11 ms·
Miso pays disputed $10k referral bonus to ex-engineer, apologizes
- aheilbut 15y agoI'd never heard of Miso before this; everybody is a winner here.
- igorsyl 15y ago+1 for paying up -1 for calling it a mistake
- throwway 15y agoAs someone who has friends at Miso, and who was considering applying there: I think its a little too late. For anyone seeking employment, the people you work with day to day is one of the most important things, and this episode doesn't really show the best side of its founders character.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 15y agoMoving forward, we have established the following clear criteria to explain how employees will be eligible for the $10K referral bonus: - The employee must provide a referral for a full-time hire. - The referred employee must work at Miso for 6 full months after hire date (excluding any leaves of absence) - The referring employee must be employed at Miso and not have given notice to depart the company prior to the date of the bonus payment. I don't understand the point of the third rule. Why isn't that 6 months too? This way they have an incentive to delay payment if they think an employee might leave.
- weixiyen 15y agoPerhaps he is trying to suggest that Joshua gave notice before his 6 months were up, therefore shift the blame back to the ex-employee. Or maybe I'm reading too much into it.
- nknight 15y agoThat's exactly what he's trying to do. This isn't an apology or an admission of any wrongdoing, it's an obvious attempt to reshape perception of their original actions by pretending their motives were different than they really were. Motives that were utterly self-evident from their very first reply: > After you lost our data and caused our entire company to scramble for 3 days, I am hesitant. Everything since then has been trying to unring the bell.
- ericd 15y agoIf he cost the company 10k in lost engineering time with his mistake, it's only natural that they'd feel hesitant, even if they legally owe him.
- greenyoda 15y agoThe third rule sucks, in my opinion. Referral bonuses are a good deal for the company: they help the company to (1) recruit good employees and (2) save money on recruiting, since these bonuses are usually much less than the hefty fraction of an employee's salary that they'd have to pay to a headhunter. If you leave a company after referring somebody, it doesn't change the fact that you found the company a good employee and saved them money, so it would seem unfair to refuse to pay you the bonus, even if you're no longer an employee -- in that case, they'd be able to profit from your connections without giving you anything in return. They wouldn't be able to get away with not paying a headhunter just because he sent his invoice in after the company decided to not renew their contract with him. The fact that they can legally get away with stiffing an ex-employee doesn't make it any more ethical.
- nknight 15y agoThe "after you gave notice" part in particular is quite stupid. It will simply encourage people to wait longer to give notice, or not give notice at all. Were I leaving a company amicably and had no other constraint on my time (say I'm planning to start my own company, or even just take a couple years off), I'd give several weeks, if not a few months' notice, to maximize flexibility for everyone. If I knew it was going to screw me out of $10,000, however, I definitely would not extend that courtesy.
- jvdh 15y agoHow about you sign up someone for your own job? I'm not sure whether this should be rewarded or not, but it seems a situation that he's alluding to in that rule.
- E14n 15y agoThis benefit scheme appears to be designed to encourage team building. The cost of replacing a good employee is greater then the benefit gained from introducing a new hire. I guess they don't want to reward someone for team building when they are actually a net loss in this area. I think they should have read this[1] and thought about this a bit more. 1. http://blog.fogcreek.com/why-do-we-pay-sales-commissions/ http://blog.fogcreek.com/why-do-we-pay-sales-commissions/
- antoinevg 15y agoThe point of the third rule is to alert their investors that they're making sure that any people who leave will not be part of the process to hire their replacements.
- pyre 15y agoThat doesn't make any sense. The rule says 'prior to payment' and the payment doesn't happen until after the new hire is there for 6 months. So if I recommend a friend, then leave 5 months later, I don't get the bonus. How does this mean that I am hiring my replacement?
- jahewson 15y agoThe thing about contracts is that you can't just put any old unfair term in there, because both parties have the right to a fair contract, and a court can rule that particular terms are unfair. I wouldn't be surprised if there is some employment law which is being broken by that 3rd term already, because it allows the company to withhold the bonus for an arbitrary amount of time: they could avoid ever having to pay it by simply waiting until an employee gives notice, then saying "oh we can't pay that anymore" - no way is that a fair term. These guys are cowboys.
- eric-hu 15y agoWhat I learned earlier this year is that tech recruiters get paid a flat fee for their services, plus a percentage of the recruitee's salary after some vesting period, usually 6 months. From what I heard, that percentage was between 15-25 percent. Consider that the average programmer's salary is above 60k. 15% of that is 9k, plus the flat fee. The company has already gotten roughly 10k out of this referral transaction. It's not just an incentive to build a strong team...it's how much they'd have to pay if there were no employee referral program at all.
- bricestacey 15y agoI think your numbers might be conservative. 60k is a low intro-level salary for most metro areas and many recruiters wouldn't bother. Finding intro-level programmers is relatively easy so the burden of proof and stakes are high for the recruiter. It's a gamble and generally not worth his or her reputation.
- eric-hu 15y agoI was indeed choosing a conservative number so there wouldn't be much of a counterargument about the 10k value aspect. My point was mainly that 10k for a 6 month vested tech hire is something other tech companies pay to non employees.
- andrewcooke 15y agothe third rule is there so that they can say that they were right to not pay this guy. that's all. they don't think they've done wrong here. in the same situation they want to be able to do the same and get away with it. these aren't people who have learnt something about keeping their word - they're paying because it's the best way to manage the crisis. the third rule is to justify their actions: they don't feel wrong; they regret that they were caught without a good excuse. they have come out of this looking appalling. worst of all, they don't get the idea that people - good, committed engineers - don't stay or leave because of salaries and bonuses. they leave because management sucks.
- ChristianMarks 15y agoThey asked themselves what almost every businessman asks himself: "what is it going to cost me not to write this check?" They didn't expect their former employee to go to the Internet. They were exposing themselves to ever increasing liability by publicly posting in their former employee's blog. The cost in legal fees and additional negative publicity wasn't worth it to them not to pay after that.
- silentscope 15y agoThey were both wrong. Any employee who leaves 10k behind didn't care enough about it in the first place. The fact that he forgot is huge. A company that talks about bonuses of that size with no legal contract didn't care enough about it to start with. The developer will pay with his reputation. Any employer who knows what happened will never fully trust him, except after a long working relationship. Miso will pay by losing potential hires. Each side loses more than 10,000 dollars worth. Justin's professional rep is worth a lot more than 10k, Miso's hiring future is worth more than one bonus. They should have worked this out in private. They couldn't, and they both lost.
- veemjeem 15y agoI think Joshua's rep broke even, or possibly slightly ahead. It shows that he's a passionate employee, and will go out of his way to make things right. In a work setting, he'll probably fix up that copy-pasta code instead of just leaving it there. Passionate employees always win over passive employees. Additionally, his name is so damn generic, it might as well be john lee. There might be 10 serial killers with his name too, but I doubt future employers would really be able pinpoint this incident with his name.
- dkokelley 15y agoI doubt that. What you perceive as passion, I perceived as whiny. Whiny as in how a 4 year old REALLY wants a toy when his parents won't buy it for him. Is a child throwing a tantrum passionate about that toy? Is that a good thing? Will this potential employee throw a fit when we don't use the libraries he wants? Probably not (like I would assume of most professionals), but this new found infamy would make me as a recruiting company think twice. I think the situation could and should have been resolved in private. I know there are more clarifying emails, but we don't get to see them. If I were considering hiring this guy, I would be much more comfortable if I could see all of the emails with each side clearly stating their case, and then the developer's calm and rational ultimatum to go to the public. Even then, I would (as a potential employer) be even more comforted if the post itself had a calm and rational voice. (I believe the voice is mixed at best.) I base my claim that this could have been resolved in private on the fact that Miso resolved everything so quickly. If the case and ultimatum were clearly communicated, Miso would have been prepared for the negative PR by releasing their version of events. Instead, the company payed up not even 12 hours after the story is published. This leads me to believe that communication was poor between the parties.
- c0mpute 15y agoAs I see it, they just patched up the situation. My beef with them is not that they screwed up on the policy front. It is about the underlying ethics. It was ok if they said they did not want to pay him as he is no longer and employee and later correct themselves saying that it was a mistake on their part as he was an employee after 6 months. What is not ok is that they used an emotional line of defense. Saying he doesn't deserve it 'cos of a screw up, tells me that both Somrat and Tim are kinda characters that would bail out when push comes to shove. Its the question of integrity and you just have to stand by the right in a startup. To me, this is the exact warning sign I need before thinking of a startup. I hope employees of Miso read into this and take home something. Many might not care, but its their opinion.
- veemjeem 15y agoIt's also the type of founder that would dilute the employee options pool first, before touching their own. "it's okay to screw employees because they'll leave anyway"
- rdl 15y agoFucking with employee options pool is about whether previous investors (including founders and earlier employees) take all the dilution of new hires, vs. the new investors sharing equally in that. It's fairly independent of how much equity hires actually receive (you can always bump the pool up later, when you "unexpectedly" run out of equity and need to make more hires -- after 30-50 hires, the only way an individual hire makes a huge difference in the option pool is if you're bringing in a CEO to replace a founder, or maybe a Sheryl-level COO or super-accomplished VP.) It's an unrelated issue, really. I think "founder has one type of expense policy for founders and execs, and another for employees" would be more apt.
- speg 15y agoScorn have no fury like an angry Internet.
- xtiy 15y agoMiso was 100% in the wrong. Small claims and labor board actions would have cost them far more than 10k.
- heretohelp 15y ago10k isn't small claims in any jurisdiction I'm aware of.
- waiwai933 15y ago"In general, a natural person (an individual) cannot ask for more than $10,000 in a claim." From http://www.courts.ca.gov/1256.htm http://www.courts.ca.gov/1256.htm, which is the small claims court which would have jurisdiction over this particular case.
- biot 15y agoHow about $25k? http://www.ag.gov.bc.ca/courts/small_claims/info/what_is.htm http://www.ag.gov.bc.ca/courts/small_claims/info/what_is.htm
- SeanDav 15y agoWell they did the right thing...eventually. Sad that they couldn't do it for the right reasons and had to be pushed.
- relaunched 15y agoI'm really glad Miso did the right thing. However, they should have done something extra, either monetary or otherwise. What's the tech equivalent of punitive damages?
- zobzu 15y agoAfter the public shaming (hey, that was WAY more efficient than a lawyer), they could at least have been honest. But hey that takes balls, moral standards, and uhm, probably either apologizing and quitting the company either saying "screw that guy we're not paying him because we don't like him". Of course, that's utopia. Obviously if they had either there would again, be no story, since they'd just have been honest to start with.
- lsb 15y agoBad karma. People get hesitant to work at your company if you don't pay your employees, so you only get people who don't mind that risk.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- antidoh 15y agoNot working there.
- cncool 15y agoThey did not do the right thing. They only paid because they got caught, and paying was probably in their best interests financially going forward.
- spitfire 15y agoUtter crap. Rewriting history after you get called out is just pathetic. They owed him money and either through mistake or malice didn't pay him. When he contacted them to correct it they tried to legalize their way out of it. If I wouldn't have anything to do with them before, I'm doubly unimpressed now.
- weixiyen 15y agoThey are also legally bound to pay the referral bonus, unless they can provide evidence that they informed Joshua before he referred his buddy that there were any exceptions to the rule.
- xyzzyb 15y agoAgreed. There's a big difference between being sorry and being sorry you got caught. Miso management is sure coming off like the latter.
- rdl 15y agoThey paid him. They admitted they were wrong and apologized. They clarified their policy so people won't dispute it in the future. I'm not sure exactly what more you'd expect them to do. I'm sure they wish they'd handled this differently, but once he posted it, they seem to have handled things reasonably well. Plus, of course, you've only seen one side of the story. Even if the company has other facts, they can't present them publicly, because then they'd potentially be open to a lawsuit. Similar reasons why people don't give honest feedback after interviews, or referrals other than "yes, he worked at this company on those dates".
- jasonwatkinspdx 15y agoWhen they thought they had all the power, they saw no reason to pay him. Once it was clear that the power wasn't imbalanced, they went for damage control. That reads pretty transparently to anyone who's been around the block a few times. The loudest expression of your morals is what you do when you have all the power. If you act poorly, later rationalizations do little to convince anyone otherwise.
- ckdarby 15y agoThis comment was on the actual site & clearly outlines how sketchy this company is! I'm agreeing with the person above... This had nothing to do with your "company policy". It was clear in the 2nd email that you were trying to get away from paying $10k because your former employee dropped the database when there were no backups. If the unclear policy was the real reason, your email would have implied that.
- dlokshin 15y agoI'm not sure that the 10k was worth it for J Wu. Employers Google potential employees, and this blog post will definitely show up. Even though I feel he's in the right this type of public shaming would make me think twice about hiring him. Just doesn't seem like it's worth the hassle even though I don't plan on doing anything terrible to my employees (criminal in this case!) To be clear, I feel that Miso is in the wrong on this. Just probably wasn't worth 10k on calling them out. EDIT: From the comments it feels like the consensus is either a public shaming or hiding and forgetting about the money. There are other avenues like trying to pressure VC / board members, court, probably more. I wouldn't want this accessible on the internet for the next 50+ years.
- jsnk 15y agoYou are probably right. It's really not worth the trouble and potential backlash it might cause in the future. I personally wouldn't do it. However, I want to thank J Wu for doing this. What he did was commendable. I know tons of freelancers who worked with companies or individuals, and end up not getting paid properly. They often fear loss of potential customer and do not take it public, even though they are fully on the right. Legal battle is often not an option for them. The cost can be hefty and even more importantly, it's a total waste of time. Legal battle breaks concentration on your work and drains you out. I hope that this kind of dispute settling becomes normalized. Fulfilling one's responsibility is done most effectively when your accountability is tested publicly.
- ahelwer 15y agoJosh made a comment under the other story stating he would donate any money he gets to charity.
- lkrubner 15y agoPeople just now checking Hacker News might have missed the earlier conversation, so here is the URL: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3955391 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3955391
- javajosh 15y agoThe world has slowly become spineless, and when someone like Josh Hwu shows a spine and stands up for what's right a rather large fraction of fellow programmers jump on him. Shameful! The CEO of Miso is an unethical egotistical person who doesn't even have the self-awareness to admit to his knee-jerk abuse of power (a mistake that many a young manager has made, myself included). The real story here is that fighting on principle is the rational thing to do. If you don't fight on principle then the predators feel empowered, and everyone suffers. People like Josh are heroes. Those who try to take away from his accomplishment by either convincing him that it would be "smarter" to be spineless or that somehow it's wrong to have a spine, are even more despicable than Josh's abusive ex-boss.
- rogerjin 15y agoAgreed. One of the best comments I've seen on HN yet.
- javajosh 15y agoThanks! Felt good to write it. One concern that I have is that the Miso CEO (and people like him) will take away the wrong lesson, along the lines of "be careful what you say to employees in email". But the real lesson is that you should keep your promises, and if you have a moment of weakness and try to reneg on a promise, don't be proud: admit the mistake and keep the promise. People make mistakes, even twenty-something CEOs of tech startups (shocking, I know).
- rogerjin 15y agoI 100% agree with your concern, and that is the problem for it extends beyond tech startups to anyone in the world who have this mindset (of which there are many -- the ruthlessly, amorally, ambitious.)
- dkokelley 15y ago> The CEO of Miso is an unethical egotistical person who doesn't even have the self-awareness to admit to his knee-jerk abuse of power Unless you have information not available in the original post or reply, you're making that judgement off of a severely limited set of (largely one-sided) data.
- cypherpunks01 15y ago> The 10k I'll be getting will be going to charity to celebrate the integrity, compassion and passion demonstrated by the community at large. I want to especially thank the Hacker News community... As an award, Josh should let us decide the charity recipient..via HN poll!
- b094i2d0n 15y ago+1 to this!
- zalyh 15y agoThis article has only reiterated my belief that any deals that you make with your employer/client should be in writing so that they will not try to weasel their way out of an agreement. It got me thinking that for every developer who manages to get frontpage on HN about their employer's dishonesty, there are probably more out there who had been screwed the same way.
- v0cab 15y agoYup, it struck me how similar it was to my own situation, though in a non-tech job. I wish I'd handled it like this guy (the fired guy) handled it.
- djhomeless 15y agoSeriously, for all of us out there bootstrapping startups or working for companies struggling to raise funding, this all comes across as petty. $10k is a lot of money. I'm glad Josh is donating the money to charity, but the onus was on him to claim the bonus while he was employed.
- citricsquid 15y agoWas it? They had a policy of paying $10k if you refer someone that sticks with the company for 6 months. It was a payment. The onus is not on you to claim your wages is it? And if you forget you're not allowed them because "you should have told us!"?
- djhomeless 15y agoNo, it's a bonus, which has to be applied for. I take it from the CEO's comments that they were not clear about the T&C's, but my point was that for all of us working for under-funded companies or projects, it takes a lot of nerve to cry foul/name and shame, over a mutual mistake.
- timo614 15y agoYou can file claims with the department of labor for unpaid bonuses earned while working at a company. Anyhow he was still working at the company at the time he should have been paid so the money was owed to him and he could have filed (for likely at least the interest on the bonus if not wages up until it was paid). "Unpaid wages, including commissions and bonuses." http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/HowToFileWageClaim.htm http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/HowToFileWageClaim.htm Either way it's a moot point now.
- Dylan16807 15y agoI think I would feel dirty if I wound up saving $10k because someone I was going to pay it to forgot to do their paperwork for a month.
- peetahb 15y ago
- antr 15y agoHN front page 1 - 0 use of lawyers
- alan_cx 15y agoIt is almost worse that they paid up. The message I receive is that they will try to screw people over, but if to gets too hot they will pay up and desperately try to cover their butts. It shows them to be fundamentally dishonest at their core. Imagine being a customer. I wouldn't want to be one. I now know that if there is a problem it will be my fault, until they get too much bad publicity. Im glad the guy got his money, but it only makes the business look worse, IMHO.
- MortenK 15y agoThe engineer came off very combative and threatening from the start. After just 3 emails, he publishes a one sided case with the sole purpose of instigating an internet witch hunt. Based on such an aggressive attitude from the get-go, it seems likely there is significant history between Misu and the guy that we don't know about. Misu surely doesn't look good in this case, but neither does he. A lot of employers will think twice about hiring a guy who is so quick to publicize a disagreement.
- MortenK 15y agoWow, put down the pitchforks guys.
- jackfoxy 15y agoFirst, congratulations to Josh (who I do not know). Second, Josh: you took a Hell of a gamble (speaking as someone with practical experience on the hiring side). From now on you will have to find some subtle way to include the entire history of this situation in future job application processes. A hiring manager stumbling upon only the first part of this episode will likely not give you the opportunity to explain the whole story.
- eyko 15y agoAs someone who's mother tongue is one in which "anniversary" actually means anniversary, reading 6 month "anniversary" just kills me.
- lurchpop 15y agoA telltale sign of a bullshit apology are the words, "sorry we didn't make it clear." It's a bureaucratic way of saying, "The only thing I did wrong was fail to hold your sippy cup for you while I explained the rules."
- jpeg_hero 15y agoThe number one lesson I learned from this saga is: Do not hire Joshua Wu.
- officialchicken 15y agoMy number one: There are many more apologetic pro-corporation white knights here than I expected, and Miso is an organization to avoid.
- felideon 15y agoThis is all sorts of wrong. Miso should have paid the referral fee (let's stop calling it a bonus as another commenter pointed out) as soon as the referred employee hit 6 months. Why are employees forced to beg for their money? For most of us, it's awkward to have to go to 'the man' and ask for our money. So we procrastinate and 'forget' about asking for the money, all while working hard anyway. Switching jobs is an excellent time to have $10k handy. And for them to say "no sorry, you screwed up at the end" shows just how much they valued that employee's contribution to the team for an entire year. This reeks of Big Co. incompetent management mentality. Sad to see startup founders power tripping and not realize it.
- tocomment 15y agoDo you guys think this whole thing was maybe a publicity stunt? And if it wasn't would this be a good, free way to drum up some interest in your company; spread some geek drama?
- yashchandra 15y agoGood job Joshua. One thing for sure, I will never myself or suggest anyone else to work for Miso. It is simple. A job where you have long hours, mediocre pay but a great team/manager is a lot better than a good paying job with team/manager that are not looking out for you and will screw you at the first opportunity they get.
- jongraehl 15y ago> The 10k I'll be getting will be going to charity to celebrate the integrity, compassion and passion demonstrated by the community at large. So much for "damaging his reputation" (assuming he follows through). This gesture paints him as shaming Miso on principle, rather than for wanting $10k. The righteous indignation we feel when we're wronged, that makes us waste time trying to get the $20 rebate (or whatever) we should have received, is part of what holds society together. Punishing wrongdoers is almost always costly. Someone has to bear that cost.