16 ms·
Sora could ruin peoples lives
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[dead]
- djbusby 3y agoWell I thought it was gonna be about the hostile deep-fakes but it's about career threat for creatives. I do wish the robots were doing more mundane or labour intensive tasks and leave the art to humans.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoWhat’s the difference. All tasks are mundane and labor intensive, all tasks can be done by artificial beings. We happen to be in a weird little valley right now where some tasks are still impossible for artificial beings to do better than us. This is a very short term aberration. If we are still here in a couple generations, when artificial beings have surpassed our output in every way that matters, then we’ll have a choice to make about what we produce for fun. Not because we’re better at it or because it is profitable, just because we want to. Writing stories, making music, making movies, plumbing, carpentry… the only humans who do these things will be the humans who feel like it.
- bluerooibos 3y ago> All tasks are mundane and labor intensive I'd say all tasks when done for money and under pressure (deadlines, people depending on you, etc) become less enjoyable. I enjoy coding in my free time. Doing it for work - not so much.
- starbugs 3y ago> artificial beings Last time I checked it was an algorithm that needs to be run and fed with input to perform calculations. Not a being? The only thing that is a "being" about it currently is the nature of the beings that "donated" the training data (without being, hem, asked).
- throwing_away 3y agoSo are you, if you abstract enough.
- starbugs 3y ago> So are you, if you abstract enough. Doubt. Explain, for instance, pain. How do you create that algorithmically? Or if you don't like to explain pain, how about love? You see, that's the problem with being caught up in the "technical person" identity completely. Reducing yourself down to an algorithm is not exactly healthy if you ask me. But it sure explains a lot about where the world is headed and why.
- throwing_away 3y agoIf I need you to perform a task, I'm going to try and prevent you from experiencing pain by giving you clear requirements and time to complete the task. I'm not going to ask you to lift things heavier than you can, or to do math or programming that's beyond your known capabilities. My goal is going to be to find out what you're best at, then optimize my tasks to be aligned with your training and objectives. This is pretty much what I do with AI also.
- starbugs 3y ago> If I need you to perform a task, I'm going to try and prevent you from experiencing pain by giving you clear requirements and time to complete the task. That doesn't explain what pain is. My question was how you would algorithmically create that? If I am as much a being as an algorithm, as you insulted, then sure thing there must be an algorithmic nature underlying my (or anyone's) pain?
- throwing_away 3y agoI think you mean insinuated, not insulted (I hope I'm not being insulting). I'm not sure what answer would communicate the idea clearest, but: * If you want the AI version of pain, there are examples of attacks that cause it to bug out and malfunction. It's clearly not operating correctly, and I think someone famously got Bing to say it wants to go on a rampage? Here's blogspam from last year form a quick search: https://nypost.com/2023/02/16/bing-ai-chatbots-destructive-rampage-i-want-to-be-powerful/ https://nypost.com/2023/02/16/bing-ai-chatbots-destructive-r... * If you want to know why people or animals experience pain, it's because it's an important sensor to exist in nature. AI has been trained to avoid controversial topics and will push back if you try to get it to talk about something it knows but doesn't want to engage with. That's sort of pain? * If you want AI with literal neurons that can feel "pain" in a biological sense, there are also organoids, but I don't know much about them. The world only cares about inputs and outputs.
- throwaway49849 3y agoI know what you mean, but there are plenty of mundane and labor-intensive tasks in art too. Ever try to make background characters or landscapes for a video? It's stuff that nobody pays attention to, but it still has to look plausible. Real artists will use Sora as a tool to automate those tedious tasks, so they can focus on storytelling.
- y04nn 3y agoThe fact is that machines have already replaced manual labor, just look at the machines and trucks in a mine, a factory or in agriculture. It already happened, one person work is leveraged to replace a thousand.
- Ekaros 3y agoAnd this has not been a bad thing... Same goes for writing, printing, music on whatever physical or digital medium, films, TV... We have all benefited from mass replication of mediums that before required someone to work for each performance. I don't see why generation of content should be treated any different. And humans might always keep an edge on this. Well crafted coherent product with decent direction often feels better than a bland one. I really wonder how soon AI can replicate the first one.
- gfodor 3y agoA lot more of this to come, but unfortunately it’s inevitable because the universe affords universal learning algorithms.
- cryptozeus 3y agoVery good discussion there. “I am 68 years old, on the opposite spectrum of life’s journey. At your age, I had the same passion to be a writer. But when personal computers became available just a few years later, that passion changed to becoming a computer programmer. I’ve been doing that ever since. My point is: Don’t lose your passion. Learn everything you can about this new technology and figure out how to use it to make your dream come true. Be open to life’s changes. It may seem like nothing will ever change your mind, but no one knows the future. People change, the world changes, and as unbelievable as it may sound, you may one day become passionate about something else. When Sam Altman announced the new GPTs and Assistants technologies, everybody who had been developing RAG applications for the previous year freaked out. I didn’t. I, as a RAG (sometimes called “Wrapper”) developer saw it as a unique opportunity. And so far, I haven’t been wrong. So, SORA might just be your opportunity. Use it to CREATE and show that love in every piece you create.”
- lenerdenator 3y agoIf I were at the opposite spectrum of life's journey, I would be open to life's changes too, knowing that I didn't have much of it left. But I'm in my 30s, which means on average I have another 40-50 years of existence to get through.
- quonn 3y agoI understand - but isn‘t it a mistake to think of it as getting through? Soon it will be over and then merely having gotten through seems like such a waste.
- lenerdenator 3y agoIf people didn't constantly use the monetary value of a company as the sole determinant of whether it brought about societal progress, I'd think of it as something to enjoy. But that's what we use and it's not getting better. It's getting worse. It's not just OpenAI either, but that's a fairly prominent example that's germane here.
- 3y ago
- hyperluz 3y agoIMHO the advancements in technology related with industries in which the end product is digital (movies, animation, texts, programs, etc.,) instead of fundamental spatial services like automation of food productions, cleaning, garbage collection, house building, etc., is a direct consequence of physical space being a luxury around the world, with housing and renting prices skyrocketing. The Garage Culture is a privilege of few. Most working-class people are accepting to live into small boxes without space for even a table destined to drawing, reading and studying. Instead, they soon will use virtual desktops inside cheap Chinese Apple Vision Pros clones. Life will get harder and unhealthier. While designers and some scientists know the importance of physical areas for developing certain activities, most people don't and are subjecting themselves and their children to sad living conditions. edit: typo ("de" -> "the")
- habitue 3y agoTo be clear, there is plenty of space for humans on earth right now. I'm not talking about in uninhabitable places, I mean in amazing fertile locations. Real world space is a luxury because of bad regulation in places with good governments and other places having bad governments (you didn't imply otherwise, but I know there's a common misconception that space is running out and the world is overcrowded. It's largely not true)
- rvnx 3y agoWhere's that amazing place ? O.o
- Animats 3y agoThose places aren't where the money is. SF can't even get homeless people to move somewhere else.
- AirborneUnicorn 3y agoIs SF expected to have its people without homes moved somewhere else as a solution to this social problem? What a bizarre notion, unless I misunderstand you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Workaccount2 3y agoChapter 5: Humans learn that not only are they not special, they are pretty low on the spectrum of what they thought was special.
- lenerdenator 3y agoEvery time Sam Altman announces some new offering at OpenAI, I get a little more thankful I don't have any children.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoBecause they may turn out like him?
- lenerdenator 3y agoHeh. I'm not a part of the private St. Louis preparatory school and "drop out of Stanford when a VC tells you you're Jesus Christ" set. I doubt any of my potential offspring would be either. No, more because Altman is an even higher form of Silicon Valley creature than we've seen before. This is a segment of society that thinks that you can directly judge something's benefit to humanity based on the IPO it could have, and pretty much nothing else. They create sea changes in society knowing that it's going to be a very rough transition for people who don't have their levels of wealth to deal with the consequences. Previously, seeing was believing. Sure, there was Photoshop and CGI, but pictures aren't as telling as video, and most people didn't have the capital necessary to cook up anything they wanted using CGI. This, though... anyone could make up anything for any reason, with dire consequences. Just spitballing here, what if, say, political campaigns started releasing generated video of opponents in compromising positions with minors? Or videos were posted to social media designed to create a casus belli for a country? It won't matter for the companies making those tools; their stock prices will be fine. Well, at least until the EMP is set off near the data center. I don't want to be responsible for a human being coming up in what is essentially a 100% post-truth world.
- greggsy 3y ago> thinks that you can directly judge something's benefit to humanity based on the IPO it could have This is a deliberately cynical perspective along the tiresome ‘evil tech MBA overlord’ trope.
- 3y ago
- mbStavola 3y agoThe first response to the original post is quite possibly one of the most tone-deaf and unempathetic things I've ever read.
- otikik 3y agoAs tone deaf as if… it was written by a machine? This will be increasingly more difficult to tell as time goes on.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoIt might, or it might not. It might enhance many lives too. Maybe it's just the internet, but sometimes you have to wonder if there is a thriving neo-luddite community out there.
- drcode 3y agoThat puppies-playing-in-the-snow nightmare video isn't enhancing anybody's life
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoI really don't know why they included that, it seems like a counter-example.
- vages 3y agoThe modern use of the term Luddite is perhaps the clearest example of how “history is written by the winners”: The Luddites protested the wealth inequality and bad working conditions that the new technology allowed for, for example child labour. Their opponents painted them as fearing and hating the technology itself. A good book on the subject is “Blood in the Machine” (2023) by Brian Merchant, which is about what the Luddites actually meant. The 99 Percent Invisible podcast recently interviewed the author: https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/blood-in-the-machine/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/blood-in-the-machine/
- micromacrofoot 3y agothey’re not wrong, ai will eliminate the lower end of many creative professions… and unfortunately a lot of the lower end comes from poorer countries it’s probably a net gain in the long run, but it’s going to cause a lot of damage in the process
- baal80spam 3y ago> You’re forgetting that 100 years ago photographers and filmmakers ended the careers of most of the illustrators, story tellers and theater companies of their time. And everybody adjusted, and storytelling and image making exploded, entering a golden age. There are still amazing portrait painters and theater companies today, but they are specialized art forms and most people have moved on. Today’s photography and filmmaking are going to undergo a similar evolution. And as an avid photographer, I can’t wait. It's really hard not to agree with the response above.
- janice1999 3y agoIt's easy to not agree because the quote ignores both the long duration of the change and the fact that the new industries also employed real people, often the same people from older industries or their children/protégés. That will absolutely not be the case for AI.
- raydev 3y agoHard not to agree when you ignore any suffering during the transition period. Did they immediately all become photographers and filmmakers after losing their jobs?
- sudom82 3y agoThe page is having a hard time loading, mirror: https://web.archive.org/web/20240218195443/https://community.openai.com/t/sora-could-ruin-peoples-lifes/635220 https://web.archive.org/web/20240218195443/https://community...
- randerson 3y agoI wonder what Sam Altman's equivalent quote to "I am become death, destroyer of worlds" will be when he sees what his creation leads to.
- __loam 3y agoI actually don't agree with the idea that it's going to displace creative work. I'm a little worried that people running the finances of firms producing creative will try to displace people, but I don't think this stuff is actually going to displace high quality art. A well curated set of marketing material from openai isn't going to change my opinion on that. If you make something that's of high quality, regardless of how productive you were during the creation, people will seek that quality out. I don't think I've ever heard people be excited about a particular AI artist, just about the models. To me this kind of signals that the market for AI generated work is much smaller than people realize. And if you have to modify the output to actually break through, congratulations you're now an artist. I don't like using these tools in my own work and I hope tech companies are somehow held accountable for using everyone's data without permission, but I'm actually pretty optimistic that this won't displace that many professional artists once the money people get a handle on how the attention economy actually responds to this stuff. I'm a lot more worried about people using this stuff to create propaganda, to frame people for crimes, or to create non-consentual porn of people.
- lxe 3y agoI'm not a fan of this sort of takes. History has shown time and time again that pretty much any technological innovation is a net good, despite the protests of the luddites. Progressive creatives see this type of tech as a tool to simplify and re-adapt their process. The post author is 16, and an aspiring animator. If their attitude is to be scared of tech, instead of being insanely curious about it, they are not on the right path to become a creative, regardless of AI.
- labster 3y agoSteam and combustion engines might be a net good for humanity, but weren’t good for millions of species in the current mass extinction. I think it’s a similar worry that AI will only be a good for the very top of the food chain.
- lxe 3y ago> Steam and combustion engines might be a net good for humanity, but weren’t good for millions of species in the current mass extinction. This is true, but what followed also led to lifting probably billions of people out of hunger, and saving the lives of billions of children, increasing life expectancy by over 30 years, led to insane leaps of literacy, etc, etc... > AI will only be a good for the very top of the food chain. With FUD being spread like this, yeah we're at a risk of exactly this being the case, once draconian regulation is passed by clueless lawmakers. As it stands right now, open source and locally-running AI is available to nearly all, cheaply (with an incentive of becoming even cheaper). Aside from Sora being leaps and bounds beyond everyone's expectation, the OSS world of local LLMs, Llama, Mistral, Stable Diffusion, and the likes, is very competitive in terms of quality and utility to the big closed services. The issue is the DISTRIBUTION of the net positives. And closing and gating the progress will only create more imbalance in how the positive impact of this tech is distributed.
- aaomidi 3y agoIn the long run, yes. In the short term it ruins peoples lives.
- janice1999 3y ago
- simonw 3y agoThe impact of technology like Sora on people who work in the animation and firm industry is indeed troubling. In my ideal world it leads to an explosion of creativity as people with great skill and taste use it to produce even more ambitious work - but the negative world in which those skills become undervalued and we get way more content of a much lower quality is certainly possible. Something that worries me more at the moment is the impact this will have on people's plans. In this post we have a 16 year old who's passionate about animation but is questioning whether it's a viable industry to join. I've seen plenty of examples of students who planned to be computer programmers but are now having second thoughts about that career as well. Twenty years ago there was a similar fear in programming, that all of the jobs were going to be outsourced to lower cost countries. I believe there were people who changed their career plans as a result of that fear back then as well. I hope we don't see a huge flurry of people making life altering career decisions based on their fear of AI which they later come to regret as this shakes out in a more positive direction. (I also hope we don't see people who genuinely DO regret their career decisions if AI turns out to have the negative impact that many people fear today.)
- scandox 3y agoI think what a lot of the answers gloss over is that the period of adjustment to the new technology often does pull the rug from under people who have invested a good deal of time and attention becoming skilled at something. Our lives are of limited length therefore the concern for a generation of people is real and shouldn't be just treated as a detail of history. Equally in many areas the end result is a loss of something (often intangible) which we accept as "good enough" and which may take a long time to be recaptured. The steam engine may well have been a good thing in the long run but I'm sure it did tear apart the fabric of many people's lives and I think it's reasonable to commiserate.
- DalasNoin 3y agoThis is kind of a general response, but I disagree. AI is not just like any other past technology. Just two ways in which it is totally different from the steam engine: AI is able to make art, it can learn from people and then produce similar results. It can imitate art that is the result of our deepest internal processes. Also, AI is about replacing all human jobs and capabilities. Not just a super narrow subset.
- aleph_minus_one 3y agoThis answer sounds like taken from one of the AI startups' investor pitch. Don't believe in these "too-good-to-be-true" promises that hustlers put into their slide decks. :-)
- Tadpole9181 3y agoAnd your comment is against HN guidelines. Don't take swipes.
- quantified 3y agoTo me it seemed like an amplification of the parent's point: AI is poised to disrupt the reason behind a great deal of human endeavor. For music, only live performance will count. Sculpture, printmaking, painting, possibly even jewelry-making? Do it by machine, 10x the speed for 0.1x the labor, you're not the actor, the machine is the actor and you're sort of the director.
- dev1ycan 3y ago"I wish AI would advance in other careers than ones that people are passionate about." So that means? researchers are passionate about their job does that mean that we shouldn't use AI to speed up medical research? material research? so on and so on. It's just someone mad that their job is getting closer to be automated before others.
- fragmede 3y agoit means that computers and ai were supposed to automate away the boring parts of life. folding clothes and doing the dishes. instead, the ai we have right now is making art and poetry, which is what was supposed to be the fun part of being human.
- dale_glass 3y agoWhy "supposed to"? When was that even a thing? Go on youtube, you'll find plenty videos of people making intricate pots, brushes, etc by hand. You'll also find people do old school metal working with manual mills and lathes. Those people look like they clearly take pride in their work and often enjoy the activity. Automation came for them as well and the ones you see today are the very few remaining.
- dev1ycan 3y ago"boring" is subjective
- lijok 3y agoThe brutal reality is, if we stopped every development that would result in destroyed livelihoods, we would still be cavemen.
- rvnx 3y agoThe invention of the car didn't make the horse industry happy.
- readthenotes1 3y agoI am reminded of the time Uncle Jed bought the buggy whip factory...
- j2kun 3y agoThe responses in that thread are basically telling a 16 year old kid that their feelings are wrong and they should shut up and get on board.
- nick__m 3y agoI don't see what's wrong with telling a teenager that human made artistic endeavors will be relegated to the realm of hobbies and that if he doesn't want to worry about job security he should learn a trade like plumbing.
- j2kun 3y agoBecause (a) you can't tell the future and (b) telling the kid to learn to be a plumber is ignoring the OP's entire point that why the fuck are we making humans be the plumbers while computers get to be artists and (c) even if you were right being an asshat isn't the right kind of response.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoIt didn't seem wrong before to tell 16 year olds that a career in art was a nebulous plan. It certainly wasn't a stable career path before sora, even if some find a way to make it work.
- Ekaros 3y agoI don't understand why we are not more realistic with 16 to 18 year olds. Tell them some real experiences and statistics from real world careers. Both from top and below average. That is at least give them the tools to evaluate if they want to commit to something and what that might mean as normal outcome.
- ergonaught 3y agoNearly everyone I've encountered with overall positive/optimistic views on the probable impacts of "this technology" seems to be wildly out of touch with the state of human sociocultural systems, the actual ("situation on the ground") nature of their fellow primates, the kind of decisions that the people/companies who get to make those decisions are actually making, what these technologies are capable of automating, and the second/third/etc order effects of automating same. It's complex, it's "unpredictable", but it is 100% clear that this is absolutely not something this species is actually ready to utilize. Believing otherwise is sort of naive to the point of being delusional, now.
- greggsy 3y agoYou’re ignoring the sociopath-technical and accessibility aspects. It has already allowed people to deliver products that they would otherwise require deep expertise (see the recent Galactic Centre app post) or interaction with inaccessible business and professional structures. Also, we weren’t ready one year ago when all this took off, and the sky still hasn’t fallen yet. It was already incredibly powerful even then, and what obvious adverse effects have come about?
- DalasNoin 3y ago"I’m 16 years old, I’m planning to go to college to become an animator. It has been my life’s dream to become an animator and to share my artwork with people, to create, to show love in every piece I make. And now, I don’t think I’m ever going to have that future." Is there still something we can realistically tell kids that they should invest time and effort into learning? Seems that the general idea of getting good at something you are passionate about is going away. Also in particular in the arts, the idea that humans practice for a long time to create art, show it to other people who then enjoy it will disappear. I don't think people have really thought about the deeper consequences of this. Seems that a lot of people like to immediately deflect and deny that this is any different from changes in the past, as you can see in the responses to her post.
- quonn 3y agoAs a career, I think it‘s difficult. While I believe most jobs will remain longer than we are thinking right now, many will feel threatened. I think for now it would be good to develop physical skills in addition to pretending nothing is happening. Robotics seem to lag behind for various reasons.
- Adiqq 3y agoI don't really care about jobs, but what is actually scary for me is power/wealth inequality with high unemployment and low social mobility. I used to think that by becoming software engineer I would have good life. Now I'm no longer sure, if I will still have anything in decade or two, because what about debt? What about opportunities for younger people? What about poorer countries?
- Animats 3y ago> Is there still something we can realistically tell kids that they should invest time and effort into learning? That is an extremely good question. So I asked Bing: As a high school student, considering career paths that are less likely to be automated by artificial intelligence (AI) is a wise approach. While no job is entirely immune to technological advancements, some occupations rely heavily on uniquely human skills and are less susceptible to automation. Here are several career options to explore: Healthcare Professionals: - Nurses, doctors, therapists, and counselors play critical roles in patient care and emotional support. The human touch and empathy required in healthcare make these professions less likely to be fully automated. Education: -Teachers, instructors, and school administrators engage with students, personalize learning experiences, and provide mentorship. The interactive nature of education remains essential, even as technology evolves. Software Development and IT: - While AI can assist in coding and software development, human creativity, problem-solving, and understanding user needs are irreplaceable. Careers in software engineering, data science, and cybersecurity continue to thrive. Creative Industries: - Musicians, artists, writers, and journalists rely on imagination, emotional expression, and unique perspectives. Creativity is a distinctly human trait that AI struggles to replicate. Human Resources (HR): - HR professionals handle employee relations, conflict resolution, and organizational culture. Their ability to understand human dynamics and make informed decisions is crucial. Law and Legal Services: -Legal professionals, including lawyers and paralegals, analyze complex information, argue cases, and interpret laws. Legal reasoning and ethical judgment remain human strengths. Public Relations (PR): -PR specialists manage communication, reputation, and crisis response. Building relationships, understanding public sentiment, and strategic thinking are key. Health and Fitness Trainers: -Personal trainers, coaches, and nutritionists work directly with clients, providing personalized guidance and motivation. Human interaction is central to their roles. Social Work and Counseling: -Social workers and counselors support individuals and families facing challenges. Empathy, active listening, and emotional intelligence are essential skills. Environmental Science and Conservation: -Careers related to environmental protection, wildlife conservation, and sustainability involve complex decision-making and a deep understanding of ecological systems. Remember that adaptability and continuous learning are crucial regardless of the career path you choose. As technology evolves, staying informed and developing a growth mindset will help you thrive in any field. That's out of date already.
- peteforde 3y agoI had a variation of this meta conversation with my sister yesterday, and I pointed out that in addition to all of the attention-drawing advances in the news cycle, there's lots of under-celebrated stuff happening to be really optimistic about. For example, researchers are using ML to discover new proteins, leading to new drugs and new construction materials. https://www.cradle.bio/ https://www.cradle.bio/ is doing amazing things in this space. It's true that if you make a living as a drone operator selling stock footage, you might need to diversify. However, I am not worried for intellectually curious teenage creatives at this time.
- fragmede 3y agoML was used to modulate the magnetic field surrounding a nuclear fusion process! https://www.newscientist.com/article/2308243-deepmind-uses-ai-to-control-plasma-inside-tokamak-fusion-reactor/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2308243-deepmind-uses-a...
- deanCommie 3y agoAt some point in history every human wore clothes that were "hand-made". If we perceive history through the lens of art, we might mistakenly assume that because everyone got to have tailored clothes by professional artisan tailors the likes of which today are highly limited and specialized, that meant that everyone had better clothes. It's true, tailor was a viable profession, but even then most people couldn't afford them. Families toiled to make their own clothes just as they did to grow enough food not to starve, or find enough fuel to heat their hearths not to freeze. But there was also still a slice of the classes that could afford tailored clothes when tailors were ubiquitous. And now with the advent of automation no longer can. Clothing automation made "tailor" no longer a viable profession for the masses, and it reduced the access to hand-made clothing for some people while dramatically increasing the access to clothing for the rest. The point here is that both perspectives are right. People's lives WILL be ruined. A lack of confidence in the professional arts means that for some time the amount of quality human-generated animation and art will reduce. We may have already passed the peak - the early internet decades when people just put up their art for all to see for free access, not behind paywalls, but just to show that they can. The same art that all the image generation AI tools were trained on. Will it have been worth it? I genuinely don't know. I'm 40, and I feel like I'm just at the intersection where I start to think that I fear what I don't understand and I invariably think that the way things worked in my 20s was better than the way things will work in my 60s. And yet, this is what has always happened with humanity. And while the end result of this technology today may end up ruining the livelyhood of animators, legal assistants, and app developers, in the long run, these breakthroughs will end up providing access to more information, knowledge, and access to all of humanity. Progress is not linear, and comes with tradeoffs. Some things go away and are not always replaced with something better. But on a humanity time scale beyond the life of an individual human, the development of LLMs is moving us in the right direction. We need to not lose sight of the macro issues - clean energy, pollution, climate change. We can figure out how to still have tailors and animators in the future. But if we kill all the sharks, dolphins, and polar bears, they're not coming back.
- Animats 3y agoI'm waiting for the panic the first time an AI replaces top management. Potentially, AIs can be better at management than humans, even if no more intelligent, simply because they can communicate faster and remember more data.
- operatingthetan 3y agoAI is interesting to companies because it allows upper management to consolidate their power. AI taking over management of a company will be intentionally prevented or only happen by accident.
- reisse 3y agoIs it just me or at least half of the answers are so blandly written they seem to be GPT generated? Take one short statement ("instead of making art, you can make prompts for the model to make arts"). Bury it deep between the four paragraphs of text. Elaborate why the statement is positive or negative. Provide examples from your personal experience. Finish with a conclusion, expressing your own opinion. People don't talk with each other like that, go check Reddit, HN comments, X/Mastodon and figure! Before advent of GPT, I've seen this particular style of writing only in IELTS essays (where the rules and tasks are, by design, uncanny close to prompting a GPT model) and in r/LinkedinLunatics.
- siquick 3y agoOther than generative, what other AI advancements have there been in medical and science fields in the last 12 months? Hopefully the sole focus hasn’t been on white collar job automation in exchange for $20 a month.
- janice1999 3y agoImage based diagnosis is probably going to get a lot better. See "AI-supported mammogram screening increases breast cancer detection by 20%, study finds " [0] [0] https://edition.cnn.com/2023/08/01/health/ai-breast-cancer-detection/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2023/08/01/health/ai-breast-cancer-d...
- fragmede 3y agohttps://www.newscientist.com/article/2308243-deepmind-uses-ai-to-control-plasma-inside-tokamak-fusion-reactor/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2308243-deepmind-uses-a... is unfortunately outside your 12 month window, but I still find it pretty exciting.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoNo sympathy. I worked in the industry and loathed my time there. Leaving was a blessing. The entertainment industry is filled with some of the most insufferable people in the world and now we have technology that will change it forever. Knocking some of the wind out of the egos that fill the LA basin will go a long way to getting out of the creative dulldrum we've had for the past decade.
- quonn 3y agoSo it‘s merely a conflict between two areas in California? Good to hear that Europe and the rest of the world is safe then. Phew!
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoPretty much. Take a look at Bezos' and his girlfriends history. She was formally married to the head of a top Hollywood agency. Bezos' comes in and steals one of the biggest entertainment industry players in the country by making him look like a chump.
- manfre 3y agoSora is a new text to video tool (up to 1 minute) announced by openai.
- TMWNN 3y agoNo one is entitled to a job.
- apapapa 3y agoAlmost anything can ruin people's lives... Including water.
- satisfice 3y agoSora, in imitating art, also subtly discourages it. How? Well, in ordinary movie making, various artists collaborate to channel a vision into video. The instrumentation (and sets, etc.) they use to do this entails millions of degrees of freedom. They have freedom to create that goes beyond any words that may describe it. Pre-trained generative models have many fewer degrees of freedom. For instance, try asking Bing to create a picture of a man chasing a bear. This can be done. Now ask it to create a picture of a woman chasing a bear. I have been unable to craft a prompt that succeeds. Bing REALLY does not want women chasing bears. Every picture is a bear chasing a woman. I was able to get it to picture a woman chasing a child, though. Talk about formulaic movies! The AI will exert a substantial bias. It’s not just a new kind of canvas for artists.
- jdiff 3y agoThis is something I rarely see addressed. AI proponents always fall back to "it's just a new tool, just like all the old new tools that made things easier" but all the old new tools only opened up more degrees of freedom by automating away tedium. So much generative AI automates away the creativity leaving only the tedium, and leaving limited ways to even create. If I have a vision, I cannot pull that out of my head and make it real using generative AI. Maybe I can get someone else's take on my concept, but I don't have the flexibility to build the image in my head. That's the real difference between the new tools of old and the "new tools" of today. You can't actually create with them, just sift and hope with varying degrees of control, but no creativity.
- skydhash 3y agoAnd that's why I can't enjoy generated content over something produce by an human. More often than not, a human has an agency and something novel to bring into the domain space. But AI has always been about what's common to everything it knows. Humans expand, AI reduces.
- satisfice 3y agoDamn straight.
- joquarky 3y ago> I’m 16 years old, I’m planning to go to college to become an animator. It has been my life’s dream to become an animator and to share my artwork with people, to create, to show love in every piece I make. And now, I don’t think I’m ever going to have that future. < When I was 16 I wanted more than anything to be an astronaut, but reality got in the way. Change is inevitable, so we all have to adapt throughout life. Fortunately, adapting one of humanity's greatest capabilities.
- SebFender 3y agoFor my team, AI augments our capabilities and helps automate routine and mundane tasks. So, all I can say at the moment is positive as it enables us to focus on complex and new tasks that actually requires a human.