9 ms·
Violent crime is dropping fast in the U.S. – even if Americans don't believe it
- anon115 3y ago[[even if americans dont believe it]]- form of gaslighting.
- mrtesthah 3y agoThat's not gaslighting. The author is literally citing the disagreement of polls about the perception of crime vs the actual statistics of crime.
- pastor_bob 3y agoThe title should really read: [Reported statistics indicate] Violent crime is dropping fast in the U.S. — even if Americans don't believe it
- mrtesthah 3y agoNo, that would be redundant. Moreover, it's a journalist's job to qualify their sources (in this case, official crime statistics), so implying some sort of discrepancy in that data without cause would itself be a form of gaslighting.
- pastor_bob 3y agohttps://www.reuters.com/article/idUSBRE828187/ https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSBRE828187/ "A New York Police Department whistleblower's report that his precinct was systematically underreporting crime - an act that resulted in a suspension and time in a psychiatric ward - has been validated by an internal department investigation."
- mrtesthah 3y agoThat's from 12 years ago, and moreover is not specific to violent crime, nor to national statistics. This article is about violent crime during and since the pandemic only. And even if your NYC anecdote could somehow be applied to all national crime statistics, it still wouldn't change the truth of the article, which is that crime has decreased relative to before. If crime were underreported previously, and continues to be underreported now, then the fact of the relative decrease in rates remains true.
- tekla 3y agoThe term "gaslighting" needs to disappear. I don't think I've ever seen anyone use it correctly.
- syllablehq 3y agoOr, the media is gaslighting people to think violent crime is up even if it’s not. Which is a rational possibility since reporting crime has political motivations.
- api 3y agoThe media and certain political interests in the US have an interest in making everyone afraid of crime. The former needs it for ratings (if it bleeds it leads) and the latter to scare you into voting for them. There are a handful of cities having property crime epidemics due to bad local policies, but crime overall continues to fall.
- dmix 3y ago> There are a handful of cities having property crime epidemics due to bad local policies That new trend seems to be the majority of news I see re: crime. That plus DAs letting repeat/serious criminals go same day. Both are often in cities with the most journalists and news too (NYC, LA) so it gets prominent coverage. Those near daily videos of people robbing retail stores were shocking and rightfully so, I don't think I've seen anything like that in my adult life. So I don't blame people for being concerned that modern systems support that. Regardless, as you said, doomers/media have always sold the world if going to shit narrative. I remember reading letters from 1500s where a famous English priest was saying the same stuff, which easily could have been a twitter thread in 2024. So I doubt that's very new. If anything the rhetoric has escalated.
- bobthepanda 3y agoCrime is a matter of relative perspective. I think what is new is that with demographic trends, crime and poverty have started to suburbanize. But to me, the places I have lived (inner cities) are generally much safer than they were in the 90s and early aughts growing up. Back then, people wouldn’t let their kids go play outside or at the local park because they might catch a stray bullet from a gang shooting; it’s not anywhere this bad yet.
- acdha 3y agoYes. I live in DC, which is a favorite punching bag for certain people and it’s eye-opening how few of the news stories mention two key details: the crime was mismanaged to the point where it lost accreditation and the prosecutors are federal appointees who don’t share priorities with or answer to the local government. There were so many doom-mongers going on about the city council, liberals, etc. without any mention of a multi-year disruption to any case requiring forensic analysis or even acknowledging that prosecutors were declining so many cases, much less discussing why. It sold a ton of ad impressions, I’m sure, but had no value for improving the situation.
- FpUser 3y agoIt is growing in Canada. I guess they outsource ;)
- TMWNN 3y ago"The thing I have noticed is when the anecdotes and the data disagree, the anecdotes are usually right. There's something wrong with the way you are measuring it". —Jeff Bezos <https://sports.yahoo.com/amazon-ceo-jeff-bezos-explains-212315127.html https://sports.yahoo.com/amazon-ceo-jeff-bezos-explains-2123...>
- patientzero 3y agoGiven the difference between financial data and anecdotes here, Amazon had better hope he was wrong.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoDepends on whether you are seeing a real pattern or disinformation. Trump isn't in power so the crime rate must be increasing. Facts don't matter!
- vaidhy 3y agoJust wanted to make sure I understand this right - Since Jeff B made that one statement, anecdotes are a better measure? And the second part of it talks about measurement, not data. People are irrational and we give in to irrational fears. If I heard about one incidence of someone who is homeless attacking a bystander, I would be afraid of all homeless people. I do not have enough data to analyze (nor do I care to analyze) how many attacks have been by homeless vs others. My gut reaction drives the anecdotes and that is not always the reality. I will give one point to this statement though - you cannot fight an emotional reaction with logic.
- Natsu 3y agoIn most places, your car will almost never get broken into. In a few cities, this will happen basically all the time. The averages are removing information about how crime is distributed and focusing on violent crime when people are more worried currently about property crime. This uneven distribution and the rise in property crime does a lot explain the difference between these national averages and people's personal experiences of crime. While the plural of anecdote isn't data, it's not some mystery why people look at local temperatures to decide how to dress themselves, instead of the national average, nor are they statistically illiterate for doing so. Nobody with any sense is going outside in a blizzard without a coat just because the national average temperature is warm. The same is true with crime. It is not evenly distributed and that variance defines people's lived experience with it.
- dvngnt_ 3y ago> There are some outliers to this trend — murder rates are up in Washington, D.C. Carjacking is also pretty rampant now
- eganist 3y agoThe stats here on carjacking are so bad that I just avoid taking my car places that show nasty trends on https://crimecards.dc.gov https://crimecards.dc.gov Example: https://crimecards.dc.gov/stolen%20autos:property%20crimes/all:weapons/1:year%20to%20date/citywide:heat https://crimecards.dc.gov/stolen%20autos:property%20crimes/a...
- tptacek 3y agoCarjacking is rampant in large part because of what Kia did, which really ought to land that company in a lake of civil liability. Carjacking, at least as it's practiced in Chicagoland, starts with a burner car that rolls up on the victim to disgorge the armed robbers. Kias, which can be hotwired with a broken USB cable, offered carjackers a literal citywide fleet of burner vehicles.
- lupire 3y agoThat's a fascinating argument then Kia's weakness is an explainable phone to an access other otherwise secure cars.
- dvngnt_ 3y ago"Toyotas and Hondas were the most commonly stolen car make in the District in 2022, with 501 Toyotas and 413 Hondas reported stolen. Hyundai and Kia were the third and seventh most commonly stolen, respectively, with 355 Hyundais and 192 Kias reported stolen last year. By comparison, D.C. police data show 1,468 Hyundais and 806 Kias were stolen between Jan. 1 and July 20 of this year, accounting for more than half of the nearly 4,000 car thefts in the District. An I-Team analysis shows that, on average, a Hyundai or Kia is stolen in D.C. every two hours and seven minutes." Though, people are more worried about armed carjacking which is manufacturer agnostic
- lp4vn 3y agoSometimes criminality drops but at a too high price. Some cities in Latin America are "safe" from a statistical point of view but nobody dares go out at night, or even during the day, in some neighbourhoods because it's too dangerous.
- jer0me 3y agoToo dangerous why?
- resolutebat 3y agoCan you give an example?
- lp4vn 3y agoSome areas of the city get historically low crime rates because they are essentially avoided at all costs, not because the place is safe. People "locked up" inside their own homes is not what I would call public security, even though the data will show that the numbers improved.
- resolutebat 3y agoI get the argument, I'm asking for an example of a city that's improving on a paper but in reality getting more dangerous. Subtext: I'm a little skeptical one exists, unless you're looking at a place like Venezuela where stats have been entirely fictional for years.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoCan you elaborate? I don't think I understand what it would mean to be "safe" statistically, but it's too dangerous to go outside. - Are you implying that the statistic data on crime is incorrect and/or falsified? - Are you including dangers besides criminality (like motor vehicle collisions or stormy weather)? - Are you implying the police make the area unsafe (the police being, practically if not literally, the opposite of "crime statistics")?
- efa 3y agoFinding out how great things are just before the election. Thanks!
- Andrex 3y ago...and the alternative is...? Just sitting on the data for an arbitrary length of time?
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoYour daily dose of "Everything is fine! Do not peak behind the curtain"
- 29athrowaway 3y agoCrime has to do with age demographics. It means the demographic pyramid is messed up.
- verdverm 3y agoThe change over the last 2 years is disjointed from any demographic changes. Consider COVID changed the demographics in your favor, yet we still see decreasing violent crime
- sxp 3y ago"The number of murders across the country surged by nearly 30% between 2019 and 2020..." "We have data from over 200 cities showing a 12.2% decline ... in 2023 relative to 2022,...." It's so annoying that even "good" news outlets like NPR are incompetent when it comes to showing statistical data. There is no good reason to mix city rates vs country rates or speak only in percentages instead of absolute numbers. Some quick Googling shows https://cde.ucr.cjis.gov/LATEST/webapp/#/pages/explorer/crime/crime-trend https://cde.ucr.cjis.gov/LATEST/webapp/#/pages/explorer/crim... (switch to the homocide data) which gives 2019-2022 numbers as 5.1, 6.5, 6.8, 6.3 per capita.
- torstenvl 3y agoWe're only up 24% from 2019 instead of 27% Somehow I don't feel that's cause for self-congratulation.
- pstrateman 3y agoProperty crimes are up in 2022, that's the first year since 2001 that property crimes got worse. 2001 was the first year since 1991.
- colechristensen 3y agoNPR is no longer a "good" news outlet. I am not aware of any "good" news outlets, unless it's one of the wire services that give you one sentence feeds per news item.
- ttyprintk 3y agoIs there a risk referring to statistical percent of 1991? From that site, I think it's fine to say we're currently living through 50% of 1991 levels.
- pastor_bob 3y agoIn NYC, you can get robbed and beat up, and the NYPD will refuse to file a report. There's your 'lack' of crime
- pavlov 3y agoWhen did this change happen? Is there some evidence that it would be the cause?
- pastor_bob 3y agoUnder De Blasio, NYPD starting protesting oversight with work 'slowdowns' " was a warning to the public as well, criminologists say, with Lynch alluding to the "Ferguson effect" argument, in which police pull back on acting, leading to a work slowdown because of criticism or administrative decisions perceived to endanger their well being on the streets." https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/police-union-suggests-work-slowdown-after-nypd-officer-fired-eric-n1044486 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/police-union-suggests-w...
- colechristensen 3y agoIn Minneapolis, police staffing is at historic lows, well below the statutory requirement for number of officers. https://www.startribune.com/minneapolis-police-staffing-levels-reach-historic-lows-amid-struggle-for-recruitment-retention/600305214/ https://www.startribune.com/minneapolis-police-staffing-leve...
- wizerdrobe 3y agoI’m not familiar with NYC or a lack of filing per se, but I could believe an honest lack of reporting downtrends the real numbers. I’ve been victim to several violent crimes in my city in the 2020-2022 timespan (multiple pistol brandishing in traffic, one shot out window, and a knife brandishing in a grocery store) In the first instance I was asked if I wanted to file a report about an hour later after the man had long fled (I had only a partial plate and they couldn’t get a match based off that information.) I was told, really, no there’s not much that would come out of it but they would file if I asked they do. I thanked the officer for his time and let him know I wouldn’t bother burdening him with the paperwork. I never bothered reporting the next several incidences. The only report I know was filed was the knife wielding man threatening to kill me in front of my child at 5.00 PM on a Friday in a crowded grocery store. I waited 35 minutes for police to respond to the call for the sole fact that the man might be waiting in the parking lot and I didn’t intend on leaving without a police escort lest I have to shoot down a man in front of my child. Never requested a report there, but I know it was filed. I found out because I was telling my barber about it a week later and he mentioned that story was in the local city paper’s police blotter. I can’t say it’s particularly unique. I’ve had coworkers harassed in similar fashions, they never reported because they knew it was a waste of everyone’s time. The police officer that works security at our old church told me he had it happen once off-duty he just flashed his own pistol and badge and the fool fled. He never filed for his own incident. Why bother?
- throwaway49849 3y agoSo a Gallup poll that doesn't ask about violent crime is used as evidence that people are misguided about violent crime? How does that work?
- causi 3y agoI maintain my position that "the content is horseshit" should be added to the list of reasons to flag a submission. Lot of poorly-researched nonsense stays on the front page far too long.
- lupire 3y agoI flag these articles but no one cares. People upvote based on politics, and downvote permissions are restricted.
- yowzadave 3y ago> I flag these articles but no one cares. Not sure what you mean--it seems like most articles that touch on politics get flagged (as this one did). Just like with upvoters, it is impossible to know whether those who flagged it did so because of politics or because they thought the article was of poor quality.
- Modified3019 3y agoThat is exactly my main criteria for flagging articles.
- bmmayer1 3y ago"Who are you going to believe, me or your lying eyes?"
- _Parfait_ 3y agoEven in the face of all the data look at the early comments in this thread. For some reason these individuals want you to believe there's this high level of crime. Blatantly ignoring the good trends and focusing on the outliers, in worse cases calling anecdotes better than facts. So strange and quite frankly weird as hell.
- morkalork 3y agoThe problem is that if one party is arguing that the other has fallen into McNamara's fallacy, they won't have the numbers to back it up and can always be written off as just anecdotal data and outliers.
- none_to_remain 3y agoI know for a fact that since pandemic I've been threatened a bunch by bums and once minorly assaulted. None of that made it into the statistics as there's no point to reporting; the city council, the state legislature, and the DA are cool with me getting threatened and assaulted. Foolish use of metrics is everywhere these days. Carefully consider what the facts you have mean. There are also crime victimization surveys which, instead of counting reported crime, sample the population and ask which crimes the respondent have been victims of - the DOJ nationwide one doesn't seem to be out for 2023 yet.
- _Parfait_ 3y agoWe can't run this country based on feeling and anecdotes. Sorry. It's not an option.
- none_to_remain 3y agoPeople can vote based on whatever they'd like.
- _Parfait_ 3y agoI suppose they can. There's plenty of countries who vote on superstition and anecdotes. A lot of them are still industrializing.
- legitster 3y ago> "The national picture shows that murder is falling. We have data from over 200 cities showing a 12.2% decline ... in 2023 relative to 2022," Asher said, citing his own analysis of public data. He found instances of rape, robbery and aggravated assault were all down too. > A Gallup poll released in November found 77% of Americans believed there was more crime in the country than the year before. And 63% felt there was either a "very" or "extremely" serious crime problem — the highest in the poll's history going back to 2000. Violent crime is going down. The survey was about overall crime. So the premise of this article is misleading. The dichotomies presented make more sense if you accept that overall crime is up even if violent crime is down: Police numbers can't prevent murders but they can prevent break-ins - homeless camps don't put people into danger but they do help fence stolen goods. A lot of low-level crimes are not even being reported anymore. I won't speak for everyone, but I don't really spend most of my days worried about getting murdered or assaulted. But I do spend a lot of time worried about getting robbed or having my car broken into (again!).
- Natsu 3y agoThe other thing is that averages remove distribution information. As even the article admits, the crime is not evenly distributed across the USA. Getting your car broken into almost never happens for most of the USA, though it's very, very, very common in a few cities.
- verdverm 3y agoIf we weight crime counts by severity, than the total area under the curve is smaller, which seems like a good thing
- legitster 3y agoEven if that was a falsifiable premise, that's not a very strong argument. If "average" income goes up just because there are a few more billionaires that move to my city, it doesn't actually mean I am richer. If most people are living measurably worse lives because of crime, but the already low rate of murders drops a few points, I don't think we should rest on our laurels.
- mortenjorck 3y agoThe article notes a major uptick from 2019 to 2020, and then refers to declines from 2021 to 2023. What about from 2019 to 2023? It could be simultaneously true that violent crime is dropping and that it remains above a baseline from 4-5 years ago (which would likely also affect perception). So is it?
- colechristensen 3y agoThere were more murders in the US in 2023 than in 2019. https://www.axios.com/2023/12/28/us-murder-violent-crime-rates-drop https://www.axios.com/2023/12/28/us-murder-violent-crime-rat... There were more murders in 2023 than any year 2009-2019. So we're down from the COVID highs, but still higher than any other year since 2008.
- colechristensen 3y agoAh yes, statistical nonsense. >The number of murders across the country surged by nearly 30% between 2019 and 2020, according to FBI statistics. The overall violent crime rate, which includes murder, assault, robbery and rape, inched up around 5% in the same period. > But in 2023, crime in America looked very different. Ok, fun fact, the 2023 murder count was still higher than the 2019 one. Covid effects and restrictions caused an incredible surge in crime rate that has still not been recovered from, years later. That's the story. The story isn't "things are great people are just delusional about crime rates" as NPR/left-wing bias wants to believe. Nor is it "things are worse than ever". But you know what, this lying and manipulation by news sources is exhausting and ridiculous. Show me a graph? Ope, things got ridiculous during covid and improved a lot but not all the way since then. Violent crime is dropping much slower than it grew. If someone would shut up about their political biases one way or the other and actually portray the facts in an honest manner, maybe people would trust the news more and not have such wrong gut feelings. EDIT: Props to Axios for an actual graph and a much more reasonable article which actually discusses the issue at hand. https://www.axios.com/2023/12/28/us-murder-violent-crime-rates-drop https://www.axios.com/2023/12/28/us-murder-violent-crime-rat...
- _heimdall 3y agoI can't find data past 2022, but the US incarceration rate rose by 2% from 2021 to 2022. Glad to see there's no correlation between the rate if violent crimes and the rate at which we lock people up.
- qwertyuiop_ 3y agoThey don’t believe it because they are witnessing brazen crimes like the illegal aliens pummeling NYPD officers and then the DA releasing them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- macinjosh 3y agoNPR always does this. They tweak the valid criticism ever so slightly in attempt to invalidate it. Americans don't believe that crime is down in general, they are narrowing it to violent crime. Car break-ins and thefts, identity theft, mail theft, shoplifting, opiods etc. are all rampant but aren't violent crime. Also the sources for the quoted study are dubious. They picked random sources that fit the narrative including an AM radio news site filled with scammy ads, and a local news station quoting unnamed police sources. The data is cherry-picked.
- NickM 3y agoIt is really scary that peoples' perceptions of reality seem to be getting less accurate over time, especially in regards to important issues like crime levels and the health of the economy. The success of democracy depends on people being able to elect effective representatives, and if people can't even accurately perceive what's happening around them in the world right now then I just don't see how we can expect people to make remotely informed decisions at the voting booth :-( If I had to guess, I feel like this problem is stemming from social media, both due to it spreading misinformation and due to it acting as an echo chamber that amplifies negative sentiments in general. I don't know if this is really what's going on though or if there's some other explanation for this phenomenon. I wish there was something I could do.
- MaxHoppersGhost 3y agoI strongly believe social media is the cause of this. I suspect that nation state actors purposely spam videos (even older ones) that drum up fear and division (eg black guy beating up old white woman or white cops beating up black kid). People can now see so many horrible things that have always been happening but are and have always been rare that they think these things are happening all the time.
- selivanovp 3y agoYeah, I've just recently rewatched The Wire, and it's one of the best shows that explains how police stats are working in elections years.
- alphabettsy 3y agoIt doesn’t matter what the numbers say, this is about emotions and anecdotes. It’s about as safe as ever for children, and yet most parents think it’s too dangerous for their kids to go to school on their own, which used to be common place and we had far less technology to help. People will tell you the world is overall more dangerous and that’s absolutely not the case.
- resolutebat 3y agoHas HN reached the point where articles on NPR of all places are getting flagged?
- zephrx1111 3y agoI just want to know, who flagged this post and why?
- HDThoreaun 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39349046#39349324 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39349046#39349324
- _blz2 3y agoGood to see this article flagged. Next time I see someone getting beat up, will make sure to remind him NPR says he should change his beliefs.