13 ms·
Every major pharmacy chain giving government warrantless medical record access
- levinb 3y agoHi, I'm a former Federal LEO that has gotten warrentless access to medical records - a long time ago. I can't speak for every agency (there are more than 100 Federal agencies with sworn officers and arrest authority, and thousands of state and local agencies), but the few times I did this in the early 2000s, even most of the HN crowd would have thought it reasonable. I was an officer in the Coast Guard and had LE powers under two different branches of law - one public safety and one criminal. When Bad Things happened on federal waterways, my job was to first investigate threats to public safety. This comes with the power to issue a subpoena. This means we can 'compel speech' and then if you lie to us, you are in trouble. This has more to do with what you might think the NTSB or FAA might do following an accident. The government has the right under current law to understand threats to the public. If a shipping company is currently doing something that could dump a barge full of Xylene into the bayou next to an elementary school (this is not a made up scenario, and you should look up Xylene) then there is a public interest compelling enough that we can tell people they have to sit down and tell us the truth, and the 4th amendment is not a barrier. However, if a public safety investigation moves past 'understanding if something is a risk to the public', and individual criminal culpability appears possible, we are then required to disclose to the individuals involved that we have moved to a criminal investigation. In this case, the 4th comes back in play and warrants are required. For me, this really only came up a couple times with individuals involved in an accident that were either using medical prescriptions ("I missed my medications, I'm not drunk") to delay us investigating a scene. Or, for a couple of injured mariners who were in the hospital at the time we showed up. We needed to go to the hospital get their version of the story and to confirm an injury; grave injuries would increase the 'level' and thus mandatory resources involved in an investigation. Also, we would need to get a witness testimony from a deckhand or something that was on a boat or facility and saw what happened (did the boat really slam into the terminal coupling or did the guy just mess up attaching it because he wasn't an officially trained Tankerman who shouldn't have been operating the equipment). Being in the hospital or at the doctors was an excuse used more than once my companies trying to slow down inquiry into their mistakes. And yes, I think for our use case, it was completely reasonable for us to be able to call the hospital and ask "was so and so admitted last night?", just for us to find out that they were not, and went back home to mom's house to hide under orders from their captain. Anyway, with all that said, it seems unlikely these powers are not frequently abused, even if most of the LEO community is just trying to do their job. So, tin-hat away, friends.
- chimeracoder 3y agoAs someone who also has a lot of experience in this area, I'll say that your comment is a classic example of the tactics that that LEOs use to minimize or defend abuses of power. It's actually a great case study, because it exemplifies the way that abuses of power are adopted structurally at an institutional level, while also drawing the line to how that is internalized and effected in practice by individuals. (This process is a key component of any stable system for abuse; that said, it's rare to see it illustrated so plainly). > Being in the hospital or at the doctors was an excuse used more than once my companies trying to slow down inquiry into their mistakes. And yes, I think for our use case, it was completely reasonable for us to be able to call the hospital and ask "was so and so admitted last night?", just for us to find out that they were not, and went back home to mom's house to hide under orders from their captain. Just because it made your job easier doesn't mean that it was legitimate. Constitutional rights, privacy laws, and case law have been created specifically to limit police power. Yes, it would be easier if cops didn't need warrants at all. No, that is not a valid argument for bypassing them. Similarly - yes, it's common for LEOs to talk to witnesses to try and get them to incriminate themselves, either by engaging them in interactions that don't legally require a Miranda warning or by ignoring Miranda requirements altogether (which happens frequently). That doesn't justify it, either legally or ethically. > Anyway, with all that said, it seems unlikely these powers are not frequently abused, even if most of the LEO community is just trying to do their job. The assumption that "most LEOs are just trying to do their job" is itself questionable, given how much documentation there is of systemic abuse of police power. Even if it weren't, that isn't a valid defense when the government has explicitly placed restraints on the ways LEO can do their job (to say nothing of the broader question of the legitimacy of that job in the first place).
- levinb 3y ago> Just because it made your job easier doesn't mean that it was legitimate. So, I suppose that the main point. In these cases, we weren't investigating the individual as a suspect, we were trying to understand the nature of an incident that could affect the safety of others in a relatively linear fashion. Imagine it's 20 years ago, there's no cameras everywhere, GPS is limited to multi-meter precision - did the 50-barge tow coming down the Mississipi river with millions of tons of cargo hit the interstate bridge broadside or did it just scrape it? There's a big pylon-shaped dent in the side of a naptha barge with cement dust on it, but the captain swears he just glanced it with the grain barge at the head of the tow. It's ancient and looks like it's battered 100 docks in the past year. So, Mr. Deckhand, what hit the bridge? In this scenario, he is not responsible for navigating the vessel, so we assume that it's unlikley that this would evolve into an investigation that would jeopardize him. And thus are free to issue a subpoenea if needed to find out if we need to shut down the only passage over the Mississippi for 100 miles. I think it's fair that the public has the right to his honesty in this scenario. Of course, these powers present the potential for abuse, and I'm sure it happens. Just not in the world I ever operated in; our powers and obligations were taken very seriously internally.
- barefootjoey 3y agoPlease explain why this is bad for anyone except RX re-sellers?
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoCapsule doesn't do this, fwiw
- ceejayoz 3y agoDo you have an official statement from them on this?
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- deelowe 3y agoThe consolidation of the medical industry has been one of the most terrible things I've witnessed during my lifetime. What is the end state for all this?
- delfinom 3y agoOne company owning everything? To be fair, some of the consolidation is purely because the costs of business have been raised so far that both doctors and pharmacists can't operate independently. From mountains of school debt, to requirements for IT services and compliances, to the insane cost of real estate everywhere. This country is heading towards one of those cyberpunk endings where corporations own people.
- jimbob45 3y agoHIPAA was a stupid mistake by the Clinton administration. I really don’t care who has my medical history and the field of medical study would be infinitely better off if it was public.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jhloa2 3y agoNow that's a take I've never heard before. It'd be interesting to have an opt-in for sharing your medical history with entities, but there is no way in hell I'd be sharing information that is so easily weaponized against me.
- hollerith 3y agoDoes anyone know of an actual case of a person who was impacted by this? The OP does not describe such a one. Is the only impact on people suspected of using prescription drugs to kill, rape or otherwise harm? I am having trouble imagining other kinds of impacts.
- alemanek 3y agoIf the police have a reasonable suspicion then they should have no problem getting a warrant. If they cant clear that bar then maybe they shouldn’t get that information. Rules aren’t just for people you like or approve of.
- hollerith 3y agoSo you're not curious at all about how this "information leak" you probably did not know about before today could bite you personally? For you, this conversation is only about public policy and how you and I might change it -- and not at all about how you personally (or someone you care about) could modify your purchasing behavior to reduce your vulnerability to adverse governmental action? I agree with the legal principle you describe, but to me that is the less interesting angle because public policy is hard to change whereas my own behavior is much easier to change. It is amusing that I cannot have a conversation here about any other angle without getting downvoted by people opposed to any writings that could possibly be useful to the opposing side in the public debate over the one angle they want to talk (write) about.
- xxpor 3y agoThe standard for a warrant is probable cause, not reasonable suspicion.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoI think OP’s point is that, without privacy, there is no standard at all.
- mindcrime 3y ago
- sneak 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- calibas 3y agoThe government can violate your rights so long as they go through a 3rd party...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pvg 3y agoBig thread last week https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38719918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38719918 and last last week https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38615841 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38615841
- dang 3y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Police get medical records without a warrant - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38719918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38719918 - Dec 2023 (258 comments) Pharmacies share medical data with police without a warrant, inquiry finds - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38615841 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38615841 - Dec 2023 (46 comments)
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoJust adding for audience clarification and context: Techdirt is mostly about post-reporting analysis. They tend to come in when a story is a few days old and understanding has some percolation time. We can get a differently ordered picture than in the instants after news has broken.
- dang 3y agoI'm sure that's true. From a HN moderation point of view though, the question is whether two articles about the same underlying story are different enough to support substantially different conversations. If not, then the resulting thread will be largely repetitive of the original, and repetition is one of the main things we're trying to reduce here. In the present case the answer is pretty clearly 'no', because the comments aren't reacting to the OP's specific analysis, they're just responding to the general topic. This is pretty much what we'd expect since that's mostly how internet comments work. That doesn't invalidate your point, it just means that unfortunately the 'nuanced analysis' article that comes later is usually going to get downweighted as a follow-up on HN when the 'hot news' version of the same story already had significant attention.
- CodeAndCuffs 3y agoI used to work in Drug Diversion investigations, which is basically any time a prescription medication gets used from something other than intended bona fide medical use. Sometimes its doctors selling prescription drugs for non-medical use, sometimes its medical staff stealing. The biggest thing we covered was prescription fraud. People stealing or forging doctor's prescriptions. Some were more subtle about it. Sometimes you'd see a patient filling a 30mg Oxycodone, 90 count. Leads would come from either the Doctor, or the pharmacy. 30mg Oxycodone/90 is generally a "You are in massive pain and probably dying" prescription. So when a health 20 something year old walks in and has it filled for themself, it raises some eyebrows. They'd either call the Doctor to verify, who'd call us to investigate, or theyd call us and then we'd call the doctor. But the state already has access to this information. All prescriptions are logged in the Prescription Monitoring Program, which I believe all states how now. Any Doctor can get a spreadsheet of all prescriptions filled in their name over the last N days, who it was prescribed to, what for, and when. It was an invaluable tool. Doctor Adams tells us he never wrote this prescription for Bill. We lookup Bill and see he has filled similar suspicious prescriptions from Doctor Charles and Doctor Daniels. We talk to Charles and Daniels and they tell us that Bill isnt their patient either. We encourage Charles and Daniels to check their PMP report, and they uncover 4 or 5 more suspicious prescriptions, and we just keep pulling at this thread uncovering more and more. Of course there is potential for abuse and neglect, but we werent (and couldnt, legally) just go into a pharmacy and ask for random documents, or lookup random names on the PMP. We had to have an initial lead, usually a doctor, or a pharmacist, who saw something suspicious. From there, its just checking state records, verifying what we saw with doctors, and getting paper evidence of the stuff we already knew was false. I had maybe 3 cases where we had a red flag, called the doc, and they doc said "Yeah thats legit" and that was the end of the conversation. I don't need to know why this patient is on this narcotic, I just needed to know if it was a fraudulent. If its not, then thats between the doc and the patient. State law gave us authority to request pharmacy records, i.e. prescriptions and pickup logs, without a warrant. Most pharmacists did it with no hesitation. A few would want to make sure it wasn't a HIPPA violation (it wasnt) and that it was legal (it was). Concerningly, I did have a_couple instances where I asked for documents and the employee started to provide them before I had a chance to identify myself. In summary, if we were to blindly look at someones medical history or records without a bona fide articulable suspicion of a crime, it'd be massively illegal. If we did have a reason to look at the records, its because someone in the medical field saw something suspicious and reported it. From there we were mainly looking at records the government already had, and then finally getting medical records from the pharmacy that was just paper evidence of records we already had.
- x86x87 3y agoNow consider states make it illegal to get birth control pills and retroactively go after anyone who has them prescribed. It's according to the law, ain't it? The states should keep their noses out of this and in effect all drugs should be made legal. If you do have a problem (ie an addiction) we should make it trivially easy to get help instead of burning resources to investigate these. As far as abuse goes: it should be trivially easy for a pharmacy to check if a doctor did indeed prescribe something without raping the privacy of everyone involved. As a matter of fact, why the hell does it take 30 minutes to fill a prescription in 2023?
- ljm 3y agoI don't agree with your proposed solution (make all drugs legal), but I do think that the pharma industry in the US basically gets to socialise their losses while privatising the gains. The Sackler family's opioids, for example, have caused untold damage, and they made billions from it. They were able to offset the cost of all of that onto the society.
- x86x87 3y agoThe "make all drugs legal" was meant as a way of saying that we should not punish people that have an addiction. I was not advocating giving highly addictive hard drugs out without prescription.
- lazide 3y agoAren’t these two stances mutually exclusive? How do you propose not punishing people with addictions while somehow never giving out hard drugs without a prescription - since addictions are by their definition destructive and Dr’s shouldn’t be giving prescriptions for things that are known to cause problems for someone?
- x86x87 3y agoAre they? You don't prosecute anyone. You get them help.
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- apapapa 3y agoThey probably van get that information 3 other ways also...
- getwiththeprog 3y agoThe story in TechDirt stems from https://www.finance.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/hhs_pharmacy_surveillance_letter_signed.pdf https://www.finance.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/hhs_pharmacy_su...