10 ms·
Android now lets you transfer eSIMs between your phones
- mschuster91 3y agoNow that's interesting. Normally, the entire point of having a SIM in the first place is to have a secure storage element for the crypto keys authenticating the subscriber to the network... so similar to a TPM, it doesn't make sense for anyone to be able to extract the private key material, while it does make sense to be able to import new key material while at the same time only allowing authorized parties to do so - hence the entire dance with eSIM provisioning and multiple layers of cryptography involved. But what's described in the article, at least to me, is that the source eSIM only creates some sort of token that a backend in the carrier then uses to provision a new set of keys for the destination device - so there will at least be some sort of record of such a change, and hopefully a way to prevent eSIM transfers... because otherwise this will be a pretty nasty attack vector, all you'd need to take over someone's phone number is to get their phone unlocked in your hands.
- jksflkjl3jk3 3y agoIf it's just transferring the provisioning token over to the other phone (which is what it does sounds like), I wonder why the tool is needed and one couldn't just reuse the QR code used to install the eSIM initially.
- asdaq1312512 3y agoDepends on the carrier if the QR code can be re-used.
- izacus 3y agoI've never seen a reusable QR code. Even worse, if there's a hiccup during provisioning it's usually immediately invalidated and you need to spend time with customer support to get issued a new one.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoeSIMs are superficially about "making phones smaller" and waterproofing. What eSIMs really are about: the industry fighting back against regulations restricting their anti-competitive SIM and carrier locking. eSIMs are about is stripping owners of the control they have via pulling the physical SIM and putting it in another phone.
- rollcat 3y agoNothing a quick regulation can't solve. If EU could make Apple use USB-C and enable non-Webkit browsers, I'm sure same could be done to fix eSIM.
- lakpan 3y agoSee you in 2035 Unfortunately we have to suffer for a long time before regulation follows, if ever. Then regulation follows and we get cookie banners sometimes.
- redrove 3y agoI got bit by this when I bought a new iPhone recently, apparently the carrier "didn't allow" eSIM transfer so I had to go get another eSIM on my carrier's website. How does Android protect against this? The carrier somehow disallowing it?
- lakpan 3y agoFrom the article: > Although carrier support is still limited, Nope. eSIM is crap on android too.
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y agoWorks great for me. Sounds like your carrier is what's crap.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- izacus 3y agoIt does not. eSIM isn't made to help you, it's made to give control back to carrier and them money.
- hef19898 3y agoHow is an eSIM any different from a normal one? I can get up to three eSIM (if memory serves well, did not check) from my carrier for free, plus up to two normal SIMs for free. And the carrier controls all of those anyway. And additional SIMs are below 10 bucks. A more general remarque so, I get it that sometimes companies monetize a tad too much. But then nobody is working for free, no service comes without cost for the provider and we all have to make money to pay our bills. Hence I do not get the "they are doing it onpy for money" attitude, especially on a site like HN with a considerable number of people making litteral FAANG money, money that comes exactly from these practices.
- mitthrowaway2 3y ago
- bgro 3y agoSomeone start a timer for the first 0 day exploit involving this
- codetrotter 3y agoTime for Android users to abandon SMS as their 2FA. (Everyone should stop using SMS for that anyway, btw.) Best 2FA is a hardware device like YubiKey. I have a handful of YubiKeys, that I use in important places. Tying multiple YubiKeys to an account rather than just one is preferable IMO, because it lessens the risk of being locked out of your account when you lose a YubiKey or it breaks.
- Aerbil313 3y agoNo. There is no future where everyone uses YubiKeys, too cumbersome for the average person. Passkeys it will be.
- xescure 3y agoYubikeys only allow for 25 resident keys. Clearly not ready for passkeys, but they can work as a second factor. My setup for the next few years will be: Bitwarden to store passkeys, passwords and sensitive data and a Yubikey that I login to Bitwarden with.
- nunez 3y agoIf only any of my banks supported TOTP or Yubikey...
- nsonha 3y agoWhy is this a big deal? Is it just the equivalence of copying eSIM via QR code or it can actually convert a physical SIM to eSIM in another phone?
- zx8080 3y agoMany services, including banks, have their users second factor auth tied to phone. Hopefully the whole esim and namely esim transfer initiative would end phone as second factor. And yes, I know that options for 2FA are limited in general. But phone is not the best one.
- Tijdreiziger 3y agoBut usually the second factor is tied to a bank app that you have to register in some way, not to your SIM.
- Aerbil313 3y agoPhones are a very good solution for 2FA, considering the requirements to obtain a phone number. The only disadvantage afaict is that SMS communication is easily intercepted and not encrypted.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI thought the requirements were being a near minimum wage employee at mobile network store (in the US) or a call center employee. Which is usually how SMS 2FA are stolen, and no one is liable for the consequences. Which means SMS 2FA is pretty low security. Convenient for most, but secure? Hardly.
- Aerbil313 3y agoWhere I live all phone numbers are tied to national ID. When you are getting a new phone number you need to provide your ID card which has a chip and it is read by a device in order to tie the number to your ID for the phone number to be activated. I assume some cryptographic signing scheme is in action.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>But phone is not the best one. Phones are the best one. Why? Because (almost) everyone has one within reach. Security enthusiasts and believers constantly fail to understand why straight passwords and to a lesser extent phone 2FA never go away: All their proposed alternatives and solutions are inconvenient. Most people couldn't give a rotten rat's undead arse about security, but they will kill for convenience. Passwords and phone 2FA win and keep winning because they are convenient with good enough security.
- nottorp 3y agoAnd that is why I'm against eSIMs. I shouldn't need the carrier's, google's or apple's permission to use different phones.
- IshKebab 3y agoI would maybe say the same except there's one use case where esims are undeniably awesome: travelling. There are tons of apps that let you get very cheap esims in any country, so you basically never have to pay roaming charges ever again. Before esims you would have to go and get a physical SIM from somewhere. I've done it before. It's possible, but it was much more of a pain than esims. The only issue with them I've found is that they're delivered by QR code via email, and the only way to install them on Android (that works) is scanning a QR code with your camera. I had do ask someone to take a photo of my phone so I could scan that photo. facepalm
- nottorp 3y ago> There are tons of apps that let you get very cheap esims in any country, so you basically never have to pay roaming charges ever again. ... you mean, with Google/Apple's permission :)
- addandsubtract 3y agoCan you link some of those apps? I'd love to have a travel eSIM just for data.
- Brajeshwar 3y agohttps://www.airalo.com https://www.airalo.com
- addandsubtract 3y agoHmm... that's 5x as expensive as getting a regular SIM, though :/
- mFixman 3y ago
- egberts1 3y agoStill a major mistake to deploy eSIM; physical SIM is an excellent security feature. Caution: never use eSIM with your real phone number; always get a new phone number just for use with eSIM. OTP does a way better job giving consumer absolutely control than the eSIM does for mobile providers. (Yeah, re-read that last sentence carefully). Disclaimer: I do eUICC vulnerability analysis with eIM. https://www.ericsson.com/en/blog/2023/12/simplifying-iot-innovative-esim-specification-takes-center-stage https://www.ericsson.com/en/blog/2023/12/simplifying-iot-inn...
- TMWNN 3y ago>Caution: never use eSIM with your real phone number; always get a new phone number just for use with eSIM. Yet again, having ported my phone number to Google Voice (GrandCentral back then), and never giving out whatever my current SIM's phone number is, pays off
- TeMPOraL 3y agoHow does this work? I thought GV and other VOIP numbers are becoming universally blacklisted by everyone because "sekhurity".
- asimpletune 3y agoI had a big carrier number that I later transferred to google voice and I've never had any issues with it since.
- oefrha 3y agoIt’s funny, I ported my number to Google Voice, two years later I got kicked off Zelle because VOIP numbers are banned. So how do I send and receive money? Sign up Zelle with email instead. Yes, a VOIP number is a security threat (never mind Wells Fargo has known everything about me financially since forever), but a random email address is A-OK.
- checkyoursudo 3y ago
- Brajeshwar 3y agoInterestingly, here in India, I have had one of the smoothest transfers from physical to eSIM and between eSIMs to new phones (so far). They have itemized steps to follow, and unlike in 2015-2016, these days, I don't even need to talk to customer support. I have done this while I still had access to my old phone (simpler), and eSIM-ed to the new phone. I have also successfully done it after I had no access to the old phone with Apple's buyback-replacement program when the guy who came to my home gave me the new phone, taking away the old one. The one key thing that happened is that they sent me confirmations and steps to the email attached to my carrier. Besides that, the security features kick in, where I can make/receive calls, but data/SMS on that number is blocked for the next 24 hours (so, no 2FA and other credentials).
- obviyus 3y agoInteresting, which carrier? I was told by AirTel transferring my eSIM is not supported. I had to go to a store to get a new SIM (physical this time).
- Brajeshwar 3y agoMine is AirTel and I was successful quite a few times.
- kkfx 3y agoI wait for a "NEW revolution", the plain old ability to log-in to services via a terminal of some kind with personal credential instead of being bound to a specific device... Because that's what we talk about. Big tech do it's best to trap users, let's say WA tied to a mobile phone number that after some time surrender and allow for a web access, still keeping the user trapped, but a bit less. You can enslave as much as you can, a step at a time the barrier will drop. New others will be built and so on, why keeping up the fight?
- KomoD 3y agoeSIMs are great. I have 4 eSIMs on my Pixel 7, 2 active, it's amazing. Getting a new eSIM is also so easy, don't have to wait for a physical sim card to arrive.
- kotaKat 3y agoeSIMs are purportedly great until you try to use them in a small cell deployment and literally nobody wants to talk to a single-cell CBRS operator to deploy eSIMs. I hate the large-scale corporate gatekeeping combined with how insane the GSMA's security requirements and bullshit cert chains keep me from provisioning my own eSIMs for my own network compared to just buying a bunch of ISIMs from China to program in a reader.
- 127361 3y agoIt would be nice if we had an open-source eSIM software emulator. However I think this requires secret crypto keys that are only available to chip manufacturers?
- rasz 3y agoSome preliminary investigations by osmocom team: OsmoDevCall - Exploring eUICCs and eSIMS using pySim, lpac and osmo-smdpp https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9V1Vx35lZ5c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9V1Vx35lZ5c
- ROLELEE014 3y ago[dead]