8 ms·
Apple Watch no longer sold with blood oxygen monitoring after patent battle loss
- tamaharbor 3y agoIt probably won’t be long before they are forced to brick the O2 functionality of existing watches as well. Why don’t they just pay up?
- prepend 3y agoI assume because it’s cheaper to lose that feature than the pay the required licensing fee. The patent holder is a medical device company that is probably used to much more expensive price points than consumer tech. So having a $300 watch available that does o2 readings as much as a multi thousand dollar medical device is probably something they aren’t super thrilled about being in the market.
- jkaplowitz 3y agoThey in fact do offer their own "consumer-targeting smartwatch, the W1 series, [with] FDA clearance for providing blood oxygen saturation levels." (Source: the article we're all discussing.) Link to their smartwatch: https://www.masimopersonalhealth.com/products/masimo-w1 https://www.masimopersonalhealth.com/products/masimo-w1 It's actually in the same price range as the Apple Watch Series 9. So their reluctance to license the patent to Apple may be probably partly about competing with Apple, partly about Apple's alleged bad-faith behavior in past dealings with them, and possibly also disinclination on the part of Apple to pay them for a license. But not about Apple's retail price point per unit.
- WWLink 3y agoThere's also a membership that doesn't look optional....
- eloisius 3y agoBlood oxygen monitors aren’t event expensive. You can buy little ones that clamp onto your fingertip for like $20. Seems odd that they couldn’t use their weight to secure a license. Where is the Apple that refused to have the “Intel inside” stickers on their laptops?
- Maxious 3y agoThey were negotiating a licence but their star engineer emailed Tim Cook offering to work for Apple directly after he wasn't made CTO of a spinoff company. > He clashed with managers, demanded multimillion-dollar budgets and wanted the ability to hire his own engineers without approval, Hotelling said in a deposition that was part of a court fight between the companies. After weeks of discussions, Lamego left Apple. After his stint at Apple, Lamego ended up starting his own company, True Wearables. In 2016, he released a device called the Oxxiom, which he called the world’s first continuous and disposable blood-oxygen sensor. Masimo sued the start-up and won a court order blocking it from selling the product. https://www.smh.com.au/business/companies/the-late-night-email-to-tim-cook-that-set-the-apple-watch-saga-in-motion-20231228-p5eu0i.html https://www.smh.com.au/business/companies/the-late-night-ema...
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Blood oxygen monitors aren’t event expensive. You can buy little ones that clamp onto your fingertip for like $20. It's not about just any blood oxigen measuring tech, there's various ways you can do it and apparently Apple's newest watch is implementing a very accurate technique developed by Masimo. Those $20 devices exist because measuring blood oxygen accurately via light refracted through flesh is way easier than via light reflect off the flesh(especially as you move around), which is what this fight is all about. >Seems odd that they couldn’t use their weight to secure a license. Or, you know, pay for it? It's not like Apple is scrapping for change behind the couch cushions.
- ffgjgf1 3y ago> implementing a very accurate technique developed by Masimo. I’m not sure it’s very technologically complex though. Seems like the patent just covers the positioning of a few sensors. It’s about as silly as allowing “multitouch” to be patented…
- kcplate 3y ago> I assume because it’s cheaper to lose that feature than the pay the required licensing fee. Without a doubt. I would imagine the number of people that would actually choose to not buy an Apple Watch because it doesn’t have a blood oxygen sensor is really really small. I also believe it’s likely that people considering upgrading an existing Apple Watch will not be deterred by the removal of the feature. My sense is that Apple felt that it had basically nothing to lose. They were going to incur some legal costs in this anyway, why not let that play out? Remove it if you lose the battle. If you lose out on maybe <500 watch sales no biggie, you still have the optics to your customer base that you exhausted all options to keep the feature.
- FireBeyond 3y agoMasimo barely targets the consumer market. 97% of their revenue is hospital devices. They’re not competing. Their devices tie in to hospital EMRs, do brain activity monitoring, and all sorts of other thing’s that aren’t in the same ballpark as an Apple Watch.
- amelius 3y ago> Why don’t they just pay up? Unfortunately, patents can entirely block the use of a technology, even if enormous sums of money are being offered to use the tech.
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y agoThere’s definitely a price tag, and Apple doesn’t want to pay.
- albert180 3y agoSomehow others competitors managed to do it without patent infringement or just pay the licence fees. Apple just thought they were so big that they could get away with stealing the IP, because they have deeper pocket for court proceedings. It's not the first time they do it
- toomuchtodo 3y agoApple will just not offer the capability until the patent expires. Consumers will still buy the watches, they bought them before this existed.
- albert180 3y agoIf the court finally determines in the End that they violated the patent, they have no choice but to pay up for all the watches already out there. If they are smart they will now offer a good deal for both sides instead of loosing and pay a huge punitive damage
- toomuchtodo 3y agoApple has almost a $3T market cap, I'm sure their legal team will be fine coming to a favorable arrangement if nerfing the functionality with software updates isn't sufficient. They can fund any settlement out of ~$380B in annual revenue. Any settlement under ~$1B is a day of revenue. The horror.
- rwc 3y agoBecause the O2 sensor was a COVID-era feature that nobody cares about now and moves zero units. Soon Apple will have definitive confirmation in the form of Watch sales data.
- al_borland 3y agoIt’s not only useful for COVID, that just got it mainstream attention. If used along with the sleep tracking, it seems like the O2 could signal someone to get treated for sleep apnea. The Apple Watch Ultra is geared toward hikers and people going off the beaten path, for those in the mountains, this is something to monitor at high elevations. It can also signal the user of heart and lung issues that they’d want to get eyes on.
- arthurofbabylon 3y agoSentence 2 is particularly interesting.
- d6e 3y agoIt’s also useful for VO2 max calculation which is commonly trained for athletes
- nradov 3y agoNo, SpO2 isn't used for VO2 Max calculations. SpO2 measured at the wrist doesn't tell you anything about how much oxygen is being metabolized. Only heart rate (including HRV) and speed or power are used as input for the VO2 Max estimate. Wristwatches can't even measure SpO2 accurately when you're running around, you have to hold fairly still to get a consistent reading.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoI care about it. Its actually the only new feature that I would have upgraded for. I know a lot of people that got it for that specific feature. Not one of them got it for COVID or medical reasons. There are huge communities of people that really like this feature. Notably, many people that do things at altitude. I won't pretend that my narrow experience is a market maker, but I also won't generalize it to say something as broad as its a feature "nobody cares about now and moves zero units." Try to think beyond your own experiences and worldview.
- jzl 3y agoBecause modern day Apple will happily cut off their hand to spite their face.
- Booourns 3y agoThe order is only that they can’t import them into the US with this feature enabled. The sensor is still on it and been disabled in software. The actual case around the patent infringement is still going through the courts and if I understand correctly nothing has been decided with that.
- Sai_ 3y agoCould apple publish a way for US customers to themselves re-enable the feature? If publishing software is a first amendment right, then I don’t see any legal way to prevent them from doing this.
- ffgjgf1 3y agoI would really love to see Apple providing explicit instructions on how to jailbreak their own devices
- paganel 3y agoAre those oxygen monitoring apps any good? (including the Apple Watch one, I mean). I remember that during Covid there was a big gap between what these devices were telling their users and the numbers measured by actual medical equipment (with the latter being those closer to the truth, of course).
- andsoitis 3y agoI use my Oura ring for that - https://support.ouraring.com/hc/en-us/articles/7328398760851-Blood-Oxygen-Sensing-SpO2 https://support.ouraring.com/hc/en-us/articles/7328398760851... Like other consumer device manufacturers they have a disclaimer that it isn't a medical device, with concomitant implications. I have not compared with medical equipment but am interested in doing so, or hear from others who have.
- amluto 3y agoNot great. I have no idea how accurate they are, but they’re very fiddly and don’t produce a reading at all unless conditions are ideal.
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoAll medical-grade blood oxygen sensors that I have seen in hospitals are put on the tip of the finger. This arrangement allows them to beam light through the human flesh and measure how much of it is absorbed - the light source is on one side of the finger and the sensor on the other and there is no bone between them at the tip of the finger, just tissue with lots of blood in it. Smart watches are carried on the wrist so they can only measure light reflected back which gives much lower sensitivity and accuracy.
- fhsm 3y agoThey can be decent but can be totally wrong too: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10039641/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10039641/
- brandonb 3y agoResearchers measured the accuracy of the Apple Watch's oxygen sensor, and found it was as reliable as a medical-grade device: https://data.empirical.health/p/is-the-apple-watchs-blood-oxygen https://data.empirical.health/p/is-the-apple-watchs-blood-ox... The FDA doesn't regulate "over the counter" oxygen sensors (including those you find at a CVS or Walgreens), but that study suggests that if they did, Apple could get an FDA clearance. They already have several FDA clearances for the Apple Watch's ECG, irregular rhythm notifications, and afib history features. The oxygen sensor is helpful for detecting, among other things, sleep apnea, where 60-80% of people are undiagnosed.
- shadowgovt 3y agoPatents are why we can't have nice things.
- echelon 3y agoThis kept Apple's grubby paws off of a small innovator. The industry needs more patents to defend against egregious titans. Apple has more than enough money to license this patent if they so choose. Apple needs serious competition. And that won't happen with their massive scale until regulators start nipping away at their all-encompassing competitive moat. The largest companies are barely innovating at all, and that should speak volumes. They're camping their position and raking in easy money from the folks doing all the hard work at the bottom.
- shadowgovt 3y agoA small medical innovator who's going to charge twice the price for a device that only has the oxygen monitor. Hooray. > The largest companies are barely innovating at all Well, Apple had an oxygen monitor integrated into their smartwatch. That's pretty innovative. ... Until the government forces them to stop I guess.
- echelon 3y ago> A small medical innovator who's going to charge twice the price for a device that only has the oxygen monitor. When it's not subsidized by the unrelated business unit profit of a monopoly, well, yeah. > That's pretty innovative. ... Until the government forces them to stop I guess. Apple's finally getting the treatment they give to their developers!
- shadowgovt 3y ago> When it's not subsidized by the unrelated business unit profit of a monopoly, well, yeah. Indeed. And that sucks for the consumer. Why should we consider subsidizing less profitable beneficial offerings with more profitable offerings a bad thing? That's how every charity the industrial barons put together that still maintain some of the civic spaces in the US came to be. The steel boom funding a library and an opera house and all that.
- roenxi 3y agoThis is a good moment to ask exactly what this patent system is achieving here. Removing potentially life-saving features from Apple's watches isn't a very helpful step; pulse oximetry is a 1935 or 1970s technology depending on where we start counting [0] and it seems a stretch to say that Apple wouldn't have figured this out themselves. So in this case, the taxpayer is paying good money to enforce a measure that hurts them. Why should they be forced to do that? What is the upside in this case? It is purposefully slowing down life-saving technological innovation. I don't see why it is believed that this is helping progress. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse_oximetry#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse_oximetry#History
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lijok 3y agoWhy are you blaming the patent system when it was Apple who stole the tech and refused to pay up?
- roenxi 3y agoI don't think we should consider the tech stolen. The concept of "stealing" a tech in this context is silly; we should want more people to do what Apple did. This court decision comes with a body count. It is a bad outcome. Nobody should support it.
- skygazer 3y agoPatents were reportedly filed after Apple Watch already had the feature, specifically to target Apple, and that ITC acknowledged Apple’s invention was entirely independent of Massimo and this is considered patent abuse by notable Apple critic: https://ipfray.com/u-s-trade-agency-itc-incredibly-portrays-apple-as-unrepentant-infringer-despite-masimo-clearly-abusing-patents/ https://ipfray.com/u-s-trade-agency-itc-incredibly-portrays-... There’s an allegation the real reason for the patents/suite is retaliation; that Apple pissed off billionaire owner by not partnering with him and instead hiring away top employees.
- 3y ago
- NoPicklez 3y agoIn all honesty, Blood Ox isn't really that useful. It seems cool but the novelty wears off quickly, especially given that having it switched on does contribute to battery life. I'd say it's only really useful for people that have a particular concern around those levels. Appreciate that this isn't what the article is about, but I don't think it will impact sales too much. Apple now need to go and implement their own Stress or Heart Rate Variability score. That in my mind is a bigger gap.
- anonuser123456 3y agoMy cardiologist suggests it’s a good screener for sleep apnea. Not diagnostic, but indicative that a sleep study may be necessary. He screens his patients that wear the watch for levels during sleep. If he sees consistent sub 90s he sends them off to a sleep medicine doc.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoSpO2 monitoring is one of the components of polysomnography which is used to diagnose sleep apnea. SpO2 statistics are reported in the polysomnogram: SpO2 minimum, maximum, mean, standard deviation. For example, a minimum SpO2 of 70% during sleep indicates your blood is not oxygenating properly for some reason during that period. Doesn't straight up prove it's due to sleep apnea but you can definitely assume it is and be right more often than not. The full polysomnogram also measures air flow, sleep architecture and more.
- StimDeck 3y ago[dead]
- instagib 3y agoI have sleep apnea. I bought a $200 very sensitive blood oxygen sensor which measures several times a second if I remember correctly. I tried to bring the case to my doctor that my Cpap machine setup was not working correctly. His criteria is “do you fall down when you walk because you are out of breath. Then you should be concerned about your lungs and you don’t want to be around anyone with issues like that. “ I would welcome HRV tracking but that will require a better sensor or an additional one. The blood oxygen sensor requires 15 seconds of no movement. ECG requires 30 seconds of wearing watch and holding the crown.
- OhNoNotAgain_99 3y ago[dead]
- RockRobotRock 3y agoWhy does this only affect the newest model?
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoBecause only the newest one integrates the more precise sensing tech Masino claims Apple used without paying them.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> Masimo claims This is apologist. Masimo claims, and multiple court cases have agreed that Apple did, in fact, use patented technology without payment (and frankly, even as an all Apple person, their behavior in this whole situation was entirely shitty). Couching this all as “claims” gives Apple a benefit of the doubt, similar to the people who refer to Masimo as “nothing but patent trolls”. Previous discussions here had multiple people referring to them being “butthurt that Apple hadn’t offered to acquire them”, or that they “lacked the product chops to bring their own solution to market”.
- ffgjgf1 3y agoPatent trolls have also won cases from time to time. Also AFAIK Masimo didn’t just want to be paid they wanted to have some direct on the development of Apple Watch. Also… the patents themselves seem like a joke and shouldn’t be valid.
- campl3r 3y agoMasimo is no patent troll, but a legitimate company
- FireBeyond 3y ago> Also AFAIK Masimo didn’t just want to be paid they wanted to have some direct on the development of Apple Watch. They had concerns about some of Apple's design and functionality decisions around the sensor on the watch. They didn't want their technology to be associated with a poorer user experience... ... you know, kinda like how Apple has a whole review process and has input on the development of your apps for their platform? Conflating that as "they wanted to be have some direction on the development of the Watch" is a notable exaggeration.
- cced 3y agoAre these watching shipping with a FEATURE_BLOOD_OXYGEN=false type thing or did apple remove hardware from watches? Any hopes of enabling this feature some time down the line? Assuming they didn’t pull hardware out if the watches.
- endigma 3y agoIt's software according to the article > Starting today, Apple will only sell the Watch Series 9 and Ultra 2, which both came out in September, with a US Customs and Border Protection-approved software workaround that disables blood oxygen monitoring capabilities. These watches will be available at Apple’s physical and online stores, Apple said. They also have part numbers ending in "LW/A," per updated Apple support materials.
- fortran77 3y agoThis isn't the first time Apple appropriated someone else's timepice technology and had a legal battle over it. See: https://appleinsider.com/articles/12/11/11/apple-reportedly-paid-21m-to-use-swiss-railway-clock-design https://appleinsider.com/articles/12/11/11/apple-reportedly-...
- jonplackett 3y agoI get pretty obsessive with stats, health stats especially But I’ve never understood or cared much about my blood oxygen reading. I’m curious - did anyone out there really use that stat? If so what for?
- dixie_land 3y agoI recall at the height of COVID, it was advised to keep an eye on one's blood oxygen level
- Tagbert 3y agoThe problem there was that, unless you were already clearly seriously ill, your blood oxygen did not drop. It was not diagnostic.
- jackvalentine 3y agoEarly on there was a lot of concern about 'happy' hypoxia where your blood o2 was dangerously low but people didn't feel critically ill. I'm not sure where that ended up clinically/evidentially as things moved on though.
- zarzavat 3y agoSometimes even clearly seriously ill people don’t go to the hospital. Especially in the middle of a pandemic.
- paulgerhardt 3y agoSome friends and I use it all the time when flying at elevation and for training breath holds for free diving. Was useful for the couple of times I had covid too. Which is to say it’s very useful to me a few times a month. I wouldn’t go out of my way to buy a Massimo watch for the feature though.
- tim333 3y agoI took one high altitude mountaineering. It was interesting seeing how low the O2 goes and how much using bottled oxygen effects it.
- chocoboaus2 3y agoand let me guess... no price drop
- gkrishna 3y ago"Apple's rep said that pricing isn't based on a single feature. It's worth noting that the watches haven't become cheaper to make, as they still have the same components as before."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chocoboaus2 3y agoSo seems like its a software fix then if its all the same hardware may not be enough for the ITC
- bananapub 3y ago... in the US, which seems a pretty important thing to include in a headline. I would have expected better from Ars.