7 ms·
Space Solar Power Demonstrator ends first in-space mission
- superkuh 3y agoNo it didn't. Transmitting power via microwave radio signal through a vacuum is no new thing. That's all they did here: transmit power a meter or two across the inside of the spacecraft while it was in space. They did not even attempt to do transmission of power to ground for obvious reasons. At 9.84 GHz their ~meter scale aperture from 400km LEO orbit to the biggest NASA dish in existence (that could track LEO) would have a path loss of 76 dB. That means something like (being generous) 0.0000000001% of the power would make it. Plenty for carrying information but useless for beaming power. Space solar power requires coherent emitting apertures on the order of a handful of kilometers to be feasible (from LEO). We can't build kilometer scale anything in LEO. End of story. Once that changes we can think about space solar power.
- jahnu 3y ago> No it didn't. I think you are reading something in the headline that isn't there. They ended their first space based mission which was to test various things. It wasn't to beam power back to Earth. The details in the article are actually interesting.
- superkuh 3y agoI read the article. It's glaringly obvious that the goal is space solar power to earth. >"Solar power beamed from space at commercial rates, lighting the globe, is still a future prospect. But this critical mission demonstrated that it should be an achievable future," says Caltech President Thomas F. Rosenbaum, the Sonja and William Davidow Presidential Chair and professor of physics. This mission did nothing to show that was achievable. The hard part isn't the vacuum. It's the distance which requires, because of physics, a large coherent emitting aperture. And the larger your aperture the harder it is to point. If they really wanted to make progress towards this they'd be building a km-scale coherent phased array for power transmission here on earth. The EISCAT scattering radars in the artic circle are much closer to proving feasibility for space based solar power than this is.
- dekhn 3y agoYou're being pedantic, and incorrectly pedantic. Complaining about a scientist saying "it's a future prosect... that should be an achievable future" is just silly. Look, I get it. I see a PR and I get angry at the implications. But it's just not worth overinterpreting this PR as justifying future research into beamed power delivery. My guess would be this has space-based military applications they're not discussing but that's purely speculation based on what we believe the military space community is already exploring.
- dekhn 3y agoThere's nothing in the press release to suggest that his specific mission was intended to demonstrate a working, economic delivery of power to earth. The article is clear about this, and the title is accurate. Whether it makes any sense to continue this line of research is an open question; they seem to be very far from having something that would produce useful power, with a long line of technical challenges facing them.
- mattashii 3y agoMany modern earth imaging satellites use something called "synthetic aperture radar" where the movement of the satellite is used to increase the aperture for the radar larger than the satellite's own dimensions. Could a similar mechanism be used as well for space to earth energy transfer, or is that unrealistic at the orbital speeds of LEO?
- superkuh 3y agoSynthetic apertures are not applicable to power transmission. That's just information processing. The velocity at which you're traveling doesn't matter. It can be done from plane. Or balloon. Or a walking human. You just have to transmit and receive from spots some distance apart multiple times (in a smaller timescale than your target is moving).
- grecy 3y agoIn case you missed it, this is Hacker News. Where people post inspiring and interesting things we can learn from, we can aspire to and maybe even improve some things from time to time. There's no need for all the negativity every time someone tries something new. It serves no purpose.
- superkuh 3y agohttps://www.caltech.edu/about/news/caltech-announces-breakthrough-100-million-gift-to-fund-space-based-solar-power-project https://www.caltech.edu/about/news/caltech-announces-breakth... The only reason Caltech is doing this is that a really rich person with delusions gave them 100 million dollars to research space based solar power. They know as well as anyone with a bit of RF experience that what they're doing isn't really increasing the TRL of space based solar power transmission. It's just humoring the donor for the money. The best that can be said is that it's the first flex pcb RF system in orbit. That's kind of cool but as a person looking to be inspired and improve things it seems like a significant waste of money. It's not like high power RF transmitters haven't been tested in vacuum in LEO before. There have been many, many radar satellites. They should've been spending they $100 million attempting to make coherent kilometer scale transmitting apertures on Earth and actually demo something that'd prove the feasibility of space based solar power transmission.
- grecy 3y ago> They should've been spending they $100 million attempting to make... I'm not sure you understand how the world works. You don't get to decide how institutions spend money that is donated to them, and I really don't know why you think you do.
- superkuh 3y agoIf the donor really wanted to work towards space based power the experts could convince them the first step is achieving KM-scale coherent transmitting aperatures on Earth. If they just want the money and have no intention of fulfilling the goal, or if the dude is as you say... not open to input, then yeah, you end up with waste like here.
- gene-h 3y agoCaltech's approach[0] is to make their satellite with solar panels on one side and a transmit antenna on the other, so pretty much the whole area of solar panels serves as a giant phased array transmit aperture. They claim that this approach can be made very lightweight and might only mass 160 g/m^2. Kilometer space structures need not be very massive, as the loads they are subject to are quite small. More often achieving a certain stiffness, such that the structure doesn't wobble around too much when being repointed, drives design more than resisting structural loads. The main loading case they consider in [0] is solar radiation pressure. Making the entire structure coherent gets interesting as it's expected to flex a bit. However, they have demonstrated methods to correct for this flex[1]. One problem they have is that their satellite has to consist of a number of smaller spacecraft connected to each other in a grid because they can't launch the whole structure at the same time. One person involved with the project had concerns about how they would align each spacecraft to within subwavelength accuracy. [0]https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2206/2206.08373.pdf https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2206/2206.08373.pdf [1]https://www.nature.com/articles/s41528-022-00218-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41528-022-00218-z
- worldsayshi 3y agoSpace based solar or fusion power - which one will work commercially first?
- IshKebab 3y agoFusion obviously. It only takes a simple back of the envelope calculation to show that space based power makes no sense even in theory. Fusion on the other hand makes total sense if you can do it. It's just a really really really hard engineering problem. Space based power belongs in the same category as solar roadways, energy harvesting speed bumps, solar windows, etc. Clearly if you want to scam investors an energy project is the way to go.
- hutzlibu 3y ago"It only takes a simple back of the envelope calculation to show that space based power makes no sense even in theory." That would be my gut feeling, but what simple calculation would you use to disproof it? Fusion is currently not working at all - but we can transmit power (with big losses over that distance) via laser etc. But since space is expensive, I just see no way to make this work economically.
- practicemaths 3y agoPeople were saying the same thing about terrestrial solar for decades. Both fundamentally are engineering problems now. Also considering that there has been a lot of investment in space launch vehicles of late the cost to lift things into orbit are lowering. Technology takes a while to develop and mature with applications for this beyond just beaming power to Earth.
- hutzlibu 3y ago"Also considering that there has been a lot of investment in space launch vehicles of late the cost to lift things into orbit are lowering." Yes, but the cost of installing solar panels on the ground are astronomically cheaper than anything you can do in space and I do not see the gap closing in the near future, even with breakthroughs. Rather the contrary, we still have lots of cheap unused land (deserts). And solar panels are getting cheaper every day. Having a space based laser/power beam sounds cool - but complicated and expensive.
- londons_explore 3y agoSo if this is in LEO... It orbits the whole earth... And most of the time is over oceans where there is nobody to use any beamed power or in darkness where it cant generate power. Given that, can it ever hope to work out cheaper than just putting solar panels on the ground?
- gwbas1c 3y agoIt's an experiment to learn about what kinds of panels work best, and about beaming power in general. New technology, especially when it comes out of a lab in an academic setting, is never commercially viable. That often takes years of refining based on lessons from the lab, and from "real" deployments that aren't profitable.
- londons_explore 3y agoSomeone must see a path to being profitable one day or they wouldn't be funding research into it...
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoSome might be looking for funding to do rocket launches, without caring if the payload they are promoting makes any sense.
- macintux 3y agoFrom the article, the primary funding is from someone who got excited by the idea when he was much younger. I sincerely doubt he expects to make his $100 million back.
- WJW 3y agoIt's a demonstrator, trying to verify that the technology can work at all. The real version would be sent out to an orbit where there is always a direct path to the sun, but sending out spacecraft that far is much more expensive than just shooting them up to LEO.
- vlovich123 3y agoWhat’s the bullish story for why solar panels in space with microwave beaming is better than solar panels on earth?
- simonebrunozzi 3y agoThere isn't. It's just another excuse to justify spending lots of money on things that make no sense.
- temp0826 3y agoHaven't you played SimCity 2000?
- doctoboggan 3y agoI haven’t done the math or really thought about it all that much but one reason could be that space has a lot of, well, space. You can build a huge array without wasting land that could be used for something else, condense the power down to a beam and send it to earth.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> What’s the bullish story for why solar panels in space with microwave beaming is better than solar panels on earth? Space-based solar power (SBSP) has three advantages over terrestrial solar: flexibility, footprint and theoretical efficiency. The classic case for flexibility is disaster zones; it's easier to set up receiving meshes than build new power plants. The problem is humanitarian crises don't pay. The real sell is military and mining. Beaming power to remote operations simplifies logistics. Footprint is minor, but worth mentioning: the receivers for space-based solar are smaller and could be laid over e.g. farmland. Last, but not least, the atmosphere absorbs a lot of solar energy. In this model, the space-based rig is a lens, converting the well-absorbed frequencies that generate power into microwaves to which dry air is more transparent. If you can get a focussed beam, a SBSP rig could also be placed far enough out that it's less subject to Earth's day-night cycles. These factors boost its theoretical efficiency. I haven't run the numbers for several years. But they only become compelling if you have ISRU and in situ manufacturing of panels. I don't think SBSP is a beachhead market for asteroid mining. But it's feasible if we have it.
- Sanzig 3y agoBarring a laundry list of technological breakthroughs, space based solar power will not be practical in our lifetimes. I recently did a lit review in this area, and it's pretty clear that this is a pipe dream for a small group of people that seems to attract bursts of grant money in 10-20 year intervals before collapsing when the people picking up the tab realize what the challenges are. There are a few extant concept designs for space based solar power, but the most mature and most representative example is a design called SPS-ALPHA [1] which came out of a NIAC contract and has been refined by its inventor in the intervening decade. Essentially, the architecture assumes a large structure supporting an array of mirrors in geostationary orbit focused on a sandwich panel. One side of the sandwich panel contains solar cells, the other contains a retrodirective phased array which beams the collected power back to a site transmitting a pilot signal on earth. This design is interesting and solves some issues that plagued the original designs developed in the 70s. The sandwich panel avoids the need to collect and transfer power between separate solar panels and an antenna, and the retrodirective array avoids the need for precise subwavelenth position knowledge of array elements across the antenna. Using mirrors also reduces the number of solar cells required, however, the achievable concentration ratio isn't very high (3x or so IIRC) due to thermal constraints requiring the sandwich panel to passively self-cool. The mirrors are gimballed, allowing the design to maintain peak power generation regardless of the position of the sun. The problem is the sheer size of the structure, and it is dictated by physics constraints. Efficient microwave power beaming over a fixed distance imposes an inverse relationship between the size of the transmitting and receiving antenna: halving the area of the space based antenna doubles the area of the earth based antenna, and vice-versa. Both antennas can be shrunk simultaneously by increasing the frequency of transmission, however, atmospheric absorption caps efficient transmission at around 10 GHz. Most designs, including SPS-ALPHA, assume a 2.4 GHz transmission frequency (probably because of the ISM band and the feasibility of building high efficiency saturated amplifiers in this band). For SPS-ALPHA, this leads to an antenna about 1.7 km in diameter in space and 5 km in diameter on tbr ground. Here's the key part: these dimensions are independent of the amount of power transferred. For efficient transmission, you need to build a spaceborne megastructure regardless of if you're transmitting 1 MW or 1000 MW. You can't really do a small demonstration plant, you pretty much have to go for the whole meal deal. And that structure is huge: the largest thing we've ever built in space by several orders of magnitude, in a very hostile radiation environment (GEO). The costs would be incredible. Could you build it? Technically, yes. But there is no universe in which it makes economic sense. [1] https://www.nasa.gov/general/sps-alpha-the-first-practical-solar-power-satellite-via-arbitrarily-large-phased-array/ https://www.nasa.gov/general/sps-alpha-the-first-practical-s...
- pengaru 3y agoMusk on space solar (2m42s): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BeUcc8sDAi0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BeUcc8sDAi0
- stevage 3y ago"Successes and lessons". I'm going to use that.