6 ms·
Nvidia is sued by authors over AI use of copyrighted works
- raytopia 3y agoReally curious about how the copy legal landscape will look in 5 years after a lot of the AI lawsuits settle.
- okasaki 3y agoTech companies will probably win. Copyright law is usually deployed to keep little people in line, and there's no danger of them being able to train SOTA AI models. We're going to be in an awkward situation where pirating can net you a $150000 per mp3 fine but big companies can train on the said mp3s and produce a nearly identical product for you. But that's why we have a giant police and propaganda machine.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stubish 3y agoI tend to think licenses will be required to train models made available to the public. The tech companies have deep pockets and lawyers, but so do the big media companies. And the big media companies have a more effective propaganda arm. My precedent would be Google Books, where a lawsuit similar to the ones we are seeing now shut down Google's plans. Although it would be hilarious to think what would happen if the news industry went to war for instance, feeding false information to the AI scrapers making them look ridiculous. I think it also ties into not wanting AI to be trained on AI generated content. The winners will want to license original sources, and licenses work both ways so you can sue if paid for clean data and got dirty.
- EMIRELADERO 3y ago> My precedent would be Google Books, where a lawsuit similar to the ones we are seeing now shut down Google's plans. What? Google Books won.
- kurthr 3y agoI guess, if they trained on their data, go for the deepest pockets?
- AlienRobot 3y ago>Were they even the owners of the product when infringement occurred? I believe that's answered in the first line of the article.
- AlienRobot 3y agoThe headline made me think they were suing the tool, but they are really going after an AI offering made by Nvidia that used the copyrighted work. >AI's rise has made Nvidia a favorite of investors. >The Santa Clara, California-based chipmaker's stock price has risen almost 600% since the end of 2022, giving Nvidia a market value of nearly $2.2 trillion. Me and Joe Nobody wouldn't be able to afford it, but I find it hard to believe a trillion-dollar company couldn't get proper rights to the data it uses to train its models.
- bongodongobob 3y agoThe issue is whether or not you'd need to. I say no. Nothing was taken or copied. If you don't want your work seen, don't put it on the internet. They might have had a chance when Google started crawling the Internet, but that ship has sailed. Imo, crawling and making an index is more "stealy" than adjusting parameters.
- andy99 3y agoI can see the argument that if you train on a currently sold copyrighted work you have to buy a normal copy, you can't just download a torrent and still call it fair use (if you accept the concept of copyright at all...). So if someone could prove that Nvidia or whoever didn't own a copy (note who has the burden of proof) they could be liable for whatever an illegal downloading infringement is worth. Otherwise I agree that training on anything public is fair use.
- stubish 3y agoOwning a copy of a book doesn't give me the right to make copies and sell them or even give them away. You can't even do that with publicly available material unless it has been put in the public domain or exceptions like fair use or satire apply. The model contains a copy of the work, and you can't distribute or publish your model without violating copyright. Offering access to this model as a service is legally in dispute, with AI companies generally arguing that liability for copyright infringement lies with the end user.
- kozikow 3y agoWhat's your feeling those types of lawsuits will land? Probably many people are also facing product decisions today keeping in mind the potential precedence law in the future. I kind of feel that in general with AI regulation, the USA will have to go all-in somehow. EU will delve into future obscurity, but this technology is too valuable and China is breathing behind's USA neck, so I expect law to continue to be lax around IP of data used to train AI models.
- andy99 3y agoFor some big players it's an opportunity to buy off the copyright trolls and cement their advantage. Someone like MSFT or Nvidia could do pretty well striking some deals and in doing so throwing up big barriers to entry. It's the smaller open source players that will get hurt eventually, you can be sure of that. It would be best if a non-profit, the equivalent of EFF or FSF could take on the trolls in the name of software freedom and ideally get some legal clarity, as opposed to just getting some deals struck with big companies.
- toyg 3y agoThat non-profit could and should have been OpenAI. Alas...
- mongol 3y agoSomething like free software is needed here. Something that copyright holders can apply and that affects models that are trained on it. GPL v4 perhaps?
- Buttons840 3y agoIt's questioned whether copyright applies at all. If it does not, then license doesn't matter either.
- chii 3y agoExactly. And if copyright applies, wouldnt it imply that someone learning something from a book could also then be controlled by the licensing of said book on how their gained knowledge could be utilized in the future?
- natch 3y agoFair use. The models learn patterns, not exact copies.
- amelius 3y agoDefine "not exact". A Xerox copier produces not exact copies in my definition.
- natch 3y agoWe are talking about AI, not Xerox copiers. AI today doesn’t come close to the word for word, pixel for pixel copy you are talking about.
- hakdbha 3y ago[dead]
- stefan_ 3y agoFair use is an admission of copyright violation. If this is your starting point, you should probably look for new lawyers. In any case, exact reproduction of the full novels as part of a dataset is of course not covered by fair use and proving that through discovery will be trivial.
- Ukv 3y ago> Fair use is an admission of copyright violation. If this is your starting point, you should probably look for new lawyers. It's an admission to copying when there's a prima facie case of copyright infringement, but wouldn't generally be considered actual infringement if the fair use defense is successful. It's perfectly fine to rely on fair use - we'll have to wait and see how it applies to machine learning, but it's not some obscure implausible theory. > In any case, exact reproduction of the full novels as part of a dataset is of course not covered by fair use It definitely can be. Consider in Authors Guild v. Google, where Google copied millions of in-copyright books, stored them internally in full, and made them accessible as snippets: "verbatim intermediate copying has consistently been upheld as fair use if the copy is ‘not reveal[ed] . . . to the public.’"
- bell-cot 3y agoGetting the news out ASAP is probably a Reuters priority...but it'd be nice to see even a tiny bit of context. They mention the AI dataset in question being taken down last October, after reports of copyright infringement. So was there any sign of "Joe Juryman would say that was copying" behavior by the AI, or did Nvidia meaningfully profit from the alleged offenses, or is there any interesting precedent in the District where the suit was filed?
- christenchrist 3y ago[dead]
- ndgold 3y agoy tho
- khaki54 3y agoSo if you're a teacher and you assign a book to your class to read and process, can you be held liable? What if they take notes? What if some or all of the students have eidetic memory? What if the students then use the knowledge they gained from your book for commercial purposes? This just seems like another way to stifle innovation
- stubish 3y agoIf you read out the book in class, that might be fine. If you recorded the class and uploaded it to youtube, that would be public broadcast and a copyright violation. If your students with eidetic memory quoted parts in public, that would be fair use. If your students recited the entire thing in public, that would probably be public broadcast and a copyright violation (for a court to decide). If you made copies of the book and gave them to your students, it would be a copyright violation and you would also lose your job (schools have pretty strict rules about how much copyrighted work can be included in course notes, because they have and will be sued beyond fair use or legal exceptions for educational institutions).