11 ms·
Are US EV sales a disaster or a booming segment? The answer may be both
- throwaway22032 3y agoThe answer for me is just that I'll buy one when it's better. Particularly for larger vehicles such as vans it just doesn't make sense. It's more expensive both to buy and to run, the payload is reduced due to the additional weight, and the range is lower. I imagine in 5-10 years that won't be the case, but for now, there's no point in me being an early adopter.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y agoFor people living in apartments, with the building providing no way to charge your vehicle, especially when parked outside, the value proposition is a lot less tempting. Takes 5 minutes to get gas, gas stations are everywhere, but having to find a charging station for your EV and having to sit there for an hour or longer is just not appealing if the tradeoff is the good feelings of one's microscopic contribution to saving the planet. You want me to pay more for extra inconvenience. I'm sure that will change eventually, but at this point it works best for home owners with garages, which isn't everybody.
- yazaddaruvala 3y agoI agree. That said when I borrow my parents Tesla, I just charge while at work. Additionally, it’s free :P
- vhold 3y agoMy apartment complex won't even let you park an EV inside or under any of the structures because of the fear they have of EV fires.
- two_handfuls 3y agoGasoline cars are much more likely to catch fire than EVs. They just don’t make the news. “per 100,000 cars sold in each category, electric vehicles had the lowest number of fires.” Source: https://www.popsci.com/technology/electric-vehicle-fire-rates-study/ https://www.popsci.com/technology/electric-vehicle-fire-rate...
- wakawaka28 3y agoAn EV fire is at least 10x worse than a gas vehicle fire. Hybrid fires due to batteries are also misclassified as petrol fires. If you catch a gas fire in time it can be put out with a bit of water or a fire extinguisher. It is also exceedingly rare. An EV fire is not extinguishable, burns several times hotter than any petrol fire, may reignite for weeks or months, and emits shocking volumes of toxic gasses that can injure anyone around. Although the fires can't be extinguished, firefighters still spray hundreds of thousands of liters of water onto battery fires, and that water is polluted and not captured. The whole thing is a nightmare. The possibility of EVs catching fire all together inside an underground parking garage in a high rise should scare the hell out of anyone sane. Sprinkers will do nothing for that, and all that heat could permanently damage the building. The gasses could suffocate anyone unlucky enough to get stuck down below.
- thebruce87m 3y ago> It is also exceedingly rare. And EV fires are even rarer. The people who study fires disagree with your other points: https://www.ri.se/sites/default/files/2020-12/FRIC%20D1.2-2020_01%20FIVE%20conference%20presentation%20Multi-storey%20car%20park%20fire%2C%20presentation.pdf https://www.ri.se/sites/default/files/2020-12/FRIC%20D1.2-20... > Observations during the fire indicate that electric vehicles did not contribute to the fire development beyond what is expected from conventional vehicles.
- wakawaka28 3y agoThat's very funny. If you have ever seen these EV fires you'll know that they are no joke. Have a look at this: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13005001/london-bus-fire-panic-capital-flames.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13005001/london-bus... Have you EVER heard of even one petrol-powered bus catching fire, much less multiple in a few weeks in one city? Insurance companies are drastically raising rates on EVs as more information comes in: https://www.theguardian.com/money/2023/sep/30/the-quotes-were-5000-or-more-electric-vehicle-owners-face-soaring-insurance-costs https://www.theguardian.com/money/2023/sep/30/the-quotes-wer... There are many reasons for this, among them the fire hazard. The EVs cost more to fix, of course, but EV batteries can reignite weeks or months after being damaged or catching on fire. So they must also be stored very far apart while being repaired. Ferries do not want EVs on board because of the fire hazard: https://www.autoevolution.com/news/norwegian-ferry-company-bans-electrified-vehicles-from-transport-on-its-ships-208942.html https://www.autoevolution.com/news/norwegian-ferry-company-b... This firefighting expert says why these fires are much worse than ICE fires in a thorough presentation at a conference. The audio sucks but the info is gold: https://youtube.com/watch?v=AIXTP-TgPEw https://youtube.com/watch?v=AIXTP-TgPEw I can't say if this battery replacement costs more than the car because of fire hazards. But I think it was deemed in need of replacement because of possible fire hazards. You be the judge: https://www.autoevolution.com/news/yikes-the-60000-hyundai-ioniq-5-battery-replacement-saga-continues-226590.html https://www.autoevolution.com/news/yikes-the-60000-hyundai-i... If you do a little actual research about lithium battery fires, all of what I'm saying will be very obvious. Idk where your slides came from but they sound very wrong.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- reducesuffering 3y ago> having to find a charging station for your EV and having to sit there for an hour or longer A Tesla can supercharge 200 miles in 15 minutes
- xenospn 3y agoIf you can find a free charger. Where I live (LA) there’s long queues more often than not.
- frumper 3y agoI imagine a gas station giving out free gas would also have a long queue.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoAnd you can go grab a Starbucks without sucking down a bunch of carcinogenic fumes during that time. I have a home charger but never use it. I have never once wished I could go to a gas station, and whenever I drive a dinosaur fume contraption and end up at a gas station I’m reminded of what a filthy end to end system the age of fire was. I’m glad to see the age of Maxwell begin.
- jajko 3y agoHere in Geneva, Switzerland there is exactly one place with superchargers, metro area easily over 1.5 million and some of the wealthiest and most powerful folks live here or often move through here. I think they have 24 chargers altogether in that spot. Next nearest in Switzerland is some 120km away. That's basically a non-existent network. Colleague who has model S told me he can charge at his house cca 9km/hour. With commuting he ends up almost empty at the end of the work week, and has this additional worry constantly. Service outside warranty is supposedly sky high. Not that great a proposition.
- ghaff 3y agoTo be fair service outside of warranty for luxury cars in general is pretty sky high, especially absent a trusted independent mechanic who you can work with. But, yeah, I haven't seriously considered an EV. There isn't a model in my sweet spot, I don't drive much on a day-to-day basis and, when I do, it can be fairly long drives to fairly remote areas. Maybe someday but I'm either on a road trip or fuel stops are generally weeeks apart from each other.
- rainsford 3y agoThat's definitely true, but that still leaves a pretty large potential market for home owners with garages (i.e. people for whom an EV is a decent value proposition) that is far from saturated. My guess is that by the time the garage owner market for EVs is getting tapped out, the charging problem for everyone else will have been solved as well. I also think the market forces work the other way around. I currently own my home, but it's a condo with a shared parking lot and no way to charge an EV. I've been looking to upgrade at some point, and one of my non-negotiable requirements is that whatever I buy next needs to have a way to charge an EV at home (private garage with power, shared parking with the ability to install charges, etc). As EV market share increased, I expect this to create more and more pressure on the housing market to meet home charging needs.
- dr-detroit 3y ago[dead]
- wredue 3y agoTo get a decent daily cross the city charger installed in my garage, I have to spend some $3,000 just on electrical work because I have to upgrade service. Currently unsubsidized because my government doesn’t believe climate change is real. This is before the average $700 to install the charger. Vehicle prices have skyrocketed, and while my family makes well in to 6 figures, cars are just not a thing we want to spent lots of money on. Dropping 80k on a vehicle is WAY past what we’d ever consider. Critical infrastructure is non-existent for highway trips (again, government doesn’t believe in climate change). For me it’s simply not practical. There’s too many annoying barriers.
- seattle_spring 3y agoJust curious, why did you use "80k" as a figure for car prices? That's very deep into luxury car prices. You can easily get a fully electric 2023+ model car used with less than 10k miles for $25k, and new ones in the 30s.
- Ekaros 3y agoIf government truly believed in climate change they would ban passenger cars. Both for taxis and private use. Or gave out very limited purchase licenses.
- hciektnxn7 3y ago[flagged]
- fnordpiglet 3y agoNot sure which government but the US has a pretty complete super charger network for Tesla owners and opening up to other brands. I actually have a charger at home but never use it. I just drop by the super chargers around town or along all the highways and grab a 15 minute charge while I grab a Starbucks or lunch once a week.
- hciektnxn7 3y agoso if the government believed that climate change was real they would provide you with free EVs and charging hardware?
- downrightmike 3y agoEV utility is less than ICE cars, but far worse than commuter rail. Most of the pollution in the bay area is from car tires. So if they really want to clean that up, they need to switch to light rail and inter city express rail
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y agoThat's wild, didn't know that. Is anything doable about car tires short of not driving a car? Are people perhaps looking into better materials for this problem?
- tschuy 3y agoFor at least one of the most toxic additives in tires, Washington State's Department of Ecology and some West Coast tribes are leading the push to prohibit, with the caveat that researchers are still looking for a suitable replacement: https://ecology.wa.gov/blog/january-2023/saving-washington-s-salmon-from-toxic-tire-dust https://ecology.wa.gov/blog/january-2023/saving-washington-s... https://apnews.com/article/epa-tires-toxic-chemical-salmon-tribes-ce4ea04af17e78d84632da5e68ab356c https://apnews.com/article/epa-tires-toxic-chemical-salmon-t...
- givemeethekeys 3y agoThe Bay Area's pollution is very low compared to most other cities in the world. People from those cities wish that their pollution primarily came from car tires.
- ramenmeal 3y agoHonest question, tires, or brakes? I was under the impression brake dust was the worst polluter. I'm sure tires aren't great either, but they should be equivalent between EV's and ICE cars. Brakes last significantly longer on EV's and therefore would help with pollution.
- whaleofatw2022 3y agoEVs -can- have worse tire pollution in some cases, i.e. low rolling resistance tires and increased weight compared to similar ICE.
- Melmolo 3y agoIt's really unfortunate for others that there are still that many hurdles. My ev is so more agile and makes a lot of fun. True not cheap and getting the electric right was like 1.5k on top but hey still a ton cheaper than a normal car with speeds anything close to my ev.
- freetime2 3y agoI get that there are lot of people who like to drive fun cars, and I have no problem with that (as long as they obey traffic laws and drive safely on public roads), but for me speed, agility, and fun are pretty low on my list of priorities in a car. I would rank practicality, safety, comfort, and affordability well above speed. For me there aren't any EVs on the market that hit the balance of practicality, comfort, and affordability that I am looking for. I'm still optimistic though that by the time I am ready to replace my current car, there might at least be options worth considering.
- Melmolo 3y agoI would say my ev is more save than a regular car. I'm much more agile when I take over another vehicle. Comfort is for me higher too because I charge directly at home. Let's see how long it will take for evs to get cheaper. I hope sooner than later.
- sibit 3y agoI just purchased a new truck within the last 6 months and I was considering Ford's F-150 Lightning but ended up going with a diesel 2500 Silverado instead. The lightning boast 350 miles but it's not clear what kind of mileage I would get when pulling my camper. I also like to travel to some of the more remote parts of the US and I just don't have the confidence that it wouldn't become a pain in my butt. As for anecdotal evidence I don't see a lot of EVs driving around in my mid sized midwest town (~200k pop). At most I notice 2-4 Teslas a week and as of today I've seen my first Rivian. If they're popular they ain't popular around here.
- freetime2 3y agoYup I don't think EVs are suitable for towing, yet. > We had been warned to expect the range to be cut in half when towing, but the effect of towing these travel trailers proved even more significant. With the smallest and lightest trailer, we measured a range of just 115 miles. That figure fell to 100 miles with the middleweight camper and sank to a mere 90 miles with the 7,218-pound Grand Design trailer. [1] Maybe when solid state batteries make their way into EVs by the end of this decade, that will change. [2] [1] https://www.motortrend.com/reviews/ford-f150-lightning-electric-truck-towing-test/ https://www.motortrend.com/reviews/ford-f150-lightning-elect... [2] https://spectrum.ieee.org/solid-state-battery-production-challenges https://spectrum.ieee.org/solid-state-battery-production-cha...
- throwaway11460 3y agoThe camper could have a battery pack too. Also its roof area might be significant enough to put on solar panels and charge on the way...
- sibit 3y ago> Maybe when solid state batteries make their way into EVs by the end of this decade, that will change. That'd be nice. I figure I'll revisit EV tech in ~10 years when I'm ready to start shopping again. Fingers crossed.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt would be nice if modern trailers would include a great big battery. Plus, that could be nice while staying in there.
- happytiger 3y agoI will never buy and EV as long as I’m beholden to the tyranny of PG&E’s constant gamification of my power. They keep raising and raising prices and there’s nothing attractive about putting all my eggs in the electric basket in California as long as the rates are controlled by cartels. PG&E will exploit any electric car progress for themselves and rip off their customers as hard as they can as soon as they thought they had a critical mass worth really rate exploiting and could get away with it. I know lots of people disagree with me, but low institutional trust is the main reason we don’t have one. That and we tend to buy and keep our vehicles for decades and I’m quite sure I don’t believe the rhetoric around durability and reliability. When it’s truly a superior product from a quality and reliability standpoint and not a car body stapled to a battery with a smartphone quality warranty, and I have choice in how to fuel it beyond predatory power companies controlled by corrupt institutions, I’m in. Nobody ever talks about the profound lack of diversity in the power suppliers, but it’s more than a minor existential risk to electric car viability in many parts of the country.
- bequanna 3y agoIsn’t this rate jump partially the result of rulings that made PG&E liable for damages from fires started by overheated transformers?
- CogitoCogito 3y agoWho else but them would be responsible for those fires?
- happytiger 3y agoWell there have been a few arsonists responsible tbh. But a lot of it is negligence.
- happytiger 3y agoIndeed. That was the story. The reality is after all these rate hikes PG&E, which so desperately complained about their future being in jeopardy, forcing worker concessions, and undergoing a 58 billion dollar wildfire fueled restructuring, paid their CEO more than 40 million dollars and cleared more than 25 percent pure profit last quarter. Oh, and this most recent rate hike was justified to bury cables. All while becoming the most expensive provider in California. And did I mention that, after announcing a massive across the board rate hike, they decided to start the very expensive program of giving dividends to stock holders. But wait! THEN they announced that instead of paying for what you use, you’re going to pay for how much money you earn and that you would now need to report income to them like they are the Government. A private corporation? Every rate payer pays on household incomes?!? What? https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news-release/2022/10/ratepayers-struggle-pay-pge-energy-bills-ceo-rakes-over-190#:~:text=Most%20of%20Poppe's%20compensation%20came,stark%20example%20of%20rewarding%20failure https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news-release/2022/10/ratep.... https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights/latest-news-headlines/pg-e-corp-s-poppe-was-highest-paid-us-utility-ceo-in-2021-71538853 https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights... https://www.nbclosangeles.com/investigations/national-investigations/pge-rate-hike-california/3302833/ https://www.nbclosangeles.com/investigations/national-invest... We’re rewarding failure and the utility is killing people.
- Workaccount2 3y agoI'm jumping right to an e-bike. Seems like a no brainer since I can get to work in the same amount of time (because of heavy traffic), and the electric part means I don't have to get sweaty doing it.
- aniftythrifrty 3y agoIt's time to raise speed limits. EVs are so fast!
- ProfessorLayton 3y agoEVs are still too compromising or expensive. All I want is an electric no-frills version of my Civic at a comparable price. Honda themselves, or any other manufacturer, have been unable to offer that. I have no interest in buying another ICE vehicle, so I'll continue to maintain my current car, but I'm ready to buy once they offer something I'm looking for.
- api 3y ago> All I want is an electric no-frills version of my Civic at a comparable price. The US car industry seems really determined not to allow anything affordable on the market. It's not just EVs. They also push overpriced bloated gas guzzlers. Eventually someone will get a cheap reliable decent-range EV like you want into the market and steamroll the entire industry.
- dalyons 3y agoIt coming, from BYD and the other new Chinese ev companies
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNot to the US. There's currently a 25% tariff on imported Chinese vehicles, and there's a proposal to raise it to 125%.
- fumar 3y agoIsn’t the automotive space filled with lobbyists wanting to maintain the status quo? I’ve witness many families go electric and none have gone back. Self selected bias? I’ve had an EV for over seven years now. We are on our second Tesla and looking at a Rivian. I could not go back to an ICE vehicle and this is coming from a long time automotive enthusiast who has competed in rallys and track events. For my family’s lifestyle it is just so simple to own an EV with low to no maintenance, home charging, solar panels cost savings, pet modes, simple to operate, and almost appliance like. We have one vehicle and a motorcycle. When I ride I can focus on manual operations like changing gears or using two brakes. But if I am honest it is rare I want such a taxing ride. I still commute at least twice per week on a two wheels. Eventually, I will get an electric motorcycle. I had range anxiety in my first month of EV ownership but you quickly realize that most trips rarely require a charging stop. Admittedly, I am in California but even traveling through the desert only one time did I need to use my mobile charger.
- dkobia 3y agoIf you own a house, an EV is a no brainer. I drive an ICE vehicle and my wife drives an EV. My car feels like antiquated technology after driving the EV. It is hard to describe how simple, cheap and fun they are to operate. To date we haven't had to use a charging station because charging at home or at the office (for free) has been sufficient. We had range anxiety maybe the first few weeks but that is long gone. It just works.
- bluGill 3y agoIf you have a house odds are you live in a family situations. Maybe you can justify one non-EV truck for towing or trips, but an EV will do everything you need from the other cars.
- grecy 3y agoThe FUD that continues to come from big money around EVs is impressive, if not a little boring and dumb. These graphs are getting mighty steep with no letting up. Any business or market segment in the world would be hailed a massive success with growth like that. [1] The Tesla model Y is the 2nd best selling vehicle in the US, behind only the F-150. The sales compared to legacy OEMs are insane. And that is just Tesla, there are plenty of other EVs that are selling in huge numbers now, with more showing up every day. Anyone who says EVs are not a smashing success is blatantly denying the hard facts as they exist, and clearly is not interested in being truthful. Akin to someone saying solar is not growing and has no demand. [1] https://cleantechnica.com/2023/09/22/electric-vehicle-sales-in-us-hit-the-accelerator-pedal/ https://cleantechnica.com/2023/09/22/electric-vehicle-sales-...
- neogodless 3y ago> The Tesla model Y is the 2nd best selling vehicle in the US, behind only the F-150. While this doesn't change the point you're making, according to this, the Tesla Model Y was 5th best selling in the U.S. in 2023. Can you show me where you got 2nd? https://www.caranddriver.com/news/g43553191/bestselling-cars-2023/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/g43553191/bestselling-cars...
- grecy 3y agohttps://insideevs.com/news/672690/tesla-model-y-second-only-ford-f-150-best-selling-vehicle-us/ https://insideevs.com/news/672690/tesla-model-y-second-only-... Exert: "Remarkably, the Model Y was the second most popular vehicle of any kind in the US after only the Ford F-150 pickup truck"
- neogodless 3y agoSo for a specific time period, it was considered Number 2: > The EV doubled US registrations in January-April 2023 But it lost ground to end up at Number 5 for all of 2023. You can't really say it "is" the second best selling vehicle, though you can say it briefly "was." It may be the way Tesla reports their sales. It looks like they were at 127k for Q1, while the Chevrolet Silverado sold 126k in that time period. But over the course of 2023, the Silverado sold 543k, while the Model Y sold 386k. Not sure when the big slowdown was for the Model Y.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ZeroGravitas 3y ago"a disaster" is very vague and could still be true if EV sales were growing faster than expected as it would still be better if they were higher. The articles discussed often specifically claimed the sales were dropping (at least in the headline, usually admitting that's not true in the text) which would give a much less wishy-washy headline.
- senectus1 3y agofor sure, EV's are becoming victims of their own success. But I reckon they'll push through the pain points.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]