19 ms·
FDA clears first over-the-counter continuous glucose monitor
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SeanAnderson 3y agoHah, what a small world. I was just talking to my friend yesterday while we worked out together. He was applying for a 6-mo dev contract at a company making a 15-day wearable glucose monitor. He was a little concerned that it hadn't been approved by the FDA yet, though. ...guess that concern is no longer an issue!
- dbbljack 3y agoyou guys sound like yuppies, using a CGM to come to the conclusion that rice and soda cause sharper insulin spikes than proteins, and exercise is good for you! Could have gotten the same info from a $10 book of glycemic indices or a $20 traditional glucose test kit. If you aren't diabetic, a CGM is widely useless and you're just manually deriving basic facts about metabolism you could have just... read.
- post_break 3y agoCan we do CPAP machines next?
- polishdude20 3y agoTechnically you can buy them on Facebook marketplace, craigslist etc
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dumbfounder 3y agoI had to buy one for a friend. But then he ordered a new one and all he had to do was send them a picture of his old one (after some persistence). It’s ridiculous.
- electriclove 3y agoAnd contact lenses too!
- gamepsys 3y agoI like this trend of the FDA making more and more things OTC.
- hanniabu 3y agoDon't be fooled by the reason though > The markup on OTC products is generally higher than on prescription medications. https://www.eposnow.com/us/resources/how-do-pharmacies-make-money/#:~:text=The%20markup%20on%20OTC%20products%20is%20generally%20higher%20than%20on%20prescription%20medications.%20That%20means%20every%20time%20a%20customer%20reaches%20for%20a%20box%20of%20pain%20relievers%20or%20a%20bottle%20of%20cough%20syrup%2C%20your%20pharmacy%27s%20bottom%20line%20gets%20a%20little%20boost https://www.eposnow.com/us/resources/how-do-pharmacies-make-....
- nickthegreek 3y agoFor medical products though, it seems great. OTC hearing aids are a big win for society.
- LordKeren 3y agoI have an extremely hard time buying into the idea that that the reason for making glucose monitors available over the counter is simply to increase the profit margins of drug stores.
- reaperman 3y agoI haven't noticed this as a consumer in the context we're talking right now. I think that article is measuring the difference between OTC and pharmacy pricing after a drug is approved OTC. But it is not looking at prices pre- vs. post- OTC approval. Olopatadine eye drops are amazing for allergy season, and they used to be like $250-400/bottle just 5 years ago or so, even the generic version. Then they went OTC for like $10/bottle. This pricing difference might be true for things that are already mostly cheap, like Omeprazole -- where branding on consumer products drives OTC markup, but consumers don't pick the brand when doctors prescribe it and the pharmacy just gives them whatever cheapest generic they have in the back that they negotiated excellent pricing on. Though you can easily close the gap on these prices by shopping for the store-brand generics at Costco, Walmart, Sam's Club, etc.
- RobotToaster 3y agoSo the ones already all over amazon aren't supposed to be there?
- barelyauser 3y agoAmazon as a gateway to illegal or fraudulent products? Please, a trillion dollar corporation must surely have professionals watching this over.
- thfuran 3y agoI just searched for one and found >Important information Legal Disclaimer : Statements regarding dietary supplements have not been evaluated by the FDA and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or health condition. At the very bottom of the description. That seems like complete BS that shouldn't hold up, but I don't know.
- mattl 3y agoThat's on virtually every supplement website it seems.
- thfuran 3y agoSure, but a blood glucose monitor isn't a dietary supplement. I think it's a bit dodgy that that kind of disclaimer means anything for a dietary supplement in the first place, but it certainly shouldn't apply to a medical device.
- mattl 3y agoProbably just placeholder text I'm sure. Look at all the legalese at the bottom of https://www.freestyle.abbott/us-en/home.html https://www.freestyle.abbott/us-en/home.html
- Johnny555 3y agoI don't see any non-prescription CGM's on Amazon, are you using Amazon USA? I searched for "CGM" and "Continuous Glucose Monitor", and only found test-strip devices and CGM devices on Amazon Pharmacy available with prescription. What search string are you using? Can you post one?
- coldpie 3y agoI'm T1D (insulin-dependent). I used a Dexcom for a couple years a while ago, back around the G3 through G5 era or so. I ended up stopping using it because my diabetes is very well managed, and I found it didn't make a huge difference to my management. With my insurance, each new sensor every week cost about $50, and would fail in various annoying ways: sometimes it would just stop working in the middle of the week, or not work at all from the start, or disconnect randomly for a few hours. Each sensor also used a ludicrous amount of plastic for its applicator, like a tennis-ball-sized hunk of hard plastic, that you just chucked in the trash, every week. Maybe things have improved, but it was a bad combo of unreliable and expensive so I just quit using it and went back to finger pokes. If it were like $5 per week, I might put up with it. Maybe this over-the-counter model will be affordable. We'll see, I guess.
- ng12 3y agoYou went back to finger sticks? I am floored. Do you follow a strict low carb diet? How often are you exercising?
- coldpie 3y agoDefinitely not low carb, no. I have a bowl of oatmeal for breakfast 4-6 times a week :) My diet is pretty consistent though. I know how that oatmeal will respond to insulin 90% of the time, and the remaining 10% random quirks I can just deal with by feel & a finger prick to confirm. The thing I'm most strict about is I only allow myself to have about one "bad diabetes meal" per week. So that's like any restaurant food, or doughnuts, or pizza, or whatever. I mostly only eat home made meals, my wife & I both love to cook. But those aren't low carb, just whatever we feel like cooking that week. I walk about a mile a day, to the bus & back for work and a bit for leisure and to get up from my desk. Otherwise I don't exercise.
- mlsu 3y agoDexcom and Freestyle both have options (G7, FSL2) that have a much narrower form factor than the old sensors. They end up being far more reliable, because the sensor doesn't dislodge. The new Dexcom sensors are more accurate. Less drift and no calibration. Out of pocket cost is obviously your own situation but I think anyone with T1 should look at them. For me they are life changing, even moreso if you have a pump that can deliver based on CGM readings. Plastic waste situation is still bad.
- bookofjoe 3y ago>Continuous Glucose Monitoring https://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/diabetes/overview/managing-diabetes/continuous-glucose-monitoring https://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/diabetes/overvi...
- 005 3y agoI don't think this is particularly special. In other countries it's possible to obtain Dexcom's current line up by purchasing it online (G6, ONE, G7) and other brands too like Abbott's Freestyle Libre. It seems like this is a stripped down version of the G7 (albeit with a longer wear time) as the ONE is a stripped down version of the G6.
- gumby 3y agoHopefully they are cheaper than the copay on the Libre 3 sensors.
- rkagerer 3y agoWhen your smartphone becomes a critical health device to support/treat a condition I wonder how that will impact case law around things like police confiscation.
- uxamanda 3y agoInteresting, never thought about that. Also wonder what happens in Airplane mode / poor reception?
- shanselman 3y agoit's all BLE and works great on an airplane as long as BT is on
- hammock 3y agoCGMs use bluetooth
- justinclift 3y agoBluetooth has a terrible reputation around reliability. :(
- pastage 3y agoIn the loop community (CGM+insuling pump) you usually have a list of phones that work well with Bluetooth. Yes that changes when the phones get new powersaving settings and driver updates, usually it works well on good phones.
- justinclift 3y agoYeah, that sounds like a practical approach for dealing with it. :)
- saagarjha 3y agoWhat happens when an officer confiscates your glucose monitor today? I assume you die and they claim they did it for some valid reason or the other.
- lacoolj 3y agoinb4 apple watch integration
- asow92 3y agoI'll be buying that apple watch if it ever gets here
- cadr 3y agohttps://www.massdevice.com/dexcom-direct-to-watch-g7-cgm/ https://www.massdevice.com/dexcom-direct-to-watch-g7-cgm/ (There is already an app to show on the watch, but you still need the phone in the loop - this is directly to the watch without the phone.)
- bradleyy 3y agoDexcom already has an integration; are you talking about hardware?
- mattl 3y agoYeah, it would be great if the watch could just do this for you, instead of needing to buy a new sensor every 14 days.
- thecosas 3y agoBased on everything I've seen so far, the technology for non-invasive glucose monitoring is still far away. Recently, the FDA even released a warning that any companies claiming they could are misleading people [1][2]. Don't get me wrong; I have had T1D for 30+ years and would love to have reliable, non-invasive, glucose monitoring on my wrist. We've come so far already from a finger stick that would take 2 minutes to get a result. Have hope :-) [1] https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/safety-communications/do-not-use-smartwatches-or-smart-rings-measure-blood-glucose-levels-fda-safety-communication https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/safety-communications/do... [2] https://www.theverge.com/2024/2/21/24079495/smartwatch-smart-ring-blood-glucose-monitoring-diabetes-fda https://www.theverge.com/2024/2/21/24079495/smartwatch-smart...
- csours 3y agoI wish Theranos had worked on a more reasonable goal - like an implantable CGM. I had T2D, well controlled now, my A1C is below the diabetic diagnostic range. I used CGMs, and they taught me a lot about how my body reacted to food and exercise. But I sweat a lot and they would always fall off, halving the useful life of each monitor. I would probably still use them from time to time if they didn't sweat off; and if an implantable version was available for a reasonable price (under $500, with no ongoing costs), I'd probably get it. I feel like a lot of prediabetic people could learn a lot about their situation with this. I think this is a very good thing.
- guidopallemans 3y agoI used to have this problem as well, so I talked it over at my endo office. They suggested that I order some specially shaped stickers to keep them on, but instead I just bought some Kinesiology Tape (hansaplast, but also exists store-brand). 10cm of that works perfectly, even for heavy contact sports combined with sweating (and many showers).
- mapkkk 3y agoJust make sure you cut a small circle from the tape overlying the breather hole of the sensor - that hole serves to let moisture buildup from underneath the sensor escape.
- csours 3y agoYup, I tried this. I sweat A LOT
- crimsontech 3y agoI tried different tapes, Kinesiology tape didn’t stick for me but Hypafix did, I can’t get this stuff off without soaking it. If you ever want to give it another go, try Hypafix. I tore my skin the first time and quickly learned to soak it and use soap to remove the GCM.
- T1DTech 3y ago
- philsnow 3y agoI dove into CGMs a little bit about a year ago, mostly just for fun. Yes, I paid money to some online prescription mill for CGMs (Abbott Freestyle Libre 3, IIRC), and then put one in my arm (the applicator is a short syringe section that has the monitor tube threaded into it, so the tube stays in your arm and your skin under the monitor remains broken) for a couple weeks. Just to see how various foods would affect my blood glucose, to see whether the “facts” I’m telling my kids about the glycemic index of various foods actually has the expected impact on a measurable result. You know, as you do. For fun. (It actually was fun, and I’ll do it again when the data ecosystem improves.)
- hasty_pudding 3y agoI would love to see the results of that!
- haswell 3y agoAside from the fun, how did it go? Find anything surprising or insightful in the process? It sounds like an experiment I’d like to do for the purpose of optimizing my daily habits and establishing a better mental model for how my eating habits impact me throughout the day. But I really dislike needles.
- smt88 3y agoIf the needle in the CGM bothers you, don't let it. It's a quick, painless jab with a tiny needle at the beginning and then the needle comes out. The part that stays in your body is just a flexible filament made of plastic. I did this experiment as well, and the main thing it did was completely stop me from snacking. My habits got better because I could see how my BG could never return to baseline if I allowed myself to snack between meals. Other than that, it was also interesting to see certain things would badly spike my BG and other things wouldn't, and they weren't always what you'd expect. A lot of "keto" and "diabetic-friendly" products are terrible for most people's BG and were for mine. I found that some things, like black tea, actually made my BG drop as well. Overall it's worth doing at least once.
- 3y ago
- terhechte 3y agoI bought a Sibionics GS1 recently and am about to use it (SIBIONICS GS1 Sensor Continuous... https://www.amazon.de/dp/B0CPDHKGYK?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share https://www.amazon.de/dp/B0CPDHKGYK?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share). Reading this thread I’m wondering if it is a safe / good product to use. Does anybody happen to have knowledge?
- dddiaz1 3y agoGreat to see it be OTC. But it's weird that it is advertised to last for 15 days, while the prescription version for T1ds/T2ds only lasts for 10 days. The hardware looks the same.
- thecosas 3y agoHad the same thought! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39621575 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39621575 Also... does this mean they are direct-to-consumer as well as retail channels? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39622192 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39622192
- chx 3y agoI got the dexcom g6 three years ago via a simple online order in Canada. Is Canada more lax? What's the difference?
- coldcode 3y agoIn the U.S., until this one, you needed a prescription to buy one. Many countries allow them to be purchased without.
- anonfornoreason 3y agoI would recommend anyone to experiment with this. I did, and found out I was more glucose sensitive than I expected. This led me to get more broad labs done, with which I was able to find additional treatable issues that are likely the cause. If I hadn't done this, I would have found out via symptoms years later, after irreversible damage had already been done. You are your only medical advocate, no one else is going to do it for you. The standard of care is shit, don't rely on it.
- epistasis 3y agoAgreed, this is one of the better things I have done to take control of my own health! It was very very surprising which foods, and quantities of foods, caused huge spikes. However, this stuff is difficult to interpret. What should be the goal number for managing glucose spikes? What's good, what's bad? Ultimately there's a lot of judgement calls, just as there is with any health or fitness goal. I learned a lot from Peter Attia's podcasts, but that required hours of listening. My doctor offered to review my data with me, which was amazing. But many people's primary care docs may not have the experience or time.
- anonfornoreason 3y ago+1 +1 +1 to Peter Attia, huge amounts of great content. My philosophy is that if there's any single topic where I should be spending five hours a month researching, it's personal health. As far as spikes are concerned, I convinced my wife and my dad to both try out the same CGM. Neither of them really ever had any spikes of significance (maybe up to 130's), even when eating cake, etc. Obviously it varies from person to person, but the fact I would spike easily above 140 with boring foods (steel cut oats with no sweetener as an example) said to me something was wrong. My daily averages hovering around 100 to 105 were not in the pre-diabetes level but were close to it, even when eating minimal carbs and being extremely fit with a natural healthy diet. Also most of what you read out there with CGMs is related to people who actually have diabetes. Finally, there's no one really to talk to about this stuff. You can eclipse your doctor's knowledge on the topic with about 5-10 hours of research. You can go get a broad set of labs and be right at the edge of the reference range on something (which is, depending on the lab, just a range of the general population, not a healthy range) and your doctor will shrug it off. The system is setup so that as long as you are in a sort of average, even with that average being pretty bad (half of the country is fat and pre-diabetic), the standard of care is to ignore it until you fall off the end. The line between hypochondria and being on top of your health is pretty thin, and most doctors will consider you a hypochondriac if you research and come ready to talk about the topic with any level of knowledge.
- FigurativeVoid 3y agoI'm a T1 diabetic, and CGMs are a great tool for blood sugar management. Combined with a closed loop system, they are literally life changing. I am glad to see an increase in access to live changing medical care for a disease that is mostly just bad luck.
- thecosas 3y agoT1D here too. Fun to see others having an interest in CGMs :-)
- moralestapia 3y agoGreat news. Reading through their website and just found out they're disposable(!). Anyone knows if there's a reason for this? I don't want to think is just a money grab. Perhaps the patch wears off?
- coldcode 3y agoAll CGMs only work for a period of time, like a couple of weeks or so. Then you get a new one. To keep the size reasonable it can't be too big.
- mapkkk 3y agoThe patch does wear off but the main reason is because there's a finite amount of enzyme (glucose oxidase) on the filament that does the actual glucose measurement on the sensor. So over time the enzyme is "spent". That, and of course it's lucrative. There are clever ways people have come up with (particularly from low income regions) where you can trick these sensors or the apps to reset and apparently you can get way longer lifespans like that (for the dexcom you also have to file down the bluetooth transceiver so that you can get at the battery within) at the risk of no longer being able to trust the readings. There's one company that's experimenting with an implantable CGM that will supposedly have a 6 month lifespan, with a bluetooth powered patch that you apply on the skin overlying the implant.
- EMCymatics 3y agoIt can help your health but I'm concerned how often the data will get abused.
- galago 3y agoI'm currently wearing the Freestyle Libre 3. It communicates with the app every minute. I have something between pre-diabetes and diabetes so I have a slight chance at being able to treat my condition with diet/weight/exercise. Its definitely changing my behavior--I'm aware that it is not as accurate as the stick test but I have a plot of my blood sugar throughout the day. Currently I'm consuming very little carbohydrates. I've learned from my own data what foods will cause my blood sugar to spike. The app is missing some obvious features, and people are right to complain, but its way better it seems than devices that came before.
- NelsonMinar 3y agoSo glad to see medical monitoring made available to people. Different problem but an O2Ring continuous blood oxygen monitor was a big help to me in understanding my sleep apnea and getting it treated.
- sdo72 3y agoI don't know why modern days we get so many problems wrong. A -> B, then B -> A => incorrect In a fire, we see firefighters, that doesn't mean firefighters cause fire. In diabetic patients, we see high glucose level. That doesn't mean eating high GI food causes someone to have diabetes. If we look at the Blue Zone, many people eat mostly carb. So carb/high GI food definitely doesn't cause diabetes. Devices like this will make other people fearful of high glucose and think they're getting diabetes. People without the disease shouldn't focus on monitoring the glucose level, focus on eating healthy instead. And of course eating healthy is another complex topic.
- migro23 3y ago> In a fire, we see firefighters, that doesn't mean firefighters cause fire. In diabetic patients, we see high glucose level. That doesn't mean eating high GI food causes someone to have diabetes. This is correct but probably not in the way you think. It is not the glucose in and of itself that is the problem but the level of the hormone insulin circulating around your system that is at the root of Type II diabetes. Glucose and insulin are highly related. Insulin is released by the pancreas to help control the level glucose in our blood. Virtually no insulin is required when metabolising fats, a small amount is required for protein and a larger amount of insulin is required when dealing with glucose dense carbohydrate based foods. The faster a carbohydrate is metabolised the greater the dose of insulin required to quell the resulting glucose rush in the blood. What does the insulin do? As a hormone it has many functions. The presence of insulin in the blood signals to all cells to burn sugar (glucose) rather than fats (ketones) for their energy. It prompts the cells in the skeletal muscles to store up glucose in the form of glycogen for later use and it signals the liver to store excess glucose that is not immediately needed. Once the liver and muscles are full then the liver then converts any excess to triglycerides. Where do the triglycerides go? They get stored as subcutaneous fat all over but largely in the belly (in men) and bum/upper legs (in women). What happens when subcutaneous stores are full? Then the triglycerides are shoved anywhere and everywhere. Fat is pushed into muscle cells as well as the cells in individual organs. The fat molecules present in cells in organs are particularly pernicious (visceral fat) but any cells that contain these triglycerides seems to disrupt the insulin signalling within the cell. This results in insulin resistance i.e., the ineffectiveness of insulin to signal to the cell to take up excess glucose. When sufficient threshold of insulin resistance is reached, you will get higher blood sugar readings and a higher A1C at which point your doc will say you have prediabetes or full on type II diabetes. Insulin is the master key variable that unlocks the type II diabetes puzzle. High blood sugar levels are just a symptom. The problem with modern day Type II diabetic care is they consider the high blood sugar as the root problem. So this is treated with meds such as metformin and eventually MORE insulin. Understanding type II diabetes as a disease of too much insulin sheds the disease in a very different light. Anyway, you are correct, the high glucose level per se is not the cause, but high levels of insulin constantly circulating around your system is the big problem. Of course an effective way of doing that is to continuously eat foods dense in glucose and fructose that are metabolised very quickly e.g., cookies, ice-cream, orange juice etc. > If we look at the Blue Zone, many people eat mostly carb. So carb/high GI food definitely doesn't cause diabetes Blue Zone areas such as Okinawa, you do find people eating carb rich foods but they are also high in fibre e.g., root vegetables, sweet potatoes etc. look at books by Robert Lustig to learn more about the importance of fibre in relation to metabolism and diabetes risk.
- hnburnsy 3y agoHope this integrates with Garmin... https://www.garmin.com/en-US/blog/health/how-garmin-and-dexcom-work-together/ https://www.garmin.com/en-US/blog/health/how-garmin-and-dexc...
- fgkramer 3y agoI’m currently wearing a CGM from Lingo (https://www.hellolingo.com/ https://www.hellolingo.com/) which is pretty much the easiest way I’ve found to get my hands on one without a prescription (as I’m not diabetic). So far it’s shown me that the sluggishness after a carb-heavy meal its heavily correlated with the glucose spike and how good my organism copes with it. Can’t wait for the day we have our own Fallout style Pip-Boys!
- autoexec 3y agoIt'd be pretty interesting to see that kind of data, but it looks like this product violates my policy on not buying hardware that requires a cell phone app to use, and my policy on keeping as much of my medical information as far away from my mobile device as possible. I'm not sure exactly who the app itself sells/leaks the data being collected to, but even having that kind of data on the device would make me uncomfortable. A quick read of their privacy policy suggests that the mobile app is full of personalized ads and they use your data for "direct marketing" as well as "research". They offer your data to third parties for both "marketing" and "analytics" reasons. They'll send your data overseas whenever it suits them, even to places where your data will not have the same protections, and they'll keep the data they collect forever unless you submit a request for them to delete it and they are actually required to do so by law. Since I'm only mildly curious to see what the numbers would look like, I'm fine with waiting until someone puts one on the market that saves its data to storage that can later be copied over to an offline PC.
- spc476 3y agoMy girlfriend as the Libre 3, and she has both the cell phone app, and a stand alone unit to store results. You can only use one or the other, not both at the same time (the Libre 3 uses Bluetooth). We have the stand alone unit because of insurance reasons.
- xen2xen1 3y agoDexcoms also have small cell phone like devices you can use. I've never put a wifi password in I can recall.
- mlsu 3y agoThey sell the data to nobody. It's considered PHI so covered by HIPAA. Dexcom has to trace custody of the data from the sensor to app to wherever it goes, so it is encrypted the whole way. Nobody has access unless the patient wants them to.
- autoexec 3y ago
- darreninthenet 3y agoMy wife already buys a Libre Freestyle over the counter here in the UK... are we talking the same thing? Why are (or were) they prescription only in the US..?
- alexnewman 3y agoCGM is cool but it interferes with my ability to swim in the ocean on the reg
- dansitu 3y agoIf you find this field interesting, Know Labs is working on a non-invasive continuous glucose monitor using RF spectroscopy: https://www.knowlabs.co https://www.knowlabs.co
- huytersd 3y agoNon invasive would be a golden goose. I don’t think I want to have something sticking into my skin for weeks on end.
- teleforce 3y agoThis is a promising non invasive glucose sensor namely GlucoRx Wearable BioXensor using microwave technique [1]. For the technical background how the sensor work and the clinical trials results please check this paper (paper also available from their university website) [2]. [1] Meet the inventor: Professor Adrian Porch from Cardiff University: https://www.med-technews.com/medtech-insights/latest-medtech-insights/meet-the-inventor-professor-adrian-porch-from-cardiff-univer/ https://www.med-technews.com/medtech-insights/latest-medtech... [2] Microwave Noninvasive Blood Glucose Monitoring Sensor: Human Clinical Trial Results: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8058721 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8058721
- thecosas 3y agoT1D here who has been using Dexcom G6 for many years now. Interesting to see the differences between Stelo and G7 which are built on the same platform. Curious if anything is driving the increase in wear time other than battery life savings from reporting back fewer readings. CGM: G7 / Stelo Wear time: 10 / 15 days Time between readings: 5 / 15 minutes
- user_7832 3y agoI seem to remember there was a "trick" with the g6 where you remove and reinsert the transmitter to get it to last longer... I suspect the time estimates are quite conservative.
- thecosas 3y agoYep, I've definitely used my G6 for two sessions using "tricks". It would definitely get wonky towards the end of that time period, but it worked.
- jonlucc 3y agoI'm not sure how much I can say; I don't work for a CGM company, but my company is very interested in diabetes. There are non-device reasons you can't use a CGM indefinitely. The site becomes less reliable over time, and it varies from peron to person. I'm not sure if the Stelo has addressed any of those, or if the G7 was overly cautious, or something else, but there are biological things happening at the site that affect the time too.
- thecosas 3y agoAh, that makes sense. I'm certain we'll never "know" but just found it interesting and was curious if people knew other trade-offs they may have been making for increased wear time, especially given that would offer a sharp reduction in cost over time for patients (and their insurance companies, etc). A 50% increase in wear time is HUGE in my opinion.
- mangoman 3y agoI recently had an unusual health event that resulted in me passing out. My wife, who is a physician, thought it might be hypoglycemia, since i'm at high risk for diabetes. She found a super friendly endocrinologist who put me on a CGM for two weeks. I never hit the hypoglycemia range during those two weeks, so it didn't really explain what my issue... but honestly the data was SUPER interesting. Just observing the various spikes made me make healthier choices, or noticing when I was feeling extra tired and seeing if that correlated to not having eaten for little while, or eating something sugary before. It's sort of like tracking your steps when you first get a smart watch. It may not have been the reason you got the device, but seeing the data, people are encouraged to act on it, even if you don't have an acute issue. since I didn't have a prescription, I couldn't get one here (didn't want to go through some sketch online site). I tried to get one from my family in India, but the prices were really high and they couldn't get the fancier one that tracks straight to your phone, so I didn't get one. I think this could be a god send for preventing pre-diabetic people who would take preventative steps if it weren't such a pain in the ass to measure consistently.
- oldgradstudent 3y ago> My wife, who is a physician, thought it might be hypoglycemia, since i'm at high risk for diabetes. Isn't hypoglycemia a side effect of insulin and other glucose lowing agent rather than of the diabetes itself?
- lr4444lr 3y agoWhat kinds of food intake/non-intake habits aside from the obvious culprits surprised you?
- rodly 3y agoLong-term they will likely make no changes because human desire, habits and behaviors are rarely unknown to us. The parent comment mentioned feeling tired after consuming something with a lot of sugar, was that really a mystery prior to using CGM? I doubt it. Sure it's interesting to correlate to your perceived wellness (or lack thereof) with a wearable spitting out data but after the novelty of this discovery wears off my guess is that people will simply stop caring to check what they already know to be the case.
- zxienin 3y agoI use Abbott Freestyle Libre 3 and it has been deeply insightful about my progress with T2D. An increase in fasting glucose over 2-3 days tells me I need course correction (more movement, choice of food). I also noticed consistent correlation between bad sleep days and raised glucose levels over the day. Made me internalize how important sleep is. I believe, next major uptick will come from CGM in wearables like Apple/Samsung watches [1][2]. I hope, even non diabetic folks use it to improve their health. [1] https://www.macrumors.com/2023/09/14/apple-watch-blood-glucose-team-update https://www.macrumors.com/2023/09/14/apple-watch-blood-gluco... [2] https://www.macrumors.com/2024/01/23/samsung-racing-to-beat-apple https://www.macrumors.com/2024/01/23/samsung-racing-to-beat-...
- thecosas 3y agoJust noticed this line in the press release from Dexcom [1]: Stelo will be available for purchase **online** without a prescription starting summer 2024. I wonder if that means that this will be direct-to-consumer in addition to retail channels (CVS, RiteAid, Amazon, etc). [1] https://investors.dexcom.com/news/news-details/2024/Stelo-by-Dexcom-First-Glucose-Biosensor-to-be-Cleared-by-FDA-as-Over-the-Counter/default.aspx https://investors.dexcom.com/news/news-details/2024/Stelo-by...
- lhl 3y agoI’d highly recommend anyone considering trying one out to give it a pin. I’ve used a CGM multiple times besides being a great feedback mechanism, it also can give you really interesting insights. Here’s one interesting tidbit showing that having an ice cream cone in between an hour-long walk actually caused no postprandial glucose spike compared to an earlier “healthy” meal served with no activity (at a metabolic health conference) https://fediverse.randomfoo.net/notice/Aafczv5LO83OOwXrbU https://fediverse.randomfoo.net/notice/Aafczv5LO83OOwXrbU
- daveisfera 3y agoI haven't seen price info anywhere, but anyone have info on what that will be?
- metabagel 3y agoI put something like this on my cat, because the vet thought she may be pre-diabetic, but stress response can also cause blood sugar to spike, so we needed to see what her blood sugar was like multiple times per day. The device worked for 5 days until she had managed to dislodge it enough so it wouldn't get a reading. The skin glue lasted another 5 days before the device fell off. Since then, she has had a "crop circle" behind her shoulder where her fur was shaved away, and which is ever so slowly filling in. Her readings were fine, so we are feeding her low carbohydrate food, because the vet thinks she may become diabetic in the future. Unfortunately, I had to place the reader device almost directly on the sensor, which was a pain, because my cat likes to hide under the bed. So, I had to squirt her with water to get her out, which was undesirable, but didn't seem to affect the readings. The device was the Freestyle Libre 2. https://www.freestyle.abbott/us-en/products/freestyle-libre-2.html https://www.freestyle.abbott/us-en/products/freestyle-libre-...
- mzs 3y agoI wonder what the price will be: https://www.dexcom.com/en-us/stelo https://www.dexcom.com/en-us/stelo
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- apatheticonion 3y agoI currently sticky-tape my Fitbit Inspire 3 to my tricep to get continuous low effort health/sleep tracking. I used sticky tape as an experiment because there are no arm bands for Fitbit products. That was a year and a half ago and have worn it like that every day since. I can't wait until trackers can be implanted under the skin, track blood glucose, and improved accuracy. Let's gooooo
- UI_at_80x24 3y agoIt's worth mentioning that in Canada, you do not require a prescription to get a CGM. However only the Abbot Freestyle Libre series is available here. It cost ~$100 and last 2 weeks. I've found it to be mostly accurate. Placing it on the back of the arm was always a problem for me, it was constantly getting knocked/pulled, and otherwise disturbed. I had to buy adhesive patches that covered the entire unit. I later discovered that another decent place to apply them in on my chest between my collar-bone and shoulder-joint but lower (towards the nipple). I always had decent reliability/accuracy there. It also hurt less (from the adhesive) then on the back of the arm. Having a CGM is amazing, and if you have medical coverage that will pay for it then you should get it.
- elevaet 3y agoCan you give the elevator pitch on why someone should get one?
- UI_at_80x24 3y agoWith a CGM you always can know what your instantaneous, average and trending blood glucose readings are. With a test-strip you know your instantaneous reading are. With a test strip, a pad of paper, a calculator, a calendar, a watch, and a good enough memory to take reading 100+ times a day you can get the same results. With the test strips, I measured myself AT MOST, 7 times a day. Often just once or twice. THAT is what makes them worthwhile. It keeps measuring so you don't have to. One helpful thing that I don't worry about: Low blood sugar alarms. Hypoglycemia is a real concern, and just as serious as hyperglycemia. A CGM will alter you when your sugar gets too high OR too low. I'm poor. I can't afford a CGM anymore. So I have been going months now without measuring. Because I keep forgetting. A CGM doesn't have that limitation. I was really hoping that Apple was going to announce a CGM. I avoid the Apple ecosystem, but I would have invested in that.
- cooldevguy 3y agoI am diabetic type 2 and I've used the Abbot Freestyle Libre 2 for a few years now. You don't need a prescription in Mexico to get it, but it is expensive ($1548 MXN ~= $91 USD). The data you get is pretty interesting but at least on my experience, the difference between readings from the CGM and actual blood test can vary from 10 ~ 40 mg/dL so you have to have that in mind. However it was really helpful to discover that, while I'm pretty active since a few years ago it was troubling for me to wake up on readings over 140 mg/dL which thanks to this turned out to be just that my body does it naturally and my blood sugar spikes while asleep and an hour or so before I wake up, which my endocrinologist just attributes to my body getting ready to work out. Even as an experiment, I'd say most people should get one just to understand their bodies, and their specific responses to certain foods, once in a while.
- NoPicklez 3y agoThese are so interesting and not just for diabetics who benefit from them the most. Top athletes have been using them for exercise to make sure their blood sugar remains in the correct ranges. But Diabetics are using them to help identify how particular foods impact their blood sugar levels (obviously). The reason being is that whilst some foods might be considered high/low in sugar, each of us reacts differently in how we absorb those foods or drinks. So a bagel you eat might not spike your blood sugar like someone else, or conversely it does. You can then correlate that spike or reduction in blood glucose with how you're feeling throughout the day, how your blood sugar levels impact exercise. Also it allows you to see how combinations of foods and the order that you eat them in impacts blood sugar. If you eat a chunk of white rice without any fibre you might find it spikes, if you each a bunch of vegetables in the bowl before hand you might find it doesn't rise as high or give you a steadier release of blood sugar. I'd use one for a few months just to see how foods impact my blood sugar and how I can make different choices. It's one thing to interpret a label, but it's another to see it's impact on your body in real time.
- briandw 3y agoI did this for fun using the veri.co service. It was interesting how little my diet immediately affected my blood sugar. Non diet things were much bigger. Do hard exercise -> spike. Take a hot shower -> spike. Fast for 48 hours -> blood sugar still rises in the morning. Walking was by far the most effective way to keep blood sugar down after a meal. Most of what I ate didn't cause a problem. However tend avoid sugar and carbs. The worst offender was a PB&J sandwich. That was surprising.
- eep_social 3y ago> hot shower -> spike Assuming this was a Libre, this is likely reader inaccuracy that does not reflect an actual blood glucose event.
- briandw 3y agoThat makes sense and I was wondering if it might be related to the device temp. I should have tried putting a hot pack on the sensor to validate.
- int_19h 3y agoBoth peanut butter and jelly have lots of sugar in them. Modern supermarket bread (in US) usually does, as well, and the carbs in it also turn into sugar quite readily right in your mouth.
- jesprenj 3y agoFor having participated in a study, they installed an Abott FreeStyle Libre 2 sensor on me for 14 days. I could get minute readings, which is not possible with either the hardware reader nor the official app, using the almost entirely FOSS android app Juggluco. Another FOSS web tool is Nightscout -- it generates reports and live graphs from data gathered from your CGM via for example Juggluco. My instance is at http://sladkor.4a.si http://sladkor.4a.si. My sensor expired, so there's no more live data. glucometerutils is an interesting repo for downloading stored data from hardware readers etc. Abott encrypted the Libre 2 USB communication to force users to use their proprietary software, but hackers managed to extract keys. http://juggluco.nl http://juggluco.nl http://nightscout.github.io http://nightscout.github.io https://github.com/glucometers-tech/glucometerutils https://github.com/glucometers-tech/glucometerutils http://ni.4a.si./anonymous/freestyle-keys/tree/freestyle_keys/libre2.py http://ni.4a.si./anonymous/freestyle-keys/tree/freestyle_key...
- 99112000 3y agoI got some FreeStyle Abotts for anyone who wants to hack away at them. Rumor has it Dexcom is cheaper in bulk than Abotts and they are losing hospitals as customers.
- davidthewatson 3y agoI'm happy for those who have been helped by these devices. The FDA approval is only a revelation to the extent that the hidden truth of the extant prescription CGM market is poor data veracity combined with high catastrophic failure of the devices under manufacturer warranty in some patients. It's difficult to know for sure the size of the patient cohort impacted here since these numbers are not made public. If the market functioned transparently, this knowledge would be of great benefit to consumers. Given the proprietary nature of these organizations, and the fact that they spend lots of money on lobbyists and lawyers to maintain the status quo, I'm not expecting this to get better, at least in the United States. This leaves the hope that the EU or elsewhere may be more aggressive in regulation, as they have demonstrated recently around Apple and Google. LSS: there's a ton of room for competition, cooperation, and innovation in CGM's and their slowly evolving ecosystem of software, smart phones, and smart watches, particularly in open source where hacks frequently work around the proprietary limitations in software, i.e. information devices that have little to do with telling time save for putting a date/time stamp on their event stream which is nowhere near the 5 V's of big data in volume, velocity, or veracity. The two leaders in the space, Dexcom and Abbott both fail at a high rate with some individuals, such as me. Turns out that at the edges, adipose tissue and its interstitial fluid are a poor proxy to plasma blood glucose in some individuals. This is likely due to fluctuations in the composition of that tissue during times of fasting: exercise and sleep. Sadly, the price of admission for my family has been high given that no one has slept normally for five years with the screeching alarms nightly at 3 AM, which are not adequately configurable. The design failure here is clearly driven by liability. It's worth considering that the brain's default mode network (DMN) is impacted by glycemia. This has been demonstrated via an fMRI lab at Harvard via Nicolas Bolo, et al using a small cohort of diabetics. The leap from there to what families of diabetics have known intuitively for decades may be phenomenological, but it isn't difficult. Put simply: diabetic mood swings may not give rise to psychosis, but the mood dynamics of glycemia have been clear for almost as long: a spectrum from hypomania or nightmares induced by hypoglycemia to hyper compulsivity or depression induced by hyperglycemia. I'm not certain that a researcher or clinician like Bolo exists to put data behind these glycemic mood associations, but speculatively, the relationship is clear to me from a subjective metacognition perspective, as someone who's been T1D for ~50 years and also has an HbA1c below the diagnostic threshold for T1D and routinely stays functional with accurate plasma BG < 50 and shows no signs of cognitive impairment accruing to these brain states after various neurology studies. It's worth noting that hypoglycemia itself is a dynamic range, not a constant, and is frequently lower for people who have eaten or trained on the ketogenic spectrum, i.e. ultra marathon runners like Zach Bitter. My experience has been that the feelings associated with hypoglycemia can be paradoxically awful at BG=80 and no problem at BG=40. If you've never eaten a half gallon of ice cream yourself with no signs of obesity, then you may not understand the zen state it takes to overcome this "beyond hunger" that's immediately familiar to any experienced diabetic on earth, while recognizing that that problem does not occur naturally with the disease. It's the result of insulin overdose, carbohydrate under-supply, or both. FWIW, Microdosing carbohydrate may be key. I believe the first use of the term in science was actually in glucagon, IIRC, i.e. the need for yet another syringe of glucagon in emergent insulin pumps that would go beyond the current crop of devices that are near autonomy, but may inadvertently overdose or underdose the patient due to the poor veracity of CGM sensors across the board and the hybrid closed loop devices which dose based on CGM which may be demonstrably inaccurate on occasion to the tune of several hundred points off high and low. I have n-of-1 empirical evidence of this given the fact that I wore several insulin pumps for twenty five years and used multiple CGMs over that time, some concurrently. All were what we call, "shipping the prototype". Fortunately, beyond Therac 25, that was not an option in other medical device markets; certainly not those under FDA oversight.
- henrikberggren 3y agoI've been wearing one for 6 years straight and wrote a post back in 2018 when I first got one. As someone who lives with Type 1 diabetes its been one of the absolute biggest game changers for my health https://blog.steady.health/the-wearable-that-changed-my-life-1a5b9bdbab22 https://blog.steady.health/the-wearable-that-changed-my-life... I also started a company focused on CGMs which was too early and didn't work. Maybe its time to try again? :)
- squirrel6 3y agoI have been doing CGM for 7 months now and the learning has been invaluable. My metrics were never in the danger zone but I feel like I’ve learned so much about how many different factors play into insulin resistance and have managed to build much healthier habits over time.
- patsplat 3y agoI just heard about a related device from a family member who is an endocrinologist. https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-clears-new-insulin-pump-and-algorithm-based-software-support-enhanced-automatic-insulin-delivery https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-clea... First off, he had discomfort with the study methodology. Didn't go into details, but was surprised that the FDA was less conservative than himself in this case. Secondly, it has been common in his practice for someone to have an unusual event. Someone does something out of the ordinary, they have an unusual circumstances, they don't adjust their treatment, and something goes wrong. His question was -- does the device have a reset button? Is there a way to restart the management and learning? The answer is no -- the device will learn! But there's no way for the patient or the physician to adjust the treatment. So his answer is -- he would never recommend this device, not the way it's currently setup. It's opaque and there's no means for a person to influence the device's learning.
- TylerE 3y agoThis is just monitoring, not a pump. There is no learning or tuning or dosing. If it’s anything like the Freestyle I wore for a while there’s a self calibration process that takes a couple hours, but that’s per-sensor, and those get changed out every two weeks.
- patsplat 3y agoYou are correct, I think he was talking about a different device: https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-clears-new-insulin-pump-and-algorithm-based-software-support-enhanced-automatic-insulin-delivery https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-clea...
- TylerE 3y agoI will point out the obvious tensions between these legitimate concerns and the usual HN "we demand full unfettered access to all the firmware knobs all the time" groupthink.
- 3y ago
- jablongo 3y agoThis is great news for the healthcare system because it is going to drive down costs for people with diabetes who really need these things. Well done Dexcom! This OTC model limits the measurements to every 15 mins instead of every 5 for the prescription version; this will limit its ability to be integrated into open source automated insulin delivery systems. Not sure why they made this choice as the hardware looks the same as the Dexcom G7. In theory they could be doing it to increase battery life or allow for cheaper batteries to be used in the consumer version.
- ijustlovemath 3y agoGlucose control is my particular area of expertise; if anyone has any questions about it, I'm happy to be a resource!
- arisbe__ 3y agoThis could lead to a large amount of helpful preliminary signals that eventually pan out into some new knowledge.
- nobrains 3y agoA family member uses Abott Freestyle libre 2 CGM and buys it OTC. In UAE.
- AbstractH24 3y agoFrom what I understand, the next step after this is a device that continuously measures ketones as well. Very interested in that
- anniversary 3y ago[dead]
- antirez 3y agoI'll be that guy to say that if you don't have a diabete problem, you don't need a CGM: here in Italy there is this crazy fashion of wearing one if you are into sports or alike. It's much better to eat clean, check your weight, and don't care about your physiological parameters all the times.
- maxehmookau 3y agoI'm gonna go against the grain here and say that I tried a CGM for a few months and found it fairly unhelpful. (I'm not diabetic.) Yeah, eating stuff that's bad for me caused a blood sugar spike and made me feel crummy. Eating healthier foods did not cause the same spike and I felt better. I didn't need to spend money to tell me that.
- komposit 3y agoMy son was diagnosed with diabetes about 4 weeks ago. The first two weeks we were measuring him through fingersticks multiple times daily. Now we have the cgm it has become so much easier to manage his condition. The interesting thing to observe is to see in real time the metabolic spectrum of the foods we consume. Liquid sugars cause glucose spikes within 6 minutes. Solid carbs 30-120 minutes depending on carb complexity etc. Proteins 3h+. Fats can be six hours or more. The thing is there are a variety of insulins available, some of which are rapid acting and others act more slowly. So to keep my son in range with multiple daily injections you are playing this game of giving him the right mix of foods where his carb digestion matches the profile of his rapid acting insulin. Pizza is an interesting case study. It is by far the most carb rich deal we've tried and it is almost impossible to manage. With so many carbs it's hard to get the insulin dosage right, and once he is high, once he is coming down from that the digestion of the fats kicks in and he remains high through the night. I think it would be a great thing for people to wear even just for a couple of weeks.
- phasetransition 3y agoMy 3 year old has type 1, and CGM has kept us out of the ER for surprise lows multiple times. It also has informed family diet change, in the direction of keto practices, that has compressed the baseline to high delta for our son. It's a relief to know that an OTC product exists as a backstop to our prescription CGMs.
- rapnie 3y agoThis article reminded me of a recent item on Dutch national news, about an artificial pancreas device for diabetis type 1 sufferers. https://www.dutchnews.nl/2024/03/artificial-pancreas-offers-hope-to-type-1-diabetes-sufferers/ https://www.dutchnews.nl/2024/03/artificial-pancreas-offers-...
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoSome of us can't be trusted with continuous stat reporting. I hit Update on HN often enough. I don't even wear a watch, I kept looking at it every twenty seconds and then realized I still didn't know what time it was, it was just a reflex. I learned to leave my phone someplace else, upstairs, wherever, just check it a couple times a day. Else I'd go crazy. I took the speedometer off my bike, I was looking at it more than the road. So I understand my limits and take steps to keep my self from compulsive behaviors. I guess(?) other people do better and can handle these things.