28 ms·
Houthi anti-ship missile systems: getting better all the time
- throwup238 3y agohttps://archive.ph/xVmye https://archive.ph/xVmye for the hug of death.
- s5300 3y ago[dead]
- BenFranklin100 3y agoThe Third Barbary War seems to be upon us. I don’t this is going to end any better for the pirates than the first two. Those shipping lanes are vital, and there is only so much disruption the international order will accept before putting a decisive end to the interference.
- hmmokidk 3y agoOr they can just stop the Genocide.
- tim333 3y agoIf there was one.
- Cyph0n 3y agoI concur with the flagged reply. The Houthis provided a solution on day 1: a ceasefire to end the genocide in Gaza. We will look back on the escalation of the conflict in Yemen as a strategic blunder. The Biden administration is digging itself deeper & deeper into a hole of its own making.
- Papirola 3y agothere's an even simpler solution to the war in gaza: have hamas release all the hostages.
- tmnvix 3y agoThat won't stop the hostilities. Israel has two stated objectives: free the hostages and eliminate Hamas. The Israeli government is very unlikely to agree to a ceasefire in return for the hostages.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> won't stop the hostilities It would undermine a lot of Israel’s international support. At the end of the day, the Houthis aren’t in Gaza. Them raising random asks is orthogonal to the security threat they pose. Piracy is piracy.
- prmph 3y agoFreeing the hostages AND giving up their weapons AND committing to not attack Israel again will end the war.
- tim333 3y agoEven keeping their weapons but saying they'll try to live in peace with Israel would be a huge change. However it's part of Hamas's founding charter to destroy Israel and they aren't prepared to give it up, which then leads the the jolly situation we have now.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoBut gazans wont do that. They live in a prison camp, why would they ever commit to not attacking Israel again?
- ekianjo 3y ago> The Houthis provided a solution on day 1: a ceasefire to end the genocide in Gaza. Really? That seems to be funny for a group that is actively promoting another kind of genocide as part of their political manifesto: > The group's slogan reads as following: "God Is Great, Death to America, Death to Israel, Curse on the Jews, Victory to Islam" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slogan_of_the_Houthi_movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slogan_of_the_Houthi_movement If you had such neighbors they might just decide to kill you if you are not of their tribe. Not sure why people would whitewash such a group of extremists.
- richrichie 3y ago[flagged]
- fakedang 3y agoBecause Westerners who support extremists are extremely stupid and self-damaging. Don't take my word for it, just listen to the UAE foreign minister's view on it: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-dV4m43xZmY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-dV4m43xZmY The West things they know Islam, specifically radical Islam, better than we do, because they did two semesters worth of courses on Middle Eastern studies at their local university.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 3y ago
- bdhess 3y agoAka cede de facto authority over international waters to a buncha thugs whose official slogan includes “death to America, death to Israel”. No thanks.
- raverbashing 3y agoOne thing that seems to be confirmed over and over is how people who come up with "just negotiate with them" seem to have a thinking process that does not span over a couple of days Funny how those people never seem to have any reservations to what hamas did, or any of the history of the past 20 yrs
- jedimind 3y ago[flagged]
- raverbashing 3y agoNot without reservations, but it's not like Israel's neighbors tolerated its existence > like the perpetual ethnic-cleansing Funny you ask that, makes me wonder what happened to the jews of the levantine and arab countries
- Incipient 3y agoFwiw, I both sides are so bloodstained that neither is the right choice. The absolute bare minimum of a position is "I'm taking the less bad side" but I think both are so awful neither honestly viable to support on a social level (political is different)
- jedimind 3y ago[flagged]
- jedimind 3y ago> Not without reservations, but it's not like Israel's neighbors tolerated its existence Of course not, why on earth would anyone tolerate a bunch of invaders taking over their land? Zionists are really still making that argument as if it makes a lick of sense. No sane human would react otherwise. >Funny you ask that, makes me wonder what happened to the jews of the levantine and arab countries What came first? Exactly, Zionists started ethnic-cleansing Palestinians and IN RESPONSE their neighbors acted in kind, which by the way was exactly what Zionists wanted anyway. They wanted and needed as many jews in occupied Palestine as possible, so it was an emotional response from their neighbors that was a moral and strategic mistake.
- ycombinete 3y agoGeopolitical Chesterton’s Fence: if you can’t explain why the Houthis existed before 2023; then you shouldn’t give opinions on what motivates them now.
- Cyph0n 3y agoOh, I have been aware of the Houthis and their agenda since their rise as part of the Yemeni revolution and subsequent civil war. Whether we like it or not, the Houthis are now a major player in Yemen. As for the current situation, my point was to clarify that the Houthis didn’t just randomly wake up in the morning one day and start attacking commercial ships for no reason. They communicated their reasoning and demands from the very start, and made it clear that this was their response to the ongoing genocide in Gaza. The US response was to simply ignore their demands and just bomb Yemen. This is a mistake. The Houthis (and Iran by proxy) are no strangers to conflict. Bombing Yemen will do nothing to stop attacks on commercial shipping - in fact, it probably will escalate them. Worse yet, starting a new conflict doesn’t help the negative reputation the US has built up over the past few months in the eyes of the so-called global south. Instead, this gives China an excellent opportunity to step in as a (actually) neutral power.
- tptacek 3y agoAnsar Allah was targeting commercial shipping in the Red Sea long before the Gaza crisis.
- Cyph0n 3y agoWell, assuming that’s true, it’s clearly happening at a different scale here. The global response is proof.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 3y agoAh yes so nice of them to worry about Gaza, I'm sure it's all due to how pure of heart they are /s > Bombing Yemen will do nothing to stop attacks on commercial shipping This is bully logic. It can escalate the conflict, yes, but destruction of artillery and missiles works
- Dalewyn 3y ago[flagged]
- jedimind 3y ago[flagged]
- prmph 3y ago[flagged]
- hackerlight 3y ago> If Palestine didn't want war they shouldn't have let Hamas initiate acts of war We should avoid collectivizing the motives and capabilities of heterogeneous individuals, many of them children, and many of them adults who do not support Hamas's atrocities but had no ability to stop them without being killed themselves. It's one thing to say that the civilian deaths in this war are unfortunate collateral damage, it's another thing to do away with the concept of collateral damage entirely and pretend that every single individual bears moral culpability for Hamas's actions, just for the crime of being born on the wrong side of the fence.
- tety 3y agoIt's tragic, but there was and is wide support of October 7 attacks in Gaza, as well there was wide participation of the civilian (non-organization aligned) population in the massacres, including looting, killing, kidnapping and probably rape. Furthermore, Hamas was elected by the population under popular vote, and it is a palestinian organization entrenched in every facet of civilian organizations and life, and strongly stems from palestinian cultural norms (e.g. islamism, martyrdom, etc) You cannot completely act as if Hamas is not the defacto government in Gaza, and in any war in history, especially urban warfare in civilian setting with non-uniformed combatants, you cannot truly hurt only the military apparatus without also hurting civilians. This is simply a fact of life. It is a Western trope going as far back as the Nazis to act as if governments have no representation of their citzenship, especially authocratic ones. Even to this day for example, the German government of 1933-1945 are called 'the nazis' rather than germans, as if they came from outer space, and returned to their planet on 1945, leaving none of their members in the Western/Eastern Germany governments.
- tmnvix 3y agoI may have missed it, but the failure of any western leaders to publicly acknowledge the Houthi's stated reasons for their actions (and by extension their demands) is conspicuous.
- tptacek 3y agoIt conspicuously indicates that nobody takes their public statements seriously.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoNo one is taking their words seriously, just their actions.
- hayst4ck 3y ago[flagged]
- Protostome 3y agoActually, there's no genocide happening in Gaza. Yes, there are way too many civilian casualties, which is awful. But here's the thing: Hamas often launches attacks from places where people live, putting those civilians in danger. They kind of use this as a tactic, because the more civilian casualties there are, the more pressure is on Israel to stop fighting. Now, about those tunnels in Gaza – they're everywhere, right? But Hamas doesn't let ordinary folks use them for safety. That's pretty different from Israel, where new apartments have had to include bunkers since the 90s, and you can find bomb shelters all over the place. So, the sad truth is, the high number of civilians dying in Gaza is mainly because of how Hamas operates, using its own people as a shield.
- hayst4ck 3y ago[flagged]
- Protostome 3y agoI get where you're coming from, But let's put things in perspective. First off, nobody's saying that the loss of innocent lives, especially children, isn't tragic. It's heartbreaking, and every life lost is a huge deal. But saying that Israel is intentionally targeting children and women oversimplifies and misrepresents the reality. You mentioned feeling ashamed, like back during the Iraq war, but consider this: have you ever been in the shoes of a country under constant threat from a radical militant group? Imagine if 1,200 of your citizens were attacked, with the clear intent of causing as much harm as possible. What would you expect your country to do? Most people would say: stop the threat, make sure it never happens again. Hamas (and many of its supporters in the west) claim that the attack is a response for Israel making Gaza "an open-air-prison" – it's inaccurate to say the least. Yes, Israel did enforce a blockade on Gaza, but it's crucial to understand why. It wasn't to make life miserable for Gazans. The main goal was to prevent weapons from getting to Hamas, a group that's openly committed to destroying Israel. And it's not like everything else was blocked – food, medicine, and other essentials were still getting through after security checks. Hamas makes their goals regarding Israel very clear in their covenant. It's not just about land or politics; it's about an ideology that doesn't recognize jews right to exist in this tiny piece of land. Sure, Israel isn't perfect. Mistakes happen in war, and they should be acknowledged and dealt with. But calling it genocide? That's a stretch. Genocide involves the deliberate, systematic attempt to wipe out a group of people. In all the conflicts, Israel has actually taken enormous efforts to minimize civilian casualties, like warning civilians of upcoming attacks, especially in this ongoing conflict. I'm curoious to get your perspective - how do you think a country should react to attacks from a group like Hamas? It's a tough question, right? What's the right balance between defending your citizens and ensuring minimal harm to the other side, especially when that side uses civilians as shields?
- prmph 3y ago[flagged]
- rasz 3y agoLike the 2022 ceasefire https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-houthis-after-the-yemeni-cease-fire/ https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-houthis-after-the-yem... ? Lets not stop there and do a ceasefire with russia by abandoning Ukraine.
- xorcist 3y agoThis is nonsense. While it is true that they recently included the customary references to Satan, Israel and the USA in their communications, that is to be understood as allegiance to the shiites in Iran. It includes references to standard phrases the Mullahs always use in their communication. The conflict in Yemen is an old one, and one that the US has always indirectly played a part in, given their seemingly unwavering support of the Saudis. Every power player in the region has been a part of this conflict. It's why there still is civil war in Sudan(!). It's a conflict so complex that makes the Palestinian conflict look trivial in comparison.
- qball 3y ago>The Third Barbary War seems to be upon us. No- you need to go further back before you see the big picture. Much as in the ancient world (which the modern world order consists of in large part), this is a Romans vs. Parthians vs. Chinese thing. These actions are just the Parthians making access to the Silk Road harder, in the hopes that Consul Biden and the Senate and People of Rome (and the provinces they control) will stop supporting the king of Judea and his recent military invasion of the Parthian-allied settlements on his border. >Those shipping lanes are vital, and there is only so much disruption the international order will accept before putting a decisive end to the interference. I'll believe that as soon as the Chinese Emperor Xi commands his warships to sail out and fire their first salvos at the Parthian-supplied forces. The "international order" you think exists is literally just Rome and its provinces, and those provinces are currently busy supplying a civil war in the European Borderland (one the Romans were a major factor in creating the conditions for it to occur) and they barely contribute anything to their obligations in the North Adriatic Treaty Organization to begin with. They don't even have any legions to deploy (not that they could raise any in the first place) and won't be anywhere near decisive in a proper fight. So that just leaves the Romans themselves... who have been engaging in proxy military action (with the king of Arabia) to remove the Parthian proxies for the past 10 years or so with very little success. To be fair to Parthia, their main goal has always been to pull nearby provinces out of Roman orbit and into Parthia's- while Judea and Arabia might never enter the Parthian orbit unless physically conquered (organization of the Parthian-sympathetic states surrounding Judea has been a long goal of the Parthians; unfortunately for Parthia, their armies keep losing) the vassal states that depend heavily on goods traveling through the Silk Road might start to view the actions of the Judeans with disfavor. And sure, the Romans could always just attack the Parthian proxies directly- but the entire reason that Parthia can get away with this is because the Senate and People of Rome aren't actually interested in yet another desert war that costs quadrillions of denarii, and by committing to assisting the King of Arabia secure his southern flank they lock themselves out of defending a breakaway Chinese province (whose unique products Rome arguably values even more than the loyalty of its own provinces) should the Chinese attempt to capture it, as they've long been threatening to do.
- mardifoufs 3y agoJust think of them as sanctions. If you try to break any embargo, you will get hit with a missile on the face. That's how embargos usually work. And by international order, you mean "western order" right? Every sanction and embargo has the purpose of disrupting some sort of order. Try running a USN embargo or blockade, I'm not sure they would be more diplomatic about it than the Houthis. We are currently seeing a higher civilian death rate than we saw back in February 2022, yet it doesn't seem like a lot of people complained about disrupting international order when Russia was sanctioned. And they were well deserved sanctions ,it just turns out that it's not just the US or Europe that can care about civilian deaths. Especially since those countries don't necessarily seem to care a lot about non white civilian deaths, since absolutely 0 western country condemned Israel even when they put literal war criminals like Russia to shame in terms of sheer destruction and indiscriminate murder. When "the international community" (aka, the west) drops the ball on that regard and lets it happen for close to 4 months now, well what do they expect?
- prmph 3y ago> We are currently seeing a higher civilian death rate than we saw back in February 2022, yet it doesn't seem like a lot of people complained about disrupting international order when Russia was sanctioned. This is a false equivalence. Israel was attacked first, brutally. Russia was not attacked; theirs is a war of agression, pure and simple. It is clear that the fundamental cause of the Ukraine war is a desire by Putin and his ilk to restore the old soviet "empire". [1] Actually, that has been the cause of many wars down through the centuries. A former power, or a country that thinks it needs to play a more powerful role in world affairs, seeking (re)ascendancy. It happened with Germany and Japan in WW2, and it is happening with Russia now. But it seems people will believe anything but what the aggressors themselves clearly want. Do you know what the Muslim nations say among themselves, what their ultimate objective is? Without understanding that, it is impossible to place the Israeli-Arab conflict in proper perspective. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/25/putin-new-russian-empire-ukraine https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/25/putin-...
- mardifoufs 3y ago
- maxglute 3y agoInternational order (includingg most US parnters) would rather eat single digit % increase in diverted shipping costs and MENA fuel costs AND have Houthis embargo Israel access to resources in red sea than deal with alternative of Houthis hitting Saudi energy infra and have energy prices spike double digits. There's a reason only USN + UK (who imports excess energy demands from US) are committing most of the hardware and doing all the interceptions and attacks, no one else - especially the international order - wants the stir the pot more for Israel. Of course US still has unilateral power to strike as please, but don't be surprised if Yemen missiles hit Saudi refineries if things escalate.
- nradov 3y agoThe US and UK are pretty much the only countries which have the hardware to carry out interceptions and attacks. France is probably the only other country that has significant capability to project power in that region.
- ethbr1 3y agoChina, who is a significant exporter to Europe. They have a very large base in Djibouti, directly across from Yemen and across town from the US/multi-national base at the airport. It's going to be interesting to see how "China, who wants to the authority of a world power" starts to run up against "China, who has the responsibilities of a world power."
- nradov 3y agoChina is still not in the same class. The ships that they can deploy to the region are weak in strike and area air defense capability. And they don't have much in the way of intelligence gathering that would be needed to employ those ships effectively. The most that the PLAN could manage would be to escort small convoys as a defensive measure.
- ethbr1 3y agoNot sure if the PLAAF/N operates fixed-wing aircraft from the base, but they have a runway and hangars. https://www.google.com/maps/place//@11.5906054,43.0625938,16z https://www.google.com/maps/place//@11.5906054,43.0625938,16... And the PLAN has 25+ Type 052D destroyers w/ 64 VLS cells apiece [0]. And HQ-9 (reverse engineered Patriot SAMs) and ground attack capable YJ-18 cruise missiles in them. They absolutely have the capability, if they weren't busy bullying their regional neighbors in the South China Sea, who have vastly less capable warships (if any blue water). [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_052D_destroyer#Armament https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_052D_destroyer#Armament
- extractionmech 3y ago[flagged]
- fsagx 3y agoThe Saudis bombed Yemen for years with US weapons and targeting. A civil war has been been waged on and off for decades too. Dropping cruise missiles on rubble (which seems to be as far as the US/UK will escalate) will not have much effect.
- ethbr1 3y agoThe US hasn't been in the business of economic destruction by air since the 1950s. Targeting key enabling (e.g. radar) or missile sites will absolutely have an effect. The Houthis have large but limited stocks of missiles, little ability to domestically manufacture, and difficulty importing more advanced models from Iran at scale. Moving interdiction left of launch is absolutely the right call, as it leverages weaknesses in Houthi air defense to more economically blunt their launches. Hell, the US/UK could just close the loop on foreign military aid and buy low-cost Ukrainian UAVs to attack Houthi targets.
- petesergeant 3y agoMeanwhile the captain of the US aircraft carrier in the region is showing off the different flavoured coffees you can get on board and handing out cookies to his sailors[0], so doesn't seem too bothered. 0: https://twitter.com/ChowdahHill https://twitter.com/ChowdahHill
- fbdab103 3y agoMilitary propaganda is a thing. Display strength or say nothing at all.
- nwiswell 3y agoThe threat is to merchant shipping, not to Navy ships, which have countermeasures upon countermeasures. The current SOTA in anti-ship technology are the Chinese hypersonic missiles such as the DF-26, which are believed to pose a credible threat to aircraft carriers. Iran is also developing hypersonic missiles like the Khalij Fars, but the Houthis don't have these and they are substantially less capable than the Chinese ones. FTA: > Civilian vessels can adopt security measures to thwart attempted boardings, but they lack defences against anti-ship missiles. While Western military vessels have advanced air and missile-defence capabilities – using them to down Houthi missiles and UAVs – they are constrained by the number of interceptor missiles they can carry and the challenge of restocking depleted inventories.
- kmlevitt 3y ago>” That suggests a strong, long-term Iranian focus on strengthening Houthi anti-ship capabilities and a potential attempt to export Iran’s model of naval coercion from the Persian Gulf and the Strait of Hormuz to the geopolitically important Red Sea and Bab el-Mandeb Strait.” Can anyone who understands this conflict explain this more? What does Iran get out of helping the Houthi disrupt commercial shipping? For that matter, how do they benefit from naval coercion in the Gulf?
- codezero 3y agoBecause of sanctions, Iran has adapted to operating without fitting into global supply chains. By disrupting supply chains, they are participating in asymmetrical warfare. It's an announcement: "We can keep doing this." They are playing against the idea that because they are acting by proxy, other nations won't act directly against Iran.
- nntwozz 3y agoWell you know what they say, foo around and find out. Carl Sagan comes to mind: The Earth is a very small stage in a vast cosmic arena. Think of the rivers of blood spilled by all those generals and emperors, so that, in glory and triumph, they could become the momentary masters of a fraction of a dot.
- samus 3y agoCarl Sagan can go breathe vacuum if he really thinks those generals and emperors spilled all that blood for nothing. That fraction of a dot is a very special part of the universe: it is so far the only known planet that is able to support human life. Meaningless on the grand cosmic arena (if such a notion even makes sense), but invaluable for humans.
- Morte42 3y agoMaybe its the only known planet because we dont know many other planets though. The universe is a largely unknown quantity and aside from the Asians space isnt interesting to most people anymore.
- walrus01 3y agoIranian anti ship missile systems. The Houthis have pretty much no domestic high tech manufacturing capability of their own.
- jandrewrogers 3y agoThis reflects the current evolution of the historical arms race. The missiles are not particularly effective, terminal guidance and warhead design is poor, but they are a threat to any non-military vessel in the region. The underlying dynamic is that technology that was very expensive to produce 50 years ago is now available ubiquitously. It isn’t per se great tech, but it is comparable to tech proper military powers had 50 years ago, which are still quite capable against unsophisticated adversaries, like shipping vessels. Modern military vessels are designed under the assumption that they will be hit by swarms of these missiles. This has parallels to the issue of there being 400M firearms in the US and an almost infinite capacity to produce new ones in a very decentralized fashion. Almost all of the leverage is on the incentive side; people should be maximally reluctant to inappropriately use what we cannot limit them acquiring. No one can stop people from acquiring or building anti-ship missiles as a practical matter. Building the missiles is too cheap and too easy. The costs to using them inappropriately have to be much higher than they currently are.
- ekianjo 3y ago> Building the missiles is too cheap and too easy That's mostly true because of Iranian support according to the article, not because the Houthis were able to develop them themselves...
- jandrewrogers 3y agoI never meant to imply that the Houthis could build it themselves, just that the technical capabilities are sufficiently distributed that most interested parties can find someone who will provide them given enough incentive. The Houthis don’t need to figure it out themselves if the Iranian government is happy to provide the hardware.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe Houti's couldn't make glass if they wanted to let alone anti-ship missile systems. They're just pawns in a larger game and they're setting themselves up as a target. Iran is pretty clever at getting others to do its bidding by supplying them with arms like this but there are a lot of global and also local parties that aren't going to let this pass unnoticed.
- fooker 3y agoDoesn't make sense to underestimate their capabilities. Anti ship missiles are really 1930s tech, there's not necessarily much modern electronics involved.
- choilive 3y agoA cruise missile is 1930's tech??
- jacquesm 3y agoTechnically a V1 is a cruise missile if you stretch the definition a bit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-1_flying_bomb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-1_flying_bomb
- georgeecollins 3y ago1944 v-1 is I think the first cruise missile. In ww2 the Germans had guided anti ship missiles and the US had aa shells with very simple radar.
- fooker 3y agoCruise missiles are for targets many hundreds of kilometers away. These just have to make it from the shores of the Red sea to the middle, a considerably shorter distance than what cruise missiles are really meant for. These are more like howitzers with self propelled projectiles. These are much simpler than cruise missiles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-propelled_artillery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-propelled_artillery
- 3y ago
- IAmGraydon 3y agoThey've launched hundreds and failed to sink a single ship. Getting better all the time!
- nomilk 3y agoJust yesterday I learned of steerable bullets: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMwWQktNlPk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMwWQktNlPk These could potentially nullify any ship-bound missile threat if they can be miniaturised and incorporated into CIWS.
- richrichie 3y agoThe author does not mention at all the extensive bombing campaign conducted by Saudi Arabia, backed by the US and chooses to focus on the Iranian logistical support. Context free discussion ia useless in geopolitics.
- WaxProlix 3y agoIt's incredibly useful, as propaganda at a minimum.
- LASR 3y agoI don’t know enough to have an opinion on the ongoing conflicts near that region. So I’ll abstain from commenting on that. But what I will say is that this corridor is extremely important for international trade across many nations. Securing it, for purely monetary reasons, might escalate this much more than for ideological differences.
- maxglute 3y agoIt's not about just getting better / more proliferation, IMO attacks demonstrate current missile defense is not good enough. While USN intercepting vast majority of missiles (at extreme costs), enough are still slipping through to deter shipping. My understanding is these are basically shit-tier AShMs with limited guidance and anecdotes of attacks from sailers suggest they're not launched in any competently coordinated way, i.e. the salvos are spread over time and limited. They're not huge 10s-100s+ attacks that arrive simultaneously that serious actors can deliver. See Iranian missiles making it past patriots in Al Asad.
- rasz 3y agoIranian not Houthis, Ships and now US base yesterday https://www.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/comments/19bqcmv/us_patriot_missiles_intercepting_iranian_tbms_at/ https://www.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/comments/19bqcmv/us_p...