10 ms·
Eating fewer calories can ward off ageing
- bcherny 3y agohttps://archive.is/wOgiW https://archive.is/wOgiW
- v7engine 3y agoOff topic, but I see many people using archive.is. My question is what if archive.is goes down, goes private or disappears from the internet altogether.
- Ayesh 3y agoI have trust in them that they will at least hand over the data for someone else to carry on if they have to turn off lights.
- dumpHero2 3y agoOff topic, but I've been missing CSS & JS warriors on HN, who'd make it a point to expose how a certain hero image on the landing site was 4MB big or expose the scandalous use of an outdated version of jQuery on a S&P 500 company's website.
- h0l0cube 3y agoIf one is concerned about the lights going off, they can always donate https://help.archive.org/help/how-do-i-donate-to-the-internet-archive/ https://help.archive.org/help/how-do-i-donate-to-the-interne...
- saagarjha 3y agoI hear if you eat few enough calories you’ll stop aging entirely.
- chimpanzee 3y agoOh you’ll keep aging, faster than ever in fact. You just won’t be alive to see it.
- kaskakokos 3y agoYes, but first you have to go through a period of 1 month, then the final change of metabolism occurs, your age is frozen and you will never increase it.
- klipt 3y agoBut exercise is also supposed to help you age better, and doesn't exercising mean you have to consume more calories?
- whirlwin 3y agoIt's paradoxal. But the least preferable would then be to eat more AND avoid exercise
- timcobb 3y agoThis is something I’ve been wondering. And the older I’ve gotten, the more it feels like I need to eat to recover even from cardio, let alone weight training. When I was young, recovery from medium-intensity cardio didn’t seem to require any extra caloric intake.
- Heliosmaster 3y agoCould this just be a perception issue? When you are young you are generally less careful about what you eat, and eat a lot of calorie dense food.
- kennethh 3y agoAs you get older it take longer to recover. I noticed this the first time around 35 and now at 51 it take even longer to recover. I also notice that real food feels a lot better compared to when I was younger, especially benefitable for me have been to eat more meat which make it possible for me to not to eat directly after training. In general I read that the digestion gets worse the older you are and you need to provide more high quality food ie no pop tarts.
- scotty79 3y agoAny recovery takes more time as you get older. Heck, if I exert myself I don't even feel the damage the next day like when I was young. It hurts on the day after the next. Not sure about food though. I don't feel any different.
- erklik 3y ago> doesn't exercising mean you have to consume more calories You can't exercise off calories. The difference in burning rate vs consumption is far too high for most cases.. I always thought the exercise that helped age better, was largely that the diet remains constant..
- akira2501 3y ago> "That has provoked an interest in finding ways to get the benefits of calorie restriction without having to engage in it." And since we're in the western world of medicine, the answer is of course, pills. Which is disappointing because the first question I would ask is do you need to calorie restrict constantly to get the same benefits? If I restrict for three days a week, eat normally the other three, then add a relative "cheat" day between the two, am I possibly getting most of the same benefit anyways? Anecdotally, I do eat this way, under the logic that our ancestors would have had similar calorie consumption patterns based around the "boom and bust" cycle of hunting, and since I've adjusted my diet I've been incredibly happy with what I perceive to be it's positive impacts on my weight and levels of energy. Anyways.. I don't think our first instinct should be to go "off label" for an answer.
- onetimeuse92304 3y ago> If I restrict for three days a week, eat normally the other three, then add a relative "cheat" day between the two, am I possibly getting most of the same benefit anyways? Unfortunately, we are more slaves to our bodies than one would think. The calories you eat are almost exactly the same as what you burn. And if you do not believe, try dividing the extra weight of a person by the number of days they lived to see how little extra calories they consumed over their lifetime. Only a tiny imbalance is enough for a person to get overweight but it also means that it is really, really hard to eat any more or less than one is actually using for energy. The biggest contributor to how much calories we actually use for energy (and based on above: consume), is our metabolic rates and activity. And metabolic rate does not differ a lot between people, the only thing that differs significantly is activity level. So when somebody says "eat less calories to live longer" what they really are saying you should be less active.
- quickthrower2 3y agoYour body fat tends to the equilibrium where calories burned is calories consumed (because fat burns calories).
- _cenw 3y ago
- woleium 3y agoRoy Walford et al are the folks to read on this topic
- atemerev 3y ago“Come on you sons of …, or do you want to live forever?”
- NickChasanis 3y agoCalories from calories are vastly different, for example red meat (beef mostly) anything non gmo etc. A balance is important but fewer calories says nothing.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> anything non gmo A good rule of thumb is to ignore health or nutrition advice that goes off on GMOs. > fewer calories says nothing There is a lot of research that suggests otherwise [1]. Metabolism is messy. Less of it means less cellular damage. [1] TFA
- trallnag 3y agoYou are telling me there is a vast difference between the calories of gmo corn and non-gmo corn? I highly doubt that
- marliechiller 3y agoI found this recent huberman labs episode particularly enlightening: https://www.hubermanlab.com/episode/controlling-sugar-cravings-and-metabolism-with-science-based-tools https://www.hubermanlab.com/episode/controlling-sugar-cravin... One of the key takeaways for me was the “calories in- calories out” (CICO) model of metabolism and weight regulation and how specific macronutrients (protein, fat, carbohydrates), fiber and sugar can modify the CICO equation. People tend to think that a calorie consumed is a calorie utilised irrespective of how the body actually processes that calorie. The definition of a calorie is "a unit of energy equivalent to the heat energy needed to raise the temperature of 1 gram of water by 1 °C (now often defined as equal to 4.1868 joules)." i.e not what our body is doing to our food when we eat it. The example used in the episode is that of a handful of almonds, say, 160 calories. The fibre content of the rusk causes approx 30 calories of those almonds to not actually be digested by you but by your gut microbiome instead!
- jrflowers 3y agoInteresting… if you eat 0 calories you will stop aging altogether
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoYou can probably eat 0 calories for a few weeks depending on your body-fat.
- wwweston 3y agoCan confirm that it's possible for at least 1 week, and I've read about cases over a month -- seems to be that under conditions where minerals/electrolytes are balanced, (some?) people can go as long as their fat stores & focus last. At the extreme end there's Angus Barbieri: https://www.diabetes.co.uk/blog/2018/02/story-angus-barbieri-went-382-days-without-eating/ https://www.diabetes.co.uk/blog/2018/02/story-angus-barbieri...
- ur-whale 3y agohttps://archive.is/wOgiW https://archive.is/wOgiW
- _zagj 3y ago> One of the eight biospherians was Roy Walford, a professor of pathology at the University of California, Los Angeles (ucla). Research by Walford and others had shown that restricting what animals ate could significantly lengthen their lives. The lifespans of nematode worms, fruit flies, rodents and dogs could be extended as much as 50% by laboratory protocols which gave them a diet with all the nutrients they needed in terms of minerals, vitamins and the like but fewer calories than were seen as normal. Roy Walford died at age 79 of ALS, and there are studies showing both excessive exercise and low-calorie diets (drivers of calorie restriction) increase the risk of ALS, for example: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(14)60222-1/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... https://www.neurology.org/doi/10.1212/WNL.0000000000007861 https://www.neurology.org/doi/10.1212/WNL.0000000000007861 https://www.thelancet.com/journals/ebiom/article/PIIS2352-3964(21)00190-0/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/ebiom/article/PIIS2352-39... I can't believe people are still beating this drum. There's no evidence calorie restriction (beyond not being fat) actually significantly (ie more than a few years) extends human lifespan, let alone can consistently get you to 100 (or even 120, like Walford speculated). And if it did work, we'd probably know already just by looking at existing centenarian populations. And even the best animal studies (where, unlike 99% of the garbage mouse studies, the control group isn't allowed to eat itself into obesity) don't paint an impressive picture: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3832985/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3832985/ > Our data indicate that under our laboratory conditions, CR does not improve mean survival in rhesus compared to CON monkeys despite clear improvements in overall health and function. Our finding contrasts with previous reports5, 19 and suggests that study design, husbandry, and diet composition are important factors for the life-prolonging effect of CR in a long-lived NHP, similar to what has been shown in rodent studies40–42. It will be valuable to continue to compare findings from on-going monkey CR studies to dissect mechanisms behind the improvement in health that occurred with and without significant effects on survival.
- ekianjo 3y agoPeople like to believe in simple solutions for complex systems.
- 3y ago
- L_226 3y agoI encourage everyone I discuss healthspan with to read the Blueprint protocol docs from Bryan Johnson (founder of Braintree/Venmo)[0]. He hired a team of specialists to make him as healthy as possible - it is his full time job to be a "professional rejuvenation athlete". Part of his protocol is caloric restriction coupled with very specific exercise and intermittent fasting. According to his published health data he is extremely healthy! His YT channel [1] is also pretty interesting, if mildly cult-like. [0] - https://protocol.bryanjohnson.com/ https://protocol.bryanjohnson.com/ [1] - https://www.youtube.com/@BryanJohnson/videos https://www.youtube.com/@BryanJohnson/videos
- Icko 3y agoI can't get a read on this guy. I have strong bullshit feelings, but I'm not 100% sure. 1. He seems to have an awful lot of referral links - $60 for a bottle of olive oil? 2. He has not posted why is his regime like that - e.g. "Here is a paper about iron deficiencies, so I'm taking an iron supplement". 3. 90% of his website is "look at how dense my bones are", "look at how healthy my liver is" - bro I just wanted to see the actual regime, and you can't even post that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tomalaci 3y agoIt is on https://protocol.bryanjohnson.com https://protocol.bryanjohnson.com site. For example, his fitness routine: https://protocol.bryanjohnson.com/#fitness https://protocol.bryanjohnson.com/#fitness Personally, I have taken few things from his routine and double-checked it with other sources and more importantly found much cheaper products/things locally than the ones that are advertised (even though, most of them are fine anyways such as in Skincare he uses standard Cerave stuff). Do note that this is -one- guy trying basically everything that seems plausible. It would likely result in frequently switching up things that are not researched well.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago
- Anotheroneagain 3y agoIt has been shown that caloric restriction works because it makes you absorb less iron.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoAre you suggesting it's desirable to absorb less iron?
- jgilias 3y agoDo you have any sources for this? And also, what’s wrong with absorbing iron? Increased oxidation or something?
- scotty79 3y agoWhere "you" means a nematode worm?
- watwut 3y agoLike, anemia is good for you, actually, theory?
- hathym 3y agoWhy bother counting calories when we all have a one-way ticket to the grave? Might as well enjoy some extra cheeseburgers and pizza along the way.. :D
- speedgoose 3y agoHaving an unhealthy body isn’t great and worth the extra pizzas.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoKey word: extra.
- kleiba 3y agoBecause the way you treat your body has a lot to do with how enjoyable that ride is going to be for you. For instance, obesity is correlated with a whole range of different health problems. But your nutrition is also vital even if you don't gain a lot of weight. Take the extra cheeseburgers for instance, where we know that excess consumption of red meat can cause colon cancer, to name just one example.
- weregiraffe 3y ago>Might as well enjoy some extra cheeseburgers and pizza along the way.. :D Or you could enjoy being more health along the way. Do you prefer decaying slowly from heart disease and diabetes, or going out with a stroke while jogging in your 80s? It's all a trade off.
- chris-orgmenta 3y agoMm, "The candle that burns twice as bright, burns half as long" and all that. I suppose it is just a case of balance. I sure am on one end of the bell curve, apparently. People don't seem like risk takers and play it safe (from my biased perspective). 'Try anything once' doesn't seem like a mantra that people actually do take to heart. "Live a little" gets proverbial blank stares. "Spend your money, what's the point in it otherwise?!" gets a concerned shuffle, then no action, from elderly relatives. "The world is your oyster!" results in no holidays being booked despite them opining the need or want for one. Well, from this very opinionated view, there are a lot of people playing it safe and hiding in their boxes, letting their resources go unused. But to each their own, if people are comfortable and happy and society is utilitarian. Book a skydive, indulge in fancy unhealthy food for once, get a flight somewhere! Last night I bought tickets to a dance festival in Albania. I just need to get to Corfu by June to get my boat trip. Next week I am going to wander around the English countryside for a week. I think in Feb I will get the train to the Netherlands. I might wander EU for a bit. Meanwhile I have a friend that is miserable, stuck in an apartment, unwilling to spend the gold pot she sits upon, but wishing she could join me. The gold pot will go to charity in her will though at least. Anyway, I suppose it is not in my nature to do Calls to Actions like this, but I found myself writing this because the person that I am replying to reminds me that IMO there is a bias in the other direction in the Overton window and in literature. It all feels very boring and safe to me. It's too longevity based and not quality based. I don't think Instagram trends are a counter-example - If anything I think they reinforce my point (that people will satiate their desire for things by watching someone else do it instead of themselves).
- watwut 3y agoAnd in another news eating disorders are totally all only about tiktok videos teenagers see. And not, like, adults being obsesssed with low calories lifeatyles themselves on all adults forums.
- anovikov 3y agoAs if Ozempic shortage wasn't bad enough already, we need those kind of posts to make it even worse.
- mynameisnoone 3y agoOzempic is the semaglutide injectable dosage for diabetes, while Wegovy is a higher dosage for weight maintenance. There is a great deal of hate and discrimination surrounding obesity that it is somehow or always entirely voluntary or lesser than diabetes. Medicare and Medicaid do not cover Wegovy, even if weight gain is caused as a side-effect of another medication. Wegovy costs $1502.51 USD/month where I live, if you can get it. Medicare could save a great deal of money if they negotiated for prices to be the same as what people in other countries are paying and medication supplemental coverage formularies also covered preventative medications. There will be pill form for Wegovy to match Rybelsus, or it may be collapsed into that single brand name differing only in dosage. The issue is the US profits on semaglutide are excessive. It, along with metformin, are the two most important medications to increase public health and reduce disease in relatively healthy populations. Perhaps the Defense Production Act could be enacted to manufacture generics of the most expensive and most QALY-positive medications.
- anovikov 3y agoWell, till today it's only widely available in the U.S. exactly because they are able to command a much higher price there (and 1/3 of the price is a kickback to the prescribing clinics/docs, by design, and it's a US-only thing). It's only available in two EU countries (Denmark and Germany), and availability is patchy, and they are no longer accepting any new patients because of chronic shortages. It will take several more years for everyone to have enough. It's like 155mm production - seems easy on paper, takes years and billions in reality, and we have to deal with chronic shortages and ridiculous 20x prices in the meantime.
- farseer 3y agoYes but fewer calories might also make you less productive at work. Might affect your reasoning and executive skills. They might also reduce your sex drive. Not sure maximum age is what you want to optimize for unless there is more data.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> fewer calories might also make you less productive at work. Might affect your reasoning and executive skills. They might also reduce your sex drive. Fewer calories doesn't mean starvation. We have evidence time-restricted feeding decreses fat mass without compromising musculature or strength while reducing inflammation [1]. Curiously, while "resting energy expenditure was unchanged," basal metabolism did go down. I don't think the solution is everyone time-restricting their feeding. But there is something here that suggests a broad quality-of-life improvement for many Americans. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27737674/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27737674/
- kuhewa 3y ago> Curiously, while "resting energy expenditure was unchanged," basal metabolism did go down. REE was the proxy for basal metabolism. They measured respiratory ratio which decreased, but that's not BM just (should) reflect what macros are being burned
- helboi4 3y agoI dunno skipping breakfast makes me way more productive at work. The only reason I don't do that all the time is because I want to build muscle.
- piva00 3y agoSkipping breakfast will not change your muscle building if you are eating enough calories and protein. I personally know a few bodybuilders who have been strictly doing intermittent fasting for years, you need to get your macros, breakfast isn't necessary.
- EZ-E 3y agoIndeed I don't feel like I see many overweight people over 70 - but it might just be related to where I live. Or older people might just eat less.
- eemil 3y agoSurvivorship bias
- NiloCK 3y agoThe premise that a ten year old car with 150K on the odometer might be in harder shape than a 15 year old car with 75K is not hard to accept, but I was somehow very surprised to realize the analogous fact on bodies. Calories are essentially mileage for your digestive tract - top to bottom. Time-on-earth is easy to measure, but not obviously a good measure. EG, is time-on-earth a better metric than total calorie consumption? Doesn't feel straightforward to me.
- chrisdrobison 3y agoThe research for years has been pointing to the fact that calorie counting is one of the worst ways of tracking food. It assumes that all calories are equal. This thinking is what led to the food pyramid in the 70s which has then led to the obesity epidemic in the US. The number of calories you put in your body is not nearly as important as the actual kinds of foods. Weight watchers has actually finally had to admit that the quality of food actually plays an important role in weight loss. They've changed their program so that things like fruit are 0 points despite not being a low calorie food. As of right now, what the research is noticing is that insulin resistance plays big role in a lot of other health problems. And if your diet consists of lot of refined carbs like breads, it won't matter how you count calories, you probably won't feel that good. Exercise is a useful tool, but if you aren't eating the right things, it does very little for you. In the end, we just need to make better food choices. It seems that doing that makes everything else fall into place with little effort.
- chrisdrobison 3y agoIf you want some interesting reads on the subject, read the books Why We Get Sick by Benjamin Bikman and Always Hungry by David Ludwig. Both are scientists in this field of research. Both provide some sounds advice based on that research for eating more healthy.
- joshcsimmons 3y agoI used to believe this but the reality isn't that simple. The truth is that both schools of thought are correct. You can and will lose weight by eating junk calories as long as you are eating in a deficit[1]. You can also eat a strict paleo diet of whole foods and gain weight - anecdotal, I have done it. I have been consistently and (very) gradually reducing my body fat percentage over the course of a year by eating mostly-healthy foods and calorie counting (the alleged worst way of tracking food). I still eat a fair amount of junk food but limit it to one day a week. Bottom line: quality of food has very little to do with weight loss, calories determine weight loss. Quality of food will influence body composition but body composition !== weight. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor...