7 ms·
Google and AT&T invest in Starlink rival for satellite-to-smartphone service
- rightbyte 3y ago[flagged]
- bhaney 3y agoI've never looked into how this particular comm tech works, but surely the phones would need to explicitly transmit to the satellites? I can't imagine these satellites being able to passively snoop on phones that aren't in the middle of attempting satellite communication.
- tyingq 3y ago"Direct to Cell works with existing LTE phones wherever you can see the sky. No changes to hardware, firmware, or special apps are required, providing seamless access to text, voice, and data." ( from https://direct.starlink.com/ https://direct.starlink.com/ ) Seems to imply it looks just like a cellular "cell" to the phone. Which would allow for some amount of snooping.
- nerpderp82 3y agoThe Starlink constellation should be able to pinpoint every handset on ground because it forms a huge phased array antenna regardless if you are a customer or not.
- gruez 3y agoEavesdropping only gets you the TMSI which tells you there's a handset, but doesn't allow track it. If you want an unique identifier (eg. IMSI) you'll have to do a MITM attack.
- tyingq 3y ago"So far the theory. If you look at the Paging Channel (PCH) of cells in real-world networks, you see a significant (10-20%) amount of paging requests that contain paging by IMSI. This seems strange on first sight, given the theory..."[1] So you can't spy on everyone, but you can spy on some subscribers whose phone is in that state. [1] https://laforge.gnumonks.org/blog/20100628-the_reason_for_paging_by_imsi/ https://laforge.gnumonks.org/blog/20100628-the_reason_for_pa...
- teeray 3y agoI think the receiver would need some knowledge of the fact that it’s a satellite. Doppler shift is a physical phenomenon that the baseband would probably have to deal with.
- pests 3y agoThe radio chipset from Qualcomm is what is enabling the satellite connectivity so I'm sure they already have it factored in.
- rightbyte 3y agoI don't know how the cell phone protocols work really. But as tyingq writes I think the satellites behave like a roaming cellphone tower from the phones point of view. And with roaming the cell towers can call my phone, so I guess some sort of id are sent to them?
- up2isomorphism 3y ago[flagged]
- peddling-brink 3y ago> Am I the only one thinking that Google do this to geolocate Apple cellphones? I mean, probably. Why would Google want to do this? > At least Musk's core business isn't spyware. No, that's a feature. https://www.reuters.com/technology/tesla-workers-shared-sensitive-images-recorded-by-customer-cars-2023-04-06/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/tesla-workers-shared-sens...
- hnu234 3y ago> At least Musk's core business isn't spyware. Tesla, Starlink, Solar, etc are all spyware. I guess SpaceX isn't quite spyware but it most definitely is a state sponsored company. Tesla has traded like it is google 2.0 for the past decade or so. I don't think investors are enamored with tesla cars necessarily.
- up2isomorphism 3y agoWhen company lost 50% of its market cap in the recent decades while being central to mobile/cloud and every other opportunities, when I saw the word AT&T in some thing, I don't feel any confidence that it will become anything useful.
- alberth 3y agoThat's a bit deceiving because a good portion of AT&T valuation came from them acquiring DirectTV and TimeWarner to create a unified TV streaming experience, but they have since divested those assets. Said differently, AT&T is not the same company it was 10-years ago. They actually do less things now than they did in the past.
- nxobject 3y agoThe corporate entity known as AT&T survives to live another few more decades!
- SeanAnderson 3y agoHow can any company be considered a competitor to Starlink while relying on SpaceX to get into LEO? If you're relying on your competitor to enable your business model then you're not competing with them. > In March 2022, AST SpaceMobile announced a multi-launch contract with SpaceX to launch its first BlueBird operational satellite.[35][36] AST SpaceMobile states that it will be able to produce up to six BlueBird satellites per month at two manufacturing sites in Midland, Texas.[37][38] The company has attributed delays in the deployment schedule of its operational satellites to supply chain issues and price increases.[39] In March 2023, AST SpaceMobile stated that it expects to launch the first five Block 1 BlueBird satellites in early 2024.[40] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AST_SpaceMobile#Deployment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AST_SpaceMobile#Deployment AST SpaceMobile does not seem like they are operating a viable business model. They have been publicly traded for several years and the market seems to agree.
- awesomeMilou 3y ago> How can any company be considered a competitor to Starlink while relying on SpaceX to get into LEO? Because SpaceX is subject to the same antitrust measures as any other company.
- adventured 3y agoAnd it's a fair bet that SpaceX won't be the only option for putting something like Starlink into orbit over time, so SpaceX might as well take their money and keep it from funding other launch competitors (whether they eventually use Blue Origin & Co, or China, or Arianespace / EU).
- xedrac 3y agoWould that compel them to launch their competitors' products into space? Seems like they could just say "build your own rockets".
- perihelions 3y agoYes—same way railroads were forced to carry their competitors' freight, at fair rates. (That when US railroad monopolies were acquiring the companies making use of their railways, so that they could kill off those company's competitors and leverage their rail monopolies into new monopolies, in different fields. These are old tricks).
- krunck 3y agoI've always thought that any service that gets delivered over media strung on a telephone pole aught to be regulated as a utility. There are only so many cables you can hang off a pole before it becomes a technical and aesthetic problem. I submit that the same goes for satellites in orbit. How many 5000+ constellations will there be around the planet before we run into space congestion/traffic and aesthetic problems?
- Ajedi32 3y agoI suspect you'd run out of spectrum long before you'd run out of orbits. But we'll see. Maybe there are use-cases for megaconstelations that don't require as much spectrum as an ISP, especially once there's the ability to interface with an existing LEO-based ISP.
- lxgr 3y agoThat's definitely the case for omnidirectional ground stations, i.e. most cell phones (beamforming/MIMO as used in 4G/5G and Wi-Fi nonwithstanding, since that mostly leverages heavy multipath propagation which is presumably not a thing for line-of-sight communication to satellites). The only reason there is even a point for Starlink to have more than one satellite covering the same geographic footprint simultaneously is that both the satellites and the ground stations use phased array antennas and are largely stationary (or at least are moving somewhat predictably/rotating in space fairly slowly), which allows reusing the same frequency for customers in the same ground cell at the same time from two different satellites. Highly mobile ground stations will likely continue to be served by a single satellite per ground location for the foreseeable future, which makes spectrum the scarce resource.
- Narkov 3y ago> How many 5000+ constellations will there be around the planet before we run into space congestion/traffic and aesthetic problems? I think you underestimate just how big space is.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 3y agoRival is the wrong word. It's based on scarcity. Satellite-to-smartphone is a massive market, with plenty of opportunity to go around for the foreseeable future. It would be stupid to enter such a large and growing market and believe you're going to immediately punch the reigning 800 lbs gorilla straight in the mouth. That's senseless.
- ttpphd 3y agoAstronomers hate this one weird business trick.
- Retric 3y agoMost astronomers really don’t care. It’s a very specific kinds of observation that get impacted quite a bit, while many others have minimal to zero impact. Starlink could directly fund some projects and completely offset their impact, but that doesn’t seem likely at this point.
- e44858 3y agoGoogle Fi currently uses the T-Mobile infrastructure. I wonder if this new partnership means that it will support AT&T as well.
- grecy 3y agoHow can any company be a competitor to Starlink when they have to pay ~$67M per launch and SpaceX's internal price is something less than half that (likely a third or quarter). Furthermore, how can they compete when Starlink already has 5,289 sats in orbit, and their current launch cadence is faster than anything any competitor can possibly hope to even equal in the next decade. I simply can't see how anyone can realistically be considered anything less than a very, very distant has-run.
- kanbara 3y agoeveryone pays something for launch, no matter who they use, and SpaceX has to build and launch the rockets themselves. Starlink may be getting some sort of deal already, but it's monopolistic to utilise your own technology (especially when it's government funded) and deny others the same right for the same price. additionally, Starlink's D2D is like what 6 satellites? most of the existing sats cannot be used for device connection, so the playing field is very much level and open to many.
- grecy 3y ago> everyone pays something for launch, no matter who they use, and SpaceX has to build and launch the rockets themselves. Starlink and SpaceX are the same company. Of couse they're getting it at cost price. > but it's monopolistic to utilise your own technology (especially when it's government funded) and deny others the same right for the same price Please stop this FUD. The government did not "fund" SpaceX anymore than they "funded" Jeep when the USPS bought a bunch of jeeps for rural mail delivery. Also are you saying Apple must sell computers to competitors for the same price they sell them to themselves to put in their own offices? Of course they "sell" themselves their own products cheaper than they sell them to other companies and competitors. > additionally, Starlink's D2D is like what 6 satellites? most of the existing sats cannot be used for device connection, so the playing field is very much level and open to many. And SpaceX are aiming for 144 launches this year. How about the "competition"? Five on the very high end.
- Angostura 3y agoI'm not totally enamoured with morejun cluttering up the night sky
- TravisCooper 3y agoGlad to see that SpaceX has lit a fire here. We'll look back and marvel at how much SpaceX accelerated our technological timeline due to aggressive optimism and engineering leadership.
- andromeduck 3y agoStarlink was originally a google idea, originally a sister project to Loon, the founder quit and brought his team to SpaceX and then got fired by Elon. Everyone who repeats this story to me says it was because "Elon doesn't suffer fools" but YMMV.
- wilg 3y agoWho was that? Can't find anything about it.
- akreal 3y agoMaybe this: "top designer Mark Krebs, who worked in Google's satellite and aircraft division" https://www.reuters.com/article/us-spacex-starlink-insight-idINKCN1N50FC/ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-spacex-starlink-insight-i...
- andromeduck 3y agoI think that might be it - it was called "Project Air" circa 2011-2015.
- jpm_sd 3y agoGlobal Bit didn't originate at Google X, it was an acqui-hire of O3B which later spun back out to become OneWeb. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eutelsat_OneWeb https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eutelsat_OneWeb There was definitely some weird cross pollination with SpaceX happening.
- ex3ndr 3y agoIIRC first version was very overengineered and team was replaced that built a simpler one.
- glohbalrob 3y ago[flagged]
- asylteltine 3y agoAnd promptly killed by Google a year later
- whatshisface 3y agoMaybe they're hoping having the world's least change-prone company team up with the world's least reliable one will create an average but salable product.
- leoh 3y agoHey, that sociopath vp who hasn't done anything in fifteen years at Google needs something new to puff up his packet.
- ChuckMcM 3y agoWow. A lot of questions about AST here, like "Starlink was already catching a lot of bad press for 'night glare' and you guys are launching something that is literally two decimal orders of magnitude worse?" "243 launches @$85M each is about $20.7 billion dollars in launch costs, that's a lot of money and I wouldn't expect SpaceX to give you a discount." "How many spares? What is your per-satellite cost? How much revenue per phone user do you need to get to even cover the cost of operating, much less the cost of operations and depreciation?" "What is the probability that your 600+ sq foot antenna will be pierced by micrometeoroids? How many until it's no long effective?" "What is your station keeping propellant load? How long does that last?" So many questions. I wish them success, yet it feels to me as if they have really chosen a very difficult path to get to where they want to get to. Success is hard already.
- crotchfire 3y ago> "Starlink was already catching a lot of bad press for 'night glare' I live in one of the least-light-polluted places in the lower 48 US states, and the night glare issue has improved massively. About 12-18 months ago you could see bright dots cruising along the horizon for an hour or two after sunset and before dawn, every day. I can't remember seeing any of those in the last six months. Whatever they did, it totally worked.
- ChuckMcM 3y agoThey did a lot of work to avoid it, there mirror film[1] apparently works well. [1] https://www.extremetech.com/aerospace/spacex-debuts-mirror-film-to-hide-starlink-from-astronomers https://www.extremetech.com/aerospace/spacex-debuts-mirror-f...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 3y agoZoom in on that photo... There are a few interesting things. The antenna seems to be made of a bunch of circular disks, each with a grid of transmitting elements on. To me, that looks like a silicon wafer. That is the only reason I can think of to make that element circular. If so, that many wafers makes this satellite fantastically expensive...