13 ms·
Dutch Police intelligence services unlawfully spied on whole population groups
- RamblingCTO 3y ago> Between February 2023 and July 1, 2022, that did not happen in three investigations, the CTIVD said. The supervisory body did not say which communities were involved but did explain that by “community,” it means a population group “based, for example, on ethnicity, religious belief, or occupational group.” So, theoretically, the police intelligence services may have been spying on visitors to a certain mosque or protesting farmers. We really have a problem with targeted surveillance of specific communities like visitors of a specific mosque? Or a pub frequented by known nazis? I don't get it. The article doesn't have enough details to form an opinion!
- n4r9 3y agoI'd be miffed if the police sidestepped the law and tracked my whereabouts just because I was in an organisation where a couple of other members have suspicions raised about them.
- krageon 3y agoThere is a dragnet law, this will happen to you and it is legal
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoI think that's exactly how it works. If you associate with sketchy people or groups, you automatically become a target for surveillance.
- bilbo0s 3y agoI was just thinking this. I mean, we're talking about tracking those hanging out at places where terrorists are known to gather, and associating with said terrorists, however casually? That's just military sense. Are we just supposed to let the known terrorist go to the bar, have his/her coded conversations with an unknown subject, and then let that subject go on his/her merry way without looking any further into the matter? That would be naive in the extreme.
- repelsteeltje 3y agoMight be a legitimate concern, but not enough evidence for Police surveillance. You mention "military sense", but this isn't a war. If there is terrorist suspicion, I'd say it is more in the intelligence jurisdiction.
- n4r9 3y agoFirstly we're not talking about "terrorists" but people who intelligence services have "received a signal" about. That's pretty ambiguous but sounds like it could mean an anonymous tip-off or information from another department. Secondly, no one's suggesting that they let everyone go their merry way without looking into anything. Only that widespread surveillance must be justified e.g. the evidence must pass some threshold and other responses have been ruled out.
- ramon156 3y agoThis shouldn't be news to anyone
- blueflow 3y agoGuilt by association? Also, some tiny question: People you think you associate with or people the Police think you associate with?
- repelsteeltje 3y agoSuspicion by association. I guess I'm a suspect for doing banking at a large bank know to also cater for criminals. Should probably look for a different bank. ...Oh, wait.
- arp242 3y agoThis really depends on the details. If, say, one member of a mosque is under surveillance for good reasons and then you extend that to everyone attending the mosque for no particular reason other than "well, maybe we'll catch something, doesn't to try": that's probably not a good thing. On the other hand, if the imam is preaching violent rhetoric, multiple members are under surveillance for good reasons, and there's good reasons to believe that the violence is an important part of the mosque community in the first place (rather than a relatively small detail): then that's perhaps not such a bad thing. You don't "accidentally" associate with that kind of thing. Or: you probably don't need detailed reasons to put someone in Don Corleone's employ under surveillance.
- n4r9 3y agoSidestepping the law is unjustified regardless of the details.
- arp242 3y agoI was just addressing the "tracked my whereabouts just because I was in an organisation where a couple of other members have suspicions raised about them" bit.
- n4r9 3y agoBut then you're addressing a different point to the one I made! I don't disagree with what you're saying inherently. But the "sidestepping legal process" is crucial to why this is so problematic.
- piva00 3y agoWould it be ok to surveil you just because you are a Twitter user, a known place for nazi gatherings? I'd say it's not ok.
- ramon156 3y agoI'm biased though. Spy on me all you want, i got nothing to hide
- weberer 3y agoWhy stop there? I hear Nazis use the internet. By that logic, all internet users should be tracked.
- krapp 3y agoAll internet users are tracked, either by American and American-allied intelligence services or their own governments, all the time. If you're in the Western sphere of influence everything you say and do on any internet connected device goes to an NSA server for analysis, assuming they don't simply have direct access to your data through PRISM or secret warrants. And we kill people over metadata. You can assume that what the Dutch are doing here is standard operating procedure everywhere, and that any laws to the contrary are just a facade.
- piva00 3y ago
- Doxin 3y agoThe point here is that this is something the intelligence agencies are allowed to do but only if done for a well grounded reason. It seems that step has been skipped.
- MisterSandman 3y ago> We really have a problem with targeted surveillance of specific communities like visitors of a specific mosque? Yes? Have you opened a history textbook, like ever?
- beeboobaa 3y agoI have, and it's pretty obvious that religion causes a lot of violence
- noir_lord 3y agoSo does politics, sports teams, newspapers, TV, radio, various websites and humanity generally. We surveil everyone all the time then?
- beeboobaa 3y agoIt's a matter of severity. If (fans of) a sports team frequently vandalizes a town after their team plays then yes, they absolutely should be surveilled.
- vouwfietsman 3y agoMaybe everyone who worships divine literature that calls for indiscriminate violence, seems like a good start.
- tomrod 3y agoThose occur way less than the religious pipeline of radicalization.
- kingkawn 3y ago[flagged]
- CamperBob2 3y agoNot as much as police.
- Telemakhos 3y ago> like visitors of a specific mosque? Or a pub frequented by known nazis? But the article had a slightly different example than yours: > on visitors to a certain mosque or protesting farmers You changed "protesting farmers" to "a pub frequented by known nazis." It's emotionally easy not to have a problem with targeted surveillance of nazis, but surveilling farmers, who are currently protesting throughout Europe? That's clearly politically motivated surveillance of ordinary, peaceful, law-abiding citizens who dissent from the government's views.
- Thiez 3y agoThe protesting farmers have been blocking highways with their tractors and lighting fires containing asbestos (also on / near highways). You could argue that the former should be allowed as part of a protest, but the latter moves you squarely outside the "law-abiding citizens" category.
- Simon_ORourke 3y agoEuropean farmers appear to be a singular career category where the government(s) will pay you to be a failure.
- olliej 3y agoThat’s the case in the US as well. What do you think agriculture subsidies are? If you want countries that don’t subsidize agriculture that has been Aussie and NZ since the 80s iirc. Though I haven’t lived in those countries for a decade or two now and Covid and various financial panics over the last decades resulted in a variety of corporate hand outs so it seems plausible that those businesses have got some government support since then.
- doktrin 3y agoWhat makes them a singular category in this regard? Genuine question. Virtually all agricultural sectors enjoy some form of subsidy, for what I think are obvious reasons. Likewise it's not like the idea of government money going to less-than-optimally-productive labor is unheard of.
- mschuster91 3y ago> We really have a problem with targeted surveillance of specific communities like visitors of a specific mosque? Or a pub frequented by known nazis? There's one of a hell of a difference between the right to religious expression and the right to drink in a pub. The former is protected in many constitutions (USA: First Amendment, Germany: Art. 4 Abs. 2 Grundgesetz, Netherlands: Art. 6 no. 1 Constitution) as well as in Art. 18 of the Declaration of Human Rights, the latter is not.
- RamblingCTO 3y agoWell, a lot of people, including you, seem to misunderstand me. I had very specific examples in my head with demonstrated (planned) actions against others or the state. I was even thinking about a very specific nazi pub in Germany. It's not about beliefs or religion for me. I couldn't care less and don't agree with "Generalverdacht" or "Sippenhaft" at all. On the opposite.
- anfogoat 3y ago> The article doesn't have enough details to form an opinion! It does, unless your interest is in justifying the breaking of law and abuse of powers. These people were granted amazing powers, are paid from taxes, and yet somehow it's too much to expect that they'd have an ounce of respect for the law and the privacy of their supposed fellow citizens. Unscrupulous individuals who work overtime to figure out ways to abuse their powers. And it really is unfathomable to me how it's possible for someone to be an agent of government, knowing you're responsible for being that for which no one nowhere should trust their government with any powers, and somehow still being able to go about your daily activities without your conscience tearing you into pieces. Impossible to say enough bad things about these specimens.
- contravariant 3y agoI have a problem with surveillance on any criteria that's only marginally more specific than 'people the government doesn't like' or 'people who don't like the government'.
- lispm 3y agoI would think that the biggest problem in the Netherlands is organized crime around drug imports.
- coldtea 3y ago>We really have a problem with targeted surveillance of specific communities like visitors of a specific mosque? That's the very definition of the thing we should have a problem with.
- pjmlp 3y agoThe first rule of intelligence services is that law is flexible, anyone that belives otherwise is in for a surprise.
- _cenw 3y agoI'm more surprised this even surfaced. I get a feeling in most other countries, this wouldn't be known about and everyone would just assume it happens.
- whoswho 3y agoI would suggest, as a kind of an amusing game in possible scenario ideation, to assume that the people who wrote and published this article are running with the presumption that people already know these things are happening. So the main goal of this, therefore, would not be to enlighten an ignorant audience. We “know” that news are orchestrated. They’re not really news because they’re often planned weeks or months in advance. We “know” that the media is there to shape public opinion. But what could they write to appeal to our biases? Perhaps make a subset of us feel righteous, angry, or smug, on a given day? Play to our vices just to play with us and keep us occupied and entertained? Think about every person who posts something like “panem et circenses,” as a response, and imagine the smugness they feel at being so clever, has been a planned-for response from the people setting it all up.
- soco 3y agoI don't believe there can be a real expectation of secrecy nowadays, everything seems to surface at some point. Unless it doesn't and I would never know what I missed :)
- instagib 3y agoSomewhat. It becomes a cat and mouse game of who knows what and will expose that if this is exposed. Once exposed the weight of the threat is lost. Similar to bringing the Gatling gun to the battlefield or MAD. There are a lot of mitigations built in to protecting the things that need protection at an exceedingly high cost.
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoThe lead: > In the four-month period between February 23 and July 1, 2022 In the body: > Between February 2023 and July 1, 2022 Somebody needs to use less chatgpt. At least read it before publishing, geez.
- nonrandomstring 3y ago> Between February 2023 and July 1, 2022 These are Dutch Timecops. The suspects were seen fleeing into the past.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoPlease refrain from baseless accusations of using AI, they (along with dutchnews.nl) are only a small company doing important work, not like large scale mainstream media outlets.
- krapp 3y agoAI is in the midst of a gold rush period. Practically every media company everywhere is trying to find a way to profit from AI, not just large scale mainstream media outlets. At this point 10% of all content on the internet is AI generated, and that number is only bound to increase exponentially until the current AI hype cycle crashes. I don't know if dutchnews.nl is or isn't using AI, but neither their size nor the "importance" of their work has any bearing on whether or not they might. If they aren't now, chances are they will sooner or later.
- berkes 3y ago> At this point 10% of all content on the internet is AI generated [citation needed]
- wkat4242 3y agoIt's very low-effort autotranslated, and clickbaity with all the capitals though. Being a small outfit doesn't excuse them in my opinion. Dutchnews.nl is very different because they have their own community. They make their own content, have guides for expats on how things are working there etc. They get a thumbs up from me for that, and I would recommend them to expats.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- jackfoxy 3y agoA former Oakland PD officer shared with me insight into how police intelligence worked back in the day. And I'm sure this still goes on. It was back in the time of the SLA terrorism and Patty Hearst kidnapping. One of the brothers in East Oakland casually mentioned to a cop "What are all these hippies doing in our neighborhood?" (It turns out they were having a strategy meeting.) This got reported up the chain of command and OPD intelligence set up traffic stops all around the neighborhood perimeter. That was it. They just asked for ID of everyone leaving the neighborhood and recorded them, with special interest in anyone White. When the sh!t hit the fan and the FBI got involved (soon thereafter) the OPD chief told the FBI they knew exactly who was involved. The FBI was dismissive and wasted valuable time. When the FBI hit a blank wall in regards to identifying SLA members they finally swallowed their pride and asked the OPD for the list. That's how the SLA membership was identified.
- rocqua 3y agoI presume you mean the Symbionese Liberation Army when you say SLA? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symbionese_Liberation_Army https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symbionese_Liberation_Army
- Scoundreller 3y agoProbably. But Service Level Agreement Terrorism has a nice ring to it.
- stronglikedan 3y agoThey gave some context by specifying "SLA terrorism" up front, so it's a safe presumption.
- supportengineer 3y agoI feel pretty terrified when I receive an SLA breach alert
- pjc50 3y ago> They just asked for ID of everyone leaving the neighborhood and recorded them Ah, the famous American freedom. Papers please. (in practice, it's practically impossible to stop law enforcement doing this kind of thing at least some of the time, no matter what country you're in or how unconstitutional it is. There will always be groups with little enough political power that they have no redress)
- maxglute 3y agoI feel like there's disproportionate coverage of Dutch intelligence drama/failures relative to size of the country. I'm assuming this is because their media is extra transparent or their intelligence extra leaky.
- Telluur 3y agoI think it's rather to do with the fact that the Dutch language corner of the Internet is relatively super small when compared to the other well connected European nations like Germany or France. We tend to mingle with the English language platforms more.
- turquoisevar 3y agoPretty much this. Plus there are a few “news” websites that bother translating Dutch news articles into English for expats and the like. You see this happen less with French or German news, those are typically picked up by bigger US outlets and get drowned out by the plethora of news from the US and global news that is deemed more relevant to the US market.
- hcfman 3y agoThere is absolutely not a disproportionate about of news on this. In fact what makes is to the news is just tip of the ice berg. And their media is nothing like transparent. In fact there’s a lot if resistance to printing anything like this. If it gets a little old due to delaying tactics on cover up’s then it’s not printed at all. Even if it’s really damning.
- fransje26 3y ago> I'm assuming this is because their media is extra transparent or their intelligence extra leaky. No, there is nothing extra transparent about the general media in the Netherlands. And because they seem to cater for readers with a short average attention span, the articles are generally short and, unfortunately, too often lacking depth and perspective. As an illustration, the NOS (https://nos.nl https://nos.nl) which has nothing of the quality of, for instance, their German counterparts. (Their cycling, ice-skating and football coverage is excellent though) Also, the modern Dutch are not a nation of philosophers, and that shows in they way they think (or do not think) about problems. This might also explain why these intelligence drama/failures come up more often. They will generally not hesitate a single instant to clearly (for foreigners, it is often felt as "bluntly") tell you what is on their mind, and perhaps some employees didn't hesitate to express loudly the complaints she or he might have had about certain law-braking approaches.
- techcode 3y agoWhat happened with previous way where countries (was it "Seven Eyes"?) would spy on each others citizens, as a way to workaround such "You shall not warantlessly mass-spy on your own citizens" limitations? From the top of my head, I recall at least USA, UK, Australia and Netherlands were among those 7.
- dsp 3y agoI believe you’re thinking of Five Eyes.
- tromp 3y agoThe Five Eyes (FVEY) is an Anglosphere intelligence alliance comprising Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States. says https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- White_Wolf 3y agoMaybe 9 eyes? The countries involved in the 5 Eyes, 9 Eyes, and 14 Eyes alliances and their partners Five Eyes countries: United States, United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand Nine Eyes countries: The Five Eyes plus Netherlands, Norway, Denmark, and France Fourteen Eyes countries: The Nine Eyes plus Italy, Germany, Belgium, Sweden, and Spain Partners of the 14 Eyes: Israel, Japan, South Korea, Singapore, British Overseas Territories
- techcode 3y agoAh yes 9 eyes - I was thinking there were 5 and then 7 eyes (and recalled NL wasn't in the first group). While trying to find years old news articles that mentioned some specific instances of Dutch doing "quid pro quo spying" for another countries ... So far I ran into https://www.jns.org/dutch-agency-spying-on-holocaust-survivors-for-years-defies-any-idea-of-civilization/ https://www.jns.org/dutch-agency-spying-on-holocaust-survivo... And holocaust survivors fits description of OP news article? /Note I didn't read this JNS article, nor know if website is credible/
- olliej 3y agoWait it’s not that monitoring an entire community is illegal, it’s just that they didn’t haven’t sufficient justification in some cases? Wtf
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nonethewiser 3y agoThis will be a problem as long as there is surveillance.
- apapapa 3y agoInspired by the US government ?
- hcfman 3y agoThe Dutch also have a law that they cannot involve a civilian in long term observation for more than a year and then they need to provide them with a contract in advance but they don’t give a shit. I know that they have kept this up for more than 10 years and is not left at surveillance but also involves harassment and criminal offences. And also against none criminally involved people. They have their laws and they have what they do. The laws are just to pacify people. But they are structurally ignored.
- hcfman 3y agoAround 20 years ago there was a big affair in the Netherlands called "The IRT affaire", Where the government themselves were becoming the biggest drug dealer. I know about this because I built the search engine for this dossier (file) for the NRC handelsblad at the time, a very large Dutch newspaper (Before later building one of the first national search engines for the Netherlands, Search.NL (https://www.eindhovenfotos.nl/1/ilse.nl.html https://www.eindhovenfotos.nl/1/ilse.nl.html)). This caused a huge shit storm. Then there was a silence for 4 years, then they started again but learned from their experience. This time they shared the blame and formed the RIEC, an intelligence agency. The RIEC actually carries out their work through "their partners", police, council etc. This shared the blame, learning from their mistakes going on here. They also have deniability, they only give the partners instructions to follow, no reasons, they are instructed to keep only the bare minimum of information in their computers (Only what is absolutely necessary, which could in principle mean everything, it could be all done by word of mouth). So they keep that secret and the partners just do what they are told, doesn't matter how immoral it is. And finally, the organisation itself was formed without a human representative as the head. This technicality makes it be above the law in the Netherlands, you cannot sue an organisation if it doesn't have a human representative at the top. So the information about all of these activities are stored in computers by the RIEC, out of touch from accountability. This new structure was a success, and they have been undermining democracy ever since. This started around the end of 2005 and the formal organisation was started around 2008. When 9/11 started they started to empower the word "terrorism" to allow them to use the word to justify any new laws and powers they wanted. For the Dutch and this new approach they clearly saw the power of the word and came up with their own version called "undermining". And they claim that organised crime is undermining the fabric of society and in order to fight them to prevent this it's no longer sufficient to find evidence and convict criminals, now they need to intervene and take direct action against this. No evidence needed, anything goes. So now the government itself have become the organized criminals. And when it goes wrong, it goes horribly wrong and they simply cover everything up. This is where the press are supposed to be the counter balance for all of this. Unfortunately, the Netherlands have very good muzzles for the press and the press are no where near as proactive at printing stories about this sort of thing than they should be, so they get away with it and democracy itself is undermined more by the government than by the criminals. And the Dutch pushed this approach to neighboring Belgium and Germany who have a RIEC now as well. Why do I know so much about this? Because I was a victim of when it goes horribly wrong. In 2004, I bought a house who's entrance passed literally between 2x other houses. Then end 2005 the guy in right house was busted for growing weed and the the guy in left house strangely appeared to be harrassing him three months before. This harrassment spread to us simply because we complained. Then after more than 10 years of serious harrassment and criminality against me I forced the case to court. It took 5x years (So then 13 years later)! (https://www.limburger.nl/cnt/dmf20180522_00062344 https://www.limburger.nl/cnt/dmf20180522_00062344). We only got to stop it at all by interrupting a live telecast of a council meeting (https://www.1limburg.nl/nieuws/1369805/boze-families-verstoren-raadsvergadering-sittard-geleen https://www.1limburg.nl/nieuws/1369805/boze-families-verstor...). Video of the protest here: (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8RBSKi-UNk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8RBSKi-UNk). When it got to court, the prosecutor lied to the courts tried to blame it on me and then he retired, in 2018. Strangely there was a burst of prosecutors leaving their roles this year and no press investigated as to why (https://www.1limburg.nl/nieuws/1357826/leegloop-bij-justitie-zeven-officieren-vertrekken https://www.1limburg.nl/nieuws/1357826/leegloop-bij-justitie...). After this, once I recovered from the trauma, I investigated as to why a prosecutor would deliberately fail a case and that's when I discovered he was the former head of the RIEC and then all of the clues and events and people fell into place. And I discovered that he had lied in court before (https://www.telegraaf.nl/nieuws/1039807/liegende-officieren-zaak-joep-j-vrijuit https://www.telegraaf.nl/nieuws/1039807/liegende-officieren-...). The entire time this guy was actually being run by the Dutch government itself. I even took the police to court, they appealed, this also took 5x years and I won the appeal as well, I got to see over 1000 pages of police files, in there was evidence the the government were running and protecting the person doing the harrassing for more than 10 years (https://www.limburger.nl/cnt/dmf20180221_00056384 https://www.limburger.nl/cnt/dmf20180221_00056384). The rest is a huge story, which I won't put here, but in any case there was absolutely no accountability possible ever and I did not put a trivial amount of effort into this. So much for the power of the press... Once I researched this it all make's sense. You have to find a stalking case suspicious when for more than 10 years of harrassment, attempted grevious bodily harm, theft and more the prosecutor only asked for 2 months provisional community service! WTF!! During this period, evidence vanished twice. The prosecutor had the role "recherche officier van justitie" part of whose job was to alignment with the head of team interventions as to what interventies they were going to carry out. The head of this department had migrated to be on the board of directors of the court of Maastricht before my case came to court. This same person (former head of team interventions) is also implicated in a case where 9x innocent people were put into jail on fabricated evidence (Search de villamoord https://kro-ncrv.nl/programmas/villamoord https://kro-ncrv.nl/programmas/villamoord), when she was the head of the organised crime unit in Arheim before moving to become the head of the organised crime unit in Maastricht in 2010, the time at which the police had been instructed to never respond to my calls anymore. The press were crap here, ignoring my attempts to get this published, mostly just ignoring all E-mails. No press in the Netherlands are willing to print my story. Mostly because they have ignored all of my attempts to communicate with them, but ones that didn't still wouldn't write about it.I even sent a message to the chief editor of the New York times about it who came to the Netherlands to talk to the press about how the press were the guardians of democracy. Unfortunately, she didn't didn't answer my mail. So much for that. So don't go thinking that there seems to be a lot of press on this subject in the Netherlands, there is no where near enough.
- nonethewiser 3y ago> So, theoretically, the police intelligence services may have been spying on visitors to a certain mosque or protesting farmers. Is this really that unreasonable? Im not sure I agree with any surveillance infrastructure but if you have it aren’t these the first places to start? I think it’s more a question of if surveillance is OK at all.
- Doxin 3y agoSurveillance like that is not unreasonable. The part that has gotten the intelligence services in hot water is doing quite broad surveillance like that without good reason. You can surveil a mosque if you suspect it to be a meeting ground for terrorists. You cannot surveil a mosque just because you feel like it.
- nonethewiser 3y agoThat's not quite the implication of the article though. If you need good cause to surveil a community and individuals then the fact that its a community is irrelevant.
- Doxin 3y agoI'll be honest, I've not read this specific article. The topic was all over the news for a few days here though so I've read plenty about the issue.
- gtvwill 3y agoLol? If they think this is a story just wait til they workout what the 5 eyes have been upto. Whole pop group? Pleb numbers. Cross borders whole nation states is where it's at.
- torcete 3y agoAnd despite this big brother surveillance, they cannot protect their princess from the mafia?
- natehouk 3y ago[dead]