9 ms·
The "End of Programming" will look a lot like programming (2023)
- Madmallard 3y agoSeeing this stuff is so mindboggling to me every time. I use GPT4 EXTENSIVELY and it actually sucks so bad for anything complex. How are these takes still coming out on repeat? I've been using it for a YEAR
- Culonavirus 3y ago- clueless people - hype - vested interests
- bitwize 3y ago20 years ago it was UML. Programmers were going to be replaced by generators that ingest UML specs and shit out Java code. 20 years before that it was CASE tools. Management has been searching for a way to eliminate us from the beginning. The "Software Crisis" of the 60s was simply the fact that programming was hard and businesses wanted software but didn't want to learn how to make it, or to depend on people who knew. This is why I'm distrustful of "imminent death of programming as a profession predicted",whether it be AI or low/no code tools, whatever. At the end of the day you have human desires that are not being met but could be fulfilled with some nonexistent software. To date only humans fully comprehend human desires, so it takes humans to bring that software into existence. If AI ever gets as good as us at coding, we need to give it personhood and full rights under the law. Either that, or scorch the sky.
- goatlover 3y agoMaybe the AIs will be less greedy and short sighted than human management. Also, I never understood why scorching the sky seemed like a good idea. Surely the Matrix machines were more likely to survive in a world without sunlight than humans, given we need food to eat.
- bitwize 3y agoHuman executives at least have families and local societies they care about. AI management will be total paperclip maximizers.
- KingOfCoders 3y agoThe end of programming will be no programming at all. First AIs will do the things that are necessary without someone telling them. If there are still companies, e.g. this means sending emails to customers (who have AIs that are reading their emails and acting on them ;-) to sell more things, create APIs or websites on their own, hire other people (AIs) to do things they can't do (regulation, other country, etc.). For the mid future, it's like Star Trek: "Computer give me the customers that perform best" - from a data lake, no data warehouse, no CRM code, no web frontend. No programmers, just users. For the near future, developers will become managers. Instead of hiring and managing people, they will select and manage different AIs for different tasks. See what those are doing, give them feedback (just like a manager would to developers), change the prompt (like a manager would clarify a task), give them data, grow them (again just like a people manager today).
- lelandbatey 3y agoSure, in the same way that we'll all stop driving cass and have self driving cars any day now. What you just described is more of a tech lead than a "manager", and that's really the point. Reality that's not encoded in pure language is a fundamental limit of LLMs; they're probably never going to correctly diagnose a hardware bug based on misbehaving software, for example, because that's a world where everything that they are (ingestion material, available documentation) and reality conflict and an LLM has very little ability to detect and overcome such a problem. Those "reality vs the text" impedance mismatches mean that LLMs are probably never going to escape human oversight. Which means we'll all probably have as many low quality (occasionally brilliant) fresh grads as we like, but taking the jobs of experts seems unlikely. The end of programming looks like lots of work for programmers.
- bongodongobob 3y agoWe have self driving cars.
- goatlover 3y agoSo why are people still driving cars? Why are there still Uber, delivery and truck drivers? 99.99% of vehicles are driven by humans. It's like saying we have flying cars. Sure, working prototypes have existed for some time now. There were (are?) companies making them. But it makes no real world difference. In the context of "no more programming", it makes no difference if some fancy AI model can in theory replace programmers, if they don't actually end up doing that on any real scale.
- ericmcer 3y agoWhy bother disputing claims about AI made by the CEO of a new AI startup. They are obviously going to be throwing lofty statements around about its capabilities.
- fragmede 3y agoI've been playing with open interpreter a bit, and to see a lot of the things I do that I take for granted written out in code made me realize how much handling of computers I take for granted. for example, I was editing files via open interpreter, and needed to add a header to some files. I, of course, got it wrong the first time and had to iterate on it a bit. As a human, editing the header is trivial, but for the computer to do it for me, it has to write a program to parse the file with a regexp of something, and while it manages to do that, its limitations become apparent, compared to a human. so the end of programming does look a lot like programming. the computer does what you tell it, not what you were thinking.
- kqr 3y agoThis seems like a long version of my favourite commitstrip: https://www.commitstrip.com/en/2016/08/25/a-very-comprehensive-and-precise-spec/ https://www.commitstrip.com/en/2016/08/25/a-very-comprehensi...
- Ma8ee 3y agoIt has been one of my favourites for a long time too. It quite much sums up why I’m not worried about no code, low code, or any of the current flavours of AI. The original fallacy seems to be the belief that what is hard with programming is to remember all that pesky syntax. If we didn’t need to do that, and instead could just tell the computer in plain English what we wanted, we could get rid of programmers all together. (And the fallacy isn’t new, see COBOL).
- lp4vn 3y agoWhat I find it funny about this LLM euphoria is that people seem to have forgotten the theoretical limits of what turing machines can do. Program equivalence, for instance, hits the wall of the halting problem. Yet somehow people think that it's just a matter of time before an AI that can solve the problem of giving you a mathematically equivalent code to an existing code.
- adamnemecek 3y ago> Program equivalence, for instance, hits the wall of the halting problem. Yet somehow people think that it's just a matter of time before an AI that can solve the problem of giving you a mathematically equivalent code to an existing code. This is a solved problem in the context of total programming.
- shubhamjain 3y agoThe article gave me a deja-vu about the no-code wave a few years back and an excellent article I read on the subject [1] > The logic doesn’t go away. Just because a decision is embedded into the wiring of a Zapier rule doesn’t remove any of the burden of maintenance / correctness. Of course, AI is a lot more powerful than no-code, but the "End of Programming" suffers from the same delusion. If AI can reliably make every decision around engineering, design, and product, it would be capable of doing every task in the world. It's surprising that so many engineers believe writing things in plain text would obviate the need to learn programming. [1]: https://www.alexhudson.com/2020/01/13/the-no-code-delusion/ https://www.alexhudson.com/2020/01/13/the-no-code-delusion/
- Buttons840 3y agoThe best and worst thing business owners could have is a nice graphical chart of all the business logic in its full glorious detail. No doubt they'll ask "hey, what's this huge blob? It's like a huge hairball or something?" to the last laid off programmer as they walk out the door.
- StimDeck 3y agoWe just need to train an LLM how to make an LLM that can make even better LLMs then rinse and repeat. Nothing beats working yourself out of a job.
- starbugs 3y agoWhat training data are you gonna use for that? That which comes out of an LLM? OK. Now you have a degrading loop of self-reinforcing falsehood.
- adamnemecek 3y agoMatt Welsh is an idiot, there saved you 5 mins reading the article.
- goatlover 3y agoI have a hard time believing that AI models will become the environments that software runs in, because they're not performant, reliable or maintainable the way Node, JVM, binaries, web browsers etc are. Or standards compliant. Nor do they have the same kind of access to the hardware these environments have. And short of software running directly on models, I don't see how programming is going to be completely automated away from humans. And even if you can make models competitive with traditional software environments, I don't forsee managers and CEOs spending their days prompting the AIs to produce the right kind of code their customers don't know they need. They will pay prompt programmers to do that instead.
- philipswood 3y agoAt the moment what the "end of programming" looks like in my experience is: * Better auto-complete for verbose languages, * A question/answer workflow significantly smoother than googling it, * A on tap rookie for 5-15 line pieces of code that don't matter much (it difficult to trust more because quality isn't great), * An awesome bash one-liner sidekick, And most of importantly * A consultable socrates-in-a-box "colleague" that is often useful, but needs to checked.
- p0w3n3d 3y agoI can't imagine explaining to the Socrates what I need from my bash one-liner, probably faster is to write it myself. Of course depends on complication level
- jart 3y agoI explain that to Google all the time and it just finds me someone on Stack Overflow who's figured it out already. Not to mention the dozens of other drive-by human reviewers that Stack Overflow offers. It's difficult to imagine AI improving on that. Unless it's like a Star Trek badge you talk to, and the LLM does the Google search for you and types the command into the terminal, because you're too lazy to pull out the keyboard.
- tarruda 3y ago> It's difficult to imagine AI improving on that It can be an improvement due to LLMs ability to quickly adapt any solutions to your specific use case. On Google you can search for CRUD web application examples and find tutorials but you will have to adapt to your specific scenatio. With LLMs ou can ask: "Write a CRUD web app using Next.js and postgres. I want the CRUD to manage entity A with fields x Tx, y, Ty..." and there's a good chance it will spit out a pretty good starting boilerplate.
- starbugs 3y ago> It can be an improvement due to LLMs ability to quickly adapt any solutions to your specific use case. My experience with that so far has been that, yes, that works quite well as long as the thing you ask is common and reasonably simple. The more uncommon and complex it gets, the less successful this tends to be. And in more uncommon cases, if it is successful in terms of the workability of the emitted code, it's often not clear if the approach taken is a good idea at all considering other aspects like maintainability. LLMs are notoriously bad at just saying "Hey dude, I don't really know what I am doing here, ok?" Also, I have often been able to trace their responses back directly to SO answers. Usually, there is not much "creativity" in their answers at all.
- stephc_int13 3y agoPredictions about a future technology that may exist at some point are almost always dumb. I don’t see programmers going away because of the current wave of AI, I don’t know about what is coming next, but for sure the current hype is very bubbly and also dumb.
- Tistel 3y agoIt will happen someday. Still decades away. No true learning in the current LLMs just plagiarism so far to get better. I work at a place that is trying to use LLM to do a thing. just hired two humans to double check the work. They now do almost all of the work ...
- danielbln 3y agoI concur that it will happen someday, but decades? C'mon.
- Workaccount2 3y agoGPT4 was decades away 2 years ago...
- ramblerman 3y agoand autonomous cars were just around the corner 10 years ago. The last 20% is really hard
- tarruda 3y agoThe last 20% is a blocker for autonomous cars because it can cause lives to be lost.
- ramblerman 3y agoSure, but not all programming is building webapps either. There are many high stakes environments, with real consequences. Additionally as the ball of mud grows, making slight but subtle changes to the system will get subsequently harder and harder to describe to the point where the tradeoff from using english is higher than flipping some code (imo).
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThe DARPA grand challenge that represented the thought that this was even possibly only happened in 2004 (29 years ago). I heard they even have autonomous taxis in SF now, which was more progress than I would have predicted 10 years ago. 10 years ago was when Siri and the other voice assistants came out right? I see a huge amount of progress between then and now, but these LLMs sort of snuck up on us in the last two years. I don’t think we are hitting an AI winter anytime soon.
- advael 3y agoI too have a lot of cool ideas that turn out to be much harder to make than to talk about. The very best case performance of code assistance tools as they currently exist seems to be that they moderately increase the productivity of developers who know what they want and know enough to check the autocompleted work. As a ML researcher who's watched the progress of both code generation and natural language processing for about 10 years in earnest, this is a crazy awesome result, a breakthrough in the field that's very laudable (except for all the shady data provenance sleight of hand that allowed the companies spearheading this effort to make progress, but that's been talked about by people who know a lot more about applicable law than I do and I won't do it justice, and it's tangential in a discussion of what's possible). But there is no result so impressive that business people in the midst of a tech hype wave won't apply some added bullshit to in order to fundraise, and "the end of programming" seems more like that than a realistic assessment of the capabilities of current systems, or even a plausible result of merely incremental progress on them
- gdcbe 3y agoImho programming is just a medium of reasoning. In that vein I find arguments like this odd. As I believe they day there is no more need for humans to be involved in any programme , is the day there is no more need for any reasoning by humans. Not something that seems likely to me. Then again this article comes from someone developing AIs… how could that not be lofty…
- sedatk 3y agoSoftware development requires certain qualities from a programmer which AI can't attain before becoming human: personality and consistency. Personality is shaped by lifelong experiences mostly irrelevant to programming itself. Personality dictates the experience you want for the users. To be able to do that, you need to know the users, you need to understand how a human thinks, functions, and understands things. Consistency is an artistic element shaped culturally. Again, you need to be exposed to cultural elements for a long time, and more importantly, develop an understanding of them. I think it's very hard to train AI on these two fronts, and that's why we'll be needing programmers for a long time. AI will keep doing the mundane tasks for us though, thankfully!
- dontupvoteme 3y agoHave you met most programmers or used much software? Consistency - This is what GPUs were made for, putting a bunch of 'effort' almost instantly into investigating any regression that any real SW dev would ignore because, life's way too damn busy.
- sedatk 3y agoGPUs can create consistent output, AIs can't.
- staunton 3y agoI don't know what you mean by consistency. What you call "personality" seems to roughly mean "predicting what humans like". That's what stuff like RLHF is for. It's also not some sort of ascension where the computer program suddenly "becomes human". It's a spectrum on which we can expect steady improvements (and still never need to call computer programs "human").
- sedatk 3y agoI meant a certain aspect of aesthetics by "consistency". When you explain your requirements to AI, you'll say "create a dialog box with two buttons" right? I mean that's how you'd communicate with a programmer, so, I should at least be capable of that. However, AI cannot guarantee you a consistent style for such a prompt because it has no understanding of the culture, something the programmer, the prompter, and the users share altogether, but not the AI. AI might have access to the vast amount of design training data, but it can't understand the reasoning behind the variety of those designs, and it can't come up with a similar design every time. It has no cultural affinity, therefore no ability to stick to cultural norms. So, in order to fill that gap, you need to become more specific with your prompt. And the more specific you get, the more your language becomes closer to a programming language, therefore contradicting the purpose of the AI in the first place. I'm sure we'll see improvements, but I find it very unlikely to have the same level of understanding without having the same level of cognition and experience as a human, hence my phrasing.
- wslh 3y agoI think it is obvious that most programming tasks will be replaced by frameworks or whatever we call it. It is not about AI but about zillions of developer reinventing the wheel and having a lof of redundancy. Once specific framework or tools is accepted (e.g. boilerplate generation) the need for more developers hours is decreased. If this is not happenning now is because there are few good crafted frameworms and/or creating them make a lot of development tools (e.g. Microsoft) irrelevant. There will always be problems that cannot be automated but they will ve minimal and very specific.
- tengbretson 3y agoThe havoc that ai will cause on education will likely, in the near term, make programmers even more sought after, not less.
- sohzm 3y agoYou mean that there will be a whole new way of educating people and that will need lots of programmers to develop it? Not fighting, just trying to understand what you meant
- smusamashah 3y agoSomeone I know worked for quite some time for an online ghost writing company. A big chunk of tasks that you get on that site is just student assignments. He isn't getting any work from the site since ChatGPT. I think this was what GP is talking about. Students are now using ChatGPT to make assignments. I am divided on will that create worse new programmers or will that create programmers who use ChatGPT for everything replacing the previous generation of entry coders who used stackoverflow for everything.
- pants2 3y agoFor a long time you've been able to just describe what you need to a dev shop in India and have your program built on the cheap. And yet, most companies don't do that...
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoWhat's the compound rate of improvement of dev shops in India?
- klysm 3y agoWho knows what they need and can describe it? I’ve yet to see that
- scott_w 3y agoI think that’s the point ;)
- pixelesque 3y agoIronically, one of the things I think playing around with LLMs like ChatGPT has got me to improve is being (sometimes overly) specific and clear in my requests to them...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DeathArrow 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- codethief 3y agoThe author's stance also used to be my stance for a long time. Then, earlier this week, I tried out AutoGPT/evo.ninja (which uses GPT-4 under the hood) and told it to "Write me a snake game in HTML, CSS and JavaScript" and, voilà, it wrote me a game that I could open in my browser and it worked perfectly out of the box. I also tried this with Tic Tac Toe – it didn't work at first due to a bug in the CSS but the agent was able to fix that bug in the second round. It knew the context, knew the files it had created in the first round, and knew what I was talking about when I said "the Xs and Os are not visible", etc. So, yes, program specs might still be needed in the beginning, when a piece of software gets written from scratch. But AI will often just fill in missing steps, and once the code has been written, the AI will simply iterate on it, and so the code will take on the role of the spec, just like it does nowadays. No need for the product manager to write detailed specs anymore. All in all, I think the second direction mentioned in the article (AI becoming a full-blown software developer) is a lot more likely than the author thinks.
- __loam 3y ago"I gave an LLM an extremely small programming task that is a common interview question in a widely used language and I'm shocked it got it right"
- codethief 3y ago> extremely small programming task Maybe, but what I was trying to get at was: If you grant an LLM access to your file system and to the internet (like evo.ninja does), it is already very powerful and can work independently. It will read in and analyze files, remember its original goal even in the middle of some subsubtask it is executing, will self-correct and iterate, et cetera, so context size and the quality of how it solves one-shot tasks are no longer the main limitation. Of course I am aware we are not "there" yet and I am sure an agent like evo.ninja will still struggle with large, unknown code bases in many cases. (Can't try it on our proprietary code, unfortunately.) But if the past year has taught me anything then it's to not underestimate the future.
- dontupvoteme 3y ago
- Animats 3y agoThe webcrap industry is mostly doing rather uniform things. That can be automated. Much of it already is. Small business sites are mostly machine generated already.
- BigJono 3y agoThe webcrap industry is crap because most of the people in it believe it can be automated lol. All the shittest most inefficient projects I've been on have been loaded to the gills with libraries, frameworks, dev tools and convoluted typescript wankery, all in the service of making things "easier" on the devs. Eventually once they've tinkered enough they get it to the point where it only takes a team of 20 devs 3 years to build a form. Success!
- zubairq 3y agoMost people who say to me that AI will replace programmers are people who haven't built and maintained a software system, and see programmers as interchangeable cogs in a machine. So the author explained in a good way many things that I have been thinking about how AI does not mean the end of programming.
- p0w3n3d 3y agoThe fear is not of being replaced at all, but of reductions which will happen inevitably
- Rexxar 3y agoI don't see how it will have more impact than compilers/libraries/internet that have already permitted to improve a lot individual productivity without significantly decreasing the demand for developers.
- joeybiden 3y ago[flagged]
- skydhash 3y agoDid they improve individual productivity or did they provide much more complexity by shifting the abstraction level? The more I code, the more I see we’re still solving the same core problem, sometimes with artificial constraints introduced by the choice of a platform. The web was seen as a hub of information, but now people has been trying to make it a computing hub, ignoring the already available computing platform we already have (the devices in front of us).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- starbugs 3y agoIn the long run, I am happy to be replaced by a machine if that’s how the people who work with me see me.
- roncesvalles 3y agoIMO the real value of AI for programming will be in helping you read code not write code. I want to hover over a function call and it can just tell me what it does like a comment blurb above the function should.
- dontupvoteme 3y agoIMO it's being (an army of_ automated software engineer hitmen to persecute any regressions, bugs or even potential bugs your project might run into so that 1. things manifest a lot less 2. you don't have to worry about maintenance I could see a proper structured LLM setup some day even resuscitating 'dead' software.
- spawarotti 3y agoCurrently some programmers, and with time more, have to write, integrate and debug LLMs, hence for the programming to end, other LLMs would have to be able to do so, too. LLMs successfully modifying other LLMs is, like, singularity. In other words, the moment programming ends is the same moment we all are going to die.
- skybrian 3y ago> One of my problems with GitHub Copilot (and similar systems) is that you still own the resulting code, and it does not provide any path to gaining confidence that it has given you a correct implementation, despite you owning the correctness of the code it generates I don’t really see the issue? You take ownership with code review and testing. It’s the same thing you would do if you copied an example that someone gave you and then modified it. The original author isn’t responsible. (If you don’t understand what the code does, throw it out and find something else.)
- konschubert 3y agoIt's like having infinite interns. Knowing when and when not to use interns is a skill in itself.
- anonzzzies 3y agoI fear the most for the hybrid, and that’s happening/coming fast as we speak; - programmers getting hired and selected by ‘ai’ (resume, interview) - programmers (their PRs) being checked/reviewed by ‘ai’ - kafkaesque standups where features/bugs are explained by ‘ai’ in a painful loop - tasks being cut into tiny tasks with time limits by ‘ai’ for human programmers where the ‘ai’ monitors and punishes/awards the human performance - parts of those tasks being written by the ‘ai’, resulting in alien code being pushed into the project - ‘ai’ being introduced willy-nilly because it’s cheaper (read; faster to market) than real computer science; why build a parser for formulas? Just put a llm! Why design a robust dsl? Just put a llm! - etc This is part of the reality now in places I see already and it will get worse. When LLMs get faster and cheaper, there will be no reason to not add LLMs everywhere and give them some sort of power.
- starbugs 3y ago> - kafkaesque standups where features/bugs are explained by ‘ai’ in a painful loop Could you elaborate on that one? It sounds "interesting".
- anonzzzies 3y agoOne of our clients uses jira with gpt4 turbo api assistants; one of the features is that when the ‘implementation team’ (mostly cheap offshore hires in this case) is doing ‘sprint planning’ or standups (in this company’s mismanaged version of agile), the right people are not there, they ‘talk’ to jira and the ai assistant to clear up stuff. From what I have seen, the tasks in jira are written out quite well and gpt does do a (much) better job at one shot ‘understanding’ of the tasks than the team does, however, when the questions go deeper or more technically specific (to their internal systems), it basically loops aka repeats itself every other answer. And so the team will make up something, which is generally not correct, and implement it. Then the next week it will be a bug instead of a feature (for instance) and explained in terms of what to fix instead what to build, which both ai and humans seem to be better at. However the initial ‘loop’ is a nightmare and very dehumanising imho.
- 3y ago
- febeling 3y ago„In general, a lot of the AI takes I see assert that AI will be able to assume the entire _responsibility_ for a given task for a person, and implicitly assume that the person’s _accountability_ for the task will just sort of…evaporate?“ This is a key insight.
- euroderf 3y agoEveryone agrees that catching errors in the design phase is far superior to catching them in implementation or testing phases. So why are requirements often mentioned only in passing ? Don't they deserve some intellectual TLC ? Writing good requirements is at least as challenging as writing good laws. And then, as the article suggests, an AI can kind of fill in the missing bits if it has good cultural context. There's many good tools now for formulating and managing requirements. Why do I not see papers about how LLMs benefit from them ?
- koonsolo 3y agoLet's face reality here: In the end, AI and robots will be able to do anything better than what we humans can do. That is the harsh reality that everyone will need to accept. What happens in the mean time will be unclear, but I think most of us still make the false assumption that LLM's are 'robots', while in fact it already became clear that emotional blackmail works on them. AI's might not be as rational and cold as we might expect. So in the end, I don't see how humans will be able to keep the upper hand on: - doing user interviews - analyzing user behaviors - optimizing business decisions - writing code - tracking down issues
- r0s 3y agoThe end of programming will be the end of code. Code exists solely for humans to interface with machine language. If code is involved at all in any solution, it's a concession to humans. An AI with the power to build software from some definition doesn't need to write code. Else it simply does not have the power to write software alone.
- fl0ki 3y agoWherever we have enough redundancy that we have to tell a tool to write out more code for us within certain parameters, is somewhere we have yet to create the right high-level abstractions. This remains a problem even after LLMs do some of the work for us. The whole point of making more expressive languages and APIs is that we should be able to solve large problems with only the required amount of specificity in each instance, leaving only the code that is the right level of detail for someone to be able to read, understand, and maintain in future. In the ideal extreme, it shouldn't be any more difficult or tedious to write the code to solve a problem as it would to give the LLM a description of the solution -- if the description was precise and unambiguous then code of similar length should have been able to encode the same. There are many ways that modern programming continues to fall short of this, and that's a problem we should still be working on instead of giving up on. Even if writing and maintaining code are completely obsoleted by LLMs, we're still going to have to demand humans in the loop on review and testing before we risk life and limb deploying that code. Code still has to be understandable by humans, so it still has to be written with appropriate abstractions to make review accurate and tractable. We still have the same incentives to want expressive languages and APIs. If we give up on that and bank on LLM generation instead, we'll stop making progress on expressiveness and be stuck with a stale snapshot of today's programming language evolution, that LLMs are limited to writing and humans are limited to reading forever. Without direct disincentive for writing and maintaining that redundant volume of code, the inevitable review will suffer the most.
- pylua 3y agoI think this is on point. Humans will take a back seat to ai and will primarily test the outputs as if the ai is a black box instead of having deep insights. There will be no need for human ingenuity. Perhaps if llm had existed at the time of assembly language being predominate there would be no higher level language for humans to use.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lasereyes136 3y agoHistory teaches us that "business people" want to "reduce cost" so they will try anything to achieve cost savings. They see the people in the software creation process as necessary evils, or uh, costs, instead of integral to the process of translating vague, usually English, business words into software. 4GLs (Visual Basic, Delphi) and Low/No Code are promised as ways to have "business analysts" or "citizen developers", i.e. lower cost resources, do the work. To be honest this is successful enough to keep selling the idea and products for a period of time. In reality most of the successful work in these areas are done by developers or people that could be developers. Code generation by LLM is the same thing. Yes, it has value. In the hands of a motivated software developer it will do great things. In the hands of someone that wants to take a short cut because "lower cost" it will fail way more often than it will succeed. That said, AI and code generation are here to stay and software developers should get used to using them.
- commandlinefan 3y agoIt seems to me that these "advances" actually make programming _harder_, not easier. The 4GLs, no code solutions, and now AI generation make a _lot_ of assumptions about how things should be done, not always correctly. When they do make an incorrect assumption, it's obvious to a human who's done this "by hand" for a few years, but completely inscrutable to somebody who's been trained to trust the computer's judgment implicitly.
- marssaxman 3y agoThe "end of programming" is something which happens over and over through one's programming career. You get used to it.
- simonblack 3y agoI've been hearing about 'The End of Programming" ever since I entered the field back in 1979. It was bullshit then. It is bullshit now. You should think of this AI instance as just one more advanced programming language, that's all. It'll be no different from having to learn to program in Java, or in Rust, or in C, or in whatever. But mark my words, there'll be some poor programmer who will have to do the work of programming.
- untangle 3y ago"End of Programming" will look like a Mag-7 interview: [program design] + [leetcode].