4 ms·
A larger family worsens kids' cognitive development, suggests 30-year study
- AlgorithmicTime 3y ago[dead]
- rpmisms 3y agoThe younger children have lower IQs because mom runs out of resources to make people as time goes on. This is a well-known and easily solvable phenomenon. Edit: I am the oldest of 11, and would not trade the experience for anything. It's wonderful, and made me more knowledgeable, since we were unschooled, and would study different topics and compare cliff notes. Still the only reason I know anything about quantum mechanics.
- pkoird 3y agoI'm sorry but what? Do you have any references for this?
- rpmisms 3y agoSure. Omega-3, a critical ingredient for having smart kids, is depleted during pregnancy, and few women supplement enough to fully replenish. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3046737/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3046737/
- halfmatthalfcat 3y agoAren't prenatal vitamins (which include omega-3) essentially prescribed by default nowadays?
- rpmisms 3y agoYes, which is why OP's study based on data from the 1950s is already problematic. However, a fixed cocktail of supplements isn't ideal. Some people actually get their bloodwork done and concentrate on what they really need.
- uncletaco 3y agoThis study doesn’t at all say what you originally claimed about moms “running out of resources as time goes on” when it comes to birth order and IQs. Either you missed the point or you honest to god don’t care about spreading disgusting misinformation.
- rpmisms 3y agoActually, it does, but only if you have reasonable reading comprehension. How is what I'm saying "disgusting misinformation"? I'm very interested in what precisely you're angry at.
- potatosalad21 3y agoThis article is about diet. Where is the source that says that women have stored reserves of omega 3 that are depleted with measurable impacts on later born children?
- rpmisms 3y agoI'm sorry, do I need to post a biology class in here too? I can post the study about how women with bigger butts have smarter children due to higher Omega-3 availability, and the study detailing the depletion during pregnancy, and the study I already posted on Omega 3 in the diet. Or, the idea that building a human depletes resources could be relatively uncontroversial, because duh.
- uncletaco 3y agoPlease post those studies I want to seem something.
- nradov 3y agoOmega-3 stays in your body for only about 6 months and must be continuously replenished. This can be an issue over the course of a single pregnancy. But it's not something that gets progressively depleted over multiple pregnancies.
- QuarterReptile 3y agoThis is obviously real, and timelines/effects differ. How could growth in utero not matter? And how could pregnancy not deplete resources? That depletion can be reduced and managed, but it happens. I would suspect that most women are anemic by third trimester, just to pick an easy one. Even keeping on weight while breastfeeding can be challenging, to look at an even coarser metric. All of this is pretty consistent with the general unlikelihood of getting pregnant within one year or , sometimes, up to 18 months postpartum, amd you'll often see 3 year spacing as an ideal target. Obviously, that spacing requires that you start having kids pretty early or continue pretty late if you want a large family. Seeking published results about this is hard because, first, social science and therefore observational studies with results that can readily be disputed; and second, this is one of those "shaming mothers" things that gets tabled or not suggested as research in the first place.
- nradov 3y agoThe actual data indicates that while gestational anemia is a significant problem, it doesn't impact most US women. The majority of US residents get adequate dietary iron, and prenatal vitamin supplements also contain iron. The problem is more severe in developing countries. https://doi.org/10.3945%2Fajcn.117.155986 https://doi.org/10.3945%2Fajcn.117.155986
- rpmisms 3y agoConsidering that OP's study is from the US in the 40s through 60s, gestational anemia probably factors in. Also, anemia is a single deficiency. How many more opportunities for deficiency are there? Hundreds?
- swozey 3y agoYou have 10 siblings and didn't attend any schools? What is the range of careers/skills everyone has? Any pods, like 3 of the youngest all learned the same skill together and went with that, like 3 engineers?
- rpmisms 3y agoI'm a software engineer, I have a couple brothers in permaculture design, one is a gunsmith, and the rest are too young to be sure yet. Plenty of shared knowledge, like gunsmithing is a hobby of mine, but he took it seriously. Still no real "pods". I'd classify us as classically educated. We had somewhere around 5000 nonfiction books in the house, and most of us had read a significant chunk of them. Nobody has a bachelor's, but I suspect that'll change with some of the younger ones who are more patient. Edit: Some of us did do real school. I paid my way through an Associate's degree at 13 because I was bored. Also online classes, apprenticeships, stuff like that.
- sickofparadox 3y agoThey say that they account for the log of the family income, but do not elaborate on that point beyond saying they do (at least after a quick skim). It seems to me that this would be extremely difficult - does anyone have insight on how they might have done this?
- dcsommer 3y agoThe bias for negativity in headlines and SEO is at play again here. Later on ITA: > While cognitive development took a hit, kids’ behaviors were assessed as better on average in larger families. Note that overall life success can depend on both of these factors. And in today's isolating times, the cognitive skills may be more replaceable/recoverable than the social/behavioral ones.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoYes but I think few metrics are as loaded and culturally mediated as "well behaved" for children. For a lot of people this could simply mean quiet and capable of extended occupation alone. It could mean different things for boys and for girls, depending on the expectations of the assessor. It seems like this is possibly self-assessment by a parent, which has what I hope are obvious issues. But even if you take say a teacher or other third party you run into a lot of the same problems with it.
- MeImCounting 3y agoEhhh I social skills are overrated. As long as you're able to do effective collaboration and work within a team you dont need to be a social butterfly. The most successful engineers and researchers I know personally; are not particularly social people, obviously they're able to exist in polite company and collaborate etc but socialization is just another tool.
- ambicapter 3y agoSounds like a false equivalence. No one is saying you need to be a social butterfly. > The most successful engineers and researchers I know personally; are not particularly social people I've seen plenty of capable or at least promising engineers torpedo their development by not being to read the room or adjust their social behavior. > obviously they're able to exist in polite company and collaborate etc Ok, so having the skills is considered a baseline? Sounds like they're pretty important then.
- MeImCounting 3y ago
- spenrose 3y agoThe underlying survey is from ~12,000 children born 1957-1964, when America was much poorer. My own aunts and uncles, who were middle class, report competing for food with their 9 other siblings. Results may not hold for, say, a 4-child household living on $100,000 today. https://www.nlsinfo.org/content/cohorts/nlsy79 https://www.nlsinfo.org/content/cohorts/nlsy79
- jdksmdbtbdnmsm 3y ago"America" the country was poorer, but it has a lot more poor people now, a lot more people living in poverty and without food security now than in the post-war years.
- alchemist1e9 3y agoIf that is true it’s an important observation however I suspect it isn’t. In general, and everywhere, the past was much tougher than the present.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoYeah, I would much rather be 5th percentile income in the United States today than 5th pc income in it 50 years ago. I don't see how this is even slightly arguable.
- alchemist1e9 3y agoIt’s not except by those who have been indoctrinated by misleading socialist propaganda.
- pastacacioepepe 3y agoI disagree. A family could be supported by a single income up until a few decades ago, not just in the US but in many countries. Today, often two incomes aren't enough for a family, even with families getting smaller since people tend to have less children.
- irrational 3y agoEh.... I come from a family of 8 kids. All of us have at least bachelors degrees, many have multiple graduate degrees, including doctorates. > Additional siblings have lower cognitive scores than their older siblings. One of my youngest siblings was valedictorian of a high school class of 4,000 students, got perfect scores on the ACT and SAT, was accepted into MIT and many ivy league schools and recently was incentivized to move to a new company with a $1 million bonus. He is straight up a genius. I mean, obviously there are outliers to everything, but this study strikes me as maybe having a correlation and causation issue.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoI mean, do you account for that fact that your family has a correlation issue? You all are in the same geographic area, social class and economic bracket, go to the same kind of schools, have the same parents. To the extent any of these things can influence degree-having (which is not, quite, intelligence) they influence it for all of you yeah?
- QuarterReptile 3y agoWeak correlations or weak effects shouldn't drive your personal behavior. If you're worried about it, make sure your 5th/6th/nth children are way out the end of the distribution of daily minutes reading; that should do plenty to combat this effect.
- oh_sigh 3y agoYour brother would probably understand that anecdotes aren't an argument against statistical phenomena. Or maybe you would, if you had half as many siblings.
- anon291 3y agoThis cannot be separated from the fact that in America and most of the developed world, poor, less educated people are more likely to have large families.
- QuarterReptile 3y agoDo you read this as distinct from the global trend that female lifetime fertility drops with increases in years of schooling (not stabilizing until safely below 'large family')? At least in every US state, it seems that larger households have higher household income, though my stat only goes to household size of 4 (https://www.justice.gov/ust/eo/bapcpa/20201101/bci_data/median_income_table.htm https://www.justice.gov/ust/eo/bapcpa/20201101/bci_data/medi...). It seems to be true that wealthy and highly educated women are less likely to have many or any children.And at the other end, I think it's reasonable to suspect that having children has a causal relationship with unwed mothers not subsequently marrying.
- huytersd 3y agoIt’s probably just women having children too late. After 30, the quality of child is going to gradually get worse.
- rpmisms 3y agoYou are correct, but as women get older, the chance of genetic defects becomes higher. The intelligence of a genetically nominal child wouldn't be affected.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoPeople generally dont want to say this outloud, and most men are not aware the degree to which this is true.
- malcolmgreaves 3y agoMen having children later in life is associated with a litany of developmental problems too.
- frozenlettuce 3y ago_The rate of Down syndrome for both maternal and paternal age greater than 40 years is approximately 60 per 10,000 births, which is a six-fold increase compared with maternal and paternal ages less than 35 years of age._
- mynameishere 3y agoYeah, this is just turning the long-standing observation about family size and cognitive ability on its head in such a way that (if it became a popular notion) would just make the problem worse. Smart parents would dutifully have just one or two kids.
- swozey 3y agoTech workers are the only people that I know in my age range (almost 40) who have a handful of children instead of the usual 1-2. Like 3-5. I will never understand why someone actually intends to have 3-5 children in modern times when we're not working on a farm or in the mines. We're at 4, ok when can we have 5? ... Why, what does having a 5th child change for you? Are you bored? Is your hobby at that point literally just raising children?
- gambiting 3y agoMy experience is the exact opposite - people in tech have either 0 or 1 kid(and swear they won't have any more - after all, how can you fit any more in your life). People outside of tech(teachers, academics, accountants, musicians) all have 2-3 kids. >>Why, what does having a 5th child change for you? Are you bored? I mean, I only have 1 personally, but I get it - kids are fun. And the process of being a parent is fun(outside of the parts that absolutely suck) and extremely rewarding, it's been more rewarding than everything I have ever done in my professional career, and I have some things under my belt that I'm very proud of - seeing my son develop is still more rewarding than any of these. I assume that with every new child you just get to repeat the process and get that reward again and again and again. So I suppose the answer is ultimately - for somewhat selfish reasons. Kids are not just mine workers or care for the elderly.
- swozey 3y agoThat's interesting considering one big obvious reason my coworkers/friends have 3+ kids is because they easily clear $300k+ single income and can live in 6 bedroom homes, etc. Drive those massive suburbans.. I have a very difficult time believing that the 3rd, 4th, etc children have a dad like you who still has the time to have fun with them and treat them properly and love their achievements each, etc. But it's possible. My mom has 6 siblings and they were raised like wolves, but they're boomers. I have one (older) sibling and we absolutely vied for our parents attention and do not get along whatsoever.
- gambiting 3y ago
- MarkusWandel 3y agoMy first reaction was "uh oh, hypermeritocracy" i.e. children drilled for test-taking success from the earliest age - so of course more children would dilute the tiger parent effect. But that was based on just a quick skim. Not an issue when I was a kid; parents drilling kids academically didn't even go as far as mine checking whether we did our homework. All four of us turned out OK by the standards of "finish university and have an appropriate (to the level of education) career".
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoFix the title? "In the old days, children in America in larger families tested poorer than those in smaller families." Possibly, completely different today? Not much relevant conclusion to draw from folks raised in the 1950's and 60's.