5 ms·
Not to say anything nice about the ideological sh*t-show of modern academia...but an article sub-titled "Academics should think more about what their industry h
by bell-cot 3y ago
Not to say anything nice about the ideological sh*t-show of modern academia...but an article sub-titled "Academics should think more about what their industry has done to lose the trust of Americans" might want to mention the decades of far-faster-than-inflation tuition increases, and destitution-level pay for most of the instructional staff, and ever-growing administrative bloat, and student-luxury-amenities arms race, and blind eyes turned to university-staff sexual predators, and ...
- paul80808 3y agoThis guy PSEs. I've worked in tertiary education policy for 20 years and this is about the best summary of structural issues possible to fit in a tweet-length post, well done.
- dastbe 3y agoPSEs?
- gnicholas 3y agoAll I can find is Porn Star Experience, which I'm guessing is what's intended, but doesn't strike me as the most natural usage of the term (which, admittedly, I've never used). EDIT: Thanks for the downvotes...I still can't tell if this is correct or not. The reply that says "post secondary educations" doesn't make sense to me because it this appears to be used as a verb, and that doesn't scan for me.
- refulgentis 3y agoHN can be frustrating, you'll get voted through the floor by the initial rush of dopamine addicts frustrated questions don't contain info. Then, you'll be told you got voted through the floor because you complained you got voted through the floor. Over the 14 years I've been here, I've gotten enough training data to A) wait it out and/or B) make an edit showing humor about it? "wow, -4 for an innocuous take you'd find at any coffee shop!?" On the net, it doesn't matter much unless you're a new account, things always trend positive as long as you don't _always_ show up with takes explaining everyone is committing group think and you're the only one who gets it. (p.s. that's not even close to what you're doing here! just illustrating the only situation in which I think people get persistently negative votes) EDIT: Lol
- smolder 3y agoThey just "verbed a noun", I believe.
- gnicholas 3y agoYeah, I guessed that. But which noun? Can someone unpack what the comment means if the abbreviation is for post graduate education?
- stavros 3y agoIt's a combination of the "this guy fucks" meme and a verbed noun, so it's like saying "this guy Facebooks". That having been said, I also didn't know what PSE was, and I don't think you should be downvoted.
- recursivecaveat 3y agoPost-secondary educations.
- Waterluvian 3y agoIndeed there are a lot of things that can help or harm confidence in an institution. I think this blog post is focusing on the socio-political aspect, rather than the economic and criminal aspects.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoThe socio-political hinterlands these bloggers inhabit is that of being unable to recognize the failures of modernism. It's an failure of their collective mind to continue to cling to a failed project - and fundamentally modernism's inherent self-contradiction: modernism's inability to modernize itself. We ventured deep into what makes something true and down every epistemological corridor, we found a chasm that could only be crossed by assuming true to our ontological priors. And when we pointed that these assumptions landed us in different realities, the modernists, blind to their own actions, were cocky enough to tell us they never did such a thing. I'm fed up with the lot. The entire weaselly bunch can get busy leaving.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoIf Gödel means I have to view shamanism and racism with equal esteem as empiricism and egalitarianism, I don't want to modernize past modernism. I don't think humans, in our present form of bio-technological evolution, can afford to without everything becoming worse.
- Waterluvian 3y agoI’ve been listening to and reading Barro for years and I’m not sure this bloviation is realistic. Ultimately he’s whoever you decide he is. But it doesn’t match my understanding of his attitudes or interests.
- jimbob45 3y agoHow would you feel about separating out post-grad and undergrad into their own separate universities?
- at_a_remove 3y agoBut where will we get our adjuncts and people to do our dry cleaning?
- downrightmike 3y agoThere is no way that addresses even one of the issues. You should dig a little deeper.
- ta8645 3y agoIt would be much more effective to separate out testing & certification, from education & training. It's a conflict of interest, and it allows universities to lose focus from just making sure their students learn the required material.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoAgreed. For "non-profits" institutions, I certainly see college administration and trustee boards getting paid astronomical amounts for otherwise dubious work and expertise while students and academics suffer. The thing that I found most insulting was when university faculty and staff would complain about entitled students. My reply was always," if your tuition for 1 year costs as much as a fully optioned luxury vehicle, I expect certain things to be present." And I can at least sell the automobile at a later date. Can't do that with my toilet paper of a degree. I wholeheartidly believe in some form of student loan forgiveness but it needs to be at the expense of higher education who created this crisis. The solution is simple: 1. Cap student visas 2. End government backed student loans. Or at least restrict them to STEM only. 3. Tax university endowment income as a percent to pay down outstanding student loan debts when tuition is over an arbitrary amount. Universities want to peddle socialism then it's time they pay their fair share.
- api 3y agoI came here to post this. This far more than out of touch politics or corruption is the fundamental problem. When NFTs take advantage of young gullible people to sell them certificates at a ridiculous markup, we properly call that a scam. When universities let students go into massive debt for degrees that do not boost earning power, that’s fine. What’s even more criminal is that tenure track positions remain scarce and academics in general remains underfunded in spite of insane tuition inflation. Where is that money going? Loads of administrators and salary increases for the higher ups of course. Administration overhead is just ludicrous. It’s a jobs program for older people funded by making the young go into debt. Goofy politics is a minor issue next to this.
- a2tech 3y agoLets not the semiprofessional sports teams that are allowed/encouraged to operate under their umbrella somehow. They never seem to funnel anything tangible BACK to the university but are always taking. I just don't get how this has been allowed to flourish. Its not healthy for anyone and has nothing to do with the academic mission of a school.
- jhbadger 3y agoI'm not a big fan of sports myself, but an argument that often gets used is that college teams (particularly when they do well) cause alumni to be more generous in giving to their schools. I don't think any school has really done the research to show that this is the case, though.
- a2tech 3y agoI'd love to see that broken down in a fair way. I've heard that a lot as well, but I've never seen any data. It seems like the athletic programs at these schools directly impact a few hundred (ish) kids that are actually in the big sports, and otherwise exist as a machine that enriches the people running the athletic program.
- arrosenberg 3y ago> I don't get how this has been allowed to flourish It has made Disney tremendous amounts of money. That's basically it.
- whyenot 3y ago> far-faster-than-inflation tuition increases > destitution-level pay for most of the instructional staff Faculty in the California State University system are planning to strike during the first week of the spring semester. Their goal: to get a 15% salary increase. Factoring in inflation and the increased cost of living near many campuses, it's not a hand up, or even treading water, it's sinking a little more slowly. If they get what they want (and they should, compensation for non-administrators in the CSU is ridiculous), the money has to come from somewhere. It seems extremely unlikely that the CSU will be able to get the funding from the legislature in a year of budget deficits. Yes, they could (and should!) cut the number of administrators, but most actually serve useful functions, and the savings would not be that great. That leaves tuition increases. Maybe things would be different if the system were still funded by the state to the same degree they were decades ago, but those days are gone.