12 ms·
Airbnb's Devastating Effect on Canadian Housing
- selectodude 3y agoAnother article blaming literally anybody and everybody other than progressive housing advocates shutting down any new housing construction for decades.
- masom 3y ago> shutting down any new housing construction for decades. That's a problem. No one is saying it isn't. The role of Airbnb cannot be ignored; it is negatively affecting housing availability as landlords can make much more profits on short-term rentals than long-term ones. On the building side, we've made it much more difficult to build low/mid rise apartments buildings. General accessibility requirements alone make it impractical to build anything less than 5 floors with a large land footprint (~20 units per floor). You pretty much need an elevator and other accessibility systems, which makes construction and maintenance of low to mid rises prohibitive. Older constructions are filled with grandfathered clauses allowing them to skip over accessibility requirements. This is why you only see requests to build ~20+ floor buildings, which people disagree to be added in their neighbourhood. ex: https://www.ontario.ca/page/accessibility-ontarios-building-code https://www.ontario.ca/page/accessibility-ontarios-building-... > Barrier-free floor access is also required for residential and office buildings over: > 3 storeys high > 600 square metres in building area
- pitaj 3y ago> The role of Airbnb cannot be ignored; it is negatively affecting housing availability as landlords can make much more profits on short-term rentals than long-term ones. It can be ignored if it's insignificant - I haven't seen any evidence to show that banning short-term rentals significantly improves housing prices.
- masom 3y agoYes it can be ignored if it is insignificant, the issue arises when it isn't and long-term rentals are being transitioned to short-term. Cities and towns should have strict licensing requirements to control the effects. Airbnb itself does not matter as it's just a platform. Some places have limited buildable land and Airbnb was taking over a lot of long term rentals. Example of how this affects larger towns: https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/montreal-tenant-receives-eviction-notice-to-make-way-for-airbnb-1.6280484 https://montreal.ctvnews.ca/montreal-tenant-receives-evictio...
- ta1243 3y agoI rented vacation houses/apartments/etc well before airbnb -- indeed I've never used airbnb. My parents did the same thing in the 1980s, we got catalogues through.
- masom 3y agoThere's a difference between purpose-built rentals, and Airbnb taking over what should have been long term rentals. I live in a resort town where we implemented strict rental licenses as otherwise the whole town would be on Airbnb, with nowhere for locals to live. There's no more land to build on within 50km. We're seeing a lot of housing be torn down and rebuilt as 4 unit townhomes on the same land. The town is now attempting to balance between vacation homes and long term rentals, with fines for unlicensed Airbnbs.
- fsargent 3y agoArticles like this are supremely annoying. The devastating effect is caused by the fact that they aren’t building enough housing. The problem is not the demand for housing, it’s the supply. Don’t blame Airbnb when you refuse to build enough housing, the markets going to figure out how to market.
- LegitShady 3y agocanada is building housing like crazy, but also allowing massive immigration numbers, and airbnb is icing on the cake. Its not just one problem. But airbnb is garbage and should be banned.
- bongodongobob 3y ago... So they need to build more housing.
- DamnYuppie 3y agoOr reduce immigration.
- nkjnlknlk 3y agoThere being one significant factor does not mean there are no other significant factors. The same goes for solutions.
- gadders 3y agoEr, no. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2024/02/29/world/politics/canada-student-trafficking-industry-trudeau/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2024/02/29/world/politics/...
- stanleykm 3y agoare you guys really so invested in airbnb being present in Canadian cities? “Just build more housing”, “Just reduce immigration” all for airbnb’s benefit?
- shortsunblack 3y agoWords 'zoning', 'nimbyism' are not mentioned in this article.
- danlugo92 3y agoRed flag for this article TBH
- optimalsolver 3y agoOn your next Airbnb stay, don't forget to smile for the hidden cameras: https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2019/03/what-happens-when-you-find-cameras-your-airbnb/585007/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2019/03/what-...
- codetrotter 3y agoIronically this is one of the least scary forms of surveillance for me. Like, a lot of people would rightfully feel super violated by this. But compared to all other kinds of surveillance that an actual vast majority of all of us is subject to every single day, this one bothers me a lot less. Ok Mr AirBnB home owner, you got to see my willy in 720p grainy illegible video from a weird angle from the bedroom ceiling for a couple minutes. Cool for you I guess. And meanwhile the much worse forms of surveillance that happens to all of us goes largely unnoticed, and when it gets brought up everyone is like “I ain’t got nothing to hide so I’m not bothered”.
- danielfoster 3y agoWhat about density zoning, lack of mass transit, and high cost of construction? These are the main drivers of unaffordable housing.
- hodder 3y agoVery weak evidence presented in the article. Airbnb is surely a factor in rental price increases, but if it were in fact a leading causative factor, how come municipalities that ban airbnb do not see rental prices drop materially? The focus clearly needs to be put on adding substantial supply, and in Canada at least, reigning in the demand from new immigration.
- johnchristopher 3y agoDo rental prices ever drop ? I think they may increase slower but that's about it.
- hodder 3y agoCertainly. If supply were to increase faster than demand, pricing would fall in real terms. This has happened many times in history in Canadian municipalities.
- johnchristopher 3y agoI am happy for you. On western continental Europe where I live I never saw that. Houses where highways are getting built see their selling prices drop though.
- Slurpee99 3y agoOf course they can drop, even in [insert your country here] but look worldwide for more extreme examples.
- bgirard 3y agoAlso an increase below inflation/wages is a drop, particularly if sustained over a long period of time.
- paxys 3y agoRents in San Francisco are well below what they were in 2015-2019.
- MBCook 3y agoBut VCs lost less than they would have otherwise. And isn’t that what capitalism is really about?
- Solvency 3y agoI'd be curious to see how Airbnb's devastation in Canada compares to, say, the influx of wealthy foreigners seizing the entire Vancouver housing market.
- lm411 3y agoAnecdotally, in my experience, a large percent of AirBNB's in Vancouver are owned by foreigners. But yeah, the really wealthy foreigners just buy up mansions and keep them empty. I don't believe the Empty Homes Tax or foreign buyer ban work very well. It's just too easy to fake and there is very little enforcement. Same for the AirBNB license requirements - barely enforced.
- danlugo92 3y agoAs I mentioned in another thread, what about 1 "SSN" (whatever Canada's equivalent is) to N houses... So N houses can only be owned or sponsored by only 1 "SSN" holder... So even if you have for example 20 Chinese foreigners, they would have to be sponsored by at least N "SSN Holders". If a "SSN Holder" buys up an 'unnatural' amount of land/houses, look into it... then maybe check who is he sponsoring (other Canadians or just 20 Chinese buyers?) and then decide from there. By "Chinese" I mean "Chinese without the equivalent of Canada's SSN" btw, no exclusion obviously should be performed against "Chinese"-descendant Canadian citizens. For any readers... this system is already implemented in the USA for bank accounts, and it works, so it could realistically be implemented in Canada but for property... even easier still I think...
- lm411 3y agoI think it's a good idea and I would support it. But something like that would never be implemented by our current government. They'd likely call you racist or xenophobic just for suggesting it. For most Canadians, the next election can't come soon enough. Hopefully the likely to win opposition will make some changes. BTW Canada's SSN equivalent would be the SIN (Social Insurance Number).
- istultus 3y agoI mean, it's an article on gentrification and rise in housing market costs. I'm sure Airbnb adds some to the general price rises, but it surely is just a small part of the many factors that have led to this effect in most cities in the Western World over the past 30 years?
- Mistletoe 3y agoI wouldn't say that at all. I currently live in an Airbnb that failed and my girlfriend informed me that the cute older house we went to an Open House for is now an Airbnb.
- kfarr 3y agoThe devastating effect of ... artificially restricted supply through regulation.
- pas 3y ago(I know it's preaching to the choir, but ...) What's the solution? Owning your own home (and public housing). What's needed for that? Drastically cheaper housing. What's needed for that? Economies of scale. (Higher density, mass-production of components with as much prefab as possible. A few standard floorplans with some customizability.)
- epolanski 3y agoHonestly unsurprising when compared to Europe. Not sure about all Canadian details but here it's a tragedy. My mother has a laundry working with Airbnbs in the center of Rome providing them with fresh towels and sheets everyday, before she mostly catered at locals. While this is good for us, Airbnb absolutely ruined the center of Rome. Locals are being forced out further and further away, neighborhoods, markets, bars, everything I grew up and that existed till a decade ago is at a rapid pace transforming our city in a tourist theme park. Some cities have it much worse, but I can't but say that locals and traditional way of living and communities are being torn apart by mass tourism. This isn't a housing problem per se as if Rome has not enough houses for locals, you can still move further away and find a place, and I'm not even complaining about the much higher prices. But it feels like Airbnb is devouring any bigger city out of its locals, eroding lifestyles and transforming cities in theme parks. Some places have it much worse than Rome, thinking of Lisbon or even worse Venice e.g. but I swear I travel a lot and it's harder and harder to see anything local or authentic in most of the places I go unless I head for very distant neighborhoods.
- Mistletoe 3y agoThere is hope. My family and friends are planning a trip to New Orleans and everyone was a resounding "NO" when Airbnb was mentioned. We are all tired of the fees and being a maid on our own vacation.
- danlugo92 3y agoAirBNB still better for multi-month stays, wherever you can receive visits of course (I've found you have to rent more than a month's time to be able to host visits)... Thing is people want to have friends and SOs over you know... which is not possible in "traditional" hotels...
- danlugo92 3y ago> But it feels like Airbnb is devouring any bigger city out of its locals, eroding lifestyles and transforming cities in theme parks. Legit concern and I've seen it happen...
- soupbowl 3y agoAirbnb did not help things but the Canadian government at all levels is what has caused such a nightmare housing crisis.
- vouaobrasil 3y agoCanadian here. While AirBNB can be a problem, the real problem is not AirBNB. It's actually housing as an investment rather than a place to live. You can shut down AirBNB or regulate it or whatever, but as long as you've got housing as a lucractive investment with not enough new housing being built, you're going to get people trading it like the stock market. I mean, come on, we've got a finite amount of land. Property investors like articles like this because they shift the blame. How about instead a regulation over how many houses/apartments a person can own? How about a maximum of one? Or I bet even two would slow it down.
- jfabre 3y agoI think you're unto something. Totally anecdotal, but my father owns around ~10 houses and small apartment buildings in Canada. I think he managed to acquire them all through mortgage refinancing or something like that I really have no idea. He rents the properties to people. Even though he's a hard worker, he has a normal 9-5 job and his income is pretty standard for a salaried worker. Knowing him, I'm sure he didn't come up with the idea himself, so I bet this is a relatively common thing to do for mid to high income baby-boomers. I could be totally off base here, but I can see that if most people have the leverage to own 10 houses in Canada through some financial instruments with the banks this could lead to a housing bubble.
- dimask 3y agoTotally agree, but imo airbnb is an accelerator making the profit out of housing investment more lucrative, increasing short term profit margins (instead of let's say owning buildings and maintaining them for long term renters producing gradual but steady profit). It has also accelerated the concentration of real estate to fewer companies. The problem is that now the market is like this, even if airbnb just disappeared.
- FpUser 3y agoI live in Canada and mostly vacation here as well. I've used Airbnb couple of times initially but since my vacations last about 2 month in a summer I find that it is way better to find local ads and the savings are way to big to ignore. No Airbnbn for me.
- danlugo92 3y agoWhere do you find these "local ads"... if I may ask...? Also please don't share if you think it will be burn out by tourists... (any reader please read my other 10 comments on this thread I'm not intrinsically anti-tourist).
- FpUser 3y agoGoogle search mostly. Sometime I just come to the area I like and ask people. Never failed to find the place that suits.
- j45 3y agoNot sure if Airbnb has eaten up this much inventory The realer issue is builders who are choosing not to build to keep prices high (profit per unit is more efficient) Housing supply can be fixed pretty quick but not by vendors who want to keep and maintain their margins
- ng12 3y agoThey basically banned AirBnB in New York. Net effect was it raised hotel prices without measurably affecting housing costs.
- xutopia 3y agoDo you have a source for that? (it's not that I don't believe you it's just that I wanted to find this and couldn't).
- ng12 3y agohttps://therealdeal.com/new-york/2024/02/10/nyc-hotels-flourish-post-airbnb-ban-housing-market-stalls/ https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2024/02/10/nyc-hotels-flour...
- masswerk 3y agoPrices like these seldom go down, that damage is already done. The best to hope for is probably a decrease in price increase.
- hemloc_io 3y agoWe just seldomly build housing to the point where it reduces prices. Building housing to meet demand will reduce rents. They did it in Austin already. https://www.kvue.com/article/money/economy/boomtown-2040/austin-rent-prices-decrease/269-23a61f78-0b42-46f7-89b6-56b34dbad686 https://www.kvue.com/article/money/economy/boomtown-2040/aus... It's doable, but for some reason Liberal areas in the US just cannot figure it out. Particularly California.
- noirbot 3y agoAnd this really seems like it's going to keep going that way in Austin. Any time I'm driving around, I'm passing under-construction apartment and condo buildings all over town. It's nuts. On my regular commutes, I pass probably 10-20 buildings, and just within a mile of me, there's maybe 5 multi-hundred unit buildings that are nearing completion.
- throwaway72024 3y agoTired of these articles. 10 years ago they blamed wealthy Chinese investors and empty homes. They added the empty homes tax, limited foreign ownership and added a bunch of bureaucracy for everyone (at least two extra filings per year if you own property). The problem has gotten much worse despite this. It’s basic logic: explosive population growth to few major cities with supply that has no hope of keeping up.
- somewhereoutth 3y agoAnd a large component of that explosive population growth is tourism. It is also the easiest component to curtail. Let's get on with doing that while there is still something left of our city centers. Best wishes from Lisbon.
- danlugo92 3y ago> tourism Are the tourists really opting for the AirBNBs over hotels though? I think it's mostly digital nomads (whatever you like to think of them they're different from just "normal tourists") occupying AirBNBs...? (With like monthly rentals and such)
- somewhereoutth 3y agoDigital Nomads can't afford the tourist rates (100Euros/night?), but they are soaking up some of the market for higher end long term rentals and monthly rentals. There aren't actually that many of them though, relative to tourists and locals, and mostly they are looking to arbitrage cost of living, so can be quite cost conscious.
- cangeroo 3y agoWhat about affordable hotels with reasonable living conditions? Maybe the hotel industry needs disruption? Every hotel I've been to was incredibly wasteful.
- asdff 3y ago> What about affordable hotels with reasonable living conditions? There are plenty of places to stay for $40 a night already considering the motel market.
- cangeroo 3y agoThen why do people use Airbnb?
- asdff 3y agoI'm not sure why anymore unless you want to rent out a single family home, many places ask for north of $200 a night now. It hasn't been the cheapest option for years. Especially considering there are services now that demand price unbooked hotel rooms for these near motel prices.
- advisedwang 3y agoAirBnB means the income a property can gives is based on worldwide incomes. This is incredibly dangerous for somewhere with lower wages/cost of living (which the article says includes Montreal), as now basically every property can make more as an AirBnB than it could renting to local people. When tourists can afford more than locals, the "efficient" market solution is to ensure the tourist market is fully supplied, even if the local market is not.
- anon-sre-srm 3y agoI think we should severely tax air travel because of the climate change contribution and of the tourist temporary hipster gentrification causing permanent damage.
- danlugo92 3y ago> lower wages/cost of living (which the article says includes Montreal) I mean, the "digital nomad" market is pretty big and sure it will include a lot of "whales", thus "beating out" the local market... Not sure how that includes Montreal but for example it might not include Geneva for example I think...? _thinking_emoji_
- xutopia 3y agoAirbnb sucks as a client for so many reasons but this article is not providing any evidence whatsoever. Articles like these existed well before Airbnb existed. Quebec has been doing poorly when it comes to new constructions for decades now and we're feeling it more and more each year.
- paxys 3y agoAlternatively – "Not building enough housing and treating housing as an investment vehicle rather than a basic need's devastating effect on Canadian housing".
- lm411 3y agoI lived in a small community / somewhat resort town on Vancouver Island a couple of years ago. Population less than 15000. Typically there would be less than 3-4 residential long term rental units available in the whole town. And there were over 350+ AirBNB units in the town - mostly empty in the off seasons. Almost all condos, apartments, or laneway houses. Many people unable to find housing... Families living in trailers, RV's, etc. Lots of single people living out of their cars. People with decent incomes. There are a lot of causes for the housing crisis in Canada, but, AirBNB definitely plays a big role in the rental market.
- betaby 3y ago> And there were over 350+ AirBNB units in the town Or about 4.6%? Right? Sounds reasonably OK for a resort town.
- lm411 3y agoSure, but, in such an extreme housing crisis it might be wise to adjust priorities so people have housing. The town also has a massive NIMBY problem.
- betaby 3y agoCome to Montreal! Our AirBnB listings peaked at about 0.025% of all apartments in 2018. If you still genuinely believe AirBnB is the problem where you live now.
- lm411 3y agoI didn't say AirBNB was "the" problem. It does contribute in a significant way. Have you seen the rental prices in Vancouver, or CRD region?
- betaby 3y agoSure I did. Also AirBnB peaked in Vancouver at 0.05% 5+ years ago of all condo stock. Thus I don't see how 0.05% of the all units can anyhow influence the market.
- lunarboy 3y agoI agree that supply is the real problem, but not because there's not enough physical units. I feel like governments need to either ban or very heavily tax owning residential property that you don't live in yourself. Just building more units without actually increasing capacity of the infrastructure to support more people isn't the solution imo
- jpn 3y agoIt's not bc of Airbnb. It's bc of rent control: https://financialpost.com/real-estate/montreal-rent-cheaper-than-toronto https://financialpost.com/real-estate/montreal-rent-cheaper-... Rent control makes renting less attractive and Airbnb more attractive. Allow higher rents will encourage more building and therefore more supply.
- danlugo92 3y agoRent control without outlawing AirBNB will surely just make all landlords gravitate to AirBNB... Whether you think that's "good" or "bad" it is what happens... Now, if you think that's "bad" then you should ask your government to ban AirBNB /ON TOP/ of rent controls else the whole thing just doesn't make sense... ...I'm not being pro-AirBNB or anti-AirBNB but I'm pro-logic and pro-democracy (whatever 51% want in a given city is what the government should follow...)...
- GuB-42 3y agoOk, there are more and more short term rentals, but in these short term rentals are people: tourists, workers, etc... Where were they before AirBnB? Hotels would be the obvious answer, but as far as I know, hotels didn't suffer a massive drop in the number of occupants to match the increase in the number of short term rentals. So, what caused the increase demand in housing for short stays?
- pmontra 3y agoMaybe the very availability of short stays. You looked for a stay before AirBnB, didn't find one, didn't go. You look for a stay post AirBnB, always find one, go. This is true especially for tourists (in combo with low cost flights) but it opens up opportunities also for workers that didn't have the same flexibly of movement and/or couldn't make the cost of a stay fit into what they get for their services.
- betaby 3y agoAirBnB peaked at about 0.025% of all apartment units in Montreal in 2018. AirBnB can not therefore have any measurable effect.
- danlugo92 3y agoSource (honest question check my history)...?
- betaby 3y agohttps://www.timescolonist.com/business/airbnb-not-behind-canadian-residential-rent-increases-study-says-7669391 https://www.timescolonist.com/business/airbnb-not-behind-can... There were multiple studies from McGill and UBC on that subject, and I cite those numbers from memory. I read them back then and it's striking how low those numbers are. One study with the online PDF https://cjur.uwinnipeg.ca/index.php/cjur/article/view/274/136 https://cjur.uwinnipeg.ca/index.php/cjur/article/view/274/13... page 123. There were totally 73K active AirBNB listings in Toronto, Vancouver, Montreal areas combined between May 1, 2017 and April 30, 2018. Dived that on total number of houses and apartments and you are in the sub percentage category. Those are pre pandemic numbers, Airbnb has declined since then because of variety of factors like COVID, additional taxes and outright bans is most condo buildings.
- vendiddy 3y agoI'm not too familiar with the causes of the rising cost of housing. Is it right to assume that lack of supply is the main factor? If so, what should US/CA be doing to address this? What are they currently doing now that makes the problem worse? Looking for a better source than the article above which feels a bit fluffy.
- qgin 3y agoGovernment: hey no fair, people are demanding more housing than we're willing to let developers supply
- ForestCritter 3y agoMost of the comments below are citing statistics for Canada or the whole Province of Quebec,not Montreal, which is like using the US housing statistics for NYC.
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoI know this isn't the most progressive thing in the world, but uh... what about a law that puts a hard upper cap on the tax rate of any primary residence while also limiting the amount of properties a person or corporate entity can own within an area? Seems to me that it would encourage cash-starved governments to encourage home building while discouraging seldom-used second-homes and single family rental properties.
- travisb 3y agoWhere I live it costs $1500 to create a new corporate entity and $500/year to file taxes for a trivial corporation. A limit like that is entirely unworkable against large corporate interests. All it would do is prevent local, small-time landlords from expanding.
- danlugo92 3y ago> All it would do is prevent local, small-time landlords from expanding. A lot of people would argue about "local, small-time landlords"'s capacity to expand you know... As I said in other threads, maybe limit capacity to N-properties for each Canadian citizen, maybe 5 I don't know. If you're a Canadian citizen you would have to go through one, even if just a lawyer that lawyer could only "sponsor" up to N non-Canadians to buy properties in Canada (or N properties for just 1 non-Canadian, whatever that lawyer or notary prefers...).
- 486sx33 3y agoVery simple solutions. Banning Airbnb or foreign buyers are lazy and lousy solutions. If you’re going to do something like that - make it a non resident tax for property and give residents a rate of 25% of the non resident property tax. Then the foreign income directly benefits the people and the local communities Allow single family homes to be built. Do not allow anyone to immigrate to the country, refugee or otherwise unless they can demonstrate an ability to pay for their own housing for 3 years upfront plus a lump sum immigration tax of $75,000 indexed to inflation to allow them access to social benefits Do not allow them to come into Toronto first, for the first 3 years move them to the north in Canada as that is where we need the population growth. Build build build, whatever people want, wherever they want.
- voisin 3y ago> Build build build, whatever people want, wherever they want. The “whatever people want, where very they want” part is where there is massive disagreement and everything gets bogged down. It takes leadership and our politicians are too busy talking about ArriveCAN or some other waste of air to show any form of leadership.
- tamimio 3y agoThe problem in Canadian housing is mostly a mix of these factors: - A slowdown in new housing construction, which has created a supply shortage and increased land values. This is due to a combination of low manpower, developers’ lobbying, and bad regulations. - A lack of affordable rental housing, which has forced many low-income households to spend more than 30% (even 50%) of their income on rent or become homeless. Moreover, all elected parties, regardless of their political side, will make laws in favor of the owners, because they are the majority of the voters. - Financialization, which means that housing is seen as an investment rather than just a place to shelter. This has resulted in a lot of investors who buy and raise rent prices. And up until recently, you did not even have to be Canadian or even living in Canada to buy properties, which is insane. I remember on several occasions I had to call the landlords who were outside of Canada and could not even speak English. Most Canadian land is owned by the crown, which limits the availability and affordability of land for housing development. - A mismatch between the types of housing available and the needs of the population. Most houses built assume single-family households with the hefty price tag that comes with it. And barely any new houses built are small units for young, singles, seniors, etc. who do not need a big house. They end up living with housemates perpetually
- Tiktaalik 3y agoThere's a pretty clear market failure here. For whatever reason, taxes, regulations, other, it's not profitable enough to create hotels and so the only relief valve for tourism has become Airbnb. In the absence of any regulation that would seek to create a more even playing field between hotels and airbnb, Airbnb has a remarkable advantage, and so accordingly investors and would be hoteliers have pivoted to making Airbnbs instead, at the expense of regular people who are just looking for a place to live. Government needs to clamp down on Airbnb and even the playing field for sure, but they should not ignore the obvious issue here that for some reason people were extremely reluctant to create hotels. There's probably some need for regulatory reform to make creating hotels a thriving viable business.
- danlugo92 3y agoThe single most powerful advantage AirBNB has, and believe me... is that... ....at least when you rent for more than a month (in most places)... ...you can receive visits and treat that place as your "own"... That's a really big advantage for digital nomads... ...they can receive friends they made at this new city, or sex workers... (regardless of how you feel about that it's a reality)... But 1-week tourists are still probably staying at hostels or hotels... So maybe allow visits at hotels and then you kill off a lot of the AirBNB market...?
- nojvek 3y agoAirbnb is just a market like the rental market or house buying/selling market.