4 ms·
What makes a language flourish? Or: Why can't I speak Latin? (2021)
- surprisetalk 3y agoI've recently been enchanted by BQN, which "aims to remove irregular and burdensome aspects of the APL tradition, and put the great ideas on a firmer footing": [1] https://mlochbaum.github.io/BQN/ https://mlochbaum.github.io/BQN/
- BlueTemplar 3y agoOh, that translation ! Thanks for the laugh.
- tempodox 3y agoDarn, I didn't read that translation because I didn't need it. But it's a nice pun on how anglophones pronounce Latin like it were English.
- k__ 3y agoAs far as I know, nobody is sure how it's pronounced correctly. I'm German and our teachers always said, Latin is easy to pronounce, just like you would do it in German, but that's just an educated guess.
- marcosdumay 3y agoPeople have been teaching each other how to pronouncing Latin non-stop since Ancient Rome. So, while it's probable that there's some deviation, it's not a guess at all. Besides, most Latin languages agree on most of their sounds, so even if we didn't know how it sounds, that guess would be very highly educated.
- t-3 3y agoLinguists have analyzed ancient texts (through common misspellings, poetry, etc) and mostly pieced together what it sounded at like at certain times/places. Pronunciation is a moving target and not much worth getting hung up on.
- dblack12705 3y agoLatin is actually very well attested, both in the classical and ecclesiastical pronunciation. There’s lots of languages, like Egyptian, where the phonology is pretty speculative, but Latin isn’t one of them.
- tosh 3y ago"It is a privilege to learn a language/A journey into the immediate" — Marilyn Hacker
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jmclnx 3y agoTo me it was the PC as he alluded to. But maybe for a different reason. When PCs came out, first we had Basic (free) then Pascal and c came along. All were cheap compared to other languages. I do not know about APL, but IIRC, FORTRAN and COBOL both cost over $1000, the others were either free or could be found for under $200. So, price won the day. I found Zortech c v1 (not c++) for $99 for my 286. That is where I ended up, and compared to Microsoft c I had at work later on, I thought it was just as good and in some cases better (disp_* libs). When I went to Linux, back then it was c/c++. For some reason at the time, to me it seemed GNU had issues with providing APL and COBOL. I think that was due to academic snobbery. Now we have GNU APL and COBOL, but too little to late.
- mlochbaum 3y agoFor what it's worth, GNU APL is GNU because the developer chose to associate their project with GNU, not because there was any sort of effort by GNU as an organization to implement APL (see also [0]). It implements what I think is a pretty outdated APL (e.g. dynamic scoping everywhere, no control structures for loops), and I'd say there are better free options now, like Kap and April, and some others listed at [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_GNU_packages#What_it_means_to_be_a_GNU_package https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_GNU_packages#What_it_m... [1] https://aplwiki.com/wiki/List_of_open-source_array_languages https://aplwiki.com/wiki/List_of_open-source_array_languages
- ghaff 3y agoDeSmet C was another cheap mostly standard C early on. It was Borland that made Pascal cheap. I remember being intrigued by APL but, at the time, on PCs, I'm not sure there would have been any reasonable way to run it. Yes, in general, language tools were very expensive for PC hobbyists in the 80s.
- gumby 3y agoThis essay is (perhaps unwittingly) about something important to entrepreneur-nerds (the putative audience for HN), encapsulated in the quote from one Janet Lustgarten: Our customers are people for whom everything else has failed. A common trope here for the past few years is “your company doesn’t love you”. Well, your customers don’t either. Sure, some products can attract a fan base for a while: Evernote. Apple. Certain car companies years ago (or even today). But that simply papers over the real issue which is that people don’t really care about your product, much less you. I have been intrigued by the phrase “people ‘hire your product’ to get a job done.” They want the hole in the wall, not the drill and bit. So they won’t buy your product unless they have to. I so often see here (and trust me, I make this mistake all the time myself) of people posting about their product/demo/something cool they wrote and but really only talking about themselves. That only works with the last of those.
- al_borland 3y agoOne of the reasons I think Apple has been successful at launching new product categories, where those before them trying to launch the same category have floundered, is they really talk up the problem statement and what the product will do for the user. “1,000 songs in your pocket.” As a consumer, I can understand this, I see the value to my life, and I don’t have to care about what technology was needed to make it possible. Consistently solve problems for customers (even if the problem was made up) and the company will have fans… until they stop solving the consumer’s problems.
- ghaff 3y agoMP3 players were already a thing. I couldn't actually tell you at this point why I first bought an iPod (my first Apple purchase) with I think the 4th gen click wheel. Presumably it was at a technology point where I felt I should probably get one of these things and Apple seemed the best choice.
- hmry 3y agoWell the popular story goes that mp3 players were a thing but either had very little flash storage, or had a big bulky hard drive and terrible battery life. Then iPod came out with a newly developed tiny hard drive, plus a flash buffer so it would only have to spin up the hd every 20 minutes, plus a good control scheme plus a fast port for transferring files plus iTunes which was supposedly better than the competing software options. Though I can't personally verify all that, since I never had an early mp3 player
- tempodox 3y ago> We language champions are enchanted, enslaved by the beauty we found. But no one else cares. I feel this way for both natural languages and formal ones (programming languages, algebra). And I still find it hard to get used to the “no one else cares” part, no matter how well I know it to be true.
- 082349872349872 3y agoYou have not experienced Shakespeare until you have read him in the original Belter Creole. https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/bGOFEvpJHIK2ZjPj-5a2tQhTIwLAvzBuKm82jy6H3zjedM2FmJcPecdUqi8Osq68X3VlnZwhEd_DyOyDbx6B6ShCDEUp9ubt8Q2n2IIfYKysAueRxYTREZPBVUmK3uG0xQ=w1280 https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/bGOFEvpJHIK2ZjPj-5a2tQhTIw... GERETERUT: Da Ofiliya im ta du kuxaku sif! KELOWDIYUSH: Felota! Da Layeretesh gonya tenye redzherosh.
- hobs 3y agoYour client does not have permission to get URL /bGOFEvpJHIK2ZjPj-5a2tQhTIwLAvzBuKm82jy6H3zjedM2FmJcPecdUqi8Osq68X3VlnZwhEd_DyOyDbx6B6ShCDEUp9ubt8Q2n2IIfYKysAueRxYTREZPBVUmK3uG0xQ=w1280 from this server. (Client IP address: redacted)
- countWSS 3y agoElegant, complex and expressive languages aren't easy to read/debug/rewrite. Having a set of special symbols, arcane syntax and complex abstractions isn't a selling point: the purpose of the language to have maintainable and performant software - not to extend the language itself or showcase its strengths. Nobody would "switch to X"/"Rewrite in X", just because X is better, it has to be substantially better for the specific use-case: like a user would not start learning Lojban just because its much better than English, a specific use-case and pragmatic reasons would need to appear where Lojban-as-tool, not Lojban-as-elegant-expression, will clearly outperform English in its domain(e.g. translating concept to some precise neutral representation), and since these use-cases are quite rare, Lojban would not get as much audience despite its rich constructive capabilities in describing concepts.
- smokel 3y agoI'm sure it's a combination of mass hysteria and flocking behaviour in humans. These find their origins in primitive survival techniques: there is safety in numbers, both for raising early alarms, and for protecting against stronger enemies. I've had great fun with Common Lisp, and I quite liked Scala and recently Kotlin, but professionally I have to make do with Java, TypeScript and Python.
- cafard 3y agoI recommend Richard Gabriel's essay "The End of History and the Last Programming Language", which you can find at https://www.dreamsongs.com/Files/PatternsOfSoftware.pdf https://www.dreamsongs.com/Files/PatternsOfSoftware.pdf . The point that stuck with me is "Languages are accepted and evolve by a social process, not a technical or technological one." But I should add that when he wrote the essay the last programming language was C.