5 ms·
Portugal eased its opioid epidemic, while U.S. drug deaths skyrocketed
- Scramblejams 3y agoIn Oregon, for example, where small amounts of drugs were decriminalized in 2020, police regularly hand out information cards referring people to a drug counseling hotline. Court data shows drug users rarely call. In Portugal, by contrast, government data shows roughly 90% of people referred to drug counseling sessions by police do turn up, at least for an initial session. Why?
- lkdfjlkdfjlg 3y agoI'm from Portugal and I've lived in the US (not Oregon). Maybe related, maybe not, but I've noticed that people in the US seem to have a chronic distrust for the police, government, or generally any authority figure. Do you agree? In Portugal if you're asked to go talk to police/gov/drug counseling/etc, you show up because that's what you're supposed to do.
- silverquiet 3y ago"Government is not the solution to our problem, government is the problem." That's a very famous quote by one of our presidents. Like all other American pathologies that have festered since I was a child, I assume it will get worse before it gets worse.
- babyshake 3y agoUnfortunately, government is (part of) the problem, but also needs to be (part of) the solution.
- lamontcg 3y agoGovernment is flawed, but there's no better solution, and it requires constant attention by the population or it forms political cancers. But its easier to just hate on it and get the government you deserve.
- screenoridesagb 3y ago[flagged]
- renewedrebecca 3y agoidk about that... Chega seems to have a lot in common with American conservatism.
- wonderwonder 3y agoIn the US its not going to go well for me if I tell my boss I have to take the afternoon off to go to drug counseling.
- martinald 3y agoTerrible article. In Portugal if you don't attend the meetings you can get a sanction of some sort (or at least you used to): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_Portugal#Laws_and_regulations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_Portugal#Laws_a... This is quite different to giving someone an information card. For what it's worth there is increasing problems in Portugal with drugs. The overdose rate is starting to really spike again, there was a good article somewhat recently about this which I can't find, but you can see the trend here: https://www.statista.com/statistics/911927/drug-overdose-deaths-in-portugal/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/911927/drug-overdose-dea...
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> The overdose rate is starting to really spike again From 50 deaths skyrocketing up to 70 deaths. This is the kind of spike the US dreams about. The stats you link to do a pretty good job of countering the pORtIgaL iS ON dRUg FIrE narrative. When compared with the rest of Europe, Portugal has a fairly low incidence of drug deaths. So thanks for posting them.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoIt's a significant spike at 40%. But my guess is that this is due to the market being flooded with ultra potent opioids right now. Decriminalisation can't really prevent that, unfortunately. Only legalisation and regulation will.
- martinald 3y agoThat's not my point. The point is the trend is going the wrong way recently after dropping so sharply after decriminalization. I am/was in favour of that - it is clearly a healthcare problem; not a criminal justice problem. However, I think it is still a big and growing problem regardless of where you sit on that spectrum, which has sharply been brought into focus with fentanyl and other synthetic opioids (which are themselves a byproduct of 'the war on drugs' in many ways, but the genie is out of the bottle now with them). I found the article I was meaning to find - https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/07/07/portugal-drugs-decriminalization-heroin-crack/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/07/07/portugal-dru...
- lazyasciiart 3y agoWhat’s the demonstrated effectiveness of calling a hotline vs attending a group?
- atlantic 3y agoI live in southern Portugal, and over the years I've observed big differences in how natives and foreigners react to Portuguese drug laws. The native Portuguese feel that it's not ok to consume drugs, but that for those that do, the law provides a path of rehabilitation before resorting to punishment. And this is in fact the intention behind the decriminalization of drug consumption. On the other hand, younger foreigners often seem to take the laws as a license to consume, some becoming unable to work and spending their days smoking pot. And their older counterparts similarly fall into alcoholism, wine and beer being very cheap here. My point is that Portuguese laws are made for Portuguese people, who tend to do things in moderation. There is no universal solution, and no guarantee that the Portuguese model would work anywhere else.
- akira2501 3y ago> "If we stopped arrests and did nothing else, that's a positive intervention because of the well-documented harms of incarceration [on people with addiction]," said Morgan Godvin, a former heroin user who now studies drug policy in Portland, Ore. "Instead of fixing the system, let's just ignore it, then pretend it's actually a greater good to just degrade these people and let them die in the gutter." I also don't buy that the Portuguese alternative is really any different: > Experts here say people who use drugs are constantly nudged toward health care and addiction treatment, including methadone programs and housing. Yet, they don't describe their conversion rate or their results in "successfully" getting people to trade one addiction for another and then accept welfare. Meanwhile, drugs are the obvious issue in and of themselves. If you don't want to criminalize people for possession then you need to openly confiscate drugs and do as much as you can to prevent people from possessing and using them.
- copx 3y agoAre drugs really the issue though? In my experience people who ruin their life with drugs have underlying mental health issues which are the cause of their self-destructive usage patterns. What is the difference between a Wall Street banker and a homeless junkie? Not the regular use of hard drugs.. Pure addiction therapy thus almost never works. The homeless junkies have PTSDs, personality disorders, bipolar disorder, severe cases of ADHS etc. all of that needs to be treated together with the addiction for a reasonable chance of success.
- johnea 3y agoIts funny you mention this. While working for some years in the south bay tech hub (san jose), I knew a guy who was a VP at a tech company. Everyday he would lock his office door at lunch and do a shot of heroin. He'd lay back at his desk and zone out for an hour or so, then wash his face and go back to work. When I left the bay area and lost track of him, he was still in the same cycle and not spiraling into destruciton. A big difference in outcomes is dictated by WHY a person is using drugs. Someone with mental health problems (and/or major life problems in general) is going to do far worse than someone who just wants a little temporary escape. After growning up in the US souteast, I can athoritatively say that a big part of the US situation is due to the uneducated, uninformed, hateful, religous population that mmakes up a significant part of the total...
- wonderwonder 3y agoTo the best of my knowledge, Europe does not have a fentanyl problem comparable to that of the US with last I checked 50+% of overdoses in the US having traces of it in their system. Our wide open southern border [not a comment on immigration] allows this poison to spread far and wide. OxyContin and similar prescription drug addictions are widespread, at one time (still?) heavily pushed by deep pocketed pharmaceutical companies. I think that was a uniquely American situation. I wonder how many of the people now addicted to other opioids in the US were initially exposed via these prescription drugs.
- spamizbad 3y agoFentanyl is smuggled into the United States by US citizens[1] and by closing the border may have accelerated its adoption. And yes, while it does come from our southern border, data suggests it's being carried over by US citizens who have the right to come and go across the border legally. Or are we using the term "open border" to suggest freedom of US citizens to leave (and re-enter) the country? [1] https://www.cato.org/blog/fentanyl-smuggled-us-citizens-us-citizens-not-asylum-seekers https://www.cato.org/blog/fentanyl-smuggled-us-citizens-us-c...
- pineaux 3y agoThis fentanyl is produced in china. It comes from factories producing it in large quantities, then smuggled to Mexico and into the us.
- op00to 3y agoWhy smuggle into Mexico first? Why not directly import where it could be hidden in plain sight?
- hef19898 3y agoCould be that it is easier and less risky to get into Mexico. Plus, the cartels there are a wholesale buyer and have established supply and distribution networks from Mexico into the US and within the US.
- levocardia 3y agoDidn't both Seattle and Portland try Portugal-style decriminalization + treatment incentives, only to see a massive spike in drug overdose deaths, even compared to similar US cities which did not pass such policies? It seems relevant that the background and current context in the US is much different: we are fresh off two decades or so of big pharma and consulting firms attempting to "turbocharge" prescription opiate sales (and succeeding). The current turn to heroin adulterated with fentanyl is certainly downstream of that.
- twisteriffic 3y agoThis is worth a watch if you want some background into why those type of measures have been less successful in the US and Canada, and how grifters have been taking advantage. https://youtu.be/o6dAkkqE5XE?si=pBHVORAFzIiVOpx4 https://youtu.be/o6dAkkqE5XE?si=pBHVORAFzIiVOpx4
- macspoofing 3y ago>Didn't both Seattle and Portland try Portugal-style decriminalization + treatment incentives, only to see a massive spike in drug overdose deaths They didn't do 'Portugal-style' decriminalization/treatment because in Portugal a drug addict can be forced into drug treatment, fined or mandated community service. Open drug use is also not allowed.
- nonethewiser 3y ago> a drug addict can be forced into drug treatment, fined or mandated community service. Open drug use is also not allowed. Was this always the case ( I would assume so), or did it come with the decriminalization changes? These policies seem not only reasonable but obvious. But I don’t think the motivations in the US for decriminalizing are consistent with committing addicts and stopping open drug use. And unfortunately they arent standards in Portland, Seattle, or anywhere else with this problem in the US really. So basically, i dont see that happening in the US. Its the same story for mental and behavioral health. People that were dangers to themselves and society used to be committed to institutions but we decided it was more humane to empty these institutions out on the streets.
- latency-guy2 3y agoOpinion pieces should present all their counters if they want to present themselves as unobjective, and not just the ones they think they have an answer for. USA is not Portugal, transport, production, and distribution of drugs is not from the same sources. Wide scale economics are not the same either. People are also quite different. For example, Portugal "solved" their problem, but their rates are annually far beyond what Singapore has in accumulation over decades. Why not aspire to be more like Singapore rather than Portugal, NPR's Brian Mann?
- spamizbad 3y agoSingapore is a police state whereas Portugal is a Liberal democracy.
- lkdfjlkdfjlg 3y agoThis. It blows my mind that people have to be explained this.
- latency-guy2 3y agoWhat explanation, precisely?
- lkdfjlkdfjlg 3y agoIf you don't see what's objectionable with saying "lets be more like that police state in how they deal with drugs", then the things we're striving for are so fundamentally different that we probably won't have a very productive conversation. I was replying to the other guy. Have a nice day.
- joemazerino 3y agoAre less overdose deaths better than more?
- baxtr 3y agoOne naive question, since I have no contact to anyone taking opioids: what is it that people get from the drug? For what is it used for exactly? If it’s regular pain, then why not “simply” prescribe Aspirin or Ibuprofen instead?
- badpun 3y agoAspirin or Ibupofren have their limits.
- herbst 3y agoThat's where opiads (and other substances come in) just not before you hit those limits.
- carlmr 3y agoIbuprofen is basically the German strategy. It's not super strong, but everything else is only for extreme pain. Get your wisdom teeth pulled? Ibuprofen. Broke some bones? Ibuprofen. Burn victim? Maybe some opiates. The strategy works. Better to have some pain, than to get hooked on opiates.
- hef19898 3y agoYou do get opiods after surgery so, if you want. Only for limited periods of time so.
- wil421 3y agoSame experience but I’m in the US.
- overstay8930 3y agoGerman doctors will unironically tell people to drink tea and go on a walk to treat mental illnesses.
- 3y ago
- zac23or 3y agoAfter years of lies from anti-drug and pro-drug guys, I simply don't believe this type of article with data to back it up. For example, the opioid crisis in America is very different from drug use in Portugal. Do opioids in America kill more easily than the drugs used in Portugal? The article contains a lot of feelings and no data.
- ElonsNightmare 3y agoare we ready to talk about 'culture' yet?
- nozzlegear 3y agoDon’t beat around the bush, just come out and tell us whatever it is you think you’re implying so we don’t have to guess.
- overstay8930 3y agoWho still believes this crap? Clearly it doesn’t actually work even in Portugal, drug use has been going up a lot. Turns out executing drug dealers actually works, who knew people didn’t want to die trafficking fentanyl.
- johnea 3y ago[flagged]
- overstay8930 3y ago“Everyone else is stupid but me” is not an actual argument, dude. I’m talking about the uptick in drug abuse in Portugal while the article is just completely ignoring it. By the way, the proposal excludes increase police enforcement. So yea, it is the Wild West even if it says it’s not. Like all “drug reform” plans, there’s no actual plan for the people who don’t want to stop using drugs.
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoLegalization and regulation, and a lot more money for mental health care is the plan. It's hard getting the voters to buy into that though.
- overstay8930 3y agoThey’re not buying into it because it’s not an actual plan. Mental health care is optional, and it’s already free in America for the poor with Medicaid. Couple that in with police reforms which discourage use of force (not saying this is good or bad, just info), and you’ve got thousands of court ordered therapy appointments that never actually take place. Your plan is entirely just “legalize drugs”, and people are opposed to legalizing dangerous drugs, believe it or not.
- neither_color 3y agoI just wish westerners who visit Asian cities like Singapore would stop gushing over the cleanliness and orderliness there while bashing the US/west if they're not willing to adopt Singaporean drug laws. You can't have it both ways. "Freedom" means accepting the consequences of people exercising it. Some people experiment and tap into massive creative potential(even Steve Jobs went through a phase), others fall into addictive traps.
- bitfilped 3y agoI wonder if heroin is still obtainable there, unlike in the US where the only option is a bag of fentanyl cut with whatever the favorite local garbage substitue is. That alone would go a long way toward the differences in OD rates.
- InSteady 3y agoI have heard anecdotally that Europe still gets lots of heroin (someone in a similar thread recently said opium poppies come to the EU through Turkish black market trade). No clue how true this is. It stands to reason that people cultivating opium poppies didn't throw up their hands in despair and decide to do something else with their lives when Chinese fentanyl (which is made in a lab without any opium) started taking over in the US. The opium is going to go somewhere. In any case, an article using overdose death as the primary metric for success/failure of drug policy should not be ignoring the dramatic difference in fatalities between fentanyl and other opiates.
- bouncing 3y ago> Cops still work aggressively to break up major drug gangs and arrest people committing drug-related crimes like theft. They also disrupt open-air drug markets like the ones that have emerged in some U.S. cities. I’m an American living in Portugal. This paragraph does not ring true. You really (I’m being serious here) walk more than a block or two in a touristy area without being accosted by someone selling drugs. They even do it when I have my 3 year old daughter’s hand in mine.