13 ms·
Drones are the new drug mules
- lagniappe 3y agoAnd anybody who's been to the Funker lately can tell you that they're the new insurgents as well. It's astonishing how overnight the terrain of war changed completely when the first drone guided projectile was launched in personal combat. I'd be curious to know what percentage of a certain brand of drones is dedicated to this purpose, and what those supply lines look like, because most of the videos I see have only but a small handful of models in use.
- scrps 3y agoUkrainians mostly use their own drones made by various groups locally to avoid being centralized, they are also running into issues with russian jamming. Consumer drone gear is very easy to jam, also easier to foxhunt (RF location hunting) so it works both ways.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoI wonder would something like a small anti-radiation missile work against whoever is sending the strong EW signal
- brucethemoose2 3y agoOr an anti-radiation drone!
- reactordev 3y agoSo now you have SEAD missions to protect your CAS missions but all in 1/14th scale FPV drones… the future is wild. It’s a game of rock-paper-scissors-lizard-spock.
- scrps 3y agoSomehow prescient: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_Soldiers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_Soldiers
- hdhfjkrkrme 3y agoA missile is too heavy, it's easier to just fly the drone into the jammer if you can locate it.
- ponector 3y agoI doubt the signal is stronger than mobile phone or satellite connection. And the drone is too small to be intercepted with missile. FPV drone costs 500-1000$ now and is the game changer in the current war. No ground offensive operation can be maid now without great loses.
- jdietrich 3y agoJamming is a mixed bag, because a) you lose your own drone capability in that area and b) you broadcast a loud beacon that says "HERE IS THE APPROXIMATE LOCATION OF A HIGH-VALUE ASSET". The Ukrainians have had some big wins from triangulating weird-looking RF signals and unleashing hell on whatever is radiating it - you can jam a drone, but you can't jam a 155mm shell.
- Manuel_D 3y agoJamming can avoid "friendly fire" through a variety of means. Directional antennas can emit RF in the direction of the enemy, but not your own assets. You can also jam on different frequencies than you're using to operate your own drones.
- scrps 3y agoThat and larger drone comms for russia I would guess are satellite based which is harder to jam and sadly out of budget for the Ukrainians. That being said I wonder if you could control small drones over satellite or if that is a $900 solution to a 99 cent problem.
- Manuel_D 3y agoSatellite communications also has the issue of bigger form factor and larger power requirements. Not an issue for a predator drone, but your DJI isn't going to be using satellite comms any time soon. The more promising areas are optical communications (but this has issues with fog and atmospheric attenuation), or directional antennas. Like, a yagi on a gimbal constantly pointed at the control station.
- _ea1k 3y agoThat's all fine and dandy, but if you can use the source to approximate a location, you can hit it with himars. Alternatively, send gps guided drones with optical targeting. If the jamming system has inadequate air defenses, it might not be jamming for long.
- jdietrich 3y ago
- reactordev 3y agoIt’s a lot cheaper to 3D print your own frame and just buy the components to build an FPV drone with an attachment for whatever payload you want to deliver. You can build one for under $300 if you already have controllers and headset to pilot one. Blades can now be 3D printed as well using SLA printers or using carbon fiber. ESC’s can be made with Arduino. I doubt they are flying DJI’s in one-way missions. Military drones are one thing but these new front-line drones have changed warfare forever.
- spywaregorilla 3y agoThe drones are so cheap it's pointless not to send them on suicide missions. The cost per kill is vastly far from the limiting factor.
- aftbit 3y agoThey are 100% flying DJI drones on 1-way missions. Even a relatively expensive DJI drone costs less than an artillery shell. War is hell in many ways, not least of which is the sheer expense and resource consumption it demands.
- mrguyorama 3y agoActually the American M795 155mm HE artillery round costs the US army about $820 each. However, FPV drones are the cheapest GUIDED weapon by far. It's finally cost effective to give every single soldier a "Fuck that guy in particular" weapon. They will be significantly less effective in a real, peer conflict between great powers though. China or the US would likely have significant EW capabilities against drones. The US would probably rather turn off GPS entirely than deal with American soldiers being donked on the head with personalized grenades every day. So drones in a conflict like that would be much less useful in "hot" locations, or will be significantly more expensive per unit so they can be made harder to jam and interfere with, or will be used more as a nuisance.
- stormfather 3y agoIn a great power war the autonomous drones with inertial guidance and optical targeting are coming out.
- melling 3y agoIt might be astonishing but it was obvious soon after the war started that drones would change warfare. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31842578 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31842578
- lesuorac 3y agoI'm not sure that's accurate. Drones have been in use long before Russia took any land from Ukraine in 2014. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drone_warfare#Notable_drone_strikes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drone_warfare#Notable_drone_st...
- melling 3y agoSure, they’ve been around for a while. However, a war like the one in Ukraine will accelerate the development and usage of drones. You could tell by the early usage in the first few months of the war. Now more global defense dollars will go into the rapid development. Wait until we see swarms of (semi)autonomous drones
- bostik 3y ago> Wait until we see swarms of (semi)autonomous drones Slaughterbots[ß] becoming reality in 3...2...1... ß: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-2tpwW0kmU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-2tpwW0kmU
- _ea1k 3y agoI think we are already there. "Optical targeting" and "edge computing" are terms getting tossed around in weird ways at times.
- dendrite9 3y agoPrior to 2022 it seemed clear this was coming, fighters in Burma were using small drones against the dictatorship both for spotting and to drop explosives. It seemed like Ukraine was where real resources could be put into action, and things ramped up significantly. Before the videos from Burma I'm not sure where else to look, maybe Syria? There were drones used by ISIS but they seemed closer to military drones than what we see now with commercial drones or drone components used. I'm glad not be in the business of protecting people/infrastructure from harm.
- cbsmith 3y agoI like the implication that drug mules aren't effectively insurgents. ;-)
- hdhfjkrkrme 3y agoFor FPV drones both Ukraine and russia but the components from China and assemble them locally. Ukraine is very worried that China is trying to cut them off, so they buy through a long chain of intermediaries.
- autoexec 3y agoOn the plus side, if you can shoot one out of the sky, you get free drugs! No pesky armed drug dealers around to stop you from stealing from them! Just watch out for GPS trackers in the package.
- mortallywounded 3y agoHopefully not near your home-- when the cartel comes to the GPS coordinates ;p
- adolph 3y agoPretty close to the plot of No Country for Old Men https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Country_for_Old_Men https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Country_for_Old_Men
- yard2010 3y agoThat's a tough and important movie
- dingnuts 3y agolol you mean a pointless movie that intentionally tortures the audience and is unpleasant to watch because that's "subverting expectations" trite critic-pandering trash imho, it's only "tough" in that the director hates you, the audience, and thinks you're stupid, and it has a nihilistic message that is the opposite of important, it's stupid and disastrous, and most of the people who I have encountered who like this film seem to be in a pissing contest with one another over who can enjoy the most unpleasant film
- wilkystyle 3y ago...? For such a strong opinion, you didn't include any examples of why you and your circle of friends feel this way about the movie.
- 3y ago
- Podgajski 3y agoTechnology wins again!
- amath 3y agoMaybe this is a contradictory thought, but this is probably a good thing. I think you could argue that most drug mules are doing it because they don't, or don't think, they have another option to change their current life. If this reduces the number of humans used to smuggle drugs, it is probably a good thing.
- PoignardAzur 3y ago> I think you could argue that most drug mules are doing it because they don't, or don't think, they have another option to change their current life. If this reduces the number of humans used to smuggle drugs, it is probably a good thing. We really don't have the same outlook on life, because my first thought was "Oh shit, what are the people with shitty enough lives to be drug mules going to turn to now?"
- ethbr1 3y agoWe should tax drone sales and use the proceeds to fund drug mule job retraining programs.
- dessimus 3y agoBecause you have drug smugglers buying them in the US? I'm pretty sure they can buy drones and parts in Mexico, too.
- Terr_ 3y agoThey'll become straw-buyers for drone parts.
- rurp 3y agoCartels don't seem like the most laissez faire employers, especially when they need a lot of people for risky menial work like drug mules. There's probably quite a bit of coercion involved in these roles.
- foobarian 3y agoAh yes, here we go again with tech taking jobs away from poor people.
- taco_emoji 3y agoleast surprising headline of 2024 so far
- gnarlouse 3y agoDrones man. I think drones are gonna be the end of mankind man lol.
- ethbr1 3y agoThings that change the future are because they change it in kind, not in specifics. Drones (a) remove the requirement to have a human present & (b) aerial ones can operate is a largely congestion-free medium. Taken together, those two attributes are game changing for a lot of things. Persistent naval ISR is going to revolutionized, just as aerial has.
- gnarlouse 3y ago> Things that change the future are because they change it in kind, not in specifics. As always not sure what you’re on about. All it takes is one moron who wants to hurt people to strap something dangerous to a drone and send it off in a civilian area. In a best-case scenario, going outside is ruined for everybody. In a worst-case scenario, like China or North Korea is the who does it and it’s a widespread/orchestrated event. Seems pretty inevitable to me
- rurp 3y ago> In a best-case scenario, going outside is ruined for everybody. It's not like progress will get to a certain point and then just stop. If terorists reach the point of being able to bomb anyone they want, an insane amount of resources will be directed at stopping that and new countering methods will be developed.
- gnarlouse 3y ago> terrorists reach the point of being able to bomb anyone they want I mean I think all they have to do is attack voters psychologically. Furthermore, what happens when these awful school shooter losers decide to apply Ukrainian tactics on after school activities? They’re all little wannabe terrorists. I personally think it’s just a matter of time, the same way Columbine was (unfortunately) a matter of time. I sure hope I’m just over-paranoid. Could be a really dark future.
- lgkk 3y agoYou know… like I get people “want” to do drugs and all. (Not me) But the older I get the more I’m on the side of this stuff isn’t necessary. It is detrimental to society and if someone wants to do drugs they should honestly reconsider their life and do something productive. If it was possible to hot patch this crap out of existence I’d be in favor of it. Might even implement it myself if I could. I don’t want my kids to see junkies or live in a world where this kind of violence happens. When there are way nicer and better options out there. And yea I get it not everyone has it well. I certainly didn’t coming from a 3rd world country, but I still found other ways. But that’s not an excuse. Honestly kind of demeaning/stupid when well to do people treat it that way.
- aftbit 3y agoMost things aren't necessary. Many things are net detrimental to society. We still allow the vast majority of them, because people are free to do what they want with their lives in this world. Just because you have kids doesn't mean that your wishes have more weight than theirs. The biggest harms from drugs come not from the drugs themselves, but from the fact that their users and sellers have been locked out of our legal dispute resolution system. Drugs only lead to violence as long as someone is trying to stop them. If they were regulated and sold openly, with just 10% of the funding that currently goes to law enforcement to futilely try to stop them instead being diverted to addiction treatment and honest non-fear-mongering education, they would result in an order of magnitude less harm.
- ben_jones 3y agoYou know... I understand people "want" to drink coffee and all. (Not me) But the older I get, the more I realize this habit isn't necessary. It's not beneficial to society, and if someone feels the need for coffee, they should really reconsider their lifestyle and find something more productive to do. If there was a way to completely eliminate the culture of coffee consumption, I'd support it. Might even take action myself if I could. I don't want my kids to grow up in a world obsessed with coffee. There are so many better and healthier alternatives available. And yes, I understand not everyone has it easy. I certainly didn't, coming from a 3rd world country, but I still chose other options. That's no excuse, though. It's honestly quite demeaning and foolish when well-off people treat coffee drinking as something essential.
- jimt1234 3y agoDoes anyone know anything about current defenses against large-scale drone attacks? The scenario I'm thinking of is 100+ small drones, each with an explosive device attached (maybe a grenade), all programmed to attack a specific target, at a specific date/time. The defenses that I know about (shotguns and nets?) might stop, maybe, half of the drones, but that still leaves 50 grenades, all set to explode on the same target. I just don't know how a target would defend against an attack like that - GPS jamming?
- aftbit 3y agoIf you want to know more about the state of the art here, read more about the Ukraine war, preferably on Slavic language sites. It seems the main defense is electronic warfare, either jamming the GPS or the control signals. This is leading to an autonomy arms race at the moment, as a drone with a preprogrammed mission and optical flow sensors is much less vulnerable to jamming.
- pixl97 3y agoThe future of MicroAI is going to be interesting for military purposes. Just think about the AI capabilities of your cell phone these days, then thinking just how a little bit more intelligence on a dumb weapon could make it far more deadly.
- gumballindie 3y agoYeah will be cool once “hallucinates” and kills friendlies. Depends which side uses them i suppose.
- rurp 3y agoI think there are enough limitations with the current tech that this isn't a big concern at the moment, otherwise we would certainly be seeing these types attacks in Ukraine. But the field is evolving incredibly quickly and it's possible this becomes viable in the future. Some current drawbacks I can think of: * Small drones carrying a load generally have a short range, which could make launching such an attack (and surviving the response) difficult. * Coordination is hard. Manually controlled drone frequencies can conflict. There have been some automated sky displays that went well, but attacking a busy hardened target is much more difficult and I don't think the autonomous software is good enough yet. * Cost in terms of money, time, and risk. Jerry-rigging drones with improvised explosives is time consuming and dangerous, plus 100 drones cost money. * Jamming can protect a specific area from drones
- Balvarez 3y agoI suspect sub/boat drones have been used in the water for a long time. Seems like it would be relatively easy.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoYeah, I've read in the past some busts of big drug submarines, but I think having some small drone subs would make much more sense: 1. Unlike air drones, relatively small sub drones would be much more difficult to spot and intercept. The ocean is already filled with a lot of stuff like fish, so it seems like it would be relatively easy to camouflage. 2. One lost drone is a relatively small loss vs. having a big sub get intercepted and lose millions worth of product. 3. Now sure how big of a battery you'd need. Curious how long, say, a 2 mile long swim by a small sub would require in kWh.
- rcxdude 3y agoThe issue is range, as you hint at with your last point. Because of how hydrodynamics works, big ships/subs are more efficient than small ones, and so it's relatively hard to make a small sub with enough range to be useful (or even enough thrust to reliably make progress in the open ocean).
- rainworld 3y agohttp://www.hisutton.com/Narco%20Subs%20101.html http://www.hisutton.com/Narco%20Subs%20101.html
- Balvarez 3y agowow that's super cool thanks!
- adolph 3y agoThe article's examples use relatively expensive and human controlled quad-copters. They would be better off with a cardboard plank like the Corvo PPDS running an ArduPilot waypoint mission: The Corvo Precision Payload Delivery System (PPDS) is a low cost, disposable UAS that is optimised for the covert delivery of small volume payloads. The PPDS is designed to be deployed into theatre in a flat pack configuration. https://corvouas.com.au/corvo-ppds/ https://corvouas.com.au/corvo-ppds/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sypaq_Corvo_Precision_Payload_Delivery_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sypaq_Corvo_Precision_Payload_... https://ardupilot.org/plane/docs/common-mission-planning.html https://ardupilot.org/plane/docs/common-mission-planning.htm...
- btbuildem 3y agoPretty cool stuff!
- j4yav 3y agoI feel like we aren’t too far away from the worlds first school or venue mass shooting via drone.
- pard68 3y agoNot the drone delivery program I was promised
- Sateeshm 3y agoPeople expected Amazon deliveries
- totalview 3y agoI notice a DJI Matrice 300 (larger drone) and a DJI Mavic 2 (can’t be totally sure if it’s a pro model). DJI is well known as the top market leader in UAV space because of its relative low cost ($13K for the Matrice, under $3K for the Mavic) for high utility/reliability (something you care about if you have a payload worth $10K plus). Similar drones made in the USA or EU are 2X-4X the cost and do not come with any other features that DJI hasn’t already thought of. I guess that being a market leader means you will have a wide range of customers using your product
- AlexanderTheGr8 3y agoThe linked article[1] says that Punjab police (state police in India) shot down the drones. I am curious how the police even detected these drones. State police / local police in India is unlikely to have resources for electronic warfare or RF (radio frequency) detection. Fun fact : one method of drug transfer (mentioned in popular media) from Pakistan (bordering Punjab) to Punjab is discus throw [2]. Here, a local athlete takes a disk of drugs and throws it over the border which is then intercepted by dealers in Punjab. A great movie about the drug trade in Punjab is "Udta Punjab" (literally translated as flying-Punjab or high-Punjab). I can only imagine how many drones they missed. Drones usually fly at an altitude that our eye can't see. The drone operators must be smart enough to fly during cloudy days and during night time making binoculars useless as well. My best guess would be ground intelligence by police. I am a bit surprised that drug trade in a state in India is using drones. The cost of drones (even commercial ones cost ~$500) is a pretty steep one when converted to Indian currency (~40,000 INR). The article[1] states that the police shot down >100 drones = INR 40,00,000. There must be a lot of money in local drugs in Punjab for the operators to be willing to sacrifice 100+ drones. [1] https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/chandigarh-news/107-drones-shot-down-442-kg-heroin-seized-in-2023-in-punjab-bsf-101704045498166.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/chandigarh-news/107-dr... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discus_throw https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discus_throw
- defrost 3y agoPretty much anywhere there's a drug trade there's an associated trade in stolen goods. A box or two of drones falling off a truck in exchange for a bag or two of drugs changes the economics.
- Plestor 3y ago[dead]