14 ms·
German credit agency earns millions through unlawful customer manipulation
- shmeeed 3y agoIt's high time this issue gets sorted out by the courts and Schufa is finally forced to change their malicious business model.
- mschild 3y agoChange it to what though? On the one hand, I think Schufa is collecting a lot of unnecessary data that they should'nt have access to. For example, when I bought a pre-paid SIM card in Germany the provider did a Schufa check. No idea why. On the other hand, I get why a credit score can be useful for larger purchase decisions. If I was a bank, I'd like to know if the person I'm lending 400k for a property, has in the past defaulted on any loans. I genuinely don't know what a good middle ground is though.
- fmbb 3y agoA good middle ground could be to only check what you suggested the bank wants to know: “Has this person defaulted before?” If someone wants to borrow huge sums from a bank the bank should take the risk and price it appropriately. If someone wants to borrow money to buy a TV the seller should take the risk and price it appropriately. The current solution seems too invasive for what it provides. How is the world better because Schufa knows someone bought a prepaid phone card and can sell that to an online store when you buy a pair of shoes and choose to pay by invoice the next week? Something is in theory cheaper somewhere but where is the proof? The only hard data we have is that Schufa and companies like them are making billions, so there is certainly money to be saved by someone somewhere by scrapping this.
- kioleanu 3y agoSchufa for buying stuff and Schufa for banks are two different branches, meaning that if I buy something with Klarna, they’ll query a Wchufa service for online purchases. A bank credit will query another service from Schufa, which probably tells them what other loans I have and will put a huge dent in the score
- burnerthrow008 3y ago> If someone wants to borrow huge sums from a bank the bank should take the risk and price it appropriately. Yes, but the point is that they can use your credit score to make more fine-grained assessment of risk. Should an auto insurance company offer the same rate to a 97 year old blind driver with a history of accidents as they would to a 30 year old in good health with no tickets? What about the 16 year old who just passed his driving test yesterday? Clearly these three people present vastly different levels of risk to the insurance company and, even though it is certainly possible for the insurance company to do so, it would be stupid to ask them to pay the same rate. The bank is simply doing the same thing: Pricing risk appropriately. The fact that they offer significantly different interest rates to different groups (or decline to offer credit entirely) just shows that these signals are effective at measuring risk. > How is the world better because Schufa knows someone bought a prepaid phone card and can sell that to an online store when you buy a pair of shoes and choose to pay by invoice the next week? Well, the shoe store is extending you credit, so it would seem appropriate for them to want to, as you put it, price the risk appropriately. The fact that you have recently undertaken other credit obligations is suggestive (yes, not conclusive, but still suggestive) that you may be in a precarious place financially and thus statistically more likely not to pay your credit on time.
- dgellow 3y agoForce them to have transparency, regular audits with consequences if they fail
- sofixa 3y ago> On the other hand, I get why a credit score can be useful for larger purchase decisions. If I was a bank, I'd like to know if the person I'm lending 400k for a property, has in the past defaulted on any loans. The amazing thing of living in the modern connected world is that we have all sorts of information available easily. We can use what other countries are doing as inspiration, or as learnings what not to do. The problem you're describing has been solved for decades in tens of countries around the world, there's no point in reinventing the wheel. In France what the bank does is ask the national bank about the person's credit history, which will only contain current and past loans, lapses in repayments, being sent to collections, etc. So only stuff that is actually relevant to the question "has this person defaulted on loans previously and are they thus a risk of defaulting again", which together with the information about current revenues is all they need.
- vdaea 3y agoWhat's the point of a credit agency if they can't get paid for making their reports?
- shmeeed 3y agoThey can and do get paid by businesses.
- victorbjorklund 3y agoThey point of a credit agency is to sell the data about your credit worthiness to OTHERS that are considering giving you a credit so they can make an accurate risk assesment.
- vdaea 3y agoThat's a distinction without a difference. Whether the renter or the landlord buy the credit report, the renter will pay for it anyway.
- JackFr 3y agoWell, no. If the applicant is denied they pay nothing.
- bberenberg 3y agoIn NYC we have application fees that are non refundable to cover background checks. It’s turned into its own scam where people show rooms to rent, collect deposits, and never run the checks and keep the deposits.
- 8organicbits 3y agoThe applicant keeps applying until they are approved, so everyone ends up paying. Being perpetually denied would mean being homeless. Not much of a silver lining.
- fabianholzer 3y ago
- sam_lowry_ 3y agoThey should market validation and non-repudiation services instead of just selling personal data. The problem is with marketing, not business model.
- f6v 3y agoI don’t know how it’s in other countries, but Schufa is a monopolist and feels like simply paying a tax. You have no choice. Interestingly, I didn’t need a credit check to rent in Belgium and Denmark.
- mschild 3y agoThere are 3 other companies in Germany that offer the same service. Schufa is the most well-known one but far from a monopoly. That said, I agree with you. It needs to go.
- bun_terminator 3y agoI have never heard of that. Schufa is THE thing you need for everything. Hard to believe they're not a monopoly in practice?
- rob74 3y agoMaybe it's the same as with TÜV? There are other companies that offer the mandatory recurring technical inspection of your car ("Hauptuntersuchung"), e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dekra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dekra, but "TÜV" has become synonymous with the process itself...
- Aachen 3y agoSame in the Netherlands, and I can personally corroborate that you don't need it in Belgium. Finland also didn't need it but for a temporary student apartment that might be different. Currently in Germany, yeah... we paid the Schufa tax twice over because we're two people renting together, and the GDPR data export thingy conveniently omits the credit score they've computed about you... Was considering whether one can make use of the 14-day return thing, but they've thought of that: it uses a sealed envelope that's hard to open without leaving evidence (under a guise of having a nice opener mechanism).
- pjmlp 3y agoI only know something like Schufa here in Germany, never needed something like that in Portugal, UK, France, Switzerland.
- ttyyzz 3y agoYou can request a free “data copy in accordance with Art. 15 GDPR”, which according to them “contains information that you should treat sensitively.” and further: “SCHUFA therefore advises against passing it on to third parties.” The product they market, the “credit report”, costs €30 and, according to them, is “forgery-proof” and “up to date” (lolz). I don't know the main differences to the free "data copy" - probably just a report with this specially invented key figure and a bit nicely prepared. All in all, SCHUFA has a very unsympathetic image here in Germany, I think rightfully so. Nobody wants to have anything to do with them voluntarily.
- kioleanu 3y agoThe free report is the list of entries they have on your name. Based on that they calculate scores and risks, but you don’t have access to those numbers unless you pay. They did buy an app last year called Bonify that allows you to see your credit score for free. There was a hilarious scandal last year as a security expert was able to get some high politicians credit score through the app and they shut the app down for a few days so this doesn’t get exploited
- amelius 3y agoQuestion. How do I know where to send my "data copy requests" if I want to know which companies have my data?
- calmoo 3y agoSome fun features of SCHUFA in Germany: 1. If you apply for a loan, this affects your credit rating. Yes - not get a loan, or default on a loan, simply by applying for a loan, your SCHUFA can be affected negatively. Especially if you are shopping around for loans, this is infuriating. This happens because your SCHUFA is affected simply by another entity checking your SCHUFA score. This is also really annoying because it can be very hard to get a loan as a recent immigrant to Germany, so you inevitably end up applying for multiple ones. 2. Your SCHUFA score is also affected by where you live, and how many jobs you've had in X years, and how often you move (which is often as a recent-ish immigrant). 3. Services like Klarna affect your SCHUFA - even if you have a perfect payback time.
- vdaea 3y agoUsing a service like Klarna means you're bad at dealing with money, so it makes sense.
- BadBadJellyBean 3y agoIt isn't. I financed my phone for free via Klarna. I could easily pay it at once but why would I. In the end I save a bit because of inflation.
- vdaea 3y agoUnless either your salary or the price of the phone increased in those months, you didn't save anything.
- TheNorthman 3y agoHe can't predict the future. The relevant metric must be 1. The chance, weighted by amount, of a price hike/salary increase 2. The chance, weighted by amount, of a price decline/salary decrease. As inflation is generally an upward trend, clearly no. 1 is more likely and thus the best bet.
- 3y ago
- pjmlp 3y agoGreat! I hope that noyb gets the case, being at mercy of Schufa has a Mafia feeling to it.
- wolframhempel 3y agoWhat surprised me about Schufa is that the certificate it provides only states that you didn't have any defaults or delinquencies in Germany. That's quite different from a credit rating in the US sense that you can build up by consistently borrowing and repaying over time. When I moved to Berlin after having lived in London, my Schufa was thus as pristine as possible - simply because I had no German credit history to begin with.
- pintxo 3y agoThey do calculate a score, for use by their customers, which also includes your credit history. But if you don't have any, well.
- heffer 3y agoI do feel they are increasingly modelling themselves after the US system, seemingly only impeded by stricter data protection laws. Schufa, as you said, used to be mostly the exchange of negative-only debtor information (i.e. Schufa having no information about you is a good sign for your creditworthiness). I'd say in the last 15 years (or so) we've arrived at the point where Schufa having no information about you is about as bad as having negative information. Exactly like in the US. The only difference being that for their main consumer product you are still fine to get the "Nothing negative to report" document, as that is what's accepted by most landlords.
- changethe 3y agothey have many different scores. the main consumer-facing score is what you are describing, which is never used by their customers. for customers (banks,insurances, retail companies etc.) they have scores tailored to their industry (branchenscore), which also includes repaid loans etc. the "basisscore" is pretty much useless, it's only a number given out to consumers.
- changethe 3y agoin case you speak german: i wrote up an article about their scoring some time ago. in the following section i talk a little bit about the differences between "branchenscores" and the "basisscore": https://onlinekredit.com/schufa-scoring#der-schufa-basisscore-und-der-schufa-branchenscore https://onlinekredit.com/schufa-scoring#der-schufa-basisscor...
- ArmandGrillet 3y agoFinally. Germany combines some of the worst aspects of the US (credit ranking, complicated abortion process, private healthcare if you want decent treatments) with the worst aspects of Europe (low digitalization, high taxation, recursive federalism: within the country and within the EU). A country like the Netherlands has its own issues (mainly housing) but doesn't have the myriad of pain points you can find in Germany like Schufa, anti-customer contract rules, or public healthcare inaccessible despite paying more than 400€/month for it as a single individual.
- tietjens 3y agoHello from Germany. No lies detected. Don’t forget about a working culture where process always ranks above results, and leaders commonly lack confidence to make pragmatic decisions.
- odiroot 3y ago> Don’t forget about a working culture where process always ranks above results, And where tenure ranks above skills or experience. Especially if unions are involved.
- anovikov 3y agoWell, this working culture makes result slow and expensive, and as a result, in many cases uncompetitive, but it does a good job of avoiding fuckups and while slow and expensive, things usually get done predictably, on time and on budget. Which probably makes it better than American reckless "fake it till you make it" approach in most of the complex projects.
- freshbob 3y agoNo, it absolutely does not. It might have in the past, when industry was booming in Germany and setup costs were huge and mistakes were very, very expensive. However, they've pretty much lost the race when it comes to software and digitalization, where setup cost is pretty much non-existent, mistakes are inexpensive (fail early, fail fast), and ROI are generally multiples of 100%.
- dhoe 3y agoI almost didn't get a mortgage in the Netherlands because if you're German, they request a Schufa report, and there was a minor issue on that. Had I come from e.g. Bangladesh instead of from Germany, I would not have had this problem. We found a workaround and ten years later the house is paid off, just for illustration of how predictive that report was. I'll cheer for whoever takes on and fights Schufa, always.
- bombcar 3y agoThe underlying issue is that bankers have no discretion (for various good and bad reasons). Everything is bureaucracy and checking the right boxes to let the computer decree your worthiness. No overrides, no explanations permitted - unless you can attack the problem from another angle.
- ffpip 3y agoIs your credit score your data? Or are they just asking the report of all your past debts be provided for me?
- odiroot 3y agoIn the process of renting a flat in Germany, SCHUFA is not even the biggest travesty. The worst part is potential tenants handing over full dossiers about their background to the prospective landlords. Passport copies, payslips, account statements and more. And as a tenant, you have no way of knowing when does it all end up. At best it will be dumped into a paper recycling bin. But who knows if all these documents aren't sold further. You also have no choice, you comply or you lose any chance of getting a flat.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 3y agoIt is incredible the amount of private information that gets exchanged in Germany to access certain things. You brought up landlords, but I've heard crazy stories about job applications or applications to services that "require" an incredible amount of private information (often even including pictures too!) handed-over for completely obscure reasons with no recourse if your application is denied or simply ignored.
- shellfishgene 3y agoAre US "background checks" any better?
- Sebguer 3y agoA US background check for most jobs is generally just a literal check on whether you've been charged with any crimes, and doesn't go much more detailed than that.
- ploxiln 3y agoFor renting apartments, it's just like this in NYC. But nothing like this in most of the country. I rented in Pittsburgh for a few years in college, and a suburb north of LA for a couple years after that, and the application documentation was much much less, pretty much just security deposit. The issue in places like NYC (and some German cities like Berlin I gather) is that the extreme tenant protection laws mean that landlords have to go to extreme lengths to protect themselves from tenants. In NYC you could have a tenant not paying, damaging the property, and pushing out neighboring tenants, for well over a year before you can force them out, if they're ornery enough. It could kill your business, and it probably did kill the business of most landlords who didn't switch to extreme draconian documentation requirements in applications: multiple tax returns, multiple statements from all bank accounts, proof of employment, records of previous residences, contact info for previous landlords ...
- yakito 3y agoI remember a few years back, they themselves had proposed a system to use people's social media posts to create a "credit" system and rate individuals based on their postings. At the time, it was quite a mess. The public did not like the idea at all, and SCHUFA had to back down, but it's not the first time they've been involved in problems and controversies. https://slate.com/technology/2012/06/schufa-s-plan-to-use-social-media-to-evaluate-applicants-creditworthiness.html https://slate.com/technology/2012/06/schufa-s-plan-to-use-so...
- amelius 3y agoCan we make data collection and data brokerage opt-in with a written consent letter that has to be re-acknowledged every year? I bet literally nobody wants their data collected and traded.
- nforgerit 3y agoGerman here. If you ask me, Germany has set up the perfect feudal state.
- rtz121 3y agoExcept without any of the good parts of historic feudalism.
- Nifty3929 3y agoPeople wouldn't be able to get this information without SCHUFA - at least not doing a fair bit of work. SCHUFA did work to build a system of gathering and providing this information in a consolidated way. I don't think people should have a right to demand this value be provided to them for free. If everybody now demands this information for free, why would this business continue to operate? And if they don't, how will landlords get information about who is financially reliable and who isn't? In the US is works because landlords typically will not accept self-obtained credit reports. They pay the credit agency directly. As a consumer I can get my information for free, easily - but my landlord will still want to pay the agency for their own copy.
- sokols 3y agoThey are required by law to provide the information once a year, for free. The complaint here is that the “free” report contains less information than the paid one. Information which could affect a decision about a loan or maybe a decision of some landlord about a prospective tenant.
- Nifty3929 3y agoThis wasn't clear to me in the article: "With the help of manipulative designs, people are prevented from obtaining a free copy of their data in accordance with Article 15 GDPR – even though they would actually be legally entitled to it." Maybe you're talking about the score, but the score isn't data - it's an algorithm. "For example, in the case of the complainant, the free information included only a 'basic score', while the paid information showed six different 'industry scores.'" And this is basically how it works in the US as well. When you get your free credit report, it will contain a score, but not the same score as is seen by a business requesting the report - because there are many different scores used for different purposes. The business pays for the score that matters to them which is different than what the consumer sees. None of this feels particularly nefarious to me.