8 ms·
GE Vernova announces order of 674 wind turbines, providing 2.4 GW of power
- InTheArena 3y agoI'd be curious how this compares with some significant projects in Europe and Asia?
- i_am_jl 3y agoAn output of 2.4Gw would make it the second most powerful onshore wind farm by nameplate output. China's Gansu is much (3-4x) more powerful. The UK's most powerful offshore farm, Hornsea, is being built in phases. Their phase 1+2 nameplate output is ~2.5Gw from 339 turbines, when finished they're aiming for 6Gw. It's big. It isn't the biggest and not really close to the biggest, but it's big.
- nharada 3y agoThat’s awesome, I wonder what the cost per MW came out to.
- chris222 3y agoiirc the transmission and generation was roughly an even split on the 11 billion raised. https://patternenergy.com/pattern-energy-closes-11-billion-financing-of-largest-clean-energy-infrastructure-project-in-u-s-history/ https://patternenergy.com/pattern-energy-closes-11-billion-f...
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoSo assuming 25 to 45% capacity factor, $10k to $18k per effective kW. Depreciate that linearly over 20 year's and you get 5.8 to 10.5¢ per kWh before maintenance and operations. Given Arizona pays about 16¢/kWh, the project seems likely to be viable.
- epistasis 3y agoYou are lumping together the transmission and generation costs, which will have different service lifetimes. Wind turbines are 30+, but advances in technology and falling costs have incentivized many wind farms to repower with bigger turbines far before the end of service life in order to increase profitability.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> lumping together the transmission and generation costs, which will have different service lifetimes Sure, it’s back of the envelope. If you have more precise figures I’m genuinely curious.
- mikeyouse 3y agoAn adjacent 350MW project from the same owners has a 46% capacity factor and signed a 20-year agreement for $0.04/kWh (they did qualify for the PTC so their 'real' cost is $0.06/kWh) - this project will surely be well under $0.10/kwh wholesale as well: > In the event Red Cloud qualifies for 100 percent of the PTC, the energy price will be reduced by $2.00 per MWh and the new energy price will be $41.00 per MWh. The price for Test Energy will be reduced to $30.25 per MWh and Excess Energy will be reduced to $16.40 per MWh. https://clkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2020/20-1217_misc_09-24-2020.pdf https://clkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2020/20-1217_misc_09-24...
- epistasis 3y agoThe best estimate was the 50% in the comment with the original link, which would correspond to $120/mile for transmission, which IIRC is right in the correct ballpark.
- guepe 3y agoExample in UK, offshore (with higher costs than onshore) are about 60 pounds/mwh (lcoe, so all included). That's 6 cents /kwh and this is offshore But UK has lots of offshore wind. Still the 10cents upper range is probably quite a bit higher than the real number here.
- epistasis 3y ago~$100/mile really highlights the challenge of transmission. Already, our transmission and distribution costs are more expensive than generation costs. Utilities want us to ignore these costs, as unavoidably, because they get to "rate base" T&D costs and charge a fixed rate of profit, meaning that anything extra they can spend on T&D is more profit that, without any competition. This is why residential solar get such stiff propaganda against it by utilities, going as far to say that residential solar "freeloads" on the grid, rather than saving everybody costs on the grid by reducing the peak needs of T&D. With wind, perhaps these transmission costs are somewhat unavoidable, but solar can be place elsewhere, and all solar that avoided this doubling of costs due to extra T&D costs should be highly encouraged by everyone (except the utilities, who lose out on profit).
- vlovich123 3y agoI find it hard to believe that truly self-sustained residential solar (solar panels + batteries all local) is going to be net cheaper than centralized grid generation. The maintenance costs should be significantly higher, particularly for the batteries. It’s not propaganda. The reason it’s freeloading is that you’re still connected to the grid and thus the T&D costs are still there as they’re largely fixed. Utilities have done a poor job of pricing T&D costs correctly (your hookup cost is massively subsidized on the assumption that you will consume an average amount of energy from the grid). Additionally, for a long time (at least in California) utilities were forced to buy back your excess electricity at retail instead of wholesale rates (even if they didn’t need it & they can’t really control electricity you generate like they can with power plants). Residential solar is a greedy tragedy of the commons solution that is subsidized by everyone else. And if everyone had residential solar + batteries + no grid hookup, someone would have to do the analysis if the maintenance cost vs T&D.
- flir 3y ago> It’s not propaganda So how come that rhetoric is only coming out of the US? The rest of the world's distribution networks don't have a problem with residential solar (afaik).
- toomuchtodo 3y agoRelated: https://electrek.co/2023/12/28/largest-clean-energy-project-us-sunzia/ https://electrek.co/2023/12/28/largest-clean-energy-project-... https://patternenergy.com/projects/sunzia/ https://patternenergy.com/projects/sunzia/
- kevincox 3y agoThe announcement doesn't seem provide any estimation of power output? Just the peak power. It would be interesting to see what the overall output is expected to be.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoTypical capacity factors of current wind farms are between 25% and 45%. Nuance is expected curtailment [1], if there are batteries at commissioning or potentially in the future for firming and curtailment reduction [2], how this compliments solar and other generation types in the US West at delivery points, etc. [1] https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=57100 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=57100 [2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352152X20318594 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S23521... (solar PV specific, but the same modeling can be applied to wind prediction)
- plorg 3y agoSiting, of course, is the other big factor. I assume the project developer has priced this in and judged this project to be at least profitable, so you might assume they have good wind.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoYes. https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/wind-resource-assessment-and-characterization https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/wind-resource-assessment-an... https://windexchange.energy.gov/states/nm#maps https://windexchange.energy.gov/states/nm#maps
- BenoitP 3y agoFrom wikipedia [1] > Typical capacity factors of current wind farms are between 25 and 45% Offshore being about 10% higher than on land. Of note is that it is in unconstrained conditions, defined by the weather; when it is needed or when a flexible production can reduce its output, or when flexible consumption can absorb it. As renewables' share increase, this is becoming a problem in some parts of the world: electricity prices can even go negative at times. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor
- tony_cannistra 3y agoAs a somewhat interesting aside, the transmission line associated with this project (the "SunZia" project) has been a bit mired in a web of (legitimate) complexities, mostly related to environmental protection and Indigenous sovereignty. The San Carlos Apache Tribe and the Tohono O’odham Nation in particular have protested the line's route in Arizona, and it's currently in Bureau of Land Management review. https://www.hcn.org/articles/south-landline-bidens-push-for-power-lines https://www.hcn.org/articles/south-landline-bidens-push-for-...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> San Carlos Apache Tribe and the Tohono O’odham Nation in particular have protested the line's route in Arizona Can’t tell if the tribes [1] want an amended path, to kill the project, to be paid off or are NIMBYing [1]. [1] https://www.archaeologysouthwest.org/wp-content/uploads/2023-03-18_Archaeology-Southwest_SunZia_Protest_With-Attachments.pdf https://www.archaeologysouthwest.org/wp-content/uploads/2023...
- yardie 3y agoThe US Govt has hardly honored any of their Native American agreements. I find it acceptable to extract money from a belligerent government in any way possible.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoWe should really stop pretending that the Native American reservations are 'sovereign states', and just label them semi-autonomous zones or something.
- mminer237 3y agoDidn't the 1871 Indian Appropriation Act essentially do that?
- chris222 3y agoTbey just announced the close of financing on Dec 27 so this is great news that the order with GE was confirmed so quickly. Things are moving along nicely. https://patternenergy.com/pattern-energy-closes-11-billion-financing-of-largest-clean-energy-infrastructure-project-in-u-s-history/ https://patternenergy.com/pattern-energy-closes-11-billion-f...
- Kon-Peki 3y agoThe GE press release made it sound like they've previously done more than 1GW worth of wind power business with this company. I imagine that the track record made it really easy to get the financing in place.
- Proven 3y ago[dead]
- foobarian 3y agoI was curious how it compares to the large nuclear plants and came across this [1] where it turns out the top 7 stations are all hydro. The top one being 22GW! Wild. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_power_stations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_power_stations
- darknavi 3y agoI really want to like hydro but it has clear negative effects on ecology (namely fish). I am really hoping wind and solar don't affect local ecology as much.
- HPsquared 3y agoLayman's question: don't the reservoirs create a new habitat for fish? They'd be "artificial" in a way but eh, so is everything else. Or is the problem that they all get turned into fish pie in the turbine...
- voakbasda 3y agoRiver fish need different habitat than lake fish. And in many areas, migratory fish are impeded from reaching their spawning grounds. Fish ladders and other contrivances are a poor workaround for an unimpeded flow.
- nereye 3y agoOne of the main issues is that dams tend to block access to the upstream spawning grounds for species such as Coho salmon. E.g. see https://www.reuters.com/world/us/save-salmon-us-approves-largest-dam-removal-history-2022-11-17/ https://www.reuters.com/world/us/save-salmon-us-approves-lar....
- bilekas 3y agoNot sure how prevalent they are bit aren't fish ladders built with dams for this exact reason? https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0925857416305936 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092585741...
- bilsbie 3y agoThis really puts into perspective how much the 1.21 GW that the delorean used.
- aperson_hello 3y agoThere's a philosophical discussion to be had here regarding the difference between a gigawatt and a jigawatt!
- airstrike 3y agoTechnically "jigowatts" per the script http://www.dailyscript.com/scripts/bttf4th.pdf http://www.dailyscript.com/scripts/bttf4th.pdf even though they really meant it to be gigawatts
- jokteur 3y agoIn the french dub, they say jigowatt.
- bilsbie 3y agoAlso could be very little energy depending on how long they needed to apply the power.
- bilsbie 3y agoWhat if they just built batteries into the base of turbine? And it could become a base load power source by smoothing its output.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> What if they just built batteries into the base of turbine? What would this gain other than making the turbines more expensive to build and maintain? It’s cheaper to put the batteries almost anywhere else and altogether.
- epistasis 3y agoAdding batteries is already quite common to allow for small amounts of price arbitrage. Its more common for utilities scale solar, with over half of new solar including storage, but wind isn't far behind, IIRC. The advantage of putting it next to the generation is that you get to reuse the transmission line, and make better use of it. And since transmission and distribution are more expensive than generation, anything that cuts those costs is a big win. Also, it's a site that the wind farm owner already controls, which makes it far easier than obtaining interconnection somewhere else, as interconnection queues are one of the biggest roadblocks to deploying more renewable resources right now. (Additionally, with solar, you get to reduce your inverters, which you can't do if the storage is placed at a second site)
- Symbiote 3y agoThe suggestion was the base of each turbine. That has no advantages compared to the point the turbines are connected to the electricity grid — N locations to service rather than 1, N copies of everything rather than 1 big one, etc.
- epistasis 3y agoYou are correct, I misunderstood! Hopefully my prattling on will be helpful to others though...
- jl6 3y ago3.5MW per turbine is quite modest. GE have a 14MW model - possibly onshore vs offshore is the difference? Also, $11bn for the whole 3.5GW project isn’t bad compared to $34bn for 2.2GW of new nuclear: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogtle_Electric_Generating_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogtle_Electric_Generating_Pla... (3.5GW of wind nameplate capacity being ~1.2GW at the typical onshore capacity factor of 35%) You could buy a lot of storage for the difference.
- seec 3y agoThe thing is you could run the nuclear stations at almost full tilt pretty much all the time while your wind turbines park will output as you noted about 35% of their theoretical capacity. So, it's cheaper but its output is also almost half of the nuclear plus the intermittent issue. Even if we consider that you "saved" $23bn, that would buy about 58 Megapack XL from Tesla, at around 4 MWh a piece. So, in the end, you would only be able to pay for 230 MWh, or 0.23 GWh. You are still very far from the excess 1GW available at any time that the nuclear station would give you. The way I see it, the economics would need to increase at least 5 folds before it can be thought of as a "solution" and that's before considering the longevity and logistics of those systems. It is extremely likely that they won't last as long and will be even more of a pain in the ass to manage in the very long term, but that's something greenwashing would rather keep under the radar. Then we will have to deal with stuff like this: https://www.texasmonthly.com/news-politics/sweetwater-wind-turbine-blades-dump/ https://www.texasmonthly.com/news-politics/sweetwater-wind-t... I was actually looking for an impressive picture of an unused wind farm I read about a bit ago (unrelated, on an urbex site) that didn't make sense to run economically but was just sitting there... Considering all their foreseeable long-term problems, most of the "green" solutions look like more trouble than they are worth. But the only other answer is to force people to consume less or kill 2/3 of humans on the planet so I guess we will keep on the lies...
- varjag 3y agoOffshore stuff is just bigger: the sweet spot is different due to substantial fixed cost of wind park installation. But for perspective, two decades ago when we had our earliest deliveries to wind power sector, 1.3MW turbines were state of the art for offshore.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jjcm 3y agoLooks like they currently have around 4.51 GW of power generation in the state based off of this (someone please double check my math, but 3250GWh in Sept / 720 hours in Sept = 4.51GW): https://www.eia.gov/state/?sid=NM#tabs-4 https://www.eia.gov/state/?sid=NM#tabs-4, so this should be a 53% increase in power generation for the state. Truly a massive project.
- andruby 3y agoThe stated 2.4GW of the article is "nameplate" output (± peak output). You computed the average generation over a whole month. The difference between both is called "capacity factor" and is of course different per region. I've found some online numbers between 30 and 45%. Multiplying your 53% number with a 35% CF becomes a more realistic but less impressive 18.5% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power#Capacity_factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power#Capacity_factor
- palemoonale 3y agoYay! More ugly landscape-disturbing things helping only during certain hours, compared to established nuclear technology, or still-in-research fusion technology. PS, the usual peeps downvoting not just me: Sure, let your emotions guide you, don't care. My comment above is not offtopic.
- alphabettsy 3y agoIt’s not off-topic, but it’s not in the spirit of HN either. I assume your tone is why you’re downvoted.
- ben_w 3y ago"Ugly" is an opinion, which means it's neither true nor false. Me, I like them, but I know that me liking them doesn't invalidate your dislike. And calling them "landscape-disturbing" is true, but so are all other things — I've been to some wind farms, they are much less disruptive to the environment than the nuclear reactors I can only see from a distance. Sheep grazing under and around them, for a start.
- lmm 3y ago> I've been to some wind farms, they are much less disruptive to the environment than the nuclear reactors I can only see from a distance. Sheep grazing under and around them, for a start. Huh? Every nuclear reactor I've seen has ended up surrounded by a de facto if not legal wildlife preserve.
- threeseed 3y agoNuclear is simply not price competitive. And according to Tokamak Energy who is one of the fusion leaders it won't be ready until 2030s at the earliest.
- justapassenger 3y ago[dead]
- kaskakokos 3y ago
- Dah00n 3y agoWhy is it every post about solar or wind have to end up with comments about how great nuclear is? It is like a religion they simply must preach.
- thinkcontext 3y agoI think those that make "what about nuclear" posts should be required to invest in a company that would build an AP1000. This is the reactor that was supposed to lead the US nuclear renaissance. Instead it's 2 projects were utter financial failures, with one getting cancelled after spending $9b on a hole in the ground and the other is coming online after going 2x+ budget in time and money. All in development AP1000 projects were cancelled after this debacle. But this shouldn't be daunting to true believers. The most advanced cancelled project was Turkey Point in FL. It had received all approvals so a developer can start tomorrow if they want. If we made everyone who said "what about nuclear" buy a $100 share that sucker would be funded in no time.
- lordofgibbons 3y agoProbably because it's the only known carbon-free source of dependable and non-intermittent energy that can be deployed nearly anywhere. Let's be realistic about the devastatingly massive amounts of environmental damage wind/solar are doing by requiring unimaginably large amounts of minerals to be mined for both solar/wind AND the required batteries. Right now, it's an "out of sight, out of mind" kind of a problem because the mining happens in poor countries. How many cobalt and lithium mines have been approved in the U.S? I can think of only a couple in the past couple of decades. Why? Because they're terrible for the environment.. so we outsource the environmental damage to poor countries. Nuclear is expensive, but if we build a new plant every 40 years... what do we expect? Each plant is a one-off bespoke creation. The same economies of scale that have made solar+wind so cheap also apply to nuclear tech. We have the technology to solve the climate emergency. Nuclear lets us do it. Everything else is wishful thinking. p.s wind and solar have a part to play - specially in unstable and failed states where the existence of fissile material could be very dangerous.
- Dah00n 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]