9 ms·
Piezoelectrics enable displays to provide both audio and touch feedback
- guardian5x 3y agoSo, does this still work for touchscreens, and how does it sound when you touch the screen while playing music?
- zaroth 3y agoExcellent question! How does it work when you’re touching the screen? Obviously that will distort the sound by some amount…
- maximus-decimus 3y agoSounds like that would also make it harder to be accurate if your input device is vibrating.
- pbmonster 3y agoThe harder the vibrating plane, the lower the actual distortion. Putting a light finger on a nylon string (or a classic speaker membrane) makes a huge difference, a thick steel contrabass string doesn't really change its frequency until you quite forcefully push it into the fingerboard. I expect you'd have to push hard into the vibrating gorilla glass of a smartphone screen to influence the sound audibly.
- wkjagt 3y agoI guess the bigger impact is when gaming, which is when there is sound, and you're touching the screen.
- AbuAssar 3y agoXiaomi Mi Mix (2016) used a Piezoelectric Speaker through the screen for audio calling
- gtirloni 3y agoFrom what I'm able to find, it was through vibrating the metal frame, not the screen, and it was removed in later revisions.
- kurthr 3y agoIt was the screen, but the piezo strain was applied at the mounting to the frame. They really aren't separate. I believe I worked on this design (though not directly on the piezo) and it was a pain. The easiest way to have a nice solid phone that doesn't rattle or come apart is to laminate it together. You can't do that, if the front surface needs to move relative to the back. You need a large area (~10cm diameter) moving a reasonable distance (~100s um) to make a speaker work at acceptable volumes in the kHz frequency range.
- CrypticShift 3y agoSo last month [1] a screen "became" a camera [1], and now speakers. Nice. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38881981 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38881981
- Kuinox 3y agoSpeakers also usually means microphones.
- scotty79 3y agoAt some point phones will really just become a slab of very complicated glass like in SF movies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- actionfromafar 3y agoSilicon is almost glass, so now just need some way to make the battery glass, too!
- weikju 3y agothen all we need is to figure out what to do with these slabs of high-tech glass beyond serving ads
- scotty79 3y agoAds are the ultimate goal for everything. The only way to avoid it is to nationalize advertising industry and ban private advert businesses. We did something bit similar with gambling. Why all those ads when single directory of products and services maintained from taxes could suffice for informing the consumers?
- twen_ty 3y agoSo IEEE is now allowing click bait articles from commercial vendors?
- gtirloni 3y agoWhat's clickbait about this article? I thought it was very informative and didn't bait me into anything.
- alok-g 3y agoThe surprise for me was that the the article is authored by someone at Synaptics, not by someone at IEEE Spectrum. Perhaps this is common and it's just me who did not know.
- nickspacek 3y agoHere is an example video I found from the author's of the article, Synaptics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HyTAcVjJsd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HyTAcVjJsd0 I wondered what would happen if you were touching the screen, but it doesn't seem to interfere with the audio too much.
- klabb3 3y agoInteresting. The camera man says you can feel the vibration on the screen. Whether that’s terrible annoying or completely fine is hard to say. Some things you get used to..
- elric 3y agoWhich I suppose means they will also become microphones?
- ben_w 3y agoSure, but the same can be said of the accelerometer and the camera — the question is "how good is it at this task?" rather than "can it be used for this task?"
- RugnirViking 3y agoif you could extract a best-guess from each one of these bad options and paired it up with some sensor fusion and signal processing you could probably improve the accuracy of whatever microphone is in there already and maybe even get some directional sound localisation going. Could be a fun research project
- visarga 3y agowifi sensing is also interesting, wonder what would come out of all of them together
- grandma_tea 3y agoCertainly not a good one.
- iefbr14 3y agoDepends where you stick them on. I am using them in my diy raingauges and one of my first prototypes had a too thin surface (where the raindrops fall on) causing a light rainshower on my graph when someone was talking within a metre or 2.
- refulgentis 3y agoYou're using microphones in DIY rain gauges? Interesting, what does it add?
- thiago_fm 3y agoReally interesting. I wonder if this can also be used for cars and other appliances.
- wt__ 3y agoTLDR/advertorial halfway through: “But we at Synaptics think that we’ve met those challenges.”
- mattbrewsbytes 3y agoAwesome if they find/build some accessibility features for folks that need it. But I'm anticipating it will end up being louder speakerphone calls we unwillingly will have to listen to in public spaces.
- loloquwowndueo 3y agoArgh yeah people who use their phone on speakerphone mode all the time drive me up the wall.
- alias_neo 3y agoI mind those people ever so slightly less than people who have their normal ear piece so loud that you can hear the other side of their conversation so loudly and clearly that it's as if they were on speaker phone. Does nobody else instinctively turn the volume down to the lowest comfortable level for themselves to hear the other person when they answer a call?
- mpaco 3y ago> Replacing traditional speakers with piezoelectric transducers will allow devices to be much thinner. I appreciate the fact that this technology could make mobile devices more durable because it has less moving parts, but I don't feel going any thinner than what's currently available is desirable from an ergonomics perspective. I just don't feel as comfortable holding a phone that's 7mm thick, or less. And I certainly don't think it's worth the risk of it folding in my pocket.
- QuadmasterXLII 3y agoI think you've hit the nail on the head with "folding in my pocket." My understanding is that the current push for thinness is about getting a folding phone into that 7mm optimum
- Izkata 3y agoMy wallet is about 25mm thick. If a folding phone is going to reduce its width/length, I think I'd want the folded thickness to be around the same as my wallet so I can stack them in my pocket without one slipping past the other. This is how I used to carry my flip-phones, which were around that thickness which closed.
- hshsnisnsi 3y agoMaking phones thinner, and hence more expensive is in some way pointless. Almost everyone gets a $20 plastic case and adds about 3-5mm to the thickness anyway. Wouldn't it be cheaper to just manufacture bulkier phones with more features like ports and which are sturdier so you don't need a case?
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- notamy 3y ago> Almost everyone gets a $20 plastic case and adds about 3-5mm to the thickness anyway. It’s not necessarily just about protection, it’s also about personalisation of the exterior beyond what the manufacturer provides.
- twism 3y agoreminds me of the best pixel to date. Pixel 5
- mihaaly 3y agoFeels like solving marginal 'issues' that noone is having. "The sound is supposed to be coming from the image that our eyes see on the screen, but our ears know it’s coming from somewhere else." => Not something bothers most of us (also untrue) in current (and even historic) screen and stereo systems - with the support of surround and other spatial technology started in movies. We have a Sony TV where the screen is the speaker and the spatial immersion gain is unnoticable compared to good stereo speakers, while the sound quality is noticeably lower. In a mobile with narrow angle of view... even less significant. "[current technology] are still big enough to limit how thin our mobile devices can get" => then we put thick camera in it that ruins thinness. Which is fragile enough already and requires followup 'inventions' sometimes (think about the iPhone 6 mishap, becoming the first foldable screen phone : ) ). Having the vibration of sound crossed with tactile feedback? Sounds confusing like the idea of a transparent TV. I know, I know, it is not about real needs but about pretentious additions to charge more money than necessary fooling customers with pompus needlessness that shouldn't be taken seriously, yet, I am still a bit grumpy when they try, repeatedly.
- kurthr 3y agoYeah, I'm a bit disillusioned having watched this technology for years. Piezoelectric speakers (and even voice coil driven larger displays) have been around in laptops since the mid 2000s. That's 20 years. I think the Sony Acoustic Surface you're talking about was based on voice coils when it was introduced in 2017, but I wasn't involved in it. It could be piezo now... certainly 50-60in surface would make larger displacements (lower frequency at higher volume) competitive with regular speakers possible. There are a lot of challenges with piezos in terms of cost, limited motion, and voltage (usually higher than 100V) that are difficult to make up for with thickness. Their performance (linearity) also seems to suffer quite a bit for any significant driving range. Generally, the bending moment (direct displacement is usually limited to a few % which is micrometers) is most useful for larger and thinner surfaces since deflection is nominally length^3/thick^3 or worse with strain. The haptics are just as challenging (and you often don't want to hear them!) for similar reasons and usually can't be localized. Touch position sensing is possible but tends to be very sensitive to mounting, wear, and dirt. There are really cool technologies developed, but there's a reason you don't see many in mass production even after 20 years. You have to have a VERY reliable and useful feature to get integrated into UI and the OS.
- sandworm101 3y ago>> This perceptual dissonance limits our ability to immerse ourselves in the experience. As opposed to the perceptual dissonance of seeing a person inside a small rectangle we can hold in our hands? Or the strangeness of hearing an entire orchestra while sitting on a bus? The fact that sound emanates from a slightly unnatural place or direction isn't a problem worth addressing, despite the fact that fixing it might make phones 1mm thinner. How about this: Give me a phone with a proper usb port, a couple sim cards, an SD slot, a replaceable battery and a headphone jack. I couldn't possibly care any less about making it any thinner. It's going into a protective case anyway.
- fkyoureadthedoc 3y ago> Give me a phone with a proper usb port, a couple sim cards, an SD slot, a replaceable battery and a headphone jack. I couldn't possibly care any less about making it any thinner. It's going into a protective case anyway. Almost nobody wants this phone. Sure you'll get cheered on by some small group of people that wouldn't actually buy this phone either, but it just wouldn't sell well enough to justify its existence. There's probably already a phone with most of these features.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- matly 3y agoYou'd be surprised about the amount of people wanting this kind of smartphone. The success of Framework, who are doing something similar in the Laptop world, could be a robust indicator for the demand. Especially the replaceable battery is something we really should get back to IMHO.
- scarface_74 3y agoThe “success” of Framework? By what metric are you defining success?
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- olelele 3y agoAs far as my experience goes and from what I know of audio engineering piezo-electric elements are terrible at flat frequency response and mostly unusable except as beep generators. There are (older?) models of Behringer cheapo PA-speakers with piezos as high-frequency drivers and they are beyond terrible. Didn't deep read the article however found no hard info as to if some kind of breakthrough has been made.
- elzbardico 3y agoReally, I don't want a thinner phone.
- StreetChief 3y agoJoe Grand has a fantastic video experimenting with the tech, where he builds "the world's thinnest boombox": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bZFQDeBpHmg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bZFQDeBpHmg
- wkat4242 3y agoI'm pretty sure that Xiaomi tried this with the first mi mix and LG with the crystal. They were all first gen full screen phones. The results were pretty crap. Muffled audio and such. I don't really see the benefit because speakers are tiny as it is. And pressing on the screen will significantly alter its resonance.
- Giorgi 3y agoCorrect, I had a Xiaomi Mi Mix back in 2017 and audio was nice, nothing of spectacular but not muffled.
- wkat4242 3y agoOh ok I never had one but I read that in some of the reviews, I was interested because I worked in mobile phone management and I really liked the idea of full-screen phones (which turned out so great that everyone does it now, of course).
- globular-toast 3y ago> Speakers usually sit on the sides or back of our devices. The sound is supposed to be coming from the image that our eyes see on the screen, but our ears know it’s coming from somewhere else. Then put the speakers on the front. Of course rear or side-firing speakers are going to sound like crap. This is a totally self-inflicted problem and could be solved by just having front-firing speakers like some phones still do. The ghost centre channel should be fine for smartphones. It's not like you have several people watching a single phone complaining that the ghost centre channel is 2 inches too far to the left/right...
- adrianmonk 3y ago> could be solved by just having front-firing speakers That makes the bezel bigger, which (for a given screen size) makes the phone bigger and harder to fit in your pocket. If this technology can move the speakers to the front without making the phone larger, that seems like a real benefit. Especially since phone size is such a common complaint.
- rcarmo 3y agoI think this was tried before and bombed in real life applications because touch or even any sort of site tension would instantly muffle the sound--but I can't remember where I saw it.
- akmittal 3y agoSpeakers are hardly visible in modern smartphones. Do we really want everything to move inside screen
- aitchnyu 3y agoIf future laptops will have a screen replace keyboard and trackpad, can it mimic the sensation of fingers moving across physical keys and the notches on F and J keys?
- Workaccount2 3y agoWhen I purchased my latest TV, I was prepared to also dish out for a speaker system to ameliorate the terrible sound that flat screens have. A junky small speaker shoved in the rear of the panel to wheeze out sounds directly into wall. However in the specs for the TV I saw it mentioned that Sony uses the entire display as a speaker. I was skeptical for sure, but man when I turned it on the first time I was actually blown away by how good it sounded. To the point where I have had people ask "Where do you have the speaker?" when looking at my presently speakerless setup. It's not perfect, it has it's rough moments, but overall it's really damn good for what it is.
- silentguy 3y agoAn interesting use-case could be localized haptic feedback on the screen. You could rotate a knob or push a button on the screen and get a localized sound and haptic feedback from the item on the screen. You may even add haptic texture on the screen. close your eyes and scan the screen with your finger. It would feel like a series of mechanical switches and knobs. It would be useful for people who don't like using only the screen in their car because of lack of haptic feedback.
- peter_d_sherman 3y ago>"So by applying an alternating voltage, you can make the transducer vibrate with rather considerable force. These vibrations can be slow—the kind needed for haptic feedback—or very fast, to the highest audio frequencies and beyond. While creating the effect with ceramic material requires relatively high voltages—in the range of 40 volts or more—it requires very little current and, hence, little power—far less than the power used by mobile device speakers today." I'm not too concerned about the high(er) voltage (than say 5V or 12V) requirement -- but the fact that this, well, let's call it "momentum in an oscillatory/vibratory (AKA trapped) mode" or, perhaps more broadly, "energy" -- requires very little current (AKA "power", AKA "energy") -- should be of interest! In other words, what devices could be conceived of, for this effect, in the future? Also, is there a potential connection here (if so, I don't see it yet! <g>) with warping space (AKA a future "warp field", if one could ever be created in the future) -- and "warping" (if ever so slightly -- on the microscopic scale) the dimensions of a piece of piezoelectric glass -- with a voltage? Well, probably not! (But then again... maybe! <g>) Anyway, a very interesting article!
- alok-g 3y agoAnyone knows if this could produce better bass?
- krystianantoni 3y agoSound is supposed to be as normal, so quality & spacial and technology to deliver that as easy to use as possible Haven’t thin/piezoelectric speakers been around for some time now without much success? What’s different now that makes them better
- callalex 3y agoThis sounds like a repairability nightmare. The number of cracked screens you see on an average walk/bus ride is all you need to know that phone manufacturers are failing to consider and meet the needs of their users.
- whalesalad 3y agoafaik this is how the mouse in a macbook pro works. you can control the click sensation in software because it is 100% synthetic.
- zython 3y agothe home button in the iphone up until the X was like this aswell
- prettydeep 3y agoDidn't Sharp do this a decade ago with their Aquos line of phones? I have one. Quality is not that great, but it works just fine.