6 ms·
The wealthy are cutting the line at the airport, Disney World and ski resorts
- ezekiel68 3y agoSo, just like always then.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bko 3y agoIt's not the wealthy, it's people that are willing to pay. This is pretty basic segmentation. You can pay with your time or money. Kind of like ad free listening/watching. What's up with news media reporting these days?
- redserk 3y agoAt the end of the day, it's yet another $189/yr cost + $99/yr/family member cost to add in. For a family of 4, that's $585/yr or $48/mo. Generally speaking (however, not absolutely true), wealthy individuals typically have a larger amount of disposable income to potentially allocate to this expense. It is not unreasonable to conclude that such a service might be more likely to be used in practice by wealthier people.
- throwitaway222 3y agoOr it is people that are employed where traveling a lot is a requirement. And most likely a company would pay for this upgrade. But why even argue about this, the people that FLY are either wealthy or have a company that is paying for the flight.
- plussed_reader 3y agoHow much business travel directs to disneyland and ski resorts annually? Whether the person is individually wealthy or connected to a profitable company what is the effective difference? The person is experiencing the benefits of wealth; the person is wealthy. It is not a permanent state and wealth/luck change.
- kennethrc 3y ago... or neither
- akprasad 3y agoThe article agrees: > Of course, businesses have long segmented customers The article's argument is that: - This kind of segmentation is more widespread and automated than it was previously. - It's appearing in areas it wasn't in before (e.g. Disney World). - It's extending to public arenas like vaccine queues, access to public lands, and TSA queues.
- tiahura 3y agoDisney introduced Fastpass during the Clinton presidency. This isn’t exactly news.
- adrr 3y agoFastpass didn't cost money till they rebranded it DisneyGenie+ in the last couple years. It was just a way to get a reservation for a ride that anyone could do.
- henrikschroder 3y agoNo, they're charging money openly for it now. It's long been possible to skip ahead of the queues at Disney by paying for it, it was just hidden for most people, since it required that you booked expensive suites at their on-property hotels. If you did that, you could magically get a lot more fast passes than everyone else.
- adrr 3y agoYou get one hour early access if you book at a Disney property. There's VIP tours for $500/hr min 6 hours that lets you cut all lines.
- tiahura 3y agoMy recollection is that in the past, staying on property on the premium floors got you access to the club room and 3 or 4 fast passes per day.
- ysavir 3y agoThat's a perspective that makes sense when all individuals are given an equal income, and it's up to each one to decide how they want to allocate that income. But that's very far from how the actual world works. In reality, some people make very little while having little to start with, some make lots of money, even when they have little to start with, and others might make lots of money while also being born into lots of money. To look at the system and ask "why are people complaining? It's the same price for everyone." ignores that is actually has a different cost for everyone, regardless of what the price might be. And that perspective is what pushes society in a direction where many are forced to pay with their time, while the few who found their way to large incomes/born with large bank accounts, can pay with money, essentially establishing a class tier.
- renewiltord 3y agoWell, we could allocate each American the US Standard Car and the US Standard Breakfast Meal and they can wear the US Standard Clothing, but there are societies that tried that and there are societies that have done what the US has done and our poor people are better than their 75th percentile, so I think having different incomes and charging more for more services is okay.
- piva00 3y agoThe retort to extremes by bringing failures of Communism do not address any of the key points from the parent comment. Red scare is a concept from the 1950s, time to update the boogeyman. Of course it's ok to charge for more services but there's a limit until your whole society is divided into an underclass and an overclass sharing the same spaces, the same rides in a theme park, the same social contexts and can see the divide. That generates social unsatisfaction, people have an inherent sense of fairness (and many animals as well) which can create social tension, boil that to the limit and you have the violence and crime you see in the USA but not in many other developed countries. The statement about what the US does is the right thing because it's one of the richest countries on Earth is ignorant, or simply naïve. Also, a comical clichê of Americans worldview.
- cyanydeez 3y agomostly because people like to believe there's equity where none exists because capitalism is antagonistic to most equitable distribution
- oliwarner 3y agoIt's segmentation in places it never used to exist. A queue was a queue and the idea that you'd allow somebody to bribe their way to the front would have been terminally unfashionable. Yes, it's just the free market, once again highlighting the blossoming wealth divide. There are few ways this doesn't end in rebellion.
- trealira 3y agoIn general, rebellion isn't inevitable. It only happens if people get together and organize it, which isn't guaranteed to happen. Individual people will just grit their teeth and put up with anything if they don't think they have the power to do anything about it.
- chkaloon 3y agoIt seems that rebellion is getting more difficult, either because of better surveillance or social media. It was originally thought social media would increase rebellion and revolution (e.g. Arab Spring). But social media also makes it much more difficult for anyone to emerge as a leader of it. Social media transparency makes the leader mythos evaporate pretty quickly. Arab Spring failed, and no real leaders emerged as a part of BLM or Occupy Wall Street.
- illiac786 3y agoYou're forgetting one very important factor in my view: desperation. This makes a single individual rebel. You get enough desperate people, feeling like they don't stand a chance to get XXX, you got a rebellion.
- trealira 3y agoIf someone is desperate, but there's no group or organization that's trying to make a change somehow, I think they're more likely to turn on those with less power or wealth and scam or steal from others, while looking out for themselves and their family, and not organize a rebellion against the government or against a group of rich and powerful people. But in this case (wealthy people paying to cut the line at the airport, ski resorts, and Disney world), I don't think anyone will feel desperate due to the circumstances, even if they think don't stand a chance at getting wealthy enough to benefit. It may make them resentful, but that's all.
- woofcat 3y agoIs this viewed as a bad thing? I suppose the person who waits slightly more might be annoyed, but would they rather their ticket cost more to avoid these line skips?
- ytx 3y agoI think part of the problem is that value of their ticket is degraded because of the longer wait times. For someone unable or unwilling to pay $$$ for skip-the-line tickets, it would perhaps be preferable for all tickets to cost $$, but remain "fair." At the end of the day it's a simple supply-demand problem, and prices probably should have gone up anyway if lines are getting longer. It's just that businesses seem to find it more profitable to charge extra for premium tickets versus raising all ticket prices.
- VikingCoder 3y agoIf I'm waiting longer because someone else paid money to get ahead of me, I personally wish that a large percentage of that money had to go to some nonprofit... That's my personal take. I get there's no way to enforce it, and it'd be a crappy law. But that's what I wish would happen.
- userulluipeste 3y agoThe issue here is how our position is perceived, right? If it's about feeling better, we may assume that the operator could have risen the ticket price for all, or did what we see instead - chose to take more only from the willing. Doesn't this effectively mean that they partly subsidy the tickets for the rest?
- VikingCoder 3y agoIt sounds like a nice theory. But selling an expensive ticket to them decreases the supply of cheap tickets they can sell to me... Right?
- userulluipeste 3y ago"But selling an expensive ticket to them decreases the supply of cheap tickets they can sell to me... Right?" Yes. But, the tickets are theirs to sell (or give, or withhold). The reason they are selling the cheap tickets to you is because you most likely won't chose to be their customer unless they offer the said tickets at that price, and they happen to desire having you as a customer in some circumstance. After filling as much seats they could with high margin offers, between getting no more money by running with the rest of the seats empty and getting some more money by running with all the remaining seats filled by some lower profit margin offer (i.e. cheap tickets), they chose the later.
- VikingCoder 3y agoYeah, but the cost of my ticket is governed by supply and demand of tickets at my price. Your theory was that selling someone else an expensive ticket would decrease the cost of mine. But I think your logic is flawed.
- j-j-j-j 3y agoDisney & sky resorts are private and are free to charge who they want how they want. You don't like it? Don't use it. But the TSA thing is ridiculous, because it is mandated by the government and their responsibility is to make sure the service is good enough so there's no need to pay to avoid it. Populace keep voting for the same set of kleptocrats, so they get what they vote for. Subsidizing stuff only rich people can afford (electric vehicles, house improvements), taxing income more than capital gains, tax code with loopholes like tax free "charity foundations", etc.
- unreal6 3y ago> Disney & sky resorts are private and are free to charge who they want how they want. Many ski areas, while private bushiness often operate on public lands through long-term leases [1]. Some amount of public access (eg free uphill access to the lands) are often requirements as a part of the lease; I don't see why certain business terms shouldn't be able to be regulated in the interest of the general public. [1] https://www.snow.com/info/colorado-forest-service-information.aspx https://www.snow.com/info/colorado-forest-service-informatio...
- snakeyjake 3y ago>I don't see why certain business terms shouldn't be able to be regulated in the interest of the general public. Implying that there is a legitimate public interest in equal-cost access to rides at disneyland does not seem like a defensible position. That's a bit like saying it is against the interest of the public to charge more prime orchestra seats than second tier balcony seats at the opera. My position is that if Disney wants to charge ten trillion dollars to skip the line to ride a rollecoaster and one cent for a rollercoaster ride with a 40-year waiting period, that's none of my concern.
- neaden 3y agoThe comment you are replying to is about skiing on public land, Disney has nothing to do with it.
- 3y ago
- bayofpigs 3y agoHave always felt conflicted about these policies. Real life works this way but somehow seeing people escorted to the front of the line violates the rules of having a line.
- chankstein38 3y agoYeah part of me feels like the solution would be that ticket prices go up and these programs are eliminated. Which would lead to a similar outcome. Wealthier people would freely be able to go to ski resorts as regularly as they want while the less privileged would have to choose between a weekend on the slopes or paying their electric bill. But it'd reduce the lines because less people would be there and, ultimately, it'd be equal for everyone. So I'm really not sure.
- userulluipeste 3y agoOn the other hand, prices can be risen enough that only people escorted now would still be in them. That prospect makes the current situation a pretty good one.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y ago(Edit, only referring to Disney / other private businesses here, not the TSA part) Is this not a good thing? People, perhaps reductively, complain about how the affluent are hogging all of their wealth, that it's locked up in a way that doesn't flow back into the economy. Is this not one antidote? Have a ton of cash and want to pay 10x for a first class seat? Yes please. Want to buy veblen goods to status signal? Sure thing. Want to hire hundreds of people to build yourself a castle? Lovely.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoIs paying money to go into Disney that goes out of its way to avoid taxes really "going back into the economy?". Let alone a government factor like the TSA. It doesn't feel like stimulation, it feels like companies are profiting off their own inefficiencies. In which case, they have negative incentive to improve.
- userulluipeste 3y agoIs paying money to go into Disney that goes out of its way to avoid taxes really «going back into the economy?»." Yes, absolutely! Even without considering the tax contributions, the mentioned money are already circulating (one step further). Disney is acting as a service provider to the public and also a channel for the money towards their employees, suppliers, 3rd party service providers, and whatnot.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoThe concern here is the whole thing about trickle-down Reaganomics, the concern with this is the enshittification of things that are public services. The TSA for the longest time was something that everyone dealt with, from the overworked mom from the projects to George Clooney. But now, those with disposable income can pay to bypass the inconvenience. (EDIT: sorry, posted this before I saw your edit about the TSA part). Granted, that's how a business works. The entire point of a business is to trade money for convenience. However, when that "business" is something that we deem as "core" or part of everyday American life, it rubs many people the wrong way. Take, for example, the new charge for drivers driving into NYC at specific times. For the wealthy, it's whatever, $15 is pocket change. But for many people who may not have access to public transportation, $15 could be the difference between having lunch or dinner that day. To me, we've gotten to the point where businesses that have become a core aspect of daily American life are going to have to begin pressuring us to either tolerate being second-class citizens or begin paying to continue to live our lives the way we used to with minimal disruption.
- yardie 3y agoHonestly, I don't give a shit how Disney or private ski resorts stratify there services. I do have a problem with a government mandated safety processes keeping that same logic. If lawmakers are going to make it suck then it should suck equally and for everyone.
- yosho 3y agoI'm not sure why this is news. Planes have had first, business and economy classes since as long as I can remember, and everyone knows the feeling of walking through business class to get to your economy seat. Why are we shocked that now other businesses are following that exact same model? A more premium experience at a more premium price is pretty much business 101.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoYeah, and before that we had lords and peasants. A few people deserve to be treated better than other people. It just make sense y'know?
- dexzod 3y ago> By removing the wealthiest or highest-paying customers from a line, there’s little incentive to advocate for better service for the rest. Why would the business want to have a better service, the long lines is the means for the business to make people pay up the premium for cutting the lines. Ideally they would want even longer lines so more people pay the premium
- renewiltord 3y agoThis stuff is great. I have Clear, TSA Pre, Global Entry and it's fantastic. You can lose the TTP privileges easily, though. Someone I know lost their GE and their sister couldn't get approved for GE soon after their uncle (who is not a US Citizen) overstayed his visa and was deported. Multiple million net worth, but no GE (which is fine since in SF Mobile Passport is faster at the moment). Even years afterwards, they never get past Conditional Approval. They have spotless personal records. There are trade-offs here with the TTP and it makes perfect sense to have for people who can make those trade-offs. Ideally, most of life is like this with segmentation appropriate to the setting. If it's a big thing for people to be about data privacy and stuff like that then don't do this stuff. It is perfectly reasonable for those of us who have differing views on this to trade up for convenience. Sure I need to go through a background check and then through this process and every time I change an address I need to explain myself. You don't have to. You don't want to. So don't. Just let me do it.
- ghaff 3y agoTSA Pre and GE are a pretty good deal if you travel a lot or even some. Probably not worth it for the flight once or twice a year. I travel less than I used to and I keep that but closed the window on a fairly expensive status upgrade from my airline last night. I can always do an upgrade a la carte but probably isn't worth it if I don't fly much.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoTSA Pre is pretty spotty from what I remember. You still have to do 90% of what the basic line does, and if the scanner beeps at you for some reason, it's basically an on-the-spot downgrade to the normal line.
- wenc 3y agoI travel a fair bit and have TSA Precheck. It’s very far from spotty. It’s not so much about what you do in line as it is about the line — it’s way way shorter than the normal line. I get through TSA Precheck lines in under 10 minutes whereas a normal line can take an hour when it’s busy. Plus Precheck lines have a higher proportion of business travelers who know what they’re doing and know the dance to get through the line quickly (3-1-1, pockets emptied to tray, no water). Infrequent travelers are usually the biggest causes of a slow line because they’re unfamiliar with the routine. Precheck lines also don’t require you to take off shoes or take laptops out of bag. Even if you are flagged for secondary, you just have to step through the full body scanner. It literally takes 3 mins. I get TSA Precheck as part of the Nexus program and I definitely see its value.
- adrr 3y agoWorst one about TSA is the first class only line. Each ticket pays $5.60 whether its first class or economy. Why does first class get its own line?
- mckn1ght 3y agoThe TSA doesn't have a first class only line, at least not at the major airports I frequent. Are you talking about the airlines' ticket/baggage counters?
- adrr 3y agoI've seen them at most airports next to the TSA pre lines and they are much shorter than TSA Pre, usually no wait to the ID check station. https://www.alaskaair.com/content/travel-info/at-the-airport/security-express-lines https://www.alaskaair.com/content/travel-info/at-the-airport...
- mckn1ght 3y agoI was about to be shocked that I've never seen it at my main hub port for my preferred airline, but then I remembered that I only ever layover at SEATAC, never going through security there. Thanks for linking, I'll have to keep an eye out elsewhere!
- adrr 3y agoVegas has them as well. I notice them when TSA gets backed up and i look around to see what the wait time on other lines are.
- whatindaheck 3y agoI've used these lines several times without a first-class ticket and I've never had my boarding group checked. Nobody cares. It's all the same security. If you get "caught" just play confused.
- fimdomeio 3y agoIsn't by definition being wealthy a way of cutting the line even if most of the times the line is a metaphorical one? If you're wealthy you don't live by the same rules as everybody else.
- _chu1 3y agoI think everyone knew about the Disney World and ski resorts doing this. If you pay an outrageous amount you can get a $70 burger with Mickey Mouse on it and skip all the lines. The airports however, THAT is shitty and should be borderline illegal.
- jimt1234 3y agoI feel the same way about all the new-ish toll roads in Southern California. It feels like the government's answer to traffic congestion is to sell a solution to those who can afford it and ignore the fact that it worsens the problem for those who can't.
- _chu1 3y agoI'm from Alabama and having to pay a toll to get to work sounds dystopian.
- underwater 3y agoI took my kids to Paris Disneyland recently. I could have paid for a fast pass, but the entry fee was already twice what every other theme park costs. I figured I'd get value for the huge amount of money I paid them for a standard ticket. But in reality the lines were ridiculous. It's clear that the Disney is incentivised to overfill the park and make the experience for most of their customers worse so they can upsell people on the fast pass. There's also a massive irony that the happiest place on earth, the idealised version of Americana, being a two tiered system of haves and have nots.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI did took my kid to Disney Sea recently. They had some rides you could sign up for free on, and some that required money. But the dollar to yen is strong, so I guess it wasn’t that expensive. At Disney world we’ve always done genie+, which still doesn’t get us on some rides available only via virtual queue. Still, a ,I h better experience then waiting in lines at universal, who have a much more expensive fast fast system.
- fragmede 3y agoAnd roads! In California, there are express lanes on the freeways now that you can pay to use during rush hour that have less traffic on them.
- userulluipeste 3y agoI wish I'd have such options in other parts of the world, to know that are there for picking if I'd really want them.
- kennethrc 3y agoTIL I'm wealthy ... someone please tell my net worth then, as it's blissfully unaware
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sershe 3y agoWhat other mechanism do they propose to distribute scarce resources? Let's say it's FCFS. I'd like to see cnn-critters write an outrage piece: "larks [people who tend to wake up early] are first in line at Disney World". Genetic (probably) privilege! It's not other guys' fault they have to sleep in! Of course not, it's always the "wealthy". Then they themselves say Clear apparently has 19m members and is planning to expand. Given realistic rate of adoption this is probably top 10% at least (and that would assume more than half of top 10% are enrolled - seems unlikely), hardly "wealthy". Of course, if you don't say "wealthy" you don't get the outrage. One tech angle here is... posting this political, non-tech drivel on HN, for me, just helps convince me that mainstream media is pernicious and that most journalists cannot be trusted. I'm trying to cling to the belief in the importance of the press as an institution... but no, I think with stuff like this, we'd do better without. Can AI, Google, Substack, e/acc, whatever please compete them out of existence already?
- lamontcg 3y agoYeah, the fees in this society are getting out of control, it's exhausting.