6 ms·
US office owners face $117B wall of debt repayments
- the-dude 3y agohttps://archive.is/VYBn9 https://archive.is/VYBn9
- mindslight 3y agoThe posted article doesn't have any relevant content ("Try unlimited access Only $1 for 4 weeks"), but based on the headline all I can think is please please pretty please maybe this time the government can perhaps let some defaulting actually happen? Of course we know the answer is always going to be more money printing to support the rigged heads-they-win tails-we-lose game, and the whole point of this article is part of the media push to make that happen. The main question is what related sector of the economy they'll ruin in the process.
- mtmail 3y ago> based on the headline all I can think is It's good that you're open about only having read the headline. Another user posted a link to the full article text: https://archive.is/VYBn9 https://archive.is/VYBn9
- mindslight 3y agoI actually didn't even try that, because archive.is is so often broken. But surprisingly there were only two captcha-nags (not the usual infinite loop!) and it actually worked.
- voisin 3y ago> let some defaulting actually happen Do you realize the impact this would have on pension plans and mom and pop investment portfolios too? It isn’t just Bezos and other billionaires who would feel pain - it would be a lot of regular folk getting annihilated financially as well.
- NewJazz 3y agoDoubt it. Most people are well diversified. I'd be surprised if anyone's retirement was more than 20% commercial real estate. Easy to stomach some moderate losses in the sector even at that absurdly high allocation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BlackJack 3y agoHave you done the math, even at a ballpark level? Commercial Real Estate (CRE) is estimated to have ~$500B loss in 2023 and nearly the same in 2024 (different from debt repayment) [1]. Stock indices were fine. In general, there's way more private investment/ownership in CRE. The market can suffer a lot more in losses before it starts to meaningfully affect mom&pop. Even stocks like SLG and BX have done fine last year. [1] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/commercial-real-estate-values-suffer-123000415.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/commercial-real-estate-values...
- mindslight 3y agoSure. "Investment" used to mean that what you invested was at risk, and if you (or whomever you delegated to) made bad investments you would lose. The answer to the current hazardous dynamic where everyone just dumps money into investment funds on autopilot is not to double down and bail them out so the Potemkin party can continue. Rather the negative possibilities of such investments need to be demonstrated so that people are appropriately leery of relying on them going forward.
- jbm 3y agoYes — in that case you can bail out mom and dad personally. If the 0.1% owns a disproportional amount of wealth any financial bailout will disproportionately help them.
- nradov 3y agoRelax. The largest US pension funds have only limited exposure to office real estate. https://www.calpers.ca.gov/page/investments/about-investment-office/investment-organization https://www.calpers.ca.gov/page/investments/about-investment...
- nsagent 3y agoI understand the sentiment, and often feel this way too, but I think it's reductive to assume the answer is to let large companies/investors to fail. Ideally, if we ensure adequate diversity in the market, then having companies default makes sense -- then one company going under won't trigger a string of defaults that can cripple a sector of the economy. But when we let businesses concentrate effort or corner markets, then there can be catastrophic consequences to the economy when these large entities go belly up. Efforts should be put in place to mitigate these issues. Ultimately, I think the pragmatic approach is to assess defaulting on debt on a case-by-case basis. I'd prefer if a panel of economists across the ideological spectrum came to a consensus for each case based on the latest understanding of the market, but I know it's more likely going to be politicians choosing the argument that best fits their worldview.
- mindslight 3y agoI do agree that limiting scopes ahead of time would be a better overall solution. The problem is that for the next part of the cycle, when the idea of regulation to limit the financialization is being debated, it will be rejected because the immediate crisis is over. So I'd say it's appropriate to argue against the scheme at each turn, even though only one aspect needs to be reformed to have just system. Also, aiming for better outcomes would be more important for situations affecting resources in the real world. But commercial real estate has to be one of the most abstract setups there is. The buildings will still exist. The tenants will still exist, still carrying out their business, making rent payments, and for the most part keeping up the properties. The only thing that changes is the paper ownership moves to the senior debt holder, and the more leveraged investors get wiped out.
- Geisterde 3y agoThis condition was created by the government selecting winners and losers in the first place. The market has to decide who wins and who loses to achieve any normal distribution of resources, otherwise it will always be captured by politicians and/or corporations. There can be no agreement among "economist across the ideological spectrum", there can only be agreement among economists who agree with bailouts, or agreement among economists who disagree with bailouts. We have directly opposing views on what makes something moral, on how value is created, even on what money is; there cant be any agreement when the differences in fundamental assumptions directly conflict. Naturally those against bailouts will be marginalized and called fringe kooks that can be safely ignored.
- axpy906 3y ago2024 will make for an interesting year for the debt world. Seems like everyone and everything has debts coming due. Commercial real estate no exception.
- xyst 3y agocommercial real estate tumbles. Followed by municipal bonds tumbling. Cities file for bankruptcy. Growth stagnates permanently since the income from taxes does not fully sustain most cities today. This is largely due to highly inefficient city planning and infrastructure planning (suburban sprawl, highways, and continued dependency on car centric travel generate significant amounts of long term debt that accrue at all levels).
- FredPret 3y agoGrowth can now decouple from cities however. Whether they are run well or not is largely immaterial to the legions of remote workers who can simply leave or even emigrate but remain economically active at the same level or even higher.
- bloopernova 3y agoI wonder if the office owners are connected enough politically to get a bailout? Not an expert so I can only really pose the question.
- fullshark 3y agoHow about city mayors looking at their tax receipts trying to balance their budgets, that's going to provide major political leverage.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoThis is the rumor at my work about management’s push for RTO. Some amount of tax incentives were provided because the office would drive additional downtown spending. Spending and tax income which does not materialize if the peons can stay at home. A few phone calls from the mayor , and “our company culture works best in person”.
- nordsieck 3y ago> This is the rumor at my work about management’s push for RTO. Some amount of tax incentives were provided because the office would drive additional downtown spending. I guess I can sort of see that if the company is locked into a lease. But I can't see that playing out in the long term - It's hard for me to believe that the city is ponying up more than the cost of corporate rent in tax incentives.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoRTO is “free” and does not hit the financials in the same way as having to record the loss of a $X tax break. Additionally, I recall some of the sweetheart deals which were being offered for the new Amazon headquarters. I could believe that officials offer ludicrously good deals that never pencil out for the city. Like sports stadiums.
- 3y ago
- the-dude 3y agoIt doesn't sound like much, I mean what does a billion buy you these days? A couple of villas and a yacht and you're done. Also, according to TFA, this is about 600 buildings, of which 224 might be problematic. What happens when they are not refinanced? They are owned by the bank just the same.
- chrisco255 3y agoThis can be a "tip of the iceberg" type figure. If interest rates remain high or go higher and economy continues to slide or if the need for office space due to remote work is permanently reduced, then demand will continue to fall and then $117B can snowball into trillions rather quickly.
- mulderc 3y agoEconomy continues to slide? US Q3 GDP was up +4.9% the economy is about as good as it has ever been.
- wyre 3y agoThere is more to an economy than GDP.
- nindalf 3y agoYeah, like unemployment, inflation, wages and so on, all of which are pretty good in Jan 2024.
- Loughla 3y agoWhy, then, is that not the reality for every day people?
- ForRealsies 3y ago[dead]
- 3y ago
- NewJazz 3y agoUnlike US home loans, commercial mortgages are almost entirely interest- only. That means developers of large properties tend to have low monthly payments, but face a balloon payment equal to the original loan the day the mortgage comes due. That is an odd detail I was not aware of... this seems to be a significant advantage for commercial mortgages over residential ones. Are they less leveraged or something? That doesn't square with the "40 per cent of office loans on bank balance sheets were under water" statement later in the article. This is not driven by fundamentals; this has everything to do with financing costs going back up Seems like a disingenuous statement. Demand for office space has fallen. And according to the article, demand was overstated when these now-due loans were originally made. “Everyone will blame Covid [for] the losses,” said John Griffin, a professor at Texas university. “But Wall Street’s aggressive underwriting of commercial mortgage debt is going to make the situation a whole lot worse than it would have been.”
- chrisco255 3y ago> this seems to be a significant advantage for commercial mortgages over residential ones. "Interest only" loans are not really advantageous. It means by default you are never paying down your principal and you are forced to refinance when the balloon payment is due (usually 5 years or so). So if you signed a loan when rates were low, you would have been better off to get a long term 30 year fixed interest loan. Otherwise your payment can more than double or triple right along with interest rates. And since you're not paying down the principal, it's easier to find your loan under water. Although it is typical for commercial real estate loans to require a 20% down payment.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 3y agoYou can - at least some places - get residential mortgages that are interest only too, but they're not popular for good reason because of the risk involved.
- jimberlage 3y ago
- _heimdall 3y agoIt'd be interesting to see the total value of derivatives based on these mortgages is, I didn't see that in the article anywhere. Anyone happen to know how common it is for these kinds of commercial real estate loans to be rolled up into other derivatives similar to what led to the housing crisis?
- EMCymatics 3y agoInteresting times.
- tantivy 3y agoSorry, got nothin on me
- xyst 3y agoIf you are wondering why you are returning to office (RTO) despite 3-4 years of profitable quarters… It’s not because of “cUlTuRe”, “wOrK pRoDuCtIvItY”, “coMmUnIcaTiOn gApS”, or “iNcReAsInG cOlLabOraTiOn” It’s because the bag holders of these assets (ie, REITs, ibanks, hedge funds, foreign ibanks and investors) are at risk. Ultimately, the US government and to a certain degree state and local governments have guaranteed a large portion of these assets. These investors need to pump their numbers (ie, occupancy rates, leases, …) in order to keep the con going. Often the building managers will dangle “free” upgrades in the faces of these corporate real estate managers to keep the leases active in exchange for guaranteed occupancy rates. I hate this country sometimes. Shit like this is why we will never have a sustainable economy
- FredPret 3y agoWhy would a company RTO to keep the building's investors happy? They probably have different owners whose interests are at odds. The real estate guys want the building full to maximize rent income, but the company owners want to minimize rent expense. They are min-maxing against one another. Companies RTO because: a) they are run by people who don't get remote work b) they do something that involves being physically present c) layoff-by-RTO d) it's possible the government incentivizes RTO, but this is a short-term trick at best. RTO is unpopular with workers and most capital are invested in companies, not office buildings. All of those companies have a natural interest in minimizing rent.
- dexwiz 3y agoExpect a ton of restructuring deals. Banks don’t want to repossess these properties, especially in the middle of this economy. At this level banks are partners, not just lenders. They have a vested interest in keeping these buildings useful. A multimillion dollar building is not a user car or even a suburban home. But commercial mortgages usually have stipulations like a minimum rental price. Everyone boogie man’s zoning, but these mortgages also limit freedom. Many empty buildings couldn’t rent at a lower price even if they wanted to. The banks don’t want managers undercutting each other, and wrecking market value. But they will have to relent eventually. Expect less new builds in the future, but more renovations. Building managers face a tough market right now, and will need to invest in existing stock to compete.
- Kon-Peki 3y ago> Expect less new builds in the future Builders want to build, and lenders want to lend. I recently discovered that in my old neighborhood in Chicago, 4 high rise residential towers have started construction in a 3-block radius in the last 6 months. And over on the other side of downtown, developers have secured financing to begin construction of an 800+ foot tall apartment building on the site of the $300 million hole in the ground (an Irish developer had planned to built a 2000 foot tall building, but went bankrupt while building the foundation). I saw a report by the city of Chicago last month that broke out office vacancy by age of the building, and in new towers the vacancy rate is single digits. Now, you and I both know that the likely explanation is that the tenants of these buildings were solid companies that signed long-term leases as the construction was finishing up. Once those first leases end, all bets are off. But, “It Is Difficult to Get a Man to Understand Something When His Salary Depends Upon His Not Understanding It”. Builders are going to point at that stat and say that new office towers are a good investment. Lenders are going to point at that stat and say that new office towers are safe to finance. Count on it.