6 ms·
Spotify HiFi is still MIA after three years, and now so is my subscription
- __rito__ 3y agoI would like to take this opportunity to ask others: - What services do you use for lossless music streaming? - When you have a FLAC file, how do you listen to it in an Android phone or a Linux/Windows machine? Which apps/softwares? And does headphone/speaker quality make a difference- or is it bottlenecked by the audio card of the PC/phone? I am a noob, and would like the answers, along with some good pointers, if possible.
- throwawayaw 3y agoI just use VLC on android with wired headphones. Bluetooth is not a high fidelity connection.
- 0l 3y agoThere are high-fidelity Bluetooth codecs such as LDAC (~1000kbps), which Android has native support for.
- skydhash 3y ago> What services do you use for lossless music streaming? - Now, I'm using Navidrome hosted on my home server (local collection). I also have MPD configured on the same server which is connected to my AV receiver via optical. - I almost always use my Mac (I use ALAC instead of FLAC). I either use the Navidrome interface, a subsonic client (submariner), or local copies with Doppler. I have a pair of Hifiman Sundara for proper listening (JDS Labs DAC and amplifier), an IEM when there's too much noise outside, and various other headphones tied to different devices. I also do airplay to a couple Homepod Mini. I need the amp for the Sundara, nothing else can drive it apart from the AV receiver. Less than good encoded files sound awful on the better headphones and speakers, especially if you've listened to the lossless files. As an analogy, I can take pictures taken from a phone. On the screen phone, it looks great, but not so good when displayed on a 43" display, but still ok. So I don't mind listening to a 128kbps mp3 file, but I found lossless files are always clearer and fill the space better.
- Congeec 3y agoI convert and upload my flac files to Apple Music which is available cross-platform, though poor on linux. Speaker quality makes a huge difference according to my experiences from lower end $30 portable speaker to stereo sound systems in cars. Last weekend I rented a Jeep Grand Cherokee. Its sound quality is noticeably terrible because I couldn't hear some backing violin/piano sound of a symphony compared with my own car.
- harry8 3y agoAndroid: vanilla https://vanilla-music.github.io/ https://vanilla-music.github.io/ Iphone: vlc Linux: rhythmbox Headphones/speaker quality are vastly more important than anything else for quality sound imho.
- uneekname 3y agoI know this is controversial but personally, Spotify Premium is already hifi. I simply cannot hear the difference between 320kbit/s and higher bitrates. I have high-end audio equipment at home, a decent DAC, etc...once I go beyond Spotify Free's 160kbps I truly can't hear the difference. I'm not calling anyone a liar, I'm sure some folks can. But I think it's worth considering how important "hifi" bitrates are to you beyond a bigger number.
- dingnuts 3y agoTotally anecdotal, but I got slightly better speakers and could instantly tell the difference between a Spotify stream and Bandcamp-sourced FLACs or mp3s The rumor I've heard is that often artists upload tracks to Spotify with a lossy codec, and then Spotify re-encodes as ogg for transport imposing a second loss on the encoding. I don't know if it's psychosomatic or not, but with a decent amplifier and speakers the difference was actually pretty shocking. I am not an audiophile and I was not trying to do a comparison -- I merely bought an album on Bandcamp and listened to it and thought "huh, my Spotify streams sound kind of muddy compared to this" Take that with a grain of salt, I guess
- jwells89 3y agoSimilarly, on Apple Music with some tracks I can hear a difference when switching between AAC and lossless modes. In fact the reason I know this is because one day when listening to music, one particular track sounded unusually bad and switching on lossless fixed it. Genre likely has some bearing on whether a person can hear the difference or not, with some genres being generally being more compressed for example which will reduce the gap between formats. It would also make sense that each codec has genres it’s more or less suited for.
- bombcar 3y agoI think that technically you can make lossy sound really good - almost indistinguishable. I also think that they may fail badly at it - I've heard lossy formats that sound like crap, and lossless that sound similarly bad. There's a lot more that goes into it beyond just "what is the setting on the compressor".
- stavros 3y agoHm, given that Spotify has a 320kbps AAC version (IIRC), why do people want lossless? Who can tell the difference?
- earthwalker99 3y agoThey don't understand how lossy compression works.
- bastawhiz 3y agoFor reference, 192kbps mp3 is considered "transparent" for most people. 320kbps mp3 is considered by many experts to be essentially indistinguishable from lossless in most cases. AAC is a more advanced codec than mp3. An AAC file with the same bitrate as an MP3 file will have higher quality audio (that is, closer to the original). Depending on the type of audio being encoded, you might be getting double digit percentage improvements [0] in quality over mp3. So the "very high" quality setting on Spotify is indeed very, very high quality. [0] Which is to say, AAC produces files 10%+ smaller than MP3 for equivalent fidelity
- jwells89 3y ago> For reference, 192kbps mp3 is considered "transparent" for most people. With the caveat that the right encoder has been used. Late 90s/early 00s 192k MP3s will sound audibly worse than those encoded by LAME[0] some time in the past decade due to the many improvements and optimizations that encoder has seen over the years. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LAME https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LAME
- xGrill 3y agoLongtime Spotify user here. I was part of the beta all the way back in 2013. I switched to Apple Music this year alongside an app that syncs the daily playlists with Apple Music. I feel like as time goes on, the Apple Music playlist recommendations are getting better and better, but what kept me with Apple Music was actually the integrate with Sonos. I have the Arc, Sub and 2 Era 500s, and the spatial audio tracks are incredible. It reminds me of a time I used to just sit back and listen to music in my room as a kid, always discovering something new about a track that I never really hear.
- pgm8705 3y agoThe spatial audio is also keeping me with Apple Music, although I will say that while most are incredible, sometimes I'll come across an album where the spatial mix is laughably terrible.
- samcat116 3y agoCan you link the app that syncs those playlists?
- input_sh 3y agohttps://soundiiz.com/ https://soundiiz.com/ https://www.tunemymusic.com/ https://www.tunemymusic.com/ https://www.songshift.com/ https://www.songshift.com/ And I'm sure there are others.
- praseodym 3y agoSonos hasn’t released the Era 500 speakers yet?
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoI'm surprised he went with Apple Music rather than Tidal if he's paranoid about HiFi audio.
- vsgherzi 3y agoimo Apple Music's codec actually sounds really good. Tidal's lack of songs was the dealbreaker for me.
- chrsw 3y agoTidal's catalog is disappointing but their audio quality and UX are good enough for me when I want to listen to popular songs. A lot of the music I listen to isn't even on Spotify anyway so I'm not able to just have one music streaming account.
- jwells89 3y agoAlso surprisingly, Apple Music is also one of the few streaming services that allows playback-capable third party clients. One can use Cider[0] among other options instead of iTunes or the Music apps. With as opinionated as people are about music player UX, it’s surprising that Tidal or other smaller competitors haven’t embraced third party player apps. It’d be an easy win over Spotify, which deprecated libspotify ages ago and has yet to provide a playback-capable replacement despite promises otherwise. [0]: https://cider.sh/ https://cider.sh/
- samtheprogram 3y agoIf you have Spotify Premium, it's been possible for years to set up a Spotify Connect receiver, and you can control your connect receivers via API, so it is in fact possible to use a third party client, if one exists. Spot knocked it out of the park with this approach. If you just want the Spotify Receiver, you could use the underlying library that doubles as a CLI, librespot, but Spot serves as a nice example of using the Spotify APIs to actually search your library and control the receiver without the Spotify app and handles this all for you. https://github.com/xou816/spot https://github.com/xou816/spot
- least 3y agoWhile I wouldn't really call myself an audiophile, I would say that I've had exposure to excellent hifi systems and have been producing and working with audio/music since I was a teenager. I've also never been able to reliably pick out between lossy and lossless formats, especially at the fidelity that streaming services generally stream at (not the data saver version). If I listen extremely closely and repeatedly to the same section of music, I usually can hear a difference, but it's only under those conditions where that's the case. Even then, I've gotten some of those wrong. So when I see articles like this, I just can't help but roll my eyes a bit. It seems asinine to give up the actual killer feature he cares about in the music suggestions for something that is likely imperceptible, even to a self proclaimed audio nerd.
- throwawayaw 3y ago[Created an account to comment here in the hopes that a Spotify employee will see this] Please for the love of music, figure out a better solution to your audible watermarking. I hear what sounds like a tenth of a second cut out of the track with the track glued back together. It sounds like shit. This creates conditions where the only way to hear an unmolested track is to download it illegally as there is a lot of stuff not available on a new CD anymore.
- cglong 3y agoSome comment I read here the other day made me realize it feels like Spotify gets an unusually high share of negative news coverage. Despite this, I personally think it's a really great product and service. Which makes me wonder: Could there be an ulterior motive driving this coverage?
- jetrink 3y agoSpotify is the largest music streamer by far, being over twice as large as its next biggest competitor, Apple Music. It's natural that the company would be the biggest target for criticism, both for Spotify-specific problems and as a stand-in for the whole industry. Also, speaking as a mostly-satisfied subscriber, Spotify still has a lot of issues. The quality of the desktop client in particular is poor and it never seems to improve.
- cglong 3y agoThis is almost certainly confirmation bias, but I feel like mainstream publications write negatively about Spotify way more than they do iPhone or Google Search. We know both the latter have several issues of their own, but I feel like I learn about most of them via small blogs linked to from here.
- acdha 3y agoI bet there’s also just selection bias: if you don’t use it, you’re more likely to skip a story about and if you use services like Twitter or Facebook they’ll stop suggesting things you don’t click on.
- miloignis 3y agoTwo things that make me quite dislike Spotify (as a real actual human ;) is their attempt to monopolize and exclusive-ize podcasts, which I treasure as an open medium, and that they pay less money back to artists (I believe). Perhaps it's my personal bias stemming from what I believe to be legitmate gripes with Spotify, but I feel like perhaps they get more negative coverage because they do negative things.
- 5350-uiop-1130 3y agothey spent those 3 years redesigning the UI 20 times.
- 015a 3y agoThe product quality and experience differential between Spotify and literally every other competing music platform, is so unbelievably large that if Hi-Fi is the the straw that broke your subscription's back I tend to think "feels like that guy had other stuff going on" [1] (for example: you're just trying to stir up drama). In a world where Apple Music, Tidal, and YouTube Music cost $10/month; Spotify could cost $30/mo before I would start questioning whether it is delivering enough of better experience to justify its higher cost. And, probably, $40/mo is the straw that breaks the subscription. That's how much better Spotify is. I'll pay for Spotify Supremium whenever it drops. But, seriously, no one cares about Hi-Fi quality. I'm actually more interested in the bundled audiobook hours that have been rumored. [1] https://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/f26113fb-c28b-4919-858b-f6e66002ff8c https://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/f26113fb-c28b-4919-858b-f6e6600...
- klelatti 3y agoIt might be helpful if you said why you think Spotify is better. I have no idea based in this comment.
- IshKebab 3y agoLikewise. I think they have some great playlists, but I dunno if I'd pay 3x for that. Also with YouTube Music you can bundle in YouTube Premium which is pretty great value if you watch a lot of YouTube IMO. I think he's right though; nobody except dumb audiophiles care about lossless. Still, I won't go back to Spotify after I tried to export playlists from there years ago and found the only way was to copy and paste them into MS Word. Yeah really. Say no to lock-in!
- klelatti 3y agoMostly agree on lossless - frankly most people don’t have gear that justifies worrying about it. As a parent with a toddler YouTube premium is close to a necessity!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lxgr 3y agoI can only assume they’ve done their market research and decided to not bother with the “audiophile” segment. For everybody that really needs extra inaudible bits, there’s always Tidal, Apple Music etc., but personally, I just run the occasional speedtest over 5G while listening to Spotify if I feel like wasting bandwidth. Audiophile pro tip: Make sure to listen to lossless 24 bit/96 kHz files via a compressed Bluetooth connection or the AAC-256 analog-digital-analog reencoding adapter contraption of the Airpods Max for extra warmth and richness!
- skydhash 3y ago> Audiophile pro tip: Make sure to listen to lossless 24 bit/96 kHz files via a compressed Bluetooth connection or the AAC-256 analog-digital-analog reencoding adapter contraption of the Airpods Max for extra warmth and richness! People who get that serious about listening to music usually have serious equipment (which you can get for almost the same price as the Airpods Max). It was about $500 for my Sundara and JDS Labs stack. You can go cheaper with the IEM/small DAC route. Wireless is usually a no go.
- karmakaze 3y agoI'm actually more bothered by more and more 'Remastered' tracks. I don't mind these alternate versions--what I don't want are original recordings disappearing and being replaced by these remastered ones that are so smooth as to lose their character. They may be more suitable for new listeners but why do the original versions have to disappear?
- cush 3y agoAbout 4 years ago I switched from Spotify to Tidal. I initially went for the audio quality, thinking I'd be sacrificing the amazing curated playlists that Spotify's algorithms produced for me. I used some app to transfer over all my favorited music and rebuild my playlists. It took Tidal's algorithms a day or two to catch up on my tastes, but then it was outperforming Spotify on playlist creation. I was very surprised. It's a bit more expensive, but soooo worth it for the much better UX, audio quality, and peace of mind that Tidal fairly compensates artists
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Sonic656 3y agoReally love the Audiophile tantrum because Spotify knows full well 320kbps Vorbis is transparent and why add a lossless mode that could go ignored?.