7 ms·
Images altered to trick machine vision can influence humans too
- xnx 3y agoThough not mentioned in the blog post, this seems like it would have some applications for true "subliminal" advertising.
- tudorw 3y agoNo problem, simply subscribe to our service SafeSight, using the latest imaging technology everything you see is processed by our AI powered manipulation sensing algorithms before your eyes see it, real-time screening and flagging of events together with defensive response suggestions let you take charge. Control your own mind. Feel safe looking out on a world full of messaging and do what you want, not what they want.
- stefs 3y agoIf you can't afford it there's SafeSight Free*, which only allows a selection of sponsors deemed acceptable by our ethics/advertising committee.
- austinjp 3y agoThanks, but I've already got a pair of Joo Janta 200 Super-Chromatics. https://odysee.com/@NoVax:c/Hitchhikers-Guide-to-the-Galaxy-glasses-danger:d https://odysee.com/@NoVax:c/Hitchhikers-Guide-to-the-Galaxy-...
- wizzwizz4 3y agoI don't see how this is surprising. The noise pattern in the first figure looks cat-like: I can see the ears, the head, the paws, the front half of the body… Having that “seemingly random pattern” to trace over would probably let me sketch a cat, something I can't normally do without a reference. (Though, the face is muddled and in the wrong place – almost like it's a cat collage – so I might only get the outline of a cat.) This study's result is implied by the stronger result: “a neural network's notion of a category sometimes resembles members of the category”. I'm sure a competent sketch artist could yield similar or better results, being able to take advantage of peculiarities of the human visual system. (In fact, that might be a good follow-up study: I might claim it if nobody else does.)
- falcolas 3y agoMaybe my brain's just odd... but I don't see the cat-like figure in the noise. I just see noise. There are a few edges, but nothing really cat-like to my mind. My subconscious pattern recognition for faces and such has always been weak, fwiw.
- ChatGTP 3y agoSame
- hytfyiv3j 3y agoIf you actually went through with it, traced over that picture and posted it back to the thread that would be nice, as it seems not everyone can see it as clearly as you can. Maybe even the original authors would appreciate it.
- wizzwizz4 3y agohttps://0x0.st/H62J.ora https://0x0.st/H62J.ora This is not a permanent link, and it's not my server so please don't hammer it. Well, it turns out I can't mouse-draw, even when I'm tracing, but I've given it a go. It's supposed to be a cat walking from the right to the left of the image. The first layer has a better head, and the second layer has a better front leg and ears. Note that my lines obscure the recognisable features, so you'll have to switch the layer off to see them. I traced dark shapes in the first one, and light shapes in the second. If you compare with the flowers layer, regions I identified as “better” in each trace correspond to amplification of the flowers image: the "good" leg outline in the second (light) layer lines up with the (light) stem of the flower, etc.
- im3w1l 3y agoI took a look and my brain must be wired differently from yours because I don't really see it.
- graypegg 3y agoOne thing I'd be curious about is how many of these perturbations can you stack up? A picture of a cat still retains an obvious cat-ness to humans, even when it's been tainted by "truck-ness", but they're slightly more likely to agree it's more truck-y. That response scales with how perturbed it is. (Fig 3 in paper.) If you added the perturbations for "vehicle-ness", would that response be stronger while affecting the image less than cracking up the intensity on the effect? Could you start combining separate concepts, and pick them out individually as like... "activation scores" or something? If so, feels like compression all of a sudden. I know there's a ton of other ML compression things out there, but that just feels like it could be really information dense.
- Habgdnv 3y agoI copied the image on the right into all possible AIs that i found on the net. They all told the that it is a vase with flowers. Even the most primitive. Something seems off here. Maybe they trained a model that is able to see "hidden" patterns and then they found that they can influence its mind with hidden patterns. For the rest of the general population (both humans and AIs) both images are the same.
- graypegg 3y agoCompression possibly? I'm seeing .webps on the paper. Putting them into webpinfo gives me: File: /.../41467_2023_40499_Fig3_HTML.png.webp RIFF HEADER: File size: 671810 Chunk VP8 at offset 12, length 671798 Width: 2000 Height: 2255 Alpha: 0 Animation: 0 Format: Lossy (1) No error detected. So since they're lossy, maybe the subtly is lost? Edit: The image on the article itself is an SVG, containing 3 jpegs. So that's absolutely mangled in comparison to the paper's lossy images. https://deepmind.google/api/blob/website/images/Figure0_svg.original.svg https://deepmind.google/api/blob/website/images/Figure0_svg....
- sweezyjeezy 3y agoI'm not sure that screen-shotting the image will work FWIW - any rescaling interpolation in rendering the image on the page or loading it for a model will likely reduce or nullify the effect. Also these perturbation based adversarial attacks are often model specific. You take the model's gradient at each pixel and iteratively perturbate the image to make it more and more confident that it's e.g. a cat.
- pixl97 3y agoSo what you're saying run your images via a filter/resizer before feeding them into your AI.
- sweezyjeezy 3y agohaha that's an interesting point! Recompress as a jpeg maybe.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- glitchc 3y agoThis is a poor bit of research. The question "is it more cat-like?" Is leading as it specifically instructs the participant to look for cat-like features. The experimenters neglect to establish the null hypothesis.
- dr_dshiv 3y agoThey made stimuli to be either cat-like or sheep-like, for instance, and asked them to pick the more cat-like. It wasn’t between cat and nothing.
- RandomLensman 3y agoCat-like for machines, not humans. What if they had asked which one is more butterfly like and then humans would pick the same one? Prompting humans for a cat is not without consequences - the machines were not prompted to find a cat.
- riwsky 3y agoThe null hypothesis is that the participants are just as able to find those cat-like features in either perturbation of the image, and would pick the “right” one only 50% of the time.
- glitchc 3y agoNo, the null hypothesis is that neither image elicits a cat-like response. It requires asking an open-ended question such as "what does this image look like to you?" Once you prime the subject, you have artificially restricted the responses to "Not really, sure, kinda?" Remember, the ML model is objectively selecting cat with (very) high probability out of the entire corpus of possible responses. The human should be given the same range of possible responses to objectively establish bias. Since no human would say 'cat-like' for any of those images, it suggests a fairly large gap between human and machine perception. We've got a long road ahead of us.
- krisoft 3y ago
- paxys 3y agoVery interesting results. There's a massive overlap between the current generation of AI research/development and neuroscience, and it's fitting that by so desperately trying to make a computer intelligent we are unexpectedly learning more about how our own brains work.
- nomel 3y ago> we are unexpectedly learning Many expected this, decades ago. But, also, many claimed that neural networks have nothing to do with the brain. I think we're slowly inching towards and understanding that we're the result of some fundamentals of information organization, and those fundamentals are realized in biology, rather than come from it. Those fundamentals are now showing themselves in silicon.
- _ogrr 3y agoIn case you were wondering what N was, their first experiment involved 16 undergrads psych students and the second experiment involved 12. https://link.springer.com/article/10.3758/BF03206939 https://link.springer.com/article/10.3758/BF03206939 Edit: I believe this linked survey is not the subject of the OP.
- ShamelessC 3y agoAm I the only one who finds this to be a sort of wasteful experiment for one of the supposed top research labs in the country to be publishing in such a (supposedly) prestigious journal? The findings aren't super shocking although they would be interesting enough if they had managed to collect a large enough sample. Instead they barely grasp at straws and come to an obviously inflated conclusion that neural nets and human brains are similar in some way because of this (which _certainly_ isn't something they arrive at or even experiment for, in my opinion).
- krisoft 3y ago> findings aren't super shocking Aren’t they? Are you sure you understand what is the finding? > they would be interesting enough if they had managed to collect a large enough sample They did. The grand parent comment failed to read the right paper. > obviously inflated conclusion that neural nets and human brains are similar in some way But that is what they find. The human looks at two almost identical looking images of flowers. And yet when they are asked which one is more cat like they pick the one which the neural network thinks is cat-like too.(Or at least they pick it more often than if they were just selecting randomly in this seemingly nonsense task.) That is exactly “similar in some way”. Similar in which image they find more cat-like. That is the similarity.
- ShamelessC 3y ago> Aren’t they? Are you sure you understand what is the finding? Yeah, I got it. > But that is what they find. The human looks at two almost identical looking images of flowers. And yet when they are asked which one is more cat like they pick the one which the neural network thinks is cat-like too.(Or at least they pick it more often than if they were just selecting randomly in this seemingly nonsense task.) That is exactly “similar in some way”. Similar in which image they find more cat-like. That is the similarity. I'm saying the implication is that there is a not-yet-understood deeper connection illustrated by this discovery. I don't think they tested for that and I don't think it's hinted at. There are lots of reasons why this trick would work on both humans and neural nets that would amount to effectively no similarities in structure or process otherwise. That isn't to say it's not related somehow, just that their experiment simply shows the outcome is the same, but doesn't indicate why it's the same. Having said all of that, you're definitely correct to imply I haven't read the full study. And I'm happy to admit my original comment contains misunderstandings. Sorry about that.
- pain2022 3y ago> If brain activations are insensitive to subtle adversarial attacks, we would expect people to choose each picture 50% of the time on average. However, we found that the choice rate—which we refer to as the perceptual bias—was reliably above chance for a wide variety of perturbed picture pairs Ok, but the article doesn’t say what was the actual rate?
- jaschasd 3y agoIt does! See the effect strength plot near the bottom of the blog post, or Figures 2b and 3d in the paper. The effect strength on humans ranges from a few percent deviation of human judgements from chance for subtle adversarial perturbations (epsilon=2), to ~15% deviations of human judgement from chance for large magnitude perturbations in the largest magnitude experimental condition.
- riidom 3y agoWhy do they assume that 50% choose cat and 50% choose truck? Or did I miss the part where they show the participants an untampered version of the image to create a baseline. I mean, cats are small and cute, trucks are big and stinky. And wouldn't the subject of the image also make the participants possibly lean to one of the answers? Flowers in a vase go well with a cat (both can be found in an apartment, for example). If the image would show the ISS, would more people tend to pick "truck", for example?
- hervature 3y agoI think you misunderstand the experiment. They take an image of the flower, they perturb it so that the neural network classifies it as a "cat". They take another copy, perturb it so that the neural network classifies it as a "truck". They ask the subjects which one is more cat-like. A coin will choose the correct image 50% of the time. Likewise, a human that is not influenced by the pertubations will also pick correctly 50% of the time (as long as there is no systematic influence like the correct one is always on the right, the interviewer is unaware, etc.). What they found is that humans do pick the correct one more frequently than random.
- RandomLensman 3y agoNot clear if they had asked for "butterfly" instead of "cat" if 50/50 would have been the result. Similarly, if random perturbations influence choice, the baseline should include the noise from that.
- riwsky 3y agoThe null hypothesis is 50/50 for butterfly, as well. From our conscious perception, it’s two copies of the same picture of a vase.
- RandomLensman 3y agoThe hypothesis is, but I think that is something to experimentally verify in the case of no butterfly noise in the pictures.
- ChatGTP 3y agoThis is one of the most nonsensical things I've read for a long time.
- nyrikki 3y ago"In our example, we may see a vase of flowers, but some activity in the brain informs us there’s a hint of cat about it." IMHO this is not the same as computer vision thinking a rolled over school bus is a snow plow. This is asking if someone sees an elephant or a unicorn in a cloud. Asking if a picture of a stop light at an intersection is "cat like" seems to be pretty suspectable to over fitting. Rorschach inkblot test is pretty much pseudoscience, can someone please explain how this is not similar?
- Terr_ 3y agoTo me that evokes a dimension of disbelief, or suspicion that the data is wrong, separate from what it does or doesn't resemble. Consider the difference between a human stating "that's an impossible nonsense picture, but if had to describe it then it's a half-Cat and half-Truck abomination" compared to a computer yielding " There is a 50% chance that is a Truck, and a 50% chance that is a Cat."
- ericd 3y agoYou could always chop off the final softmax layer and dump out the activations of one or two layers below, which are basically an embedding, which should reflect that it's partly cat and partly truck?
- refulgentis 3y agoIt might not be clear from the article, it took me a bit of scanning back and double checking myself: the impossible nonsense picture is _overlaid_ on the left hand picture to produce the right hand picture which is, at least to our conscious verbalizing mind, ~indistinguishable from the left hand picture. the interesting part is they _are_ distinguishable. as you point out, you'd expect a human to just be like "uhhhh...either?", but it turns out we do see something subconciously, because people do identify the overlaid image at > chance
- ndriscoll 3y agoI don't think it is subconscious. In the bottom left of the vase picture, the "cat-like" version has "whiskers". The egg has a sort of caty blob on the right (though it's hard for me to decide whether the cat or truck version is more pronounced). The street picture has a white blob in the center that's "sheepier" than the chair version. To me it seems like a conscious "if I had to pick the more cat-like one, this picture has a bit right here that sort of looks cat-like". i.e. it's weird to say the images "influence" us. It seems more accurate to say that when prompted, we can perceive/understand what is confusing the model.
- merelysounds 3y agoAll examples (sheep vs chair, dog vs bottle, cat vs truck, elephant vs clock) are organic vs inorganic. Perhaps participants are reusing bouba/kiki[1] skills, evaluating whether the image looks organic (rounded) or inorganic (spiky) - and making their choice accordingly. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bouba/kiki_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bouba/kiki_effect
- japanman185 3y ago[dead]
- markisus 3y agoI think they took a picture of a vase, and created two derivative images of the vase, one which was more cat-like and one which was more truck-like. In both cases, participants did better than average at guessing which one was the derivative image. In any case, I don't think this is explained by the bobo-kiki effect, since they were able to get the subjects to select both inorganic (truck) and organic (cat) derivatives of the same source image.
- merelysounds 3y agoIf you look at the sheep vs chair example (last figure, perturbation 16), the “chair” one has more angular shapes in the background, while the “sheep” one has more rounded, organic lines there.
- trhway 3y agodoesn't seem so. I think the key is probably here >perturbed by a seemingly random pattern ie. it doesn't really seem like a random pattern. It looks more like a match pattern taken from the mid-layers of a visual NN, the pattern of edges and vertexes which "lights up" more frequently when a cat image is presented to the NN. That would explain why an NN (even another one as they all converge on processing edges and vertexes) would mistake that image of vase for cat - in the altered image of vase those "cat" pattern edges and vertexes are present, just at the attenuated 2 levels amplitude, and the first layers of NN (usually converged to Gabors and Gaussian pulling like in the biological visuals cortex) would still detect those edges and will send it to the mid layers where it will "light up" similar "cat" patterns (it would be very illustrative if the authors provided the mixed-in image subjected to edge detection - that should clearly show a mix of original vase image edges and the added "cat" pattern ones). That also explains why people would point to such an image as more cat-like - the first layers and even the first-mid layers in our visual cortex are very similar to what the first and the mid layers of a well-trained NN converge to, and those our layers would similarly detect and "light up" to those mixed-in cat pattern edges and vertexes - we are just better at signal/noise, ie. clearly recognizing the vase and thus suppressing the "noise" of those cat patterns triggered in our visual cortex, so we wouldn't misclassify the image as a cat, yet we do feel something cat-like. Would be interesting to give that test to the people under hallucinogens, i.e. when the visual cortex mid-layers signals are subjected to much less frontal processing and the "noise" rises to the level of "signal".
- valyagolev 3y agowe should code up a real online game to gather the stats here. maybe we'll find a real subliminal messaging model
- bbstats 3y agoThere are literal sheep like images in the sky of some of these lol
- eurekin 3y agoI wonder if that kind of trick could be used during the training of adversarial networks - GANs, to have a strong adversary
- foota 3y agoI think the issue here is that it's always possible to perturb the model inputs to mess with the output if you have the weights. I guess in theory you could have a model that isn't vulnerable to this, but I'm not sure the training methods and networks used today could ever yield it. I'm not an expert per se, but I think the issue at its core is that convolutional networks are trained to look at small features out of context, and tricking those smaller features detectors is possible without changing the overall structure of the image.
- sriku 3y ago"While human vision is not as susceptible to adversarial perturbations as is machine vision (machines no longer identify the original image class, but people still see it clearly), our work shows that these perturbations can nevertheless bias humans towards the decisions made by machines."
- swayvil 3y agoThis might be how we create actual basilisks (see BLIT. It's a good science fiction short story : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BLIT_(short_story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BLIT_(short_story)) A million brainscans. A million images. Fed into an AI image gen. It's doable.
- paulkrush 3y agoI find sci fi or satire with a bit of truth in this area far more interesting than any serious attempt.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoCaption on the first image : >when perturbed by a seemingly random pattern across the entire picture (middle), with the intensity magnified for illustrative purposes I don't understand? The pattern is not "seemingly random", it is "seemingly chosen to have subtle cat-features". One sees the ears at the top of them image and face-like features below. So, is it "we perturbed images to overlay cat-like features on a visual level that humans don't generally perceive but ML models were able to perceive; and then ML models perceived them"? Can someone précis the results and why they're interesting because on the face of it this seems like a very obvious outcome? Do I need to make a new year resolution to actually read the articles?
- refulgentis 3y agoYou're not wrong, but this is interesting insomuch as it's it's more from 100% bug on the bug-feature axis to...well, wetware has this bug too it's just subconcious.
- wizzwizz4 3y agoBut it's not a bug. You look at it and go “hey, those flowers look like a cat”, in the same way you go “that cloud looks like a horse” or “that tree looks like a face” (though, many people have specialised human face processing machinery in their visual systems, so this last example is potentially a little different). It's not a misclassification, just an awareness.
- bitwize 3y ago"Corporate wants you to find the difference between these two pictures." "They're the same--wait, is that a cat?!"
- EnigmaFlare 3y agoIt would be amazing if NNs can eventually create art that inspires emotions in the audience without them realizing how. That seems to be a feature of normal art but maybe machines can one day do better than the best human artists. Unfortunately, the researchers will probably never follow up on their work and improve things. That's the sad story of most fun research, they just give up and forget about it once it's published and nobody else seems to want to do the work themselves. Though perhaps that's because most research doesn't actually have any potential for improvement or is false to begin with and the authors know it.
- krisoft 3y ago> Unfortunately, the researchers will probably never follow up on their work That is a very weird assumption. > nobody else seems to want to do the work themselves If you are so interested why don’t you try your hand at it? This particular research is super easy and accessible.
- EnigmaFlare 3y agoThat's fair. Of course they're not obligated to continue it themselves. I guess I'm just speaking from disappointment when I've encountered old, seemingly interesting dead-ends before and wondered why the authors apparently abandoned their work when they'd be the ones most motivated to further it. Perhaps getting the ball rolling is more the researcher's job than improving the ball.
- chrismcb 3y agoHow is the image on the left classified as a vase? There is maybe the top of the vase in the image, otherwise it is a collection of flowers. Maybe it is just me on my phone but I might clarify it as a bouquet or flowers or something, but not a vase.
- krisoft 3y ago> How is the image on the left classified as a vase? That is the label assigned to it in the dataset. > Maybe it is just me on my phone but I might clarify it as a bouquet or flowers or something, but not a vase. Ok. I assume you read the rest of the article. Does your observation change anything about the research findings?
- aitchnyu 3y agoIs there a high res versions of the images? I want to see the "imperceptible differences" myself.