization. We're used to synchronization being easy today, but it was really hard to synchronize anything until the 1980s, when phase-locked loops became easy and cheap.
- rightbyte 3y agoDoes the belinograph need syncing though? I imagine you would just have a waste ribbon around the photo and start it after the call with say a delay you both agreed too. Or maybe you could send light in some known pattern with a starter strip and the receiver could look at the lamp. Attenuation most have been a problem though? I guess you could send some sort of calibration photo to adjust gain? I don't think practical FM signal modulation was a thing yet in the 30s?
- barrkel 3y agoYou need to synchronize the spin rate of the drums on either end. If there's a difference of half a rotation over however many hundreds (thousands?) of rotations to transmit the photo, you'd end up with a completely distorted picture.
- jnewkirk 3y agoI had a pair of these transceivers when I was in my teens, from a somewhat later period, thanks to my grandfather who refurbished them from his time as a telegrapher at Western Union. Synchronization at startup took ten seconds or so while each unit adjusted its timing and apparently sent a correction signal to the other, drums whirling all the time and gradually matching initial positions. It looked like the most primitive process possible, but worked every time.
- at_a_remove 3y agoI have some old wire photos in a particular set of movie memorabilia I've been constructing from press kits, pamphlets, film cells, foreign posters, slides, lobby cards, et al.
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y agoOriginal source link: https://youtube.com/watch?v=cLUD_NGE370 https://youtube.com/watch?v=cLUD_NGE370
- caditinpiscinam 3y agoHow did they get the incandescent bulb on the receiving end to switch on and off fast enough to avoid blurring the picture?
- clintfred 3y agoI think the video said it was a neon bulb, which reacted "fast enough".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- waltwalther 3y agoA neon tube was used on the receiving end because it reacts more quickly to current. This is mentioned at about 6:45 into the video.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zdragnar 3y agoThe video explains that they used a neon bulb, which is far more reactive to current changes than standard incandescent. Incandescent lights produce visible light largely through heat of the filament, whereas neon lights emit by passing current through the gas, meaning that rapidly changing the current is more effective- the had e doesn't need to cool down like a filament to stop producing light.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- asimpletune 3y agoThat scene (around 3:45) with the two, coupled spools of rope that transmit the picture from one spool to the other is simply amazing.
- abrookewood 3y agoAgreed - really conveys what is happening in a simple and effective manner. It's a great addition to the video.
- userbinator 3y agoThat also shows up several decades later in Hunkin's The Secret Life of the Fax Machine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuUyt9RG7pk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuUyt9RG7pk
- VWWHFSfQ 3y agoLow-res video! Basically the width of the rope!
- fanf2 3y agoFax machines go way back to the 1800s, before phones, surprisingly old! Another classic is Tim Hunkin’s secret life of the fax machine https://youtu.be/yuUyt9RG7pk https://youtu.be/yuUyt9RG7pk which features a clip from the video in TFA.
- ted_bunny 3y agoOlder even than the Pony Express.
- anon-sre-srm 3y agoWestern Union predates the Pony Express by about 10 years, which operated for only 18 months. It was the Webvan and WU was the Amazon.
- anon-sre-srm 3y agoPantelegraph -> wirephoto / radiofax / teleautograph -> telex / weatherfax -> fax
- maxlin 3y agoI love this. It's so immensely simple. Truly human technology. We need to burn all computers and limit technology to this level.
- thfuran 3y agoI think you may have gotten a bit carried away.
- insane_dreamer 3y agoLong live the Butlerian Jihad!
- goatlover 3y agoThe spice must flow!
- account42 3y agoYou may start with yours ;)
- ornornor 3y agoCrazy what we had to do before fully digital circuits. Also, that GO/STOP traffic “light”!!!
- ajb 3y agoEven older is Jacquards self portrait on 24000 punched cards - a 2Mpixel image in 1839 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Marie_Jacquard https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Marie_Jacquard
- anovikov 3y ago1930s? These machines were widely in use even in the very end of the Soviet era like in 1989 or so, in the USSR. I personally seen them in operation in post offices being a kid. I think the very last of them fell out of use when modern faxes appeared but just like telegrams existed for a while when email was already a thing, i think these stayed formally available even if not in demand, well into 1990s.
- Tor3 3y agoNot sure if it's the same tech or just similar, but all newspapers used to transmit photos from correspondents by telephone, all the way up to the eighties at least. I remember seeing it in practice - I was taking part in a multi-day bicycling competition, and a newspaper sent a two-person team to follow the tour. They developed their photos in their hotel room every evening, and sent them by phone to the newspaper back home, and the newspaper had a new story with photos every day.
- anovikov 3y agoSame tech. That stuff was mainly used by press indeed (and law enforcement, like sending suspect photos and fingerprints).
- flyinghamster 3y agoNote that in the original 1965 Ian Fleming novel The Man with the Golden Gun (which has little in common with the movie save character names), James Bond describes being picked up by waterfront police in Vladivostok, and his prints being "belinographed" to Moscow, after his mission to Japan. The term is obvious enough to convey its meaning, at least.
- IvyMike 3y agoFor a slightly later version of this: My most popular YouTube upload is the telecopier scene from Bullitt, where you can see the police use the latest and greatest "fax" technology of 1968. I uploaded the video without almost no information, but in an surprising twist, a lot of the youtube comments are actually pretty informative. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQGAaCSFlJI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQGAaCSFlJI
- bofh23 3y agoThere’s a similar device used to transmit the first recovered victim’s fingerprints from the funeral parlor to FBI field offices in Silence of the Lambs.
- IAmNotACellist 3y agoI like how it's nearly two minutes of men standing absolutely motionless, with a completely stationary camera, with no score, no building tension, no close-ups showing emotion or what we are supposed to be feeling, as they listen to a whirring sound. Riveting television
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoAre you perhaps being sarcastic? Because it's a great scene. The whole movie's great on the same basis. It's classic film that has the authentic feel of the period, for those who weren't alive then, and lets people simply experience what's happening on the screen. The devices you mention are what makes most movies unwatchable. The over the top and increasingly forced devices used to essentially manipulate the viewer, lest there's any ambiguity as to what they "should" be feeling. No room for subtlety, just shove it down the viewer's throat. They're a great alternative to fine acting, directing and cinematography that's able to speak for itself.
- mikehollinger 3y agoThis is remarkable. Lasers were invented in 1960 as a point of reference. The painted rope on two spools was also remarkable because of its simplicity - and it holds up today on explaining what a "download" is. ;-) And even cooler - if we wanted to, I would wager a high school student could implement something along these lines using lego today. There's optical sensors, and you could rig up something to hold a pen like this [1] to render the image. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=dHmgaLgFRGM https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=dHmgaLgFRGM
- Lucasoato 3y agoImagine the effort, creativity and commitment they’ve put with the rope on two spools, just to let the watcher better understand how they were transmitting the images. Why even this simple thing seems unthinkable nowadays?
- petee 3y agoA neat variation from the era is Hellschreiber teleprinter, graphically prints the characters using a spinning head that impacts the tape strip, which results in readable messages even with heavy interference https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hellschreiber https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hellschreiber Edit: some ham radio operators still use it for fun, and I'd heard that one of the SDR decoders can read it
- drmpeg 3y agoWith SDR, you can paint an image into the receiver waterfall with OFDM. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=saac0ZtTeX4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=saac0ZtTeX4 (be sure to switch to 1080p) https://github.com/drmpeg/gr-paint https://github.com/drmpeg/gr-paint
- nyanpasu64 3y agoBreaking an image up into lines is similar to how television cameras/displays and raster scan CRTs operated (IIRC TV dated back to the 1920s?), though wrapping the image on a drum was clever and not found in television technology. I wonder how they synchronize lines between the transmitter and receiver though (all video standards have hsync pulses, while I didn't see any such here). I'm not sure how fax machines worked/work either.
- VWWHFSfQ 3y agoAlso very impressive was the making of this video itself. Transitions between scenes, overlayed graphics (arrows) pointing and moving in the diagrams.
- hinkley 3y agoThis was featured on an episode of Connections 3 way back in the long ago. Moral equivalent of thermal paper but with electricity.
- snerc 3y ago"This is called [pause for effect] scanning."
- pneumatic1 3y agoAmazing. Stuff like this is why I come to HN.