7 ms·
American cars are huge and unsafe, but automakers don't want the simple solution
- chiefalchemist 3y agoNot really, it's not the automakers, it's the auto buyers. The American market wants and expects BIG. There's no incentive for anything otherwise, especially when the price of gas is *once again* falling. This isn't going to be solved until we have "autos on demand", and then pricing will be based on the vehicle size ordered. At that point, there will be no justification for an SUV if there's just a single person needing to get across town or across state.
- sp332 3y agoSmaller cars are less available. They have longer wait times and higher dealer markup. In the article, the two smaller cars mentioned aren't even sold in the United States.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoIt’s not like car makers haven’t tried to go smaller at various points, including imports from over seas. Longer wait times and higher markups are by product of low demand. Americans like bigger cars. That’s just a fact, and it’s not up to the supply side to dictate to the demand side what demand is. It’s just not how these things work. “Educating consumers” was a topic in the article, and it’s about as absurd an idea as I’ve ever heard. People want long range not because they’re idiots, but because they occasionally do longer day trips and don’t want to be isolated based on the car they bought. You won’t “educate” people out of the idea of not being tethered to their urban core no matter how much automakers market small short range vehicles.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoAnd that's because smaller cars are less desired by The Market. Let's forget small / smaller for a second. Let's just go with mid-sized. *Plenty* of options there and yet SUVs and trucks are the goto choice. See? It's the market.
- unnamed76ri 3y agoGas prices are still up more than 50% from just a few years ago. No one is out buying SUVs because the average price is $3.22 today vs $3.29 a year ago lol
- chiefalchemist 3y agoGas prices blipped up for a hot second. On the other hand, compare the USA gas prices to Europe and US gas is severely lower. Think about it...Uncle Sam is offering tax credits and such in order to encourage the purchase of EVs. And that same Uncle Sam is doing all he can to keep gas prices down (for a number of different reasons) which discourages and disincentizes EVs. Make sense, right?
- comprev 3y agoIf the only vehicles available to buy are big (or the wait times for smaller less produced models are longer) then the customer rarely has a choice. They need _a_ car _now_ .
- francisofascii 3y ago> The American market wants and expects BIG. I guess the question is, why. It is because marketing works? Or a sense of safety? Bigger is associated with wealth, power? etc.
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoDrive a big car. It's really nice to have a large cabin. It seems like everyone wondering about big cars is missing the most obvious reason.
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoMost MPV's will have larger (and more useful) interior spaces than these warfare vehicles. Auto makers have figured out how to push our buttons and buy larger and more wasteful vehicles in what is a de facto arms race on the public road.
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoPerhaps, but... they are very ugly.
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoNo, you have been socially conditioned through media that they are not aspirational and they do not transmit power and prestige. If you are the man you must buy NewAuto TM, you wouldn't want to look weak.
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoThis is basically fortune cookie wisdom. Sounds intelligent, has zero evidence to back it up.
- DoingIsLearning 3y ago
- chiefalchemist 3y agoWTF? Down voted? Who on HN failed Economics 101? God bless you, but please stay away from the DV button.
- kwertyoowiyop 3y agoIf there was no demand, there’d be no supply.
- RosanaAnaDana 3y agoThe main business of any industry is manufacturing demand.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoPretty slanted. Could write a complementary article: large cars are safer for the passengers. Why don't we keep pedestrians separate from traffic more effectively?
- pmontra 3y agoPedestrian bridges on every intersection? Cars mandated to use only yet to be digged underground roads? Any other idea?
- resoluteteeth 3y agoLarge cars aren't inherently safer for passengers. They are only safer in collisions with other cars that are smaller, at the expense of the safety of the people in the smaller cars. Having an arms race where people buy bigger and bigger cars to be safer in collisions with other cars is really not ideal, because it doesn't improve overall automobile safety on a national level even just for drivers, and it hurts safety for pedestrians.
- cozzyd 3y agoThey also will typically stop slower and are often more vulnerable to rollovers...
- Scoundreller 3y agoIt’s also a matter of comfort. Cities including mine are drunk on putting speed humps everywhere. But obviously they’re not “tuned” for each vehicle size. A coupe/sedan needs to slow down to half the speed limit to go over, while a larger vehicle with a suspension and tire sizes to match can take them at speed. Same story for potholes, which of course are worsened by heavier vehicles while small vehicles pay the price. Literally encouraging an arms race when it comes to vehicle size.
- kemayo 3y ago"Large cars let me ignore speed humps" sounds exactly like prioritizing the occupants of the car over the safety of others...
- orangecat 3y agoYou could just make them smaller. There's no rule saying you can't. There kind of is. Fuel efficiency requirements are stricter for smaller vehicles, creating a perverse incentive to increase size. Here's a 2011 paper that predicted exactly what would happen: https://news.umich.edu/cafe-standards-create-profit-incentive-for-larger-vehicles/ https://news.umich.edu/cafe-standards-create-profit-incentiv...
- Scoundreller 3y agoAnd tax advantages for “business use” vehicles when they weigh over 6000 pounds: https://www.taxfyle.com/blog/list-of-vehicles-over-6000-lbs https://www.taxfyle.com/blog/list-of-vehicles-over-6000-lbs
- Scoundreller 3y agoI wonder where the weights they added to the Lincoln Aviator are to get it to 6001 pounds. Can they be removed?
- qbrass 3y agoThey added half a ton of hybrid system.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoThis is the reason we are all driving beasts. For a small wheelbase vehicle to meet CAFE standards it has to get an unreasonable 90mpg or the manufacturer gets fined.
- gruez 3y ago> For a small wheelbase vehicle to meet CAFE standards it has to get an unreasonable 90mpg or the manufacturer gets fined. Source? At least according to this source[1], a car with footprint similar to a Honda Fit only needs to hit 51 mpg this year, which it currently meets[2][3]. There are certainly cars that are even smaller than a Honda Fit, and maybe those do need to hit 90mpg, but the existence of cars like the Honda Fit proves that you can have CAFE compliant cars that aren't "beasts". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_average_fuel_economy#Updates_under_Biden_administration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_average_fuel_economy... [2] https://hondanews.eu/eu/fi/cars/media/pressreleases/1523/honda-jazz1 https://hondanews.eu/eu/fi/cars/media/pressreleases/1523/hon... [3] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=+4.5+L%2F100km+to+mpg https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=+4.5+L%2F100km+to+mpg
- CodeWriter23 3y agoIJS what we now call “Full Size” like the Impala, we used to refer to as “Compact” up till the early 90s.
- gruez 3y ago>we used to refer to as “Compact” up till the early 90s. source?
- RosanaAnaDana 3y agoHave you ever been in a car?
- gruez 3y agoI was in a car this morning, why?
- RosanaAnaDana 3y agoSource?
- gruez 3y agoAs luck would have it, I do have pictures of myself in a car. However, for privacy reasons I would rather not upload pictures of my face on the internet. I'd be happy to provide the picture to a trusted third party auditor of your choosing (eg. Deloitte, E&Y, KPMG, PWC) for verification, provided that you pay the fees :^) Now, I don't imagine that there would be any privacy related issues related to providing evidence regarding whether a Chevrolet Impala was considered a compact car or not, so I look forward to receiving correspondence from your auditor and whatever evidence you have that Chevrolet Impala was considered a compact car.
- tharne 3y ago> source? A bunch of us were alive in the 90's and driving cars.
- cozzyd 3y agoBack when I used to have a car (over 10 years ago now...) I drive a 2001 Subaru Forester. Newer Foresters are much bigger and nigh unrecognizable. I occasionally rent cars and always ask for a sedan, but half the time I get "upgraded" to a tank that has huge blind spots (how are you supposed to see cyclists?), uses twice as much fuel and is much harder to park in front of my condo building (which requires maneuvering around elevated train pillars). My toddler even calls it a bus.
- 303uru 3y agoSimilar, I'm always getting an "upgrade" when I travel. Inevitably to a Suburban or most recently a Expedition MAX which was one of the biggest pieces of absolute crap I've ever driven. The hoods are so long, tall and square you could hide an entire classroom behind them. They drive like absolute trash, slow to stop, body roll for days, turn the wheel 4 times to make a tight turn, etc... I know there is some demented subset of people who equate their masculinity to these things, but who else actually want to drive these monstrosities?
- throitallaway 3y agoI've always driven small cars. One time when I had to get a rental vehicle they only had F150s available. The visibility was so bad that I ended up backing into a shopping cart in a grocery store parking lot. I hate that everyone is running around in multi-ton death machines nowadays.
- dukeofdoom 3y agoSmaller cars use less sturdy components and tires A pothole or even snow can take them out.
- cyberax 3y agoWhat a bunch of bull. It's a complete opposite, a heavier vehicle chews through tires faster.
- dukeofdoom 3y agoI write from experience. My parent's Ford focus wheel fell off after hitting a pot hole. Not even a big one. Just less sturdy components that rusted.
- cyberax 3y agoI write from experience: large cars just fall apart. My rental SUV with 150 miles had a wheel falling off. Dude, you do understand that making extrapolations onto all cars from a single datapoint is idiocy?
- dukeofdoom 3y agoMaybe it would be, but only in your head. It's not just single data point that I base my opinion on. The average SUV can cost significantly more than a typical car. The manufacturer tends to build SUVS with larger wheels, and sturdier components. Very often SUVs will be built on a Truck body for example. The larger wheels, sturdier frame are much better going over potholes, and clearing snow. Just curious, do you live anywhere with snow/winter weather?
- closewith 3y agoIs that true in the States? In Europe a Polo with winter tyres is going to be more than adequate in snow and any paved roads.
- anvuong 3y ago
- Barrin92 3y agodoesn't make a lot of sense to put this on manufacturers. The safety aspect is a collective action problem. When only one person buys a smaller car they're not safer, so you need to get everyone to change. Next big factor is regulation and protectionism. Read a depressing blog about the effort a guy had to go through to get a mini truck from China to the US and he couldn't even drive it on some roads. Importing the thing cost almost as much as the truck. Also the US still has no carbon market, putting a higher price on fossil fuels creates an actual incentive to buy more efficient cars. These are structural issues, asking manufacturers to just make different cars won't magically create demand for them.
- tzs 3y ago> The safety aspect is a collective action problem. When only one person buys a smaller car they're not safer, so you need to get everyone to change. The difficulty with getting people to agree to that is that when it comes to crashes between two cars, or between one car and some stationary object like a big tree, "everyone has a smaller car" is less safe than "everyone has a larger car". "Everyone has a smaller car" would be safer for pedestrians and cyclists, but something like 80% of deaths involving cars are from cars hitting cars or cars hitting stationary objects accidents so that's probably going to be the priority for most people.
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoLots of people want big cars, and they vote with their checkbook. I have a big car. I have children. They have stuff, and friends and we go on long drives sometimes. It's nice to have a big car.
- Apreche 3y agoI grew up before SUV existed. I had siblings. Somehow we survived. Many countries around the world don't have an SUV epidemic. Somehow families there make it work with smaller cars, even today. Many people around the world have large families and zero cars. Somehow they make it work. People are MADE to want big cars by advertisements. Other than the emissions standards mentioned by other commenters, the real solution is to ban car advertisements. We should ban gambling and alcohol advertisements as well. It worked for tobacco.
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoPeople also survived in caves long ago. The fact that humans have survived various uncomfortable situations doesn't make them stop wanting to be more comfortable. Nope. People go test drive them, and realize it's nicer to have more space. There are cars in every shape and size in the US. I went to buy a midsized SUV and ended up with a full SUV after test driving. It's much more comfortable. More space is valued by humans in houses, cars, airline seats, hotel rooms and various other places.
- nradov 3y agoThere's really no substitute for having a big car. Sure it's possible to live with a small car (I've done it), but having more interior space and cargo capacity makes everything so much easier. Especially if you have children who participate in team sports.
- readthenotes1 3y agoIt is also far safer to have a big car since there are so many other big cars on the road.
- 3y ago
- cyb_ 3y agoI was curious how they defined 'unsafe' in this context. Following the links in the article, I found this quote: > These massive trucks are actually safer for their occupants, but far more deadly to the people outside
- kcplate 3y agoI’ll point out and it will probably get downvoted again because it is an inconvenient truth, but making vehicles safer for the occupants at the cost of slightly to somewhat more dangerous for non-occupants can still result in a net improvement of overall safety because pedestrians and vehicle accidents happen far less frequently than vehicle to vehicle accidents.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNo it doesn't. The larger vehicle in a collision is safer, but the smaller vehicle is less safe. If you buy an Expedition, you're more likely to kill a pedestrian, plus you're more likely to kill the occupants of any other vehicles you collide with. You're more likely to die in a rollover, and dont significantly affect your odds when colliding with a fixed object. Your personal risk goes down because as you say vehicle to vehicle is the most common and you win that zero sum game, but overall the score is very negative.
- kcplate 3y agoSo you do or don’t agree with my statement of “making vehicles safer for the occupants at the cost of slightly to somewhat more dangerous for non-occupants can still result in a net improvement of overall safety”?
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNo, you are making it far worse for people driving smaller vehicles too.
- 3y ago
- MorrhinKev 3y agoConosidering how unsafe they are, why aren't there more "small-cars-friendly" regulations for manufacturers? - I wonder