9 ms·
NASA selects a plan to "swarm" Proxima Centauri with tiny probes
- sp332 3y agoLet’s see, total surface area of 1 square km, 1,000 probes in the swarm, that’s 1,000 square meters per probe… but it can only weigh a few grams? Also it can’t be sparse because the point is to capture light energy instead of letting it pass through.
- robin_reala 3y agoThe 1km^2 figure in the article was for the receiving “antenna” on earth. It doesn’t give a figure for the size of the sails, but Breakthrough Starshot’s equivalent swarm members were going for 4m^2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_Starshot#Light_sail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_Starshot#Light_sa...
- snakeyjake 3y agoBreakthrough Starshot is a scam and I can't believe that NASA is falling for it. 1. Extremely high duty cycle 100 gigawatt laser. (edit: now apparently it's an "array" because someone with a brain mentioned that a 100 gigawatt laser is ludicrous) That's right 7 peak summer output Grand Coulee Dams and 12 Palo Verde nuclear power plants with all reactors operating simultaneously COMBINED would be needed to power this laser. 2. "Swarm" (jfc buzzwords) craft that are currently impossible to create. The swarm behavior including networking, sensors, radio, and command and control do not exist and are impossible at a simple base level when considering RF energy requirements even with far-future theoretical energy harvesting technology. 3. Perfectly-spherical-frictionless-cow-ifying the EXTREMELY REAL effects of space weather. Forget the interstellar medium, these things will be blown out of the beamwidth by the time they reach jupiter's orbit from solar winds alone.
- chuckadams 3y agoIt's one of many competing research projects, the sum total of which add up to less than a single shuttle launch. I'm content with a dead end or two.
- snakeyjake 3y agoAfter writing my comment I looked it up and it’s the financial equivalent of a couple of post-docs for a year or two so I’m a lot less negative. Post-docs need to write papers. Let them write some about an impossible thought experiment. If they go past that though…
- hex4def6 3y agoI'm curious about whether it's even feasible based on dispersion issues. My understanding is that it's hard to beat dispersion over long distances, regardless of your optics on the laser (and we're talking long distances here...) Any optics experts able to chime in?
- 6d6b73 3y agoNot an optics expert but I consult for a company that makes lasers. Afaik not currently possible. The beam divergence is only one of many limiting factors
- wombatpm 3y agoI am not a physicist. Does beam divergence decrease in a vacuum? Could we put the lasers in space at L5 to power the swarm? Or L5 for Venus for the increased solar flux?
- selecsosi 3y agoBeam divergence, while happening at greater rate not in a vacuum, is a property of how photons propagate, so it's not something that can be eliminated
- jiggawatts 3y agoIt's almost entirely a function of wavelength and aperture diameter. It's basic wave mechanics, and is almost impossible to improve upon. I just recently watched a great video explaining how lithography machines push the limits of what's possible: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdlZ8KYVtPU&t=1151s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdlZ8KYVtPU&t=1151s Note that the best ASML machines can eke out an improvement on the order of a factor of two at best, not two thousand, which is what would be likely needed to power space probes at light-year distances.
- kragen 3y agomost laser systems get close to diffraction-limited divergence, which is governed by the size of your optics. vacuum vs. air affects it, but the effect is so small that you need sensitive instruments to detect the effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaussian_beam#Beam_waist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaussian_beam#Beam_waist the divergence angle is inversely proportional to your aperture diameter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airy_disk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airy_disk in theory by putting a bunch of laser emitters in solar orbit and operating them as a phased array you can make an aperture the size of the solar system. 1.22λ/d at, say, 400nm and 2 astronomical units of diameter is about 1.6 attoradians of divergence; at a radius of 4.3 light years (the distance to proxima centauri) this works out to an airy disk focal point of 66 microns. optical phased array lasers have been demonstrated https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phased-array_optics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phased-array_optics but nobody knows how to make one out of satellites yet i've only glanced at the proposal https://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.07061.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.07061.pdf and they're proposing 4.1-meter-diameter 3.6-gram probes, which would allow you to use a phased array about a million times smaller, about 5 million km, 13 times the distance to the moon. i don't see where they're proposing how they propose to beam 100 gigawatts onto the probes so i don't know if this is their proposal dispersion, by contrast, which means wavelength-dependent indices of refraction, doesn't affect lasers and doesn't happen in a vacuum; probably the person who mentioned it was using the wrong term by accident and meant divergence
- lxe 3y agoGiven 1.6 sq meter 500W solar panels, that's an area of 320 square kilometers. That can be constructed at $1/w at $100 billion. Also it's not necessary (or technically, it's actually impossible) to have 100% duly cycle laser for propulsion. It's definitely a megaproject, but it's not a "scam"
- numtel 3y agoFor comparison 320km2 is about 2.5 San Franciscos
- lxe 3y agoI asked chatgpt to make a quick demo to demonstrate the size of the 18x18 km2 square: https://lxe.github.io/map/ https://lxe.github.io/map/
- bumbledraven 3y agoNeat. How did you ask it to make that? Do you mind sharing the transcript?
- lxe 3y agoHere you go! https://chat.openai.com/share/024a7117-f3d0-4a23-8186-86eeeaeab9a2 https://chat.openai.com/share/024a7117-f3d0-4a23-8186-86eeea...
- dylan604 3y agoyeah, when you look at that over the default location over London, it looks big. Moving it closer to the Western US, it looks tiny
- jchanimal 3y agoSize of a Texas ranch. Call it “reverse solar” and you might have a winner.
- 3y ago
- dylan604 3y agoYou announce this kind of project so Congress Critters can get all up in arms about wasteful spending and is something that can then later be sacrificed to make them feel like they've done their job. Meanwhile...you have other projects that have been protected from the axe because the sacrifices of this farcical project.
- PeterisP 3y agoSo you're saying it's like the Queen's duck? https://bwiggs.com/notebook/queens-duck/ https://bwiggs.com/notebook/queens-duck/
- dylan604 3y agoThis is a tactic as old as the review/inspection process itself. The reviewer always needs to feel like they've done their part, and no product can be perfect on the first pass, right? So put the obvious thing there for them to find, or they will find the thing you are trying to squeak through the process. I had one building inspector tell me that when he found the obvious thing that was obviously obvious, he would then look for the thing trying to be hidden.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gumby 3y ago> Breakthrough Starshot is a scam and I can't believe that NASA is falling for it. I know some of the folks involved and they are working on 50 years to launch. It's a long term (multiprong) research project. I wouldn't call it a scam, I would call it "blue sky" (if it weren't a space project!)
- pengaru 3y ago> I wouldn't call it a scam, I would call it "blue sky" (if it weren't a space project!) Uh, don't we already have "moonshot" for this kind of endeavor, which the name "starshot" already plays on / speaks to?
- gumby 3y agoSeems likely some of the tiny probes will end up in the star so I suppose the name would be appropriate :-)
- huytersd 3y ago50 years to launch is a scam. I literally calculated rough trajectories using basic software (NASA EMTG) on how to get a probe out in the rough direction of proxima centuri now. A 50 year timeline on relatively simple things like this should be laughed out of the room. Even though Elon Musk is morally reprehensible now, his “unrealistic” schedules of 2 years may go over for moonshots but even twice the amount of time means the project is done in 4-5 years. Not some ridiculous 2 generation long schedule.
- mlyle 3y agoIf it takes 2-4% of the world's current electricity production to propel the things alone, we're maybe not ready to do it quite yet. But we're ready to start thinking about it. Just like we dreamt about rockets going to the moon decades before we attempted going to the moon.
- poulpy123 3y agolet me understand: you played with a software vaguely related to the topic for 5 mn and it was enough to decide that 50 years to make happen a mission that was never done before is a scam ?
- jessriedel 3y ago> 1. Extremely high duty cycle 100 gigawatt laser. (edit: now apparently it's an "array" because someone with a brain mentioned that a 100 gigawatt laser is ludicrous) That's right 7 peak summer output Grand Coulee Dams and 12 Palo Verde nuclear power plants with all reactors operating simultaneously COMBINED would be needed to power this laser. That's not how this stuff works. You would use some sort of large capacitor/battery bank which is charged by a much smaller power draw over a long time, and then dump the energy over a short time. The laser array currently operating at the National Ignition Facility has a peak output of 500 TW, more than three orders of magnitude higher than the number you called ludicrous. Obviously Starshot would be applying that power for a much longer time interval, and indeed would be a global undertaking dwarfing NIF. But it doesn't need 100GW of dedicated power plants.
- 6d6b73 3y agoNIF's laser works for only 1microsecond, took over a decade to build and the price was over 3.5 bln. "Peak current for the system exceeds 100 million amperes and the peak power exceeds 1 terawatt (1 trillion watts)" https://lasers.llnl.gov/about/how-nif-works/power-conditioning https://lasers.llnl.gov/about/how-nif-works/power-conditioni...
- jessriedel 3y agoPeak NIF power is actually only ~a nanosecond. And I acknowledged that Starshot would be a global undertaking that dwarfs NIF. I'm just saying that it's wrong to say this is going to require 100 GW of industrial power plants.
- andrewflnr 3y agoDo they not need to run it/them continuously for years for a solar sail approach to make sense? NIF is not a good comparison for exactly that reason.
- jessriedel 3y agoNo, the acceleration phase is only for a few minutes. (I agree with you that if it requires 100 GW of power for years, his criticism would be accurate.) After a few minutes, the probe is already so far away from Earth that you can't focus the lasers effectively on it.
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoYour comment is a scam, and I despise shills.
- p1mrx 3y ago100 GW isn't absurd, compared to global human energy consumption of around 20000 GW. The problem is, until we figure out how to stop burning fossil fuels and fix climate change, the amount of spare power we have is actually a large negative number.
- nynx 3y agoThe power is so high so that the probes can be accelerated up to 20% of the speed of light while still in the solar system. The array does not run for long periods of time.
- readyplayernull 3y agoThinking whether they could use one of the projects aiming to launch small payloads into space, sort of space trebuchets: SpinLaunch - Developing a system that spins a payload at ultra-high speeds inside a vacuum chamber, then launches it into the sky using stored rotational energy. They claim it could launch small satellites for a fraction of the cost of traditional rockets. Launchloop - Proposed concept of using a powerful electromagnetic accelerator called a Launchloop to fling payloads into space. It would use low-cost electricity rather than expensive rocket fuel. Still in early feasibility stage. TAES - Developing a space trebuchet mechanism that uses centrifugal force similar to how a trebuchet launches projectiles. They're aiming to launch 6U CubeSats (10x10x30cm) to Low Earth Orbit for a relatively low cost per launch. Rocket Lab - Makes small Electron rockets for launching 150kg payloads to LEO. Over 20 successful launches to date and helping enable more frequent smallsat launches. Virgin Orbit - Uses a modified Boeing 747 to carry a 2-stage LauncherOne rocket to altitude, then releases and ignites to place payloads in orbit. Aims for frequent, affordable smallsat launches.
- 14 3y agoNone of those solutions are suitable for this mission. These satellites need to be traveling a hundreds of thousand of kilometres an hour or more. Think about voyager 1 traveling at 65,000km/hr. It is still over 18,000 years before it will reach a light years distance and this mission is talking about 4 light years. So the launch really has zero importance as does getting these satellites up to massive massive speeds. Anything less then like 1million kilometres per hour is probably just too slow. Edit: even at 1 million kilometres per hour it would still take over 4000 years to reach the full distance so really we need to be going unimaginably fast to get there.
- temp0826 3y agoDo these launchers actually make sense? Maybe from the moon (obviously not for earth orbit-destined satellites, but deeper space)
- kolinko 3y agoLaunching from altitude gives you very little, so does spinlaunching. It is because it’s about speed, not altitude. Witch Spinlaunch, they plan to laumch around 5000kmph, and you need a speed of around 25000kmph to reach orbit. In other words, they would need to use their setup to launch a rocket of a size of 1/2-3/4 of size of a falcon1 to get into orbit, and even then, unless they land the second stage, they will come out far more expensive than what SpaceX is doing. The tech may work on moon, but even on Moon a different solution - similar to maglev - may be better, bacause there would be no issues with crazy centrifugal forces. Anything launching from earth will require some sort of a rocket fuel (or some new laws of physics), because even if you managed to launch at the speed of 25000km/h from the ground, the payload would slow down before it left the atmosphere.
- pokstad 3y agoJust put a frozen brain in space and use nukes to send it there.
- cdelsolar 3y agoInb4 death’s end
- m3kw9 3y agoThis is the one time they are forcing the issue when the tech isn’t even close but instead throwing 100billion to make it happen. Maybe use half that to do research for better fuel, materials, miniaturization and the other 50 to launch with higher chance of success
- dtgriscom 3y agoThis idea has shown up multiple times. I've never understood how they plan to communicate back, especially with a) gram-scale devices b) moving a significant fraction of the speed of light away from us while being c) multiple light-years away.
- mjrpes 3y agoThis article attempts to explain: https://www.nasa.gov/general/swarming-proxima-centauri/ https://www.nasa.gov/general/swarming-proxima-centauri/ "A swarm whose members are in known spatial positions relative to each other, having state-of-the-art microminiaturized clocks to keep synchrony, can utilize its entire population to communicate with Earth, periodically building up a single short but extremely bright contemporaneous laser pulse from all of them."
- 6d6b73 3y agoSo all these tiny satelites will also carry a laser and a power source for it? Yeah, good luck with it
- gumby 3y agoA kind of bucket brigade. They aren’t planning to launch a cloud of these things and be done, they’ll be launching a long stream of them for years. The probes can get power from the launch laser. At least that’s the idea I got from talking to some of these folks last year.
- GartzenDeHaes 3y agoProbably also worth noting that the laser would have practical military uses.
- rvbissell 3y agoLAZLO: "Looks at the facts: very high power. Portable. Limited firing time. Unlimited range. All you need is a tracking system and a large spinning mirror, and you could vaporize a human target from space." KNIGHT: "This is not good."
- ta93754829 3y agolets say we did this, and we got the tiny probes up to even ~speed of light... then what are they going to do when they get there? what sensors can they carry and report back. And we wouldn't be able to slow them down, so they're going to transit through the target solar system relatively quickly (days even).
- gumby 3y agodang, could you fix the title? This isn't NASA's plan, it's a collaboration between Space Initiatives and the Initiative for Interstellar Studies. The article's title is 'NASA Selects a Wild Plan to "Swarm" Proxima Centauri With Thousands of Tiny Probes'
- jessriedel 3y agoThis happens constantly. Some random scientist at one of NASA's dozen's of labs write a speculative proposal, and all the news articles say "NASA plans to do X".
- cwillu 3y agoKinda true, but the article did say “The concept was recently selected for Phase I development as part of this year's NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts (NIAC) program.”
- gumby 3y agoThey got a grant, just as the article title says.
- dang 3y agoWhat's a more accurate and neutral title?
- dvirsky 3y agoWhat would happen if a 1g probe traveling at 10% of the speed of light hits an inhabited planet with an atmosphere? The kinetic energy is insane, but will it just burn out in the atmosphere or will it manage to hit the surface and go boom, assuming earth like atmosphere?
- barbegal 3y agoThe energy is something like 100 tonnes of TNT so a big bang but not catastrophic to the planet.
- cryptoz 3y agoSure but such a thing could easily be taken as an aggressive action or attack and traced back to us. I mean, if there is a technological civilization there, that is. I love Breakthrough Starshot but this is an interesting risk to think about.
- MadnessASAP 3y agoI would like to think that a sophisticated civilization would understand what was happening. I also giggle at the idea of a highly advanced civilization arriving at earth to tell us humans exactly what they think of someone firing a relativistic shotgun at their planet. Even if it was only loaded with bird shot.
- cowboysauce 3y agoWould they even notice it though? Normal bolides of similar energy happen fairly frequently (see https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/fireball-and-bolide-reports https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/fireball-and-bolide-reports for an example). And even if they did, would they interpret it as a hostile act when similar events happen naturally without ill effect? It would mean the "attacker" posses the technology to accelerate materials to appreciable fractions of c while simultaneously not knowing that the impacts wouldn't do any damage to the target. Should we similarly be afraid of making radio broadcasts lest our intended recipients interpret our beaming of energy as a hostile act? A somewhat similar concept is actually mentioned in the novel Blindsight. You could even go full Dark Forest and say that we're a threat simply by existing all the while brazenly advertising our presence through the oxygen in the atmosphere.
- barbegal 3y agoWith a big enough laser and a big enough collecting device for a reflected signal, I can imagine that communication even at such distances is possible. On the other hand I can't understand the propulsion mechanism. The acceleration is such that any device will simply be ripped apart by the immense forces. The "sail" must be both impossibly thin to even allow such high acceleration but also impossibly strong to transfer all that force to the craft itself, and if that's not enough it needs to be impossibly reflective so that the laser doesn't vaporise it instead of accelerating it. I can't see how anyone could think the concept could ever possibly work.
- trhway 3y agoWe can use the Sun as a focusing lense - need to place the antenna at 500+ AU behind the Sun on the line of the desired communication. >On the other hand I can't understand the propulsion mechanism. Yes, i also think the laser propulsion isn't the one to go, at least with the current tech. With current tech my bet would be on ion drive https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38445404 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38445404
- paulhart 3y agoGood typo in the article: “the energy source for a lightsail is photos (which have no mass and move at the speed of light).” So, it can be powered by memes?
- seized 3y agoOnly by memes of cats with buttered toast attached to their backs.
- andrewstuart 3y agoThe distance is so ridiculously incomprehensibly far is hard to see this as anything except science fiction fantasy. If you think this sort of thing is possible you really don’t understand how far it is. To put it in relative perspective, if we represent the furthest distance humans have ever traveled as 1.3cm then the nearest star is 200 kilometers away.
- happytiger 3y agoTrue but we haven’t been further than the moon, our nearest neighbor. Unmanned missions have gone much further with success (and even returned).
- grecy 3y agoRemember people said exactly the same thing about flying, and about stepping foot on the moon. Everything is impossible until it's done.
- andrewstuart 3y agoThe comparisons don’t hold up. It’s not simply a country we haven’t found yet with a six month sailing journey.
- onethought 3y agoTrue - we know exactly where it is, how far, what technology will be required and we have light speed communication. The six month sailing journey sounds waaaaay more ominous.
- spacecadet 3y agoyeah people died on those, entire ships lost.
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoSince you want to take such a condescending tone about it, here we have an entire fucking article about how NASA thinks it's possible and is working on potential solutions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aussieguy1234 3y agoCould the tiny robots, at the other end, self assemble into something bigger?
- andrewflnr 3y agoThey'll be far away from each other then, probably lightseconds or even lightminutes, so I'm guessing no.
- blindriver 3y agoHow do they slow down?
- lgkk 3y agoI wish I could be alive when humanity’s first Dyson sphere powers up.
- sidlls 3y agoThis is ridiculous. Set aside the (incredibly optimistic, to be charitable) thinking that is going into the acceleration of these probes. The astronavigation itself is hugely questionable, especially with probes that aren't big enough to hold the kinds of equipment necessary to detect bodies that would perturb the trajectory, let alone make adjustments after encountering these. I don't think people realize how mind-bogglingly, incomprehensibly HUGE space is. It's BIG. Like think of the biggest thing you can comprehend, and it's not even the size of an atom in comparison to even "short" distances in space.
- Shawnj2 3y agoSomething I would point out is that this is more of a conceptual proposal than something real NASA is planning on doing. This mission as described here will never happen. With that said it’s still a useful exercise because we will do space probes to Alpha Centauri at some point and doing a pretend proposal for one and solving all the problems that come up when you try to do so will help make it feasible to actually do that type of mission in the future eg. The Europa Clipper or a lot of the other space probes we’ve done.
- GolfPopper 3y agoI'm a little surprised there's been no mention of Project Daedalus[1] in either the thread or the discussion. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Daedalus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Daedalus
- joe_the_user 3y agoIs there any plan to slow the probes or would they inspect Proxima Centauri very quickly?
- Log_out_ 3y agoThe cool thing is that swarm can form a half sphere mirror halfway, slowing one probe at the center down.
- jbperry 3y agoI don't see a way to slow down. So they would be travelling thru that solar system at .2c. At that speed, they wouldn't be in that solar system for long. Imagine this was Proxima Centauri doing the same mission on our solar system. Assuming that some of the swarm was on target enough to go thru the inner solar system: Mars is ~13 light minutes from the sun. So double that for the whole diameter of the orbit, 26 light minutes. At .2c that's 130 minutes total transit time (less really unless it passes really close to the sun). So probably less than 2 hours total in the inner solar system. And that's assuming you can hit that small of a target from 4.25 light years away. Light distance Sun-Saturn is 1.3 hours. 2.6 diameter. 13 hour transit time for most of the solar system. You don't know where the planets actually are going to be, or were to point a camera or any other instrument, except the sun. And you have probes that weigh grams. That's a tough problem, without considering the laser. But I like thinking about it.
- yencabulator 3y agoHow about step 1, you let us know when you have gram-scale computers, we can make some money on-planet and use that to fund the rest of your program.