4 ms·
When people say "the internet is dying" (and really, they mean "the web", not "the internet"), they don't mean it will cease to exist. They mean that it's chang
by JohnFen 3y ago
When people say "the internet is dying" (and really, they mean "the web", not "the internet"), they don't mean it will cease to exist. They mean that it's changing in a way that makes it increasingly worse for them.
"Dying" is an appropriate analogy because if the decline gets far enough, it may as well not exist to those people who are affected.
At least, this is what I mean when I say the web is dying. Most of it is already nonsense of no value to me and comes with ever-increasing security exposures. There's not a lot further it can go before there is no reason for me to use it at all anymore.
- Joker_vD 3y ago"He's not dying, it's his body just rapidly decomposing and ceasing to support the so called homeostasis, yes, but calling it 'death' is a misnomer". No, sorry, if it looks like a rotten corpse, smells like a rotten corpse...
- charcircuit 3y agoThe MAU of the internet continues to grow. How is it a corpse when it hasn't even reached its peak yet?
- chmod775 3y agoA decomposing body will be full of active organisms and life too! You could have made the same argument about settler colonialism: No, the culture of the indigenous population isn't being destroyed. How can it be dying when there's more and more people living there?
- charcircuit 3y agoThat's not even remotely the same argument.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bruce511 3y agoWhen people say the Internet is dying, they typically don't even mean the Web, they mean one site on the Web that matters to them. The article us a rebuttal to [1] where someone is complaining that Reddit is going public. For some reason this strategy, or indeed the need for reddit to earn revenue, seems to be shocking to the author. To anyone with half a brain, and has seen the internet since it was an infant in the 90s, its obvious the internet is not dying, it's "growing up". It's waaaay better now than it has ever been, and a pale shadow of examples it will become. Yes we can pause to reminisce, yes we can fondly remember the yesteryears of carefree childhood, we can fondly really the lazy days of summer. All while forgetting the sound a modem makes when connecting. [1] https://www.wheresyoured.at/are-we-watching-the-internet-die/ https://www.wheresyoured.at/are-we-watching-the-internet-die...
- ajkjk 3y agoDon't agree. People are referring to at least a large part of it, basically the "visible surface" as exposed by social media + google. There are tons of good parts but if you wander it the way we used to wonder it in the 2000s and earlier, you don't see them so much anymore.
- chii 3y ago> All while forgetting the sound a modem makes when connecting. the physical technology can improve independently of the (imho decline of) quality of the sites you visit.
- ants_everywhere 3y agoA basic test is to ask how quickly you can find information about a topic that is unbiased by commercial interests. On some topics it's nearly impossible: - medicine - cosmetics - cooking/nutrition/recipes For many other topics, it's only really possible by finding forums where people who are not blog spammer discuss things. This used to be possible by appending "reddit" to a search term, but this is getting harder as Reddit's quality is decreasing.
- Forgeties79 3y ago
- convolvatron 3y agoI think the internet, as in the ability for arbitrary attached hosts to communicate using global addresses and properly formatted layer 3 messages, has been under attack for quite some time - and reachability isn't getting any better but yes, that's not what people normally mean.
- antegamisou 3y ago> "Dying" is an appropriate analogy because if the decline gets far enough, it may as well not exist to those people who are affected. We need to start saying it the way we feel reluctant to do: The Internet is getting exponentially shittier. SEO-prioritization and poorly-regulated access to AI content generation are some of the emerging methods that help it get worse.
- rhelz 3y ago"Dying" is the correct word, because living people are being replaced by bots, both on social networks, and as content creators. Live people are being replaced by dead computers. Last presidential election, I'm convinced I wasted endless hours arguing with knuckleheads who were actually bots using weaponized early LLM tech. This presidential election the tech will be perfected. Machines can spit out so much content/chats/post so quickly, anything written or created by living people will just be swamped out. Eventually web search engines will just be so swamped by the automatic machine-gun-like production of content, that the probability of you being able to find anything written by a living person will be indistinguishable from zero. Life will have been squeezed out by lifelessness; the internet will be dead.