12 ms·
How we turned the tide in the roach wars
- aqme28 3y agoThe audio plugin does not work on my Firefox
- munchler 3y agoLet me save you a click and a long read: the innovation is Combat roach traps, which contain a poison bait that a roach brings back to the nest and transfers to other roaches. This resulted in a 93% drop in roach complaints in one survey.
- shermantanktop 3y agoIt was entertaining, though.
- leetcrew 3y agothese do work well in my experience, but there is a tradeoff to consider if you live in a large apartment building. if you have roaches in your unit, your neighbors probably do too. if you use this kind of trap, you might attract everyone else's roaches to your apartment. it can be an unpleasant few weeks as they all stumble out to die, one by one. if the infestation is really large, this basically never ends. if you have a decent landlord, I recommend trying to engage them first. they can hire someone to spray all the units, so you don't have to turn your place into a roach graveyard.
- jghn 3y agoThe large apartment building issue is a big one. I lived in a building (10 stories, 70 units plus commercial space on floors 1-3) for ~10 years. The first several years were great, not a single pest of any sort. And then the roaches (German cockroaches) started to show up. The problem was that once they got into the building they were impossible to eradicate everywhere as no one, including the owners, were willing to bite the bullet and treat it as a whole-building problem. So instead you'd get little pockets of treatment and a never ending cycle was created. Years later in our house we found and killed a single German cockroach. And of course, living in a city, if you find one that means there are many more. We were terrified. But after a single treatment by a pest control company we haven't seen any other activity for several years. Still have no idea if somehow we *did* only have that single one or what. But I'm not complaining.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> Years later in our house we found and killed a single German cockroach. And of course, living in a city, if you find one that means there are many more. Being in a city has nothing to do with it. Cockroaches are social, like sheep (or humans). If you live in a city and you find a spider, it was just the one spider. If you live in the remote wilderness and you find a cockroach, it was hundreds of cockroaches.
- jghn 3y agoThe point I was raising was regarding the different species of cockroaches. In rural areas there are species that primarily live outside but can find their way inside. German cockroaches tends to be more urban and indoors, so if you see one you can't hand wave it away as having just having hitched a ride into your house.
- jurassic 3y agoI had the same experience in a big building. I basically rendered my own kitchen unsafe for human food preparation with all the poisons I tried, but still it hardly made a dent because there was a near infinite population of german cockroaches waiting to recolonize my unit from the walls and surrounding units.
- ne8il 3y agoI had the same situation recently - a single German cockroach chilling on the front of our dishwasher. Being sufficiently terrified by reading r/whatisthisbug and the like, I had a pest control company out the next day to treat. They could find no signs of infestation and I haven't seen a single one since (and we did set out traps to monitor). The Orkin guy who came out said it's not uncommon for a lone individual to venture into a home.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pastor_bob 3y agoInteresting, Advion is what people in NYC swear by (It does the same thing)
- duxup 3y agoTraps that do the same with ants has worked for me too. Put it out, they swarm it and after a bit ... they're all gone.
- aidenn0 3y agoDoesn't work reliably against Argentine ants; they form supercolonies so even if you take out one or two queens, it may not be enough. [edit] AFAIK, it's still the best way, but it's not the near 100% knockout it can be against other ant species.
- Slevin11 3y agoOnly thing I’ve had that worked against argentine ants was termidor sc. Non repellent, and slow kill time. Spray it on an active walkway, and it will slowly spread through the colony and kill them all off. Again, supercolonies, so it isn’t a perfect solution. But it’s the only thing that works for me for 6+ months at a time. Then, I have to spray again as soon as I see another Argentine.
- wincy 3y agoWe have effective pest control for roaches, probably developed around the same time. Using growth regulators like Gentrol make it so the cockroaches can’t breed effectively, so after a generation or two they go extinct. Somehow roaches got into our suburban home and I was able to destroy them using this method. Pesticides and roach bait didn’t do much — the growth regulators were key in permanently removing the infestation. I’d guess the difficulty in a place like New York is similar to the problem I’m having with mice because we have a forest behind the house — an essentially endless reservoir of new roaches living in the pipes and throughout the city. Source: was professional exterminator about 15 years ago. Growth regulators were the only thing that worked.
- klodolph 3y agoSpeaking of New York—everyone’s story with roaches is that they get them when a new neighbor moves in. You can’t get rid of roaches in your apartment as long as your neighbors contribute the steady stream of new roaches.
- lbotos 3y agoIts... wildly accurate. Neighbors decided they were tired of tenants and roach problems so they removed the kitchen from their rented apartment. Roach problem went away for them and me. I will randomly get a few waterbugs (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oriental_cockroach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oriental_cockroach) which are alarming but it's usually when temps are dramatically changing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 3y agoThese are one of the favorite hunting conquests for my two cats. They are fast and change directions quickly and can fly. They are tough to catch to throw back outside, but not as fun as a cicada that is flying around and your cat(s) are jumping off of the furniture trying to catch them again. There are times where the cat and I are trying to catch the waterbug before it gets somewhere hard to get, but for very different reasons.
- kleton 3y agoThis kind of filler-laden writing will be quickly eradicated, like the cockroach, but by AI. I had bing or copilot, whatever microsoft is calling it in the edge sidebar answer the question I clicked the bait for. > According to the article, they solved the cockroach infestation by using a new product called Combat, which was a bait that contained a slow-acting poison that could kill roaches through various mechanisms of transfer, such as feces, vomit, cannibalism, and necrophagy. The bait was attractive to roaches and could wipe out entire colonies, even if only a fraction of them ate it. The product was developed by American Cyanamid, a chemical company, and tested by Austin Frishman, a cockroach expert. The product was launched in 1985 and became a huge success, reducing cockroach complaints and populations across the country. The article claims that this was a forgotten achievement in the history of pest control, and that the roaches are slowly coming back due to behavioral resistance to the bait. Source: Conversation with Bing, 12/27/2023 (1) The Cockroach Cure - The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/podcasts/archive/2023/11/cockroach-bait-invention-combat/676167/ https://www.theatlantic.com/podcasts/archive/2023/11/cockroa.... (2) Cockroach Infestation - Signs, Prevention, and Control of Roaches. https://www.familyhandyman.com/article/cockroach-infestations/ https://www.familyhandyman.com/article/cockroach-infestation.... (3) How To Get Rid Of Roaches - This Old House. https://www.thisoldhouse.com/pest-control/reviews/how-to-get-rid-of-roaches https://www.thisoldhouse.com/pest-control/reviews/how-to-get.... (4) How To Get Rid Of Roaches – Forbes Home. https://www.forbes.com/home-improvement/pest-control/how-to-get-rid-of-cockroaches/ https://www.forbes.com/home-improvement/pest-control/how-to-....
- makeworld 3y agoIt was entertaining to read.
- oconnor663 3y agoI think it's a transcript of a podcast, to be fair. But yeah I had the same reaction.
- CommieBobDole 3y ago>This kind of filler-laden writing will be quickly eradicated It's a transcript of a podcast. I agree it was annoying to read, but the purpose of a podcast is not maximum-efficiency transmission of information.
- gumby 3y agoThe TL;DR is that a product was developed in the 80s that poisoned the roaches, but not immediately so they could return to the nest and spread the poison. And it worked for a long while until the only survivors are ones that aren’t attracted to the taste of the poison. This approach was used to suppress rabbits in Australia, us in the disease myxomatosis. The infected rabbit didn’t die immediately but would return to the burrow to spread it. When I was a kid you could see myxie rabbits outside, dying, with pus coming out. Of course the survivors eventually were the ones immune to myxomatosis.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, you are always supposed to cycle through insecticides. And, of course, you won't ever be able to contain an species that occupies an otherwise unfilled niche. Make sure to preserve the predators and clean any artificial niche or populate it with some alternative species. I believe people already knew that in the turn to the 20th century, but somehow almost no big project anywhere does the full set of actions.
- troad 3y ago> Make sure to preserve the predators and clean any artificial niche or populate it with some alternative species. Rabbits are not native to Australia, and they have no natural predators on the continent. Introducing new species to Australia's wildly unique ecosystem is rightly frowned upon (see rabbits, introduction of). Neither of these solutions would be effective.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> And it worked for a long while until the only survivors are ones that aren’t attracted to the taste of the poison. I used that product in a vacation house in Spain and it really worked wonders. And that was around 2017/2018. So not all cockroaches have evolved yet!
- cptaj 3y agoAnother amazing product is Bravecto for ticks and fleas. I've had dogs all my life in a very tropical climate. I've battled with ticks for ages. It was always a combined-arms war of attrition just to keep them in check. But then came Bravecto which is basically a WMD/Genocide machine for fleas and ticks. Just one simple pill and it eradicates them all. It stays active for 6 months too so it really just wipes them out from the area and the dogs stay clean for over a year after that. This is a massive technological conquest, IMO
- ericmcer 3y agoHow does it work? I have always wondered how flea and tick medicine works. It makes your blood poisonous?
- huytersd 3y agoIt’s not for people but yes, it makes the dog’s blood “poisonous”.
- krisoft 3y ago> It makes your blood poisonous? It makes the blood poisonous to the central nervous system of the ticks. Here is an article about them if you prefer reading: https://www.petmd.com/how-do-common-tick-medications-work-pets https://www.petmd.com/how-do-common-tick-medications-work-pe... Or this video about them if you would rather watch and listen: https://youtu.be/4QDDHjRZIZM https://youtu.be/4QDDHjRZIZM
- hackernewds 3y agoif it affects flesh that way wouldn't it have clear effects on the internal organs? or are the biology of insects so much different vs mammals this kind of technology perplexes me
- positr0n 3y agoLots of poisons (and herbicides, and medicines too) work by targeting a single chemical pathway. E.g. binding to a specific receptor or doing something to a specific protein. I think insects and mammals do have pretty different biology, but even if they didn't it would only take one chemical pathway that insects used and mammals didn't that you could exploit.
- cm2012 3y agoRoaches are very easy to exterminate with gel bait + gentrol + maybe powder for cracks. About $70 worth of equipment for a big infestation (I've solved a few for friends in NYC). It's just that 90% of exterminators in cities are useless, its a minimum wage job and its in the pest control company's interests to not solve the problem permanently.
- faet 3y agoGel bait has been huge for me. We're in an area that gets roaches pretty frequently. They still get in, but we'll find them dead and in much smaller numbers than when we used a spray. About 2-4/year now always dead vs ~10-15/year half of which were alive.
- kilolima 3y agoThe best solution to roaches I've found is to support your local ant colonies! Healthy ants will eat all your other bugs and the only drawback is having to keep your dry foods in ant-proof containers.
- dividedbyzero 3y agoWon't they evolve around this too at some point? I feel like the only truly effective way to eradicate pests long-term will end up being swarms of little robot predators that wipe them out by force.
- probably_wrong 3y agoThe article covers that point near the end.
- spydum 3y agoBut then you are just introducing two new types of bugs..
- bazzargh 3y agoinevitably, because evolution acts on the regular expression of genes.
- stevenwoo 3y agoNear the end of the article it says there appears to be a very slow comeback with roaches in slightly increasing numbers that do not prefer the sweetness of the effective bait pesticide combo, apparently not developing an immunity.
- VincentEvans 3y agoWhen I was a landlord - i found foggers that I bought at Home Depot very effective. Nuked roach populations between tenants multiple times. Had personal experience living in the same unit - after putting out traps, fogging, and subsequently keeping the place clean - no more roaches. But as soon as nasty people move in, they come back.
- VincentEvans 3y agoBy the way, you mileage may vary based on construction etc, but in brick row homes where I rented - I found that roaches from neighbors weren’t an issue. Once eliminated in my unit - I didn’t see them coming back from the neighbors. Mice however, were much harder to control. I was never able to completely eliminate them. Nearly but never entirely gone - they travel between shared walls. In a single home - I was able to completely eliminate them relatively quickly and easily, but not in a row home.
- drewzero1 3y agoI lived in the lower unit of a duplex that was a converted 1880s house and saw mice in the basement and heard neighbors' complaints of mice upstairs, but we never had them on the first floor. Later we moved to the upper unit and found that when the kitchen was put in to convert the house to a duplex, someone had cut a big hole for the kitchen pipes that left a clear view down to the basement-- and a perfect tunnel for mice. We covered the hole and didn't have any more mice after that.
- jjgreen 3y agoIf you've got mice, you've not got rats ...
- quantumsequoia 3y agoIf they kept coming back, that means you never really exterminated the population, just got their numbers low. You need to make the population go extinct
- 3y ago
- chuckadams 3y agoAwesome. Now do bed bugs. Please.
- elwebmaster 3y agoTotal nonsense article. The tide on roach wars was indeed turned but much later by the invention of PfDNV in Wuhan.
- astrange 3y agoIt doesn't appear that's the kind of cockroach they have in NYC. But it was the kind we used to have in Atlanta. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smokybrown_cockroach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smokybrown_cockroach vs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_cockroach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_cockroach
- elwebmaster 3y agohttps://horizon.documentation.ird.fr/exl-doc/pleins_textes/pleins_textes_7/b_fdi_59-60/010025973.pdf https://horizon.documentation.ird.fr/exl-doc/pleins_textes/p... At least four species have been shown to be susceptible to PfDNV including the American cockroach. It’s basically Covid for cockroaches.
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoThis is a great article, but man, the tone of news media used to be great. Can you imagine an NBC journalist writing something as funny as "Congressman Silvio Conte, dressed to kill today, proclaimed a war on Capitol cockroaches." particularly about a Republican(gasp!)? Polarization is so much worse now, but the issues people faced in this period were nuclear annihilation, the ozone layer falling apart, Iran shitshow etc. Crime was 10x higher. I miss when things were a bit kinder, I guess. Everyone is such a dick now.
- kibwen 3y agoIn this context, saying that he was "dressed to kill" was not the journalist complimenting his dapper attire, but rather making a corny pun. TV news networks force their anchors to use groan-worthy lines like this to this day, as a way of keeping the audience's attention.
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoObviously, but it's still fun and witty - instead of "TRUMP|BIDEN - A TRAITOR - IS HERE TO FUCK YOUR KIDS" that you get from the mainline media now.
- roywiggins 3y agoConte was dressed as an exterminator (it's mentioned further down in the piece). It's a pun.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- PKop 3y agoToo many "like's" and "I mean" filler words. Things become unreadable/unlistenable when when every other sentence has an unnecessary like injected into it.
- chrisweekly 3y agoYeah, transcripts of verbal conversations are like that.
- PKop 3y agoNo I don't think we should excuse speaking this way, which isn't something everyone does nor something so many people did years ago. It is a particular style of speaking that is over-represented in certain journalist types.
- kibwen 3y agoThe use of "like" in this way has been attested since the 1920s, and had been overwhelmingly common in colloquial American English for around 30 years.
- PKop 3y agoIt's, I mean, distracting and unpleasant to, like, listen to when every other sentence has, like, meaningless words injected into them which, I mean, could, like, be removed without changing the meaning at all but which, I mean, would be more, like, concise and sound better. No, it is certainly not true that people have been talking this way since the 20's nor that radio shows, media, journalists etc presented information in this sloppy manner. It is trivially verifiably not just a default way of talking by listening to podcasters or journalists that exist right now that don't do this but also watching/listening to older media especially. This is akin to vocal fry, another recent grating social phenomenon that has become acceptable for a certain type of public speaker that is drastically different than most people and media types spoke even in the 80's and 90's let alone decades prior.
- 3y ago
- pers0n 3y agoI always have a bottle of silver powder and when I get a new apartment (every year) I pull out the oven, fridge and dishwasher and put that stuff down after vacuuming the area. One time the situation was so bad I also had to use the diatomaceous earth power in combination. I stored all my food trash in my refrigerator for months an no food was left out that wasn’t in a sealed plastic container. Along with having the apartment spray I was able to get it under control.
- ww520 3y agoBoric acid works, too. In fact it works well against any insects with a shell exoskeleton, like cockroaches, ants, or termites. The boric crystal punctures their exoskeleton causing them to lose body fluid. It also works against the colony as it’s a slow acting agent that the insects can bring it back to the colony. The insects communicate by touching so the powder is spread from one to the other when they rub each other’s antenna during meeting. Boric is really cheap. A large bottle in Home Depot is about $4 to $5. Edit: story time. My parents used to live in a mixed use condo building where the commercial ground floor had a number of restaurants. They had a bad cockroach problem. I got him a bottle of boric acid and sprayed around the pipes and corners. He never saw another cockroach again. We had a swarming of termites outside around the house after a raining season. Called the termite guys. They came out and said it’s the subterranean termites under the ground outside and the water disturbed them. They drilled holes around the house and injected liquid solution into them. They sprayed the crawl space underneath. I asked them what the solution was. They said it’s basically boric. Oof. Their service charged $2800 and the material was boric.
- hackernewds 3y agoIsn't inhaling boric acid in indoor settings going to produce the same effect for our lungs?
- ww520 3y agoHuman and pets have soft tissue that don’t seem to be bothered by it. I meant inhaling a large amount of fine powder of any type is a problem. Boric acid seems to be pretty heavy that they’re not airborne easily. Boric acid was used in detergent, pool cleaning, eye wash, mouth rinse, toothpaste, skin treatment, and some food preparation.
- uxp8u61q 3y agoAsbestos was used everywhere, that's not proving that it's safe in any way...
- Zak 3y ago
- prpl 3y agoWho would have thought Joe’s apartment would be unrelatable?
- Solvency 3y agoI don't understand why we don't just create a genetically engineered cockroach that wipes them all out by outcompeting and then dying off? The same way they want to with mosquitos. Almost nothing subsists on cockroaches. It wouldn't disrupt the ecosystem at all, especially in cities like NYC.
- michaelcampbell 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mimic_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mimic_(film)
- linusg789 3y agohttps://ghostarchive.org/archive/OJMMe https://ghostarchive.org/archive/OJMMe
- gagabity 3y agoYou need to go to your local China Town and get the real poison the type that Amazon/Walmart wont sell. Roaches start moving out on their own when they see that stuff.
- tcoff91 3y agoYeah combat and all that shit at home depot doesn't do jack. Bengal is the only thing available from mainstream ecommerce retailers that actually works. Not sure if the best version of it can be shipped to california though.
- joegahona 3y agoIs that "the chalk"? When I lived in NYC that was legendary -- you could watch a roach touch it and almost immediately fall over dead. The only thing that worked for me was sealing up holes, and that wasn't 100%. I tried the genetic-warfare gel that others here are talking about, and it didn't seem to work -- it could've been working, but being in a 6-floor walk-up meant there were probably millions of roaches to take the place of the dead ones. The other thing I noticed is that whether you have roaches in NYC is a complete crapshoot -- I lived directly above a bar/restaurant and had zero bugs of any kind, and I lived with no bar/restaurant in sight and had a roach problem. Go figure.
- gen220 3y agoLiving in a big + damp city for years, roaches are unavoidable (especially in the summer months). We adopted cats in 2020, and haven't encountered a (living) roach since. I'm afraid our cats aren't very cost effective as pest control, but they do the job!
- ProllyInfamous 3y ago>cats aren't very cost effective You're catting wrong. Requires more scritches.
- borbtactics 3y agoI have a legitimate fear of cockroaches and sometimes I wish editors would refrain from putting a gigantic roach picture at the top
- LeoPanthera 3y agoEvery fall our house in the mountains has an invasion of dampwood termites. Never very many, at most you'll see about four or five a day, for 2 or 3 weeks. And then they're gone. But they are relentless, and always at the same time of the year. We've called four different exterminators and they all say the same thing. "They only eat damp wood. Find it and get rid of it." And then they leave. But we're surrounded by redwood trees so... we're just screwed I guess.
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoI know they're pricey, but when I lived in a subtropical rain forest for 7 years (in a decaying 100+ year old cabin) the solution to termites/roaches/mold ended up being running three dedicated dehumidifiers (~2000sqft). This cost me hundred$, annually, but was absolutely worthwhile. Diatomaceous Earth will also kill anything, including fleas/bedbugs/ticks.
- blastbking 3y agoI think they're celebrating a little too soon. A few years ago I lived in a roach infested apartment in Seattle and we used every form of pesticide imaginable, essentially to no effect. We were finding them in our food, inside kettles, etc. It maybe wasn't as bad as the waves the post described. I guess this quote from the article even admits that roaches have become wiser and are on the rise again: So, roach numbers are slowly going up again. And if you read publications of the Pest Management Association newsletter, which maybe I’ve done recently, you can see that there’s, you know, there’s some chatter about how roach calls are increasing. Okay, so I pulled some numbers. I went to the American Housing Survey from the federal government. In 2011, 13.1 million estimated households had signs of cockroaches in the last 12 months. In 2021, 14.5 million.
- throwaway232792 3y agoI'm hoping housing architecture evolves to become anti-roach and anti-termite as first class citizens. Any nooks and crannies and I know a german roach is hiding in there.
- mberning 3y agoMan growing up in the suburbs sounds like heaven compared to this. Pouring your cereal and roaches come out? Thats a scene from a nightmare or horror film. Growing up in the midwestern suburbs in the 80s we saw them occasionally, but nothing like what was described here.
- kylehotchkiss 3y agoSame for me in suburbs in the 90s/2000s. Never saw anything other than millipedes (which are also gross). Now in San Diego and every time I go to little Italy I wish I wasn’t wearing sandals because so many of the big ones scatter across the street (why can’t the city do more to get rid of these?)
- alekseiprokopev 3y agoThere is a quite peculiar article on Wikipedia [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depopulation_of_cockroaches_in_post-Soviet_states https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depopulation_of_cockroaches_in...]. Also, please check the Russian version of the article.
- pkulak 3y agoI really wanted this to go more into how the poison works, and contrast it with previous solutions, maybe talk about those as well. If the roaches no longer like sweet, can we flavor it like something else? Instead it was talking about how roaches make the hosts feel in their presence and then absense, and how they feel about the Combat inventor’s perceived sleight.
- Projectiboga 3y agoHere is some Bed Bug info, went through that before both in my apartment and a separate infection my mom got after being in Geriatric Rehab. Her place was extra tough with all the clutter, but the dishes for the bed legs and getting the bed free standing is the best first method. I'd advise against most pesticides as many or neurotoxic. Growth regulators are probably ok. Ecovenger by Exoraider is the best verses bedbugs. It was Developed at Rutgers University. Here is a totally different Rutgers Professor who has really advanced Bed Bug Control. Traps and isolating bed legs and getting beds away from furniture and walls is the basic method. https://njaes.rutgers.edu/bed-bug/methods-to-control-bed-bugs.php https://njaes.rutgers.edu/bed-bug/methods-to-control-bed-bug...
- ijhuygft776 3y agoI you don't destroy the cockroach, life might come back more quickly if you keep them alive (after a mass extinction). /s