8 ms·
BlackCat ransomware group implodes after apparent payment by Change Healthcare
- 0x53 3y agoI should be against the law to pay a ransom for data.
- bluGill 3y agoI'll make an exception for payments with tracable money made on behalf of the fbi.
- bluGill 3y agoOr better yet pay to Ukraine who is at war with the governments allowing this.
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- _yb2s 3y agoI would agree, except I don’t think it would keep people from paying regardless.
- sam_bristow 3y agoYou'd end up with a bunch of shady "data recovery" firms that may or may not be related to the ransomware crews.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoRansomware becomes a death sentence to the business if this were to apply, which the US has no appetite for. We even let critical infra out from improving their cybersecurity [1] [2] [3], because it is expensive and hard. The asymmetry of cybersecurity makes effective defense challenging for even the most resourced orgs [4]. You have to win every single day, against social, phishing, auth/identity, and vulnerability attacks throughout the stack. They only need to win once. (head of infosec, holds tabletop exercises with legal counsel on a cadence as part of ransomware insurance requirements) [1] https://www.cybersecuritydive.com/news/epa-rescinds-cybersecurity-water-system/696744/ https://www.cybersecuritydive.com/news/epa-rescinds-cybersec... [2] https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2023-10/action-memo_rescinding-cyber-memo_october-2023.pdf https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2023-10/action-me... [3] https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2023-08/2023.08.03%20%20Missouri%20%20Petition%20for%20review%20%208th%20Cir.pdf https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2023-08/2023.08.0... [4] https://arstechnica.com/security/2023/09/hack-of-a-microsoft-corporate-account-led-to-azure-breach-by-chinese-hackers/ https://arstechnica.com/security/2023/09/hack-of-a-microsoft...
- TedDoesntTalk 3y ago“We do not negotiate with terrorists.” - Richard Nixon Does it work? Depends on who you ask. https://www.chathamhouse.org/2022/01/we-do-not-negotiate-terrorists-why https://www.chathamhouse.org/2022/01/we-do-not-negotiate-ter... says that individuals (in the case of corporate ransomware - corporate entities) end up paying and not reporting the kidnapping: “Historical evidence from Colombia and Italy shows that outlawing ransom payment has various adverse consequences. Where ransom payments are illegal, victims’ families have no state support, while reporting of the kidnapping goes down and understanding of its prevalence is diminished.”
- jstarfish 3y agoIt's a crime in Japan to pay protection money to Yakuza. It seems to be working. They are a shadow of their former selves. You can mitigate adverse consequences. Punishments for child kidnapping used to be severe, but then abductors would just kill the hostage since they had little more to lose. Today's sentences are next to nothing to encourage surrender.
- ryandrake 3y agoDoesn’t the existence of a ransom “out” put a cap on how much money/seriousness a company willingly puts into infosec? Why would a company invest $22M into security if they can just pay criminals when they get owned? If ransom was off the table, maybe they’d be motivated to actually secure their data? I don’t know—I’m not in infosec. It’s probably not that simple.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoCorrect. You calibrate your budget to your risk appetite (board/C-level tolerance, industry specific compliance requirements, civil considerations, etc). Every company puts a budget on how much they're willing to spend, as resources are finite. Even the US DoD has a budget, there are limits. We risk accept what we deem within our risk tolerance, or too expensive to derisk. I think on HN, there is this belief that you can use incentives to force organizations to have perfect security, which does not exist. Employees are human, people make mistakes, budgets constrain staffing as well as control implementations and operations; there are simply limits to what you can do. You can use policy and incentives to encourage good/best behavior, but failures will still occur. The goal is attempts at desired outcomes, measuring those outcomes, and iterating; not 100% success (as that is impossible).
- anon373839 3y agoPolicy is quite far from that: ransoms are even tax deductible.
- bklyn11201 3y agoAre there no legal consequences for knowingly paying money to a known criminal group based in Russia? What about the existing OFAC sanctions?
- sidewndr46 3y agoI don't really think companies do KYC on ransomware groups. The government just does not prosecute it.
- petre 3y agoHiring bounty hunters to hunt down the perpetrators should also be tax deductible then.
- famahar 3y agoThe stories I've read about these ransomware companies are wild. They have whole customer service departments to help you easily pay your ransom. They operate like a legit business.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- foxylad 3y agoOr simply make exchanging bitcoin for anything of value illegal. It makes extortion of all kinds too easy, and company data is just the tip of the iceberg. I was in Italy recently, and saw articles about the epidemic of kidnappings there in the 70s. It won't be long before organised crime figures out how to use crypto to bring back the glory days. Killing bitcoin would shut down an enormous illegal economy overnight. And stop the crazy electricity consumption at the same time. Maybe you can help me here, but I'm having difficulty thinking of a single real downside.
- tradertef 3y agoOh yeah.. there were no ransom business before Bitcoin.
- yonaguska 3y ago> shut down an enormous illegal economy overnight. Despite not owning any Bitcoin, I find it quite comforting to know that there is a currency that exists outside of the purview of a central bank or a government that can devalue or outright take the accruement of my labor on a whim.
- Zenul_Abidin 3y agoThen what's stopping the criminals from going back to good ol' wire fraud like in the 90s and 2000s? PS. All of the smart ransomware groups are not demanding payments with Bitcoin anymore, they are using another cryptocurrency called Monero. It turns out that Bitcoin is actually traceable by governments via its public ledger, but Monero is a private currency that can't be traced, hence why the IRS posted bounties some time back to encourage people to break Monero's obfuscation. The only gangs that are still demanding Bitcoin are the less-educated and savvy ones.
- tasuki 3y agoCan't they receive the money in Bitcoin and then run it through Monero to "clean" it?
- literallycancer 3y ago
- deathanatos 3y ago> Dmitry Smilyanets, a researcher for the security firm Recorded Future, said BlackCat’s exit scam was especially dangerous because the affiliate still has all the stolen data, and could still demand additional payment or leak the information on his own. It is wrong to put temptation in the path of any nation, For fear they should succumb and go astray; So when you are requested to pay up or be molested, You will find it better policy to say:— "We never pay any-one Dane-geld, No matter how trifling the cost; For the end of that game is oppression and shame, And the nation that plays it is lost!" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dane-geld_(poem) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dane-geld_(poem) & https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danegeld https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danegeld … now imagine if they'd put that $22M — an amount that would fund my entire team for the remainder of our lives — into engineers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- iamleppert 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- robomartin 3y ago[flagged]
- duxup 3y agoSomething about not caring about sick people getting hurt sets me off too. Same response for scammers targeting old people.
- brickteacup 3y agoI agree. Actually everyone I don't like should be classified as a terrorist and denied any sort of due process or civil rights. It's fine as long as we only do it to really really bad people who make us very very mad.
- neilv 3y agoAlso, based on this Krebs bit, sounds like attacking a medical organization wasn't just a fluke -- they'd declared open season: > The ransomware group also declared it was formally removing any restrictions or discouragement against targeting hospitals and healthcare providers.
- deathanatos 3y agoI think there's a point you could make here without the "caveman mode". I agree that attacking healthcare infra is serious, and that human lives could suffer as a result. But, it seems like people believe the hacking groups here are based in Russia[1][2]. "send[ing] SEAL teams to hunt them down" sounds like a quick ticket to WWIII. I'd rather lean on organizations to secure their infra. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIN7 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIN7 [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DarkSide_(hacker_group) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DarkSide_(hacker_group)
- ls612 3y agoWell sending seal teams might be extreme but I’m sure in Russia there are ways to let criminal elements know that they could receive a hefty payday if certain individuals are found dead. And that the CIA is capable of determining these ways and using them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dralley 3y agoIt's a funny story, but I don't know that we'd be able to verify the difference between this story and "Russian hackers infect healthcare network, take money, make up a funny story for deniability and then wreak havoc on critical US services anyway, secretly get medals from Putin" These kinds of organizations sit always somewhere on a blurry line between "state-tolerated" and "state-affiliated" in the first place. Given current geopolitical circumstances it wouldn't surprise me if they've been given a green light to hit more significant targets.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lionkor 3y agoThis seems pretty far fetched, there are way too many governments who would like some extra cash, and way too many normal people who would like some extra cash.
- ckdarby 3y agoNot far fetch at all. Governments already get individuals into large corporations to steal IP.
- endisneigh 3y agoWhat's the simplest way to prevent this from happening these days? Daily Backups off site?
- jeffmcjunkin 3y agoThat helps with "we've encrypted your data; pay us for the key" but doesn't help you with "we've made copies of your patient records, leadership's emails; pay us or we publish it all". The phrase to describe this is double extortion. As for your question, https://www.cisa.gov/stopransomware https://www.cisa.gov/stopransomware is a decent start, but it's a complicated issue. In short, if a pentester can get inside your environment and gain privileges, so can an attacker. You want to slow down attackers enough to buy time for detection and response capabilities.
- endisneigh 3y agoHm - is the expectation that this stuff isn't encrypted at rest?
- adolph 3y agoSince the user's eyeballs don't have builtin decryption there is a window of opportunity to steal information after encrypted at rest and encrypted transport. Hopefully vendors will be able to fix this defect by using Neuralink.
- Aeolun 3y agoIf it’s at rest encrypted you generally do not manage to get 4TB of data before anyone notices.
- blincoln 3y agoI think you'd be surprised. How many organizations have their "encrypted at rest" data in a cloud provider account that's set up to give all developers (or at least all production support engineers) access to decrypt the data, maybe even transparently? How many have the "encrypted at rest" data on servers that are set up to give all administrators transparent access to the data? How many only allow application service accounts access to decrypt the data directly, but the credentials for those service accounts are stored as Kubernetes secrets that anyone in IT can read? Etc.
- fddrdplktrew 3y agoFirst time I hear of something like this happening... quite surprising.
- autoexec 3y agoIt was always a bad idea to pay ransomware groups, but I'm surprised they'd eat their own. I guess "There is no honor among thieves" after all.
- QuiDortDine 3y agoBad idea to guarantee the improbable (deleting their own copies), a valid choice for a one-time result (unlocking your data on your device).
- autoexec 3y agoThat's typically what backups are for. No business should be so negligent as to ever need to pay a ransomware group in order to get their own data back.
- nonethewiser 3y agoBut if they are, it may make sense to pay. For the company. Not from a more macro view.
- autoexec 3y agoThat I can agree with. If the company has already screwed up so badly they're stuck paying the price and hoping for the best.
- pants2 3y agoIt may also be about not wanting their data to be made public.
- danlugo92 3y agoYeah...
- irjustin 3y agoIn this case I would include "getting their systems back online"
- xoa 3y agoSo Kreb's comments and a bunch of others so far talk about "don't trust criminals" and "no honor amongst thieves" etc, but putting aside the atrocious moral angle musing on this a bit I think there's a broader point that applies to legal communities as well, which might be something along the lines of: >Beware the change from an ITERATED prisoner's dilemma game to a SINGLE game. Or perhaps alternatively to remember the difference between a "salary" and an "exit". Particularly when there is a long history of iteration people have gotten used to. The interesting HN discussion that comes most immediately to mind was last year's implosion of Silicon Valley Bank and the Stratechery article [0] about it. Classic game theory points to major differences in any ecosystem where the players are playing iterated vs single games. Iterated games encourage thinking about the longer term health of the overall ecosystem, not burning bridges, etc. The optimal strategy isn't pure defection but more cooperate+punishment. However, the ransomware ecosystem, like the startup ecosystem, seems to have followed an arc from small to large where the amounts of money start to pass an inflection point where they hit "set for life with a single payday" amounts. Ie, groups can chase "unicorns", hit one, and then at least from a pure economic standpoint potentially burn all bridges and reputation and be done forever. That in turn pushes towards short term thinking and extracting maximum value as fast as possible even at the cost of future returns. It being a black market certainly accelerates this further, because a lot of traditional controls to help push more towards iteration (from information symmetry to flat out physically coercive criminal punishment). But at least in terms of idle hot take contemplation, it seems to me there are parallels in a lot of different industries through history. So yeah don't pay ransomware anyway due to it funding a host of evils, encouraging more, governments should punish companies that do etc. But from a pure cold realpolitik standpoint it's perhaps also worth thinking about what the person on the other side can do afterwards. If a company is effectively paying them a "salary" class money, as if it was a $1000/hour pen tester, so a 100 hours of work attack is $100k, they may be more likely to be treating it as a "job" where they'll be doing it again and again. Which is bad here, but also perhaps more reliable, they have reputational skin in the game and an interest in the "health of the ransom ecosystem". But if the company is paying them "founder exit" class money, tens of millions of dollars, the odds of someone being ready to take the money and run, and having the amounts needed to make that possibly work, are probably going to be higher? Anyway just interesting to think about a bit. ---- 0: https://stratechery.com/2023/the-death-of-silicon-valley-bank/ https://stratechery.com/2023/the-death-of-silicon-valley-ban...
- yieldcrv 3y agoIts crazy that Ramp doesn’t offer or require escrow it is very easy to do this with crypto and much cheaper than payment processor or attorney solutions and you can do it with any money source lol
- ak217 3y agoPaying ransoms to ransomware groups needs to be made illegal and prosecuted under the RICO regime.
- blackoil 3y agoTry visualising that on individual level, someone points a gun and person gives up his wallet. Police comes and arrests victim under RICO.
- rightbyte 3y agoThere is no threat of violence involved? At the very least it is participation in tax fraud to buy protection from a criminal IT-gang. I guess they don't pay VAT?
- boringuser2 3y agoWar-gaming this, what if it were legal to pay out bounties with the ransom amount as a war-chest to collect scalps of hacking groups, or damage their reputation or operation in some way? This tit for tat type response would seem to be more consistent with how governments respond to terrorism, so I'm assuming it would be better to deter future hacks.
- jstarfish 3y agoAttribution is easily deflected. You really don't want to recruit mercenary vigilantes to respond to a false flag operation. > This tit for tat type response would seem to be more consistent with how governments respond to terrorism Lol. Not a selling point these days. The US has always had a very strange policy of criminalizing hacking, regardless of intent. Places like Russia and Israel look the other way as long as the target is foreign, and we outsource our own phone forensics to the latter (Cellebrite). Thus, Israel has a better understanding of our own vulnerabilities than we do. So you never know who you're up against given some ambiguous heuristics. As retribution, you might end up inadvertently attacking an "ally." It's safest to keep us disadvantaged.
- loandbehold 3y ago[flagged]
- lmm 3y agoHow do you suggest we do this in practice? Decent countries already make it illegal to buy cryptocurrency for real money, but it's difficult to enforce when it's a mutually profitable transaction for somewhat desperate people (just as in many cases paying a ransom to a kidnapper is illegal, but that doesn't completely stop it happening).
- jimbob45 3y agoIf you can shrink the marketplace of US crypto holders with a simple ban from tens of millions of users down to a five-figure number, it becomes considerably easier to police.
- fragmede 3y agoYou're right, but "if" is doing a lot of work. We all know how well banning cocaine has worked, after all.
- AnonC 3y ago> Decent countries already make it illegal to buy cryptocurrency for real money, I don’t know if English is your first language or not. The use of the word “decent” here seems inappropriate and totally lacking justification or nuance.
- lmm 3y agoI don't know if English is your first language or not. The use of a condescending tone here seems inappropriate and totally lacking justification or nuance.
- hilux 3y agoDo you really believe that banning cryptocurrency would be "easy"?
- hannabaker 3y ago[dead]
- devmor 3y agoI generally do not think it is wise to pay out ransomeware payments but in this case I do not blame Change for doing so. The data involved could severely hurt millions of people if released and not having that data was actively hurting people - potentially putting their lives and health in danger by delaying access to medical care and prescriptions. (Full disclosure: I am an employee of a competitor to Change Healthcare)