4 ms·
Low-Power Wi-Fi Extends Signals Up to 3 Kilometers
- leroman 3y agoThis is really cool! one use case I can think of is car to car communication to allow them to share some dangers up ahead for example
- Mjr_Mojo 3y agoVehicle to vehicle WiFi communication is standardised under the 802.11p and 802.11bd ammendments. They main difference between 11p and standard WiFi is they have halved the bit rate to increase the range and provide a way for vehicles to broadcast info outside a pre-established network context. 11bd builds on 11p adding more functionality. I don't remember the specifics of 11bd as at the time I was working with the technology 11bd hadn't finished standardisation yet. 11p and 11bd are more generally V2X comms of which there are a cellular variants (C-V2X and NR-V2X)
- kwhitefoot 3y agoUnless you are far from civilization you can just use the cellular network and not need yet another radio. My Tesla gets real time updates for traffic congestion already, it's not much of a stretch to think that it could upload it's location to a server and receive relevant information concerning the surrounding vehicles through the existing channels. Such a centralised system could also do some sanity checks. But in a peer to peer system how would one guard against malicious actors shouting false information?
- Mjr_Mojo 3y agoDirect vehicle-to-vehicle communication can be used to provide a lot more detailed localised info (e.g. heading, speed, current position) on a lot shorter timescales (+ end to end data delivery timelines guarantees) for collision avoidance and warning systems. The current intended standard is to broadcast these basic safety messages at 10Hz but that could be higher with 802.11bd and NR-V2X. Additionally there is dedicated spectrum set aside for vehicular communications on an international level, which helps ensure there is less congestion for these safety critical applications. Using localised peer to peer comms also eliminates some of the privacy concerns with directly sharing this info with a centralised authority as well as removing the need for any global persistent identification for this info. They also eliminate any reliance on the cellular network/internet which cannot be guaranteed to function normally for safety critical communications. There are also alternate cellular standards for vehicle to vehicle comms called C-V2X and NR-V2X so it's entirely feasible one cellular radio could do general data comms and the P2P safety standards.
- iisan7 3y agoThat's great but I'm still left wondering about the malicious actors problem. I thought consensus from multiple vehicles but easily spoofed. Validation against third party data but then what's the point. I can't see an easy way to improve trust, and without it I don't see the feasibility of this approach.
- refulgentis 3y agoRight, but no one's trying to build systems that rely on precise velocity & its deritatives & related measures from nearby emitters - its implausible physically as well, your velocity can change very rapidly for reasons beyond your control. But they are being used to build systems that are advisory or are closed systems.
- iisan7 3y agogood points. driver advisory ("possible slowdown/disabled vehicle ahead") or closed systems (cargo road trains) make a lot of sense.
- westurner 3y agoCould this [1] be possible with "Wi-Fi HaLow, based on the IEEE 802.11ah standard", too?: [1] "Sensor-Free Soil Moisture Sensing Using LoRa Signals" (2022) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38768950 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38768950
- westurner 3y ago- "43 km line of sight with USB WiFi stick (2005)" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30541576 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30541576 - Kreosan English's modded lunar rover WiFi antenna videos: "100s of km" https://youtu.be/Nk-nj_BwoBE?si=0iwpQBFs9ZqFP0p8 https://youtu.be/Nk-nj_BwoBE?si=0iwpQBFs9ZqFP0p8 ... 10x: https://youtu.be/GWq6L94ImX8?si=V2R8hpa3vAosbhvi https://youtu.be/GWq6L94ImX8?si=V2R8hpa3vAosbhvi
- int_19h 3y agoWhen you have unobstructed line of sight, a 5W handheld can reach all the way up to ISS without problem. It's very different on the ground, though, especially on high frequencies, where much smaller objects can prevent propagation.
- westurner 3y agoAre helically-polarized emissions more likely to have higher S/N at range and through e.g. plasma? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39119248#39132365 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39119248#39132365
- zokier 3y ago1Mbps over 3km doesn't sound exactly impressive by itself. People have been doing multikilometer wifi links for ages now. Random paper reviewing some of them: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/281644239_Outdoor_Long-range_WLANs_A_Lesson_for_IEEE_80211ah https://www.researchgate.net/publication/281644239_Outdoor_L... Select example: > Next, Paul et al. [62] reported on their observation of the WLAN link performance in open outdoor networks. The deault packet size was 1470 B for all reported measurement campaigns. They achieved a maximum range of 1800 m LOS at 148 Mbps with IEEE 802.11n links in outdoor locations for back-haul connection among WLAN APs. I'm sure there are things here making the actual tech impressive, presumably biggest thing being power consumption and size. But just saying that the demo is not doing much when they don't provide any details of the setup.
- lxgr 3y agoWith what antenna type? IoT-like use cases often don't lend themselves towards the usage of highly-directional, large antennas and high-power transmitters.
- zokier 3y agoThat's exactly the problem, this demo doesn't tell anything about antennas or power levels, so it's completely impossible to say if their thing is worth anything.
- akira2501 3y agoThis appears to be their development kit. https://www.mouser.com/catalog/specsheets/MorseMicro_142024_MM6108_EKH01_ProductBrief_Final.pdf https://www.mouser.com/catalog/specsheets/MorseMicro_142024_...
- teleforce 3y agoIf you want an excellent reference using Wi-Fi for long distance coverage plese check this book, but it's a bit dated and out-of-print now: Deploying License-Free Wireless Wide-Area Networks: https://www.ciscopress.com/store/deploying-license-free-wireless-wide-area-networks-9781587050695 https://www.ciscopress.com/store/deploying-license-free-wire... For long distance terrestrial wireless communication on sub GHz wireless frequency, now people normally use Low Power Wide Area Network (LPWAN) solutions like LoRa, SigFox or ELTRES, but SigFox has been out of business, and ELTRES being Sony mainly limited to Japan at the moment. That leaves majority of the LPWAN installation based on LoRa. LoRa however is not without its problem namely the spreading factor (SF) between 8 and 12 limitations, if you want to go further you really want to use the highest SF but the bandwidth goes down exponentially and instead of Kbps you have merely lowest bits/bytes speed transmission even with clear Line-of-Sight (LoS). We have tested LoRa transmission over the sea (island to mainland) and it even works for more than 20 km. That's OK if you have only IoT systems where the job is turning some remote switch or relay to be on or off. There is a real need for efficient low power higher bandwidth transmission (Mbps range not Kbps) and this how HaLow by IEEE as inside this post come into the picture, and another cellular based Reduced Capability (RedCap) standardized in 5G release 17 standard by competing organization 3GPP. These new standards has more higher bandwidth than the existing LoRa and existing 4G/5G standards for examples NB-IoT and LTE-M but the facts the latter standards use existing 4G/5G infrastructure is a big plus and the latest RedCap standard want to capitalize on that.
- jokoon 3y agowell at some point, long distance wifi is just a 4G/5G antenna of course the protocol is not the same, but it's not very different either 4g/5g might also have techniques to improve connectivity in a 3km radius when you have buildings and so many other problematic things, while wifi was designed for building interiors. I don't know how expensive is a cheap 5G antenna, but seems like it's a tech designed for longer distance, so why use wifi?
- ComputerGuru 3y agoBecause the frequency doesn’t require a license and its use won’t land you in jail?
- transcriptase 3y agoYeah, there are very few frequency ranges where you don’t need to be licensed and meet regulations that generally prevent a given idea from working even if technically possible.
- sidewndr46 3y agoWell in pretty much all cases you need to meet regulations. The difference is some bands allow operation without type acceptance at very low power limits.
- ianburrell 3y agoI think what we need is cheap 4G or 5G microcells. The difference between Wifi and 4G/5G is that 4G/5G requires lots of infrastructure to run. Then need a non-profit provider. Let's anyone sign up and manage cells. It runs in the CBRS bands. It is open to anyone. Although, might be commercial opportunity to restrict access for businesses and households.
- transpute 3y agohttps://www.researchgate.net/publication/317433640_Using_UNII-3_Wi-Fi_Frequencies_to_Establish_Long_Distance_Point-to-Point_Links_Experimental_Validation https://www.researchgate.net/publication/317433640_Using_UNI... > This paper demonstrates the use of Unlicensed National Information Infrastructure (UNII-3), 5.725-5.825GHz, Wi-Fi frequencies, in the IEEE802.11a/n standard ... A link distance of 24.3 kilometers, the longest so far, has been achieved. An average peak throughput of 98.4Mbps has been observed ... using a TDMA based Wi-Fi radio overcomes the fundamental challenges associated with the use of the off-the-shelf Wi-Fi radio whose Media access layer is based on CDMA/CA MAC protocol. 2021, "Open-source private LTE and 5G networks", 600+ comments, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27946947 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27946947
- boringuser2 3y ago>Most people have probably experienced the frustration of weak Wi-Fi signals. Even getting a network to cover every corner of a fairly modest house can be a challenge That's... not why your AP signal is weak. It's because of laws that limit your broadcast strength.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sidewndr46 3y agoFrom my experience with in-home WiFi most access points can cover a house just fine. The issue is even in the suburbs, you have dozens of other signals on the same frequency. So your signal to noise ratio is awful, leading to it being unusable in the spots farthest from the access point.
- boringuser2 3y agoI've managed to mostly mitigate this problem using a ruckus r710, which competes expertly for air space. Saturates fully. 2.4ghz is still too crowded in urban environments, but every smart device on it has enough bandwidth to function. I've given up trying to improve this after spending a decent amount of time and money.
- sidewndr46 3y agoI use the DFS bands when I can in the US
- hinkley 3y agoApartments are also no fun. Not just the people on your floor and the neighboring ones, but the next apartments as well.
- hinkley 3y agoIf memory serves the early wrt54g replacement firmwares could go to around 2x the legal broadcast limit. I assume they still can. Unlikely to be caught doing it, unless you live in the urban core. And for an apartment, a directional antenna likely would have sufficed for many uses, prior to MiMo ubiquity.
- nammi 3y agoBarely related, but reminded me that a recent comment here linked to this DEFCON talk from a former darknet vendor. He claimed to use WiFi from a house a mile away using a Yagi antenna https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01oeaBb85Xc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01oeaBb85Xc
- bb88 3y agoPringles can wifi hacking has been around since 2005ish. I also remember someone using a spider strainer as a cheap handheld dish with a USB stick wifi transceiver placed near the focus. https://www.instructables.com/Wifi-Signal-Strainer-WokFi/ https://www.instructables.com/Wifi-Signal-Strainer-WokFi/ At some point people were trying to set the record for the longest range wifi signal.
- wtallis 3y agoEven 20 years ago, WiFi distance records were mostly a matter of geography. The limit quickly became the curvature of Earth's surface, so the ideal geography was two mountains, separated by empty ocean in the middle, with easy access up their facing slopes.
- tyingq 3y agoThere's troposcatter...bouncing off the troposphere. That's been around with microwave transmission for quite a long time. Requires a little more power though.
- sidewndr46 3y agoWiFi links over a mile is kind of amateurish. 3+ miles is easy to do if you've got a little bit of elevation and the surrounding land is flat
- squarefoot 3y agoWith the right directional antenna you can already go like 10 miles and more. I certainly went over 1 km like 17 years ago just by using a grid reflector antenna connected to a cheap consumer 802.11b access point using legal power and a normal PCMCIA card with no external antenna on the other side. The point of the technology should be to allow long range communications with some speed restrictions but without sacrificing portability, which of course using a big directional antenna is not possible.
- spacebacon 3y agoSo 3 times faster than LoRa but a third of the range on a similar band.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoPeople tend to forget, that if you can transmit 3km away, all the signals from everyone in that 3km circles are being received by your device too. With 2.4ghz wifi in busy apartment buildings, all the channels are overcrowded already, there is some space left on 5ghz, but not a lot, so that's why we've been going higher in frquencies for more bandwidth. We also have other systems for unlicenced long-range communications (eg. LoRa), but once that becomes (more) popular, the spectrum will be full of that too.
- kurthr 3y agoExactly, high absorption creates the localized cells each of which is typically limited in the number of (transmitting) devices. For something like this long range IoT cell to work you would want to create temporal cells or limit them to very low power. The problem is that those require agreement between devices (and noise sources) while simple absorption doesn't (treats everything equally).
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoWould dynamic directional RADAR be feasible? Or would overlapping RADAR signals going in different directions interfere with each other?
- Namidairo 3y agoGiven the passive radar code in KrakenSDR apparently fell afoul of ITAR, one would have to be careful around this.
- kurthr 3y agoSome routers do have 3/4/5 antenna directional antenna systems. I'm not sure if there's enough room or cost margin for an IoT device. If they were only directional then, I'm not sure they would help all that much, if there were other devices in the same direction (within 3km). However, there might be very short range differential (eg quadrapole) that could have faster than r^2 fall-off. The problem is that you're relying on all other devices in-band to do the same. I think that's one of the reasons why unlicensed (ISM in the case of WiFi) spectrum is best used where the natural cell size (due to attenuation) is small.
- zw123456 3y agoA few years back, I had a condo on Lake Washington (east of Seattle) and a buddy of mine is a microwave engineer and we were hanging out one day out on my deck with our laptops and he mentioned how amazing it was that there were so many WiFi signals and he said he had a 4 foot dish from a 2ghz MW link in the junk pile at work that they had replaced with a newer 11Ghz link. He went and got it and we put a USB WiFi dongle on the feed horn on a tripod and it was amazing, we could point it across the lake and get all these WiFi hot spots some were open. It just shows, a big antenna on one end really helps with the link budget, of course, the beam width is super narrow so it's pretty finiky on the positioning. I am not sure the distance exactly there but it had to be a mile or two.
- 7373737373 3y agoI liked this video for showcasing (directional) long range wifi: https://youtu.be/lYJFwXw1ZIc https://youtu.be/lYJFwXw1ZIc There is hardware advertised for 1Gbps for 100+km links!
- greggsy 3y agoIn Australia, people are ripping out those old 11ghz tv dishes (when they remember they have them on thier roof still) now that the DVB-T free to air is somewhat decent in cities, and online streaming has taken off. It’s not entirely unrealistic to get several and replace the LNB’s with Wifi adaptors, and set up multi diferectional internet spongeing setup. Of could it would look ridiculous.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Of could it would look ridiculous. Put it on a camper, and it'll look like yet another old hippie tinfoiler from movies/TV shows.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoMeanwhile I just installed three Ubiquiti APs in a ~64sqm (~700 sqft) apartment because fuck if reinforced concrete walls and thick doors are going to stand in the way of us having good WiFi coverage at home.
- rmason 3y agoAllied Media in Detroit is connecting wi-fi over long distances. They find say a church steeple to setup the base station. Then anyone who wants wi-fi they mount an antenna on their roof or balcony and point it at the steeple. I am not certain of the distances they get but I am sure it is at least a mile. Here is an article on their project and they have published a book on the what they're building in Detroit. It is a charity that I personally support. https://medium.com/read-write-participate/connecting-the-unconnected-in-detroit-f56790bea8e0 https://medium.com/read-write-participate/connecting-the-unc...
- minipark 3y agoIs the 900 MHz band open for public use? I don’t think that’s the case, at least in Europe. So this does not seem to be consumer electronics.