6 ms·
This is a great writeup. I am not a lawyer, but I've received several C&Ds for various things over the decades. The first one scared me to death. The second an
by JohnFen 3y ago
This is a great writeup.
I am not a lawyer, but I've received several C&Ds for various things over the decades. The first one scared me to death. The second and subsequent ones did not, because I understood what they were: just the company saying "I don't like what you're doing".
When I receive a C&D, the first thing I do is talk to my attorney and go over what the C&D is complaining about. If I think I'm doing something that could be legally risky (which does not automatically mean doing something actually wrong), then I change that. Otherwise, my attorney acknowledges that the C&D was received and I ignore it. If they really have a serious beef with what I'm doing, they need to actually sue me. I have yet to be sued.
- smallfryty 3y agoDo you have an ip defense insurance policy ?
- mysterydip 3y agoWhat's the proper course of action if you don't have an attorney?
- throwup238 3y agoIf you eat the stationary that the C&D is printed on, it's like it never existed (IANAL).
- gwright 3y agoI'm going to avoid the snarky "hire an attorney" answer but once you get past that necessary first step I do have a few tips: * get comfortable reading legal documents, this will allow you to have more intelligent conversations with your attorney * don't let your attorney make your business decisions, one of their jobs is to point out risks, one of your jobs (owner/ceo/leadership) is to figure out how to mitigate risk but that is not the same thing as avoiding all risks * learn to draft legalese, it will help minimize your attorney's billable hours
- mysterydip 3y agoI appreciate that. As someone with a hobby making software, I can see the need for hiring at some point but I don't even know where to start. Do you just look up one online and call and say "I got a nasty letter, will you be my attorney"? Is there some kind of ongoing subscription cost to keep being "my attorney" or just pay per hour when you have an issue?
- chociej 3y agoFor small, transactional dealings where the amount of work is easy to predict, there may just be a fixed fee for that. For more open-ended work, it is often billed by the hour (time and expense). If the work is non-trivial, they may ask for a retainer, which is a down payment against future hourly work and expenses incurred by the firm. Another common billing model, called contingency, is generally reserved for cases where the firm is optimistic they will be able to receive a significant monetary judgment or settlement, which they will take part of for their time and effort.
- hiddencost 3y agoGetting connected to an attorney by someone you trust is the best path. Just picking one after googling is dangerous. Expect to pay more than you expect to pay. ETA: America is a "pay to play" country, and those payments are mediated by lawyers. What I mean is: enforcement of laws mostly happens via suing people, and you need to be able to pay an attorney to win that suit.
- ncallaway 3y agoI’d start by asking people around you if they know an attorney. Recommendations from people you know will almost always be more valuable than a Google search. If you don’t know anyone that would be in the area of law that you’re looking for, ask for _any_ attorney recommendations, then ask those attorneys for recommendations for people in the area of law you need. If you absolutely cannot find a lawyer through people you know (and, really, try asking people), then you can look up a lawyer referral service for your state. Most state or county bars will have some program for making referrals to lawyers. Often these will have a low-ish flat fee, which will get your a short initial consultation with a few lawyers in the relevant area of law. For billing, it’s something to ask your lawyer, thought most lawyers will have some kind of billing program where you pay hourly for what you use, and don’t need to pay some ongoing fee just to have the lawyer as “your lawyer”. Small business that only need a lawyer for a few hours a couple times a year aren’t uncommon clients for business lawyers.
- JohnFen 3y agoMy main piece of advice is to get an attorney, preferably one who has experience in your industry. They know more about how this stuff really works than you or I ever will, and you won't be able to judge what risk you're really taking without that knowledge. But, if I were operating "without a net" like that (which I would never do!), and I really felt that the C&D was about something I wasn't doing wrong, I'd be inclined to ignore it. There's chance that you'll end up being sued, though, so you should be prepared for that possibility. That means you'll need an attorney anyway, and it will cost more than consulting one about a C&D to begin with.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y ago> They know more about how this stuff really works That's really the key. I used to work for a very small company that happened to have an attorney as one of the owners (there were a lot of cooks in that particular kitchen!). One day he came to me with a letter from a large RAM manufacturer demanding payment for a license on some technology I don't even remember. His only question was "do we use anything they make as far as you know?" "Nope." "OK. It's just a fishing expedition." Balls up the letter, throws in the trash and walks away.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoYou are entitled to sue to get a court to state that you have the legal right to do something. Probably overkill, but I bet it would get a surprised pikachu face from the C&D sending company. Now whether it's a good idea to sue without an attorney, I have no idea. I genuinely don't.
- bigfatfrock 3y agoMultiple C&Ds?! You make me realize I might not be living the adventure I should be.
- nostromo 3y agoThey're usually more boring than you might realize. For example, if your new business's trademark is similar to an established company's.
- JohnFen 3y agoYes. Most of the C&Ds I've received have been mundane. My favorite one was over a set of game rules that I wrote that were very vaguely similar to a board game that was on the market. That one was so ridiculous that I didn't consult my attorney at all about it. I just told the company to sue me. I never heard from them again.
- ben_w 3y agoMine was where a customer who had signed a contract with ${company} to make and distribute an app, sent a C&D to stop distributing the app. Not even sure how that happened. New lawyer? Lost paperwork?
- zamadatix 3y agoYeah, we received one about having t-shirts that said "network ninja" for instance. We held a small party that afternoon celebrating that someone actually noticed our marketing.
- JohnFen 3y agoI think I've just been doing this for a long time.
- stephenhuey 3y agoBefore we sold our fintech SaaS startup in 2015, we received a C&D from Dealogic and I thought, wow, we've made it into the big leagues! My adrenaline wore off pretty quickly though, because after our attorney sent them a defiant letter warning their London law firm to not mess with a Texas LLC, we never heard from them again. We were flying below the radar, so we just surmised some Dealogic customer had showed a Dealogic sales rep our product, and they probably carpet bomb anytime they see anyone playing anywhere near their entrenched & wildly expensive product.
- hodgesrm 3y ago> I am not a lawyer, but I've received several C&Ds for various things over the decades. The first one scared me to death. The first time I got a letter for a trademark issue it seemed completely hostile and threatening. My lawyer said, basically, that it was no big deal and that they were in fact being pretty nice. We answered back and everything was resolved amicably. It actually turned out well because it made me realize we had not been paying enough attention and were unthinkingly referencing other brands instead of our own.
- bokohut 3y agoMultiple C&D recipient here as well which upon receiving the first, as some commenters have shared, I too may have needed an underwear change while reading the legal verbiage. However as with many things in life though once you get through the initial experience the latter experiences only get easier. My personal take is I must be doing something of value if other’s lawyers are writing me threatening letters. IANAL so YMMV
- person23 3y ago>once you get through the initial experience the latter experiences only get easier. Just for clarification, do you mean soiling your underwear or dealing with a C&D?
- hyperdimension 3y agoYou eventually get used to either, I suppose.
- dheera 3y agoIt's weird to me that big tech hasn't thought about offering a financial reward with C&D's. "We will pay you $10000 if you C&D" seems like pennies to them, much less than the cost of legal fees, a nice amount of cash for a personal project that hasn't monetized yet. Or a job "We will give you a job offer to work on X if you C&D your own work on X" also seems like a great strategy. If someone has already demonstrated enough talent to be a threat to your company, it seems like it would make full sense to try to hire them.
- bluefirebrand 3y ago> Or a job. "We will give you a job offer to work on X if you C&D your own work on X I'm honestly surprised this doesn't happen more in the gaming industry with companies buying big name mods and hiring the mod writers. I know a lot of mod writers would probably be opposed because they actually just want to make free stuff, but some would probably launch careers off of it.
- ntqvm 3y agoThis exact situation happened with Roblox - they shut down then hired the biggest cheat developers for their game. Kinda funny.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoYeah, there are examples of it happening here and there. That's part of why I'm surprised it doesn't happen more. It seems like an easy avenue to hire talented and passionate people who want to work on your thing.
- BobbyTables2 3y ago> It's weird to me that big tech hasn't thought about offering a financial reward with C&D's. That would be incentivizing bad behavior! There is already a reward — they’re giving you a chance to fix their problem for free before they take you to court and sue you for damages.
- 3y ago