8 ms·
Mixed Reality gone in Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 26052
- taneq 3y agoWow, is there any indication of an alternative? Or are they just going to brick everyone's WMR headsets (except HoloLens of course, because that's their one)? Edit: As far as I can tell they're just yanking support from Windows and tough bikkies. I asked Bing about it and it basically said to buy a different headset or hope a third party releases alternative software that can run the headsets. Oh and also no you can't prevent Windows from auto-updating and disabling it. Extremely disappointing behaviour on MS' part. I can understand them sunsetting development, but actively rendering fully functional devices unusable is criminal.
- caslon 3y agoThey announced this a long time ago. WMR headsets work on Linux pretty well nowadays.
- karmakaze 3y agoGoogle search results says in Nov. 2026/2027: > Is WMR discontinued? "As of November 1, 2026 for consumers and November 1, 2027 for commercial customers, Windows Mixed Reality will no longer be available for download via the Mixed Reality Portal app, Windows Mixed Reality for SteamVR, and Steam VR beta, and we will discontinue support." Dec 27, 2023
- taneq 3y ago> WMR headsets work on Linux pretty well nowadays. Works pretty well as in 'apt-get install wmr-for-linux' or as in 'spend three weeks setting up a build environment for some hairy proof-of-concept code which isn't compatible with SteamVR games'? WMR is one of the last things really tying me to Windows, if it's practical to use on Linux I could see myself switching back.
- caslon 3y agoWorks pretty well as in, "Install Monado using your distribution's package manager, set it as your default OpenXR runtime, hit three buttons to get Valve to begrudgingly respect system defaults instead of the closed-source 'Open'VR runtime." Optically-tracked WMR controllers work, depending on how new of a build your distribution has and the type, but WMR controllers are generally considered to be pretty bad to begin with. You can use a different style of controller with a WMR headset if desired. That said, building Monado isn't hard if your distribution doesn't currently have a version that supports WMR controllers. The repo lists all of the dependencies you need, and what they're called for popular distros. It also tells you the exact things you need to run to get it to build; you can just copy and paste the build instructions after installing its dependencies. You can probably get it done within ten minutes.
- sudosysgen 3y agoOptically tracked WMR controllers do not work yet in Monado. Some people have code to do the optical part of the tracking, but there is a bit of reverse engineering left to synchronize the IMUs and control the LED brightness to enable sensor fusion. Hand tracking however does work.
- jsw08 3y agoCan't you use basalt for controller tracking? https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mateosss/basalt https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mateosss/basalt https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mateosss/basalt/-/blob/main/doc/monado/WMR.md https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/mateosss/basalt/-/blob/main/d...
- tensor 3y agoAnnouncing this long ago doesn't make it any less shitty that a fully working still relevant and expensive VR device is now a paperweight. Keeping a minimal framework alive so that the devices can be used with e.g. steam would have been the right thing to do. Also, no one using WMR devices on Windows wants to bother with Linux. Most of us were using the device with things not available on Linux, and even if they were we don't want to run Linux on a desktop. It's not a solution.
- ladyanita22 3y agoThen don't.
- caslon 3y ago> Also, no one using WMR devices on Windows wants to bother with Linux. Most of us were using the device with things not available on Linux, and even if they were we don't want to run Linux on a desktop. Cheaper headsets for Linux users, then! It's a solution in one way.
- sudosysgen 3y agoMost users of WMR headsets had a Reverb G2 because it was by far the cheapest headset with its featureset, and were willing to bother with the issues that WMR brings and tinker around.
- jaffacakes 3y agoI wouldn't call it pretty well, not quite yet. The Monado driver has come a long way, but doing anything useful with it still has too much legwork involved for the majority of WMR users, not including the switch to Linux. Although since the announcement, work on WMR-specific stuff seems to have sped up, so hopefully the situation improves. I also recall seeing a working demo of hand tracking for WMR (maybe just the G2?), so that's neat. https://monado.freedesktop.org/ https://monado.freedesktop.org/ Monado OpenXR platform https://stardustxr.org/ https://stardustxr.org/ Stardust XR display server
- Levitating 3y agoMicrosoft is making Linux more attractive by the day. I wonder if they'll ever get to regret that.
- daviding 3y agoThe official deprecation was made in Dec 2023. Removing it in the next feature update is too soon. Lots of people still having working WMR units, so this feels super cheap.
- tsimionescu 3y agoAfter what MS did with Windows Phone and the first Lumia headsets*, I think you need to be crazy to release hardware that depends on a not-yet-established MS product. They're very good at keeping their successful products backwards compatible and at least somewhat supported for years, but they can dump unproven products like led disregarding any kind of marketing push. * Nokia's first Lumia smartphones released with an older version of Windows Phone, while MS was publically working on the Windows 8 push for a common OS across all form factors. They promised everyone in huge marketing campaigns that the Lumias would be upgradeable to the new Windows Phone 8, which all the marketing was pushing for. Fast forward two months from the release, they announce that no, they would not upgrade and you'll have to buy a whole new phone if you made the mistake of buying a first generation Lumia.
- MikusR 3y agoSo another thing Microsoft abandons just as it starts growing. It happened with Mobile phones, browsers, tablets, AI.
- caslon 3y agoThey've been in the process of pulling out since before the Vision Pro was announced; HP was the canary in the coal mine, firing or moving around everyone they had working on WMR devices a year or two ago. When HP pulls out of a Microsoft initiative, it's over.
- vdaea 3y agoAs it starts growing? Is there any indication that mixed reality in Windows 11 has ever grown?
- andybak 3y agoThey meant "Mixed Reality" in general. The Apple Vision Pro has just launched. You can debate whether it will be succesful or not (please - do that in another discussion thread as it a topic I grow weary of) but the timing is worthy of note.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoSo the entire opinion of "Microsoft leaving as a field starts growing" rests on the Vision Pro coming out and therefore VR growing, but we should not question the fact that Vision Pro is unquestionable proof VR is growing in this thread... No. VR is not growing. Apple was supposed to put out Vision Pro in 2021 when everyone was aboard the VR hypetrain, and AI was not in the public's mindset. Vision Pro is not the VR industry growing, it's an echo from yet another dead VR hypecycle.
- andybak 3y ago> but we should not question the fact that Vision Pro is unquestionable proof VR is growing in this thread... I was simply asking that we don't recycle the same metadiscussion yet again.
- pavlov 3y agoWhy did Microsoft give up on AR/VR just when Apple and Meta have shipped the fruits of their massive R&D investments and are spending to create the market? Sure, Windows Mixed Reality wasn’t great. Maybe in the current marketplace it was the Windows 2.0 to Apple’s Mac. But the old Microsoft would have persisted when underestimated and come back with a sneakily good 3.0 product.
- KingMachiavelli 3y agoBecause Microsoft doesn't get a 30% cut of products sold for it's platforms. Also Windows on ARM hasn't caught on and x86 has only recently been closing the performance per watt gap with ARM. Meta's headset is Android based so it has 18+ years of low power, ARM performance and power tweaking. And Apple is using their in-house M series chips. Microsoft's bread and butter is B2B; Azure, Office, etc. The Xbox and consumer divisions are just too small to take on high cost, novel devices. They've historically not been great at branding or marketing direct to consumer either. (Zune, those Microsoft store commercials, etc.).
- pavlov 3y agoFundamentally those are excuses based on Microsoft’s current market position. When they invested in Windows 1.0, their existing users were not asking for it and didn’t have a use for it. MS-DOS wasn’t a good foundation for a GUI, the IBM PC hardware was misaligned (e.g. terrible graphics), and obviously Apple was miles ahead. The product didn’t fit any of Microsoft’s existing strengths and felt like a toy rather than a credible business tool. By the same logic that’s applied to AR/VR today, Microsoft absolutely should have exited the GUI market in 1988. (They were even a leading Mac software vendor! Why bother making their own worse GUI?)
- bonzini 3y ago> IBM PC hardware was misaligned (e.g. terrible graphics) In 1985 it was terrible for games due to no sprites, but business applications run on the Hercules graphics card (monochrome but 720x348) or EGA, which had decent resolution and was way better than the competition for business applications. It had worse color resolution than say the Amiga, but by 1988 the VGA had fixed that as well.
- threeseed 3y agoThis makes sense for Microsoft. They have a great relationship with Apple and Meta and have already brought their full suite of applications and services to their respective XR platforms. With Google/Samsung aiming for third place there just isn't room for another OS.
- fh973 3y agoThey developed MSFS 2020, which is the killer app for VR headsets, and announced a successor already. At least there seems to be some strategic misalignment.
- LegitShady 3y agoThey're display devices, they don't need their own operating system. Microsoft's problem was actually that they did what you're talking about - Mixed Reality had all of these nonsense things microsoft built into it that didn't improve the experience and just put barriers in front of using the device to play games or whatever. When you plugged in the headset it would automatically pop up mixed reality whether you wanted it to start or not. I couldn't keep mine plugged in and not running reliably. It would restart mixed reality at random times. When you logged in instead of a well designed menu system, they made it stupidly spatial and you had this virtual house where functions were in different rooms you had to navigate to instead of just letting me start the application I wanted. It had a whole new set of widgets and interactions. A lot of designers got paid to create little toys that didn't improve the experience at all and just complicated things. And microsoft's own device wasn't aimed at consumers and cost more than the vision pro, so you were buying HP or some other 3rd party's implementation microsoft's of mixed reality on windows. It was fine to play games but not an improvement over steamvr.
- iAkashPaul 3y agoWho knows we might just get Microsoft Mesh through Apple Vision Pro after all instead of HoloLens updates
- caslon 3y agoFor what it's worth, on the off-chance that anyone at MS who worked on this views the thread, I thought it was cool. I liked what you did. I'm sure that seeing people review the Vision Pro is frustrating, seeing how many things you already did being declared revolutionary. I'm sure it's like that for Oculus developers, too. In retrospect, people like John Gruber and Tim Urban will mock the industry prior to the Vision Pro for not Getting It Right, or for fundamentally-flawed interaction models, ignoring where things were right. Eye-tracked selection was already a thing in the Sony headset. Tracking windows fixed throughout your environment has been a thing in the Oculus inside-out devices since release, good enough to keep track even on different floors. Varjo does reprojected AR better than Apple, for a cheaper price point (though still a steep one). Microsoft, for their part, captured a sort of mundane magic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=97mqPUn-4x0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=97mqPUn-4x0
- andybak 3y agoI still dispute that eye tracked selection will prove to be the correct solution. I think it might be part of the correct solution but eye, hand and controller based interactions all have distinct advantages and disadvantages and I'm very sceptical of anyone claiming that only one of them should be the only option across a wide range of applications. Personally speaking I have used all three and if someone put a gun to my head and insisted that I had to pick just one, it would be 6DOF controllers. (and that's me also trying to take into account future improvements in implementations for each)
- jncfhnb 3y agoI want a little track nub like thinkpads have that’s glued to my thumb so I can click as if doing a bomb detonation movement or do basic 2D movement inputs
- salad-tycoon 3y agoWhat about that track pad you use with your tongue? [1] Or maybe some wires implanted into your tongue nerves that activate cursor movement when you think about moving your tongue and shock your throat muscles when you become apneic at night (a la inspire device). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35684828 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35684828
- taspeotis 3y agoUnrelated but get off my lawn. > We are trying out a new experience for Copilot in Windows that helps showcase the ways that Copilot can accelerate and enhance your work. This experience will show when you copy text – since Copilot supports helpful actions that you can take with text content. In this scenario, the Copilot icon will change appearance and animate to indicate that Copilot can help (there are several different treatments so you may notice a different visual effect) Full disclosure: I like AI. I also like my clipboard being mine…
- weikju 3y agoMicrosoft owns your computer so your clipboard isn’t yours I’m reminded of the 90s era Slashdot that had a Bill Gates of Borg icon for every Microsoft related article. Seems to be where they are headed
- MrPatan 3y agoCan't spell "copilot" without "clip"
- thelastparadise 3y agoActually... CLIP is an image-to-text computer vision model. It has nothing to do with copilot.
- mangamadaiyan 3y agoI think GP was going for a clippy reference.
- teekert 3y agoWe have a potential Linux convert right here guys!
- rogual 3y agoI can't wait to experience this new experience in my clipboard experience. Every time I get upset about the decline of MacOS, Microsoft manages to cheer me right up again.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoFrom the Deprecated Features page which is linked mentioning the Windows Mixed Reality item (https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/whats-new/deprecated-features https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/whats-new/deprecat...): > Windows Mixed Reality is deprecated and will be removed in Windows 11, version 24H2. This deprecation includes the Mixed Reality Portal app, Windows Mixed Reality for SteamVR, and Steam VR Beta. Existing Windows Mixed Reality devices will continue to work with Steam through November 2026, if users remain on their current released version of Windows 11, version 23H2. After November 2026, Windows Mixed Reality will no longer receive security updates, nonsecurity updates, bug fixes, technical support, or online technical content updates. > This deprecation doesn't affect HoloLens. We remain committed to HoloLens and our enterprise customers -- Some more HN discussion about it when it was announced back in December: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38762095 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38762095
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- edandersen 3y agoThese headsets had a nice standard HDMI and USB A 3.0 port. Could have plugged straight into Xbox for "Xbox VR".
- pornel 3y agoWMR itself was annoying and pointless, but it’s required by HP Reverb G2, which is still technically a very good headset.
- Levitating 3y agoI owned a Lenovo headset myself. Imported from the UK for about 200 euros. By far the best price-value at the time. The only major issue I had was of course WMR itself. Why couldn't they just make it behave normally.
- criddell 3y agoI never used WMR, but I never understood why it had to be part of the operating system. Why load that onto millions of computers when so few people use it? IIRC, it was one of the things that Microsoft made difficult to remove. You could uninstall it through some PowerShell incantation, but chances are it would be back in a couple of Tuesdays.
- steelframe 3y agoI own two HP Reverb G2s and am not at all happy about this. I shouldn't be forced to choose between being able to use my hardware and getting security updates. This behavior on the part of Microsoft should be illegal.
- psyclobe 3y ago[flagged]
- NBJack 3y agoThat's a real shame, but it's clear they stopped investing in it years ago. This is just an acknowledgement of that fact. I have a WMR collecting dust as we speak. I loved the concept for a usable VR workspace! And it had a LOT going for it. But too many issues, bugs, and QoL issues were never addressed in the workspace: * Allowing a user to exclusively use a physical keyboard (the floating keyboard would automatically pop up if you clicked inside a text box or app) * Only about 4 windows/apps floating in your view could actively refresh (a damn shame as having a bunch of floating SSH sessions felt quite cyberpunk, and it put tabs for browsers to shame) * Only one desktop view at a time, even if you had multiple monitors * Bad performance on most mobile devices * No support for non-WMR headsets (i.e. I could never use one of my Quests with it) * They made a tease of a Halo demo that never panned out (OK, I admit this was sour grapes, but it was just a tease at the end, just when it got interesting) So much potential. But they basically created version 1 and either never listened to the audience, or never invested in it again.
- bitwize 3y agoAs with other things, the technology didn't really exist until Apple invented it.
- sudosysgen 3y agoOn the brighter side, the Monado project is not too far away from a fully featured experience for WMR devices on Linux, and maybe eventually on Windows, too. Currently, the headsets even work with positional tracking and hand tracking.
- dang 3y agoRelated: Goodbye Windows Mixed Reality, we hardly knew Microsoft's VR software - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38762095 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38762095 - Dec 2023 (74 comments) also: Microsoft has laid off entire teams behind Virtual, Mixed Reality, and HoloLens - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34472549 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34472549 - Jan 2023 (236 comments)
- calamari4065 3y agoI won't miss it. WMR was by far and away the worst experience available on the market. Putting aside the numerous bugs in the VR environment, the software itself was typical Microsoft garbage. It absolutely infests your system and clobbers any and all other VR runtimes you have. Difficult to remove, and once you do uninstall, your other runtimes like OpenXR or SteamVR are still left broken and you have to reinstall those too. I had to develop an app for WMR at the same time we were working on OpenXR/SteamVR apps. I simply could not do my job until I ripped out WMR. We relegated it and the headset that only works with WMR to an isolated machine used exclusively for testing WMR. The industry is much better off without Microsoft trying to elbow their way in to disrupt standardization around OpenXR.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoOut of curiosity, did you try just isolating it into a separate virtual machine? (I have no idea to what extent special pass-through support was needed for WMR.)
- calamari4065 3y agoNo, because Windows would recognize when a WMR headset was plugged in and throw up a big screen inviting you to install WMR at every boot and at random times between.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Log_out_ 3y agoMicrosoft really has graveyard of dead projects similar to Google. Just to highlight What I'm missing from these sites though is a short, snappy lesson and a link to a similar product that succeeded. Basically turn it into a counter argument lookup page. Like this gravestones : " hololens, given up 2025. Succesor: Apple vision pro. Reason: better execution, endurance, clarity of vision. Loss: whole ar/vr market" Make the failure into a monolith throwing shade at incapable management, that left market on the table by half heartedly abandoning side battles. And if your MBA tech career has a gravestone in it and your decision was pro burrial, your career should be over.